News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by angst_ridden on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:07PM (#33291870)
There's a firm in Southern California that's suing restaurants / small theaters / community organizations / etc after bulk-scanning web sites for embedded video that lack links to caption files.

It's all ADA abuse, lawsuits in the $5k-$7k range. A huge percentage of those sued don't have the means to fight back, and settle.

The company that's suing people had some incompetent coder write their scanner, so it only parses the TRACK tag from a video container in certain circumstances. I was able to defend an organization by demonstrating this.

A vigorous countersuit is in the discussion stages.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ronsor on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:33PM (#33292141)
Can you list their IP addresses so I can firewall them... and drop the ranges from my BGP tables?
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by angst_ridden on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:39PM (#33292203)
I'm afraid I don't have that information. I believe they did their scan last July.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by BolexNOLA on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:11PM (#33291914)
I genuinely do not understand how they can sleep at night. Thanks for pushing back.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by plussed_reader on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:13PM (#33291935)
"If it were wrong it would be illegal."
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by littlestymaar on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:22PM (#33292022)
What I genuinely wonder is why there's so few arson against companies doing that. How can every people victim of such a rapacious behavior keep their calm.

I mean that's quite an achievement in the direction of civilization and reduction of violent crimes in a society: when people have internalized so much that doing justice by themselves is wrong, that they won't even do it when there's no other justice to seek.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by galangalalgol on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:41PM (#33292220)
This is essentially a legal protection money racket. People running a racket never leave you with nothing left to lose. Most obviously because they can't come back for more. But also because people with nothing left to lose will burn down al Capone's house and not care that they are about to be killed in some horrible way.

These legal rackets know if they hit you for something you can afford to pay and keep your business running, that you aren't likely to throw it all away for empty vengeance. Cameras are everywhere now.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by orangepurple on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:00PM (#33292423)
Cameras don't work if the neighborhood transformer is down for unscheduled reconfiguration
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by hedora on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:18PM (#33293972)
These days, they do. Batteries and solar panels cost less then running a cable.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by littlestymaar on Saturday October 22, 2022 @08:57AM (#33297957)
> Cameras are everywhere now.

They clearly aren't, and there are around a hundred arson committed each day in average in the US so it doesn't look like the sheer number of surveillance camera is enough of a deterrent for the typical criminal.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by tehwebguy on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:35PM (#33292161)
> companies doing that

Doing which, making services unavailable to disabled people or suing those that do?

I mean if my health insurer, for example, couldn't accommodate a disability of mine, especially something as common as low vision or hearing, I'd certainly feel like getting revenge but doesn't everyone feel that way about every health insurer every year or two?

If you meant the other way around, like if someone sued me because I was the one essentially locking people with a disability out from using my service I'd probably just take a really logical approach to handling it (for instance, making the accommodation they request). From what I've read the most common outcome in these cases is that the defendant is ordered to make the accommodation.

Getting sued or even just threatened with a lawsuit is pretty scary though, if anyone here is facing threat of lawsuit I'd suggest you consult with several attorneys right away but also find a YouTube attorney to set your expectations of the process. It's super easy to get fleeced by your own attorney unless you direct them pretty intentionally.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by angst_ridden on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:42PM (#33292236)
I believe in making things accessible, and strive to do that on all my projects.

I object to abuse of the ADA. Businesses / organizations should be given an opportunity to remediate their web sites before an automated script files an erroneous lawsuit.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by tehwebguy on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:19PM (#33292597)
That is already the most common out come of ADA website suits it would seem:

> The most common penalty at the federal level is a demand that the website be updated swiftly to better cater to people with disabilities.

[0] https://ddiy.co/can-you-be-sued-if-your-website-is-not-ada-c...

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by hedora on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:38PM (#33294100)
That doesn't apply in California or New York. I heard California is trying to bring back the grace period.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by jibe on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:09PM (#33292501)
It should be an easy legal fix - you have to give notice and ~120 day window to fix before you are allowed to file a lawsuit. Also, not sure private parties should be plaintiffs here.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by drc500free on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:31PM (#33292706)
Without private action, they would need funding for enforcement. To have funding for enforcement, they would have to either levy fines against offenders or raise taxes. Those are non-starters for getting the legislation passed, and the opponents hope that they can later claim that the private action is an abuse of the legal system.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by knodi123 on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:43PM (#33292253)
> Doing which, making services unavailable to disabled people or suing those that do?

You think these people are champions of the disabled?

If a disabled person wanted to see the video, and could not, and asked them for help, that would be one thing. This ain't that. They're fucking vultures, they are in this to make money off of as many people as possible, regardless of the harm they cause. This is no more sane than the Texas law that allows people to be amateur bounty hunters and dogpile on anyone who might have played any kind of role in any woman's abortion.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by tehwebguy on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:10PM (#33292516)
I don't know anything about the unnamed firm mentioned up the thread other than what the OP said but it doesn't sound like they are actually following the law: I doubt that simply "finding" a website with a video that lacks captions is enough for a viable suit.

From Googling, it appears that suits without actual damages are getting thrown out[0], so I'd guess the attorneys running that show are doing something unlawful but not illegal by filing these suits, or maybe something not even unlawful by simply making legal demands without filing.

Probably one of the biggest causes for all of this pain is that so many "white collar" violations of public trust are either a) not actually illegal or b) not handled by any law enforcement.

The Prenda Law debacle comes to mind though -- these guys spent years terrorizing people with copyright law before anything really came of it but, incredibly, they actually ended up convicted on fairly serious charges. It's super wild to read about, I wonder if they had dialed it back a tiny bit they would have stayed under the radar completely.

[0] This doesn't help the defendants in question with their own attorney's fees but does send a message about viability of these garbage suits to the plaintiffs and every other firm looking into it.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by miki123211 on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:10PM (#33292512)
If a disabled person asks for anything, they usually get a generic "we care about your feedback, this is on our radar" response and nothing actually happens.

I'm speaking from experience here, I've done quite a few accessibility-related support requests, and getting a human to answer is very often a struggle.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by drc500free on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:29PM (#33292687)
You'll recognize the same rage that there was against the mcdonald's coffee lady. These cases get stoked by tort-reform interests to show "what's wrong with the legal system." It took several decades and a documentary for people to understand they were misled about that personal injury case, it will take a while for them to understand disability law.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by hedora on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:45PM (#33294146)
Those cases are completely different from each other.

If McDonalds coffee lady was buying coffees everywhere, checking them with a thermometer, suing because she could have burnt herself, and then used the proceeds to hire more people to do the same in a profit sharing scheme then her case would be comparable to the current ADA abusers in California.

Instead, the McDonald's in question had been repeatedly warned by health inspectors, was in violation of corporate policy, and the woman was an actual customer that was hospitalized as a result of the business violating the law.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by drc500free on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:16PM (#33294725)
1. Refuse to fund enforcement of disability protections, and require citizens to crowdsource it via a bounty program.

2. Label anyone who tries to enforce it an “ADA abuser” and claim they are misusing the system to make money.

3. Disability protections are successfully ignored, corporations make more profit.

Usually there’s a “???” in the middle, but this one is pretty straightforward.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by hedora on Saturday October 22, 2022 @03:57AM (#33296378)
I think this a good summary of why civil suits usually can only be brought by a party that actually suffered some sort of harm. (The ADA works that way in 48 states, avoiding abusive suits.)
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by drc500free on Saturday October 22, 2022 @12:27PM (#33299696)
Can you define for me what makes the suit abusive?

Is the defendant following the law and being wrongfully sued?

Or are they breaking the law but should only be held accountable if a disabled person has the energy, time, and money to go through the court system?

It’s sounding like “it’s annoying to serve disabled people, businesses should be able to get away with not doing that.” In my mind we are literally dealing with people who are abusing (ignoring) ADA to make a profit, but you are calling the OTHER side profit-seeking abusers.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ccvannorman on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:27PM (#33292078)
This "wonder" you find yourself with is a result of the mismatch between observable data, statistics, and our intuition.

On the news we may read about Arson (or other "angry actions" by individuals) but this is highly negative selection bias - the actual incidence rate is near zero.

Because we have a lot of data like this (negative news that you are exposed to) we tend to over-estimate the incidence rate of arson (e.g. 1% instead of 0.001%)

So, when you ask the question "Why isn't $action provoking more $arson here", the answer is simple: statistically speaking, each individual is extremely unlikely to do arson (or similar), so even though they've been perturbed, the incidence doesn't really go up.

Another way to say it: Everyone knows the ROI on arson is negative, no matter how upset you are, crime is never worth it as a response, because you have zero upside. So almost everyone (overwhelming majority) don't do this (but we might think they would, again because we're exposed to negative bias news data)

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by verisimilitudes on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:04PM (#33292463)
I'd bet money they're basically only doing this to white and asian people.

Anyway, just wait. Once these parasites destroy society, we'll see some changes.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by rat87 on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:25PM (#33292651)
It is illegal, that's why they sued.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by yieldcrv on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:32PM (#33292129)
In their minds they are just chasing alpha to sleep at all. They have probably been burned along the way and just passing the trauma forward. Everyone has to save themselves.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by drc500free on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:01PM (#33292438)
It's no different from not having curb cuts on your sidewalk. Culturally tech companies have gotten away with selling non-compliant products and websites, and feel like it's unacceptable to be required to follow regulations because everyone has level-set their expectations around not doing that.

A competent regulatory scheme would have had the government enforcing this from the beginning, instead of depending on private action that seldom happens, but here we are. Uber ignores taxi regulations, AirBnB ignores zoning regulations, and everyone ignores accessibility regulations.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by jacobsenscott on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:23PM (#33292633)
> A competent regulatory scheme would have had the government enforcing this from the beginning

If there was a regulatory scheme (competent can't really be defined) at the beginning of the internet we would all still be using aol dial up at best, there would be 3 content creating entities at most, and we would be paying for monthly "bundles" of web sites.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ivan_gammel on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:28PM (#33293234)
On the contrary, we could have accessibility by design and accesstech industry enabling it at low cost. Every business deterred by the effort required to make interfaces accessible would inevitably be replaced by those who think they can still earn a lot of money (we are talking about trillion dollar industry here, people are ready to kill for much less).
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by knewter on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:26PM (#33294789)
Ahh yes, the ol' "only wealthy people may start a business" plan
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by drc500free on Saturday October 22, 2022 @02:26AM (#33296023)
It's the ol' "only people willing to be members of society and follow the rules that protect people may start a business" plan. You don't get to flush toxic waste down the drain, put poison in your pills, and ignore disability accommodations.

It sounds like you think there should be no disability accommodations. Is that the root of the disagreement?

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ivan_gammel on Saturday October 22, 2022 @02:43AM (#33296086)
Accessibility is effort, not money. It’s not rocket science, it’s not building pyramids, every hard working and intellectually capable person should be able to do it.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by knewter on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:51AM (#33318319)
> Accessibility is effort, not money.

I've been paid to implement accessibility. I made a lot of money.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ivan_gammel on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:22AM (#33329040)
So what (not a question).
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by extantproject on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:12PM (#33292527)
> If people followed the law, they wouldn't get sued.

non sequitur

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by drc500free on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:21PM (#33292613)
Great point, and I just edited that out on re-read because I realized it's simply not true. In fact, it's the core problem with using private action as an enforcement mechanism. You pass a specialized regulatory problem to a generic court and waste everyone's time with cases like this one where the companies may in fact be perfectly compliant - but first you need to spend money teaching the judge what the facts are.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by lamontcg on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:15PM (#33293570)
A curb cut on a sidewalk is a pretty well defined piece of civil engineering.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Macha on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:38PM (#33294484)
So are captions for video content?
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ruined on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:07PM (#33294664)
curb cuts on sidewalks are the classic example of an obvious, commonplace accessibility accommodation that is standard now, but was initially only gained via unauthorized direct action
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Handytinge on Friday October 28, 2022 @08:17AM (#33370445)
For the non Americans:

A "sidewalk" is a footpath adjacent to a road.

A "curb cut" is ramp from footpath to road.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by sangnoir on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:28PM (#33292674)
Discriminating on disability is not cool, and it also happens to be illegal. If people on HN can complain about how some websites are unusable with Javascript disabled (by choice), I think those who depend on screen readers[1] have a more cogent case, as they don't have options.

For all the hate the "bloated" web frameworks get, the one thing they usually have out of the box is accessibility.

1. Or other assistive tech.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by jbirer on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:26PM (#33293211)
We often assume that most people have empathy / conscience. It's simply not true.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by chriscjcj on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:51PM (#33292337)
Is it Potter Handy, LLP?

I think this article from yesterday might be related:

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/crime/san-francisco-and-los-a...

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by angst_ridden on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:29PM (#33293242)
I'm not at liberty to give specifics right now.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by punyearthling on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:15PM (#33292560)
That's pretty specific - maybe a California thing - but I'd heard as an engineer, you just had to show an attempt was made at making your site accessible. Targeting specific ADA violations is odd to me.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by nnf on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:39PM (#33295193)
Showing an attempt might or might not help you with a judge, but the attempt alone doesn’t release you from your accessibility obligations.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by roenxi on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:24PM (#33293195)
> It's all ADA abuse...

The HN gestalt confuses me on this one. The other week the EU had that charger standardisation law and the mood on HN was undeniably positive. Now we have a comment that Californian web accessibility laws are being enforced and the top voted comment is decidedly negative. These laws are remarkably similar in intent and likely outcome.

What is different here? Is it the same people but you're all drawing a distinction that I don't see? different people and a US vs EU thing? Hardware vs Software?

When there is a law saying that websites are supposed to be accessible, suing websites that aren't accessible doesn't seem like abuse to me. This sounds like the intended outcome.

Enforcing laws isn't a pretty business.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by comte7092 on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:33PM (#33293278)
Does it actually confuse you or is that a rhetorical question?

On the one have you have global manufacturers being required to switch from one well established standard to another, it’s a requirement that barely touches on their resources as a firm and has more to do with their business strategy.

Contrast that with organizations that are likely well meaning but barely have the technical competence to put up and maintain a website. What they are currently doing is at the limit of their technical capacity.

The two situations couldn’t be more different.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by dereg on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:43PM (#33293360)
Do you see how many qualifiers you added to this? What if it significantly touches on their resources as a firm? What if the company is “global” but revenue is primarily domestic?

It’s always easy to carve these lines in the sand ex post facto. Good legislation lays out a set on consistent principles and enforcements, ex ante.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by comte7092 on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:48PM (#33293390)
Hacker news commenters are not legislators, it is therefore entirely reasonable for commenters to draw those lines however they see fit for the purposes of discussion.

Further, it is drawing lines on the basis of number of employees/operating revenue/etc (the use of the word “global” in this case is clearly a colloquial reference to a very large firm along these metrics), is already a very common and well understood basis for drawing such lines, so such and insinuation on your part that this is some ex post facto finger pointing is without serious grounding.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by lupire on Sunday October 23, 2022 @08:32PM (#33311714)
And bad legistlation gets exploited by scummy lawyers to hurt everyone except themselves, which is the topic of this thread.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by yucky on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:40PM (#33293335)
You think it's weird that people expect random website owners with limited resources not to be held to the same accessibility standards as multi-billion dollar manufactures?

Why?

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by roenxi on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:36PM (#33294847)
Because that would be treating the value of an individual as dependent on the power of the entity they are interacting with, which is a bit weird.

It isn't really a defensible position to say that you have an interaction with someone and to work out how they ought behave you need to go and do a tally of their assets and mull over their balance sheets. It'd be tantamount to saying we'd need to know what Haim Michael's assets were to know how to feel about this article. The law shouldn't change depending on whether he is broke, has $100k in savings or is a multi-millionaire. The issue here under the law is whether disabled people can access his website or not.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by yucky on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:59PM (#33294989)
>The issue here under the law is whether disabled people can access his website or not.

A website is a work of art, and nobody has a right to someone else's art. Disabled or not.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by roenxi on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:39PM (#33295195)
On what basis do you say that? You seem to be in conflict with Israeli law on this one, and I think on a moral level that is a bit shaky. If your art could be appreciated by disabled people, it seems a bit questionable to assert that there is a 'right' to exclude them.

I want to be clear - I think all this regulatory interference is doing more harm than good. But I don't see why this case is different because it is working on behalf of disabled people rather than ... I can't figure out who the charger stuff is meant to be helping, I see a lot of people outraged that they bought 2x chargers, which seems like a funny group of people to be protecting.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by yucky on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:34PM (#33295460)
A blind person can't see a painting, therefore we shouldn't paint. A deaf person can't hear music, therefore we shouldn't make music.

This argument is absurd. Nobody has a right to prevent someone form expressing themselves just because they can't enjoy it.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by roenxi on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:19AM (#33295830)
> A blind person can't see a painting, therefore we shouldn't paint. A deaf person can't hear music, therefore we shouldn't make music.

That is a bit of a strawman argument though, is there anyone saying that? The actual situation is likely more like if a blind person can't see your painting you have to describe it to them. And I don't see how this is going to fit in with your original point on multi-billion dollar corporations.

If we want to keep to the idea of absurd outcomes, why is it so much more absurd that Mr Michael has to make accessible videos but world's best phone design company isn't considered competent to design a phone? These are both pretty absurd.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by yucky on Saturday October 22, 2022 @08:44AM (#33297871)
>That is a bit of a strawman argument though, is there anyone saying that?

Yes, you did. And then followed up with the same line of reasoning again in the next sentence:

> The actual situation is likely more like if a blind person can't see your painting you have to describe it to them.

But my painting is only meant to be appreciated visually because that is how I choose to express it. The idea that I should be forced to represent my art in a way I never intended it to be, is absurd.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by roenxi on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:06AM (#33298425)
If you feel that describing your painting to a blind person is beneath your dignity as an artist, to the point that you'd rather have left it unpainted, then truly I sit in awe of your principles.

But why you think that you can apply that sort of standard to yourself, but not see a level of absurdity in the EU commission trying to wrest phone design away from Apple of all companies is still a profound mystery even after all these posts. They have as much a "right" to design integrity as an artist does.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by yucky on Saturday October 22, 2022 @11:06AM (#33298892)
>If you feel that describing your painting to a blind person is beneath your dignity as an artist

It has nothing to do with dignity it has to do with artistic vision. If you don't want to present your art in ways you don't intend it to be consumed, you shouldn't be forced. If someone else wants to do it for others, that's fine. You could even start a business taking art forms and describing them for people who can't appreciate them in their natural setting.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by nyberg on Sunday October 23, 2022 @04:41AM (#33305506)
It's not just apple, it's all devices of a similar size which currently reduce accessability by having their own unique charging cable as a requirement. Forcing USB-C imcreases accessibility for the public and reduces general waste for physical devices.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ekianjo on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:10PM (#33295046)
>The issue here under the law is whether disabled people can access his website or not.

Soon you will apply the same standard for video games too? After all, why can't people without arms enjoy the same video games as you do? This kind of line of thinking has no end in sight, and is purely aimed at killing smaller companies and reinforcing the centralization of a few actors.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Nexxxeh on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:00AM (#33295754)
I disagree with your rhetorical question, as people without arms absolutely can enjoy the same video games I do.

I don't know about Sony and Nintendo, but Microsoft and 3rd parties on PC have absolutely ploughed resources into making sure that's the case.

Notable examples include the Xbox Adaptive Controller [1] which greatly simplifies making custom setups for the specific needs of gamers with limited motor control or limb difference etc.

Features like Co-pilot [2] which allow cooperative controller use.

And that's JUST from Microsoft, there's plenty more from third parties and hackers.

Hell, one absolute lunatic [3] has been playing COD and SF4 with a recorder (the musical instrument). You can absolutely build custom controllers, be that for limb difference or just to make ridiculous Twitch streams as you headshot someone with a C Sharp.

Most games now include the obvious traditional stuff like subtitles. Useful for me personally.

Plus stuff like visual changes for the visually impaired (inc specific palettes for colour blindness) are common.

And we're starting to see many more with newer "cognitive accessibility" options like motion sickness reduction presets for graphical options, objective assists and difficulty reduction, etc.

[1] https://www.xbox.com/en-GB/accessories/controllers/xbox-adap... [2] https://support.xbox.com/en-GB/help/account-profile/accessib... [3] https://www.twitch.tv/DeanoBeano

I think you're completely wrong on this. Gaming should be accessible and there's no excuse for it not to be in future.

It's not aimed at killing any companies. It's about enabling us all to kill each other, race each other, build stupid forts with each other, and hunt demons together. Armless or not.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ekianjo on Saturday October 22, 2022 @11:44AM (#33299226)
> I don't know about Sony and Nintendo, but Microsoft and 3rd parties on PC have absolutely ploughed resources into making sure that's the case.

Hence proving my point that this is the stuff of big companies. If you had to develop solutions as a small manufacturer because it is "mandated" you would go bankrupt before accomplishing anything

> I think you're completely wrong on this. Gaming should be accessible and there's no excuse for it not to be in future.

"should"'s are meaningless. Resources are limited and you can't expect to serve all the needs out there when you make a product. Making choices matter, and that's precisely why you cannot make a product for "everyone".

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Nexxxeh on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:36PM (#33301988)
>Hence proving my point that this is the stuff of big companies.

No, it doesn't and no it isn't. Your rhetorical question is fundamentally wrong, and I gave you examples to prove it.

And I'm not talking generally, I've destroyed the specific example you gave.

>Soon you will apply the same standard for video games too? After all, why can't people without arms enjoy the same video games as you do?

Yes. Yes they can.

But to address the other stuff you're saying...

Just because even big companies are doing it now, doesn't mean it is necessarily difficult or expensive. Microsoft went big and hard on it not because it needed massive investment, but because it warranted it and is a subject they're passionate about.

Accessibility is and deserves to be expected. There's no excuse for lacking it in the gaming space.

They did it at Microsoft scale and made a product that's effectively a standard now.

And disabled gamers represents more potential revenue. Win win.

(It wasn't immediate clear if you were arguing about the first or second part of the sentence. I'm assuming second, but in case it was the first "Sony and Nintendo" bit:

I didn't know the specifics of non-MS consoles because not owned a Nintendo console newer than a Wii, and have no reason to have a Playstation. Especially as many of the Sony exclusives are coming to PC anyway.

A quick look at PS4/PS5 accessibility features, they include RT transcription for squad comms in addition to standard closed captions, controller remapping, visual accessibility features. First game I picked to look at was TLoU Part 2 has a LOT of accessibility features with sensible presets for physical and cognitive disability.

And you possibly need an adapter, but you can use the Xbox Accessibility Controller with PS4/PS5 as well.)

All the controller-level stuff could literally be done by hobbyists and was done by hobbyists and small companies, and big companies.

A quick Google will show you stuff like the [Thomas] Controller from 2013.[1] AbleGamers have been going since mid-2000.

Big companies have started bringing economies of scale to help drive adoption. You are wrong with your fundamental premise, and I'm proving you wrong with the specific rhetorical question you posed.

And at the software level we're mostly talking about features that aren't expensive to implement. They're as close to free as you can get. Even solo devs can do the majority of it because it's largely stuff you'll have in for ease of debugging, localisation and QA.

With the possible exception of high-end new stuff like comms transcription, slap 'em under the right menu headers, add some sensible presets, GOOD TO GO.

It's basically a modern cheat menu.

[1] https://hackaday.com/2013/06/20/building-custom-game-control...

>"should"'s are meaningless.

No they aren't.

>Resources are limited and you can't expect to serve all the needs out there when you make a product.

Agreed.

>Making choices matter, and that's precisely why you cannot make a product for "everyone".

I'm not disputing that. But you're fundamentally wrong about accessibility. "Should" does matter, and the very example you used demonstrates why.

People without arms DO enjoy the same video games as I do. Just as it should be.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Adrox on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:49AM (#33296598)
There is dozens of laws in EU that only apply for companies with more than 100 employees, or X in revenue:

- Mandatory canteens.

- Mandatory retirement savings plan.

- Break rooms (in Sweden my company had a nap room that had to have a locked door from inside).

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by unethical_ban on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:46PM (#33300401)
It is entirely defensible to have different expectations of the amount of effort and money a provider of services can put into accessibility and regulatory compliance based on how much money they make.

I assert that it is rational to expect a large bank or city government to have accessibility standards and at the same time, not expect Hacker News or a personal blog to have the same.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by itsoktocry on Saturday October 22, 2022 @06:10PM (#33302670)
Because requirement to obey the law shouldn't be based on your resources.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by throwaway41597 on Saturday October 22, 2022 @07:41PM (#33303227)
Considering how vast, obscure and absurd the law is, I think it should. As a matter of fact, it often is.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by jtsuken on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:43PM (#33293361)
> you're all drawing a distinction that I don't see?

The distinction you are not seeing is between actual harm and a pretext for lawyers to sue.

Actual harm to the environment and real business profits result from manufacturers producing and selling proprietary charing devices (I bought at least 3 and disposed of at least 2 Apple magsafe2 chargers, while having perfectly working generic chargers around my home).

An indie developer hosting a free website is neither causing permanent and irreversible damage to the environment nor is he making any money as a result of his websites not being accessibility compliant.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by dereg on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:02PM (#33293475)
> An indie developer hosting a free website is neither causing permanent and irreversible damage to the environment nor is he making any money as a result of his websites not being accessibility compliant.

Odd complaint seeing as how Apple no longer includes chargers with iPhones, on environmental grounds. There are many people who complained about that, as well.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by themitigating on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:45PM (#33294527)
The developer is causing harm to those who want to access it but can't and he's making money by not making it accessible.

As for harming the environment, that's unrelated

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ok_dad on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:52AM (#33296609)
And now no one can use it. Perhaps there’s a way to provide access to those who need it but not sue a person for making a hobby site?
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by themitigating on Saturday October 22, 2022 @07:24AM (#33297354)
You're assuming the only outcome is the website is shutdown. That's what happened here.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ok_dad on Saturday October 22, 2022 @03:27PM (#33301327)
No, I’m saying that the law actually reduced access for this set of lessons, and perhaps we should figure out ways to make things accessible for everyone other than putting the onus on the little guy. Maybe if you’re just one person, then there could be a program where larger companies are required to pay a small tax or donate developer time (in lieu of tax) to help you make your site accessible. That way, the larger companies who can afford to make their site accessible follow the law and do so, and then they also take some of the profits they made off of the public to do a public good.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by lamontcg on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:12PM (#33293549)
"Accessibility" is an overly broad topic so you shouldn't expect any consistency.

Charger standardization around USB-C really isn't that abusive or produces much if any regulatory capture, and it is pretty easy to understand what needs to be done.

These disability laws hit every business with a website and there's no easy standard to show that websites are compliant, they are an example of regulatory capture since larger corporations will be able to hire the staff to audit and implement the changes required, and they're vague enough that they produce an army of lawyers.

The principle and intentions behind the disabilities laws are fine, but they either need to solely target larger firms or they need to have clear guidelines for what gets audited and remediated. If the government ran a free service which would scan your website and give you either a clean bill of health or a list of remediation steps that would be better. Tossing it over the fence to let the lawyers have a field day is poor.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by themitigating on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:43PM (#33294517)
If I was the parent I would have noted how people constantly claim most of the people here are libertarian.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by hedora on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:15PM (#33293957)
In most cases, businesses are given a grace period to address the complaint before civil liability creeps in. As I understand it, that is not the case in California or New York.

So, you can either hire a full time ADA attorney to continuously audit literally 100% of the public facing surface of your business, or pay random extortionists every time you (alegedly) violate an obscure ADA standard in some minor way.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ekianjo on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:07PM (#33295034)
> Now we have a comment that Californian web accessibility laws are being enforced

Sending random legal action letters and forcing small companies to settle hardly sounds like "enforcement" but rather blackmail/extortion.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by hyperman1 on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:16AM (#33296457)
Enforcement should start with a warning shot. A business should first get a warning and, say, a month to fix things.

My car light was broken once without me knowing. The police stopped us, gave an official notice. I should go to theur building in a week and show a working car light, or I would get a fine.

Here we have random people standing at the side of the street, demanding money from everyone with a minor spec of dust on their taillight.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by itsoktocry on Saturday October 22, 2022 @06:08PM (#33302647)
I dont get it. The lawsuit is the warning shot; comply or pay.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by paranoidrobot on Saturday October 22, 2022 @09:17PM (#33303660)
Many of these are actually not warning shots. They are demands to settle or we file suit.

There is no chance to cure.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Linosaurus on Saturday October 22, 2022 @05:14AM (#33296700)
> different people and a US vs EU thing?

Both.

The EU people are large companies that can afford the legal costs, and capable of either changing charger or not.

The US people are small business that can often not afford the legal costs (ie settle wether guilty or not), and completely following the law is almost impossible if a manual mistake on a single video opens liability.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by dTal on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:01AM (#33298379)
One might uncharitably surmise that it has something to do with the fact that most HN users are personally inconvenienced more by incompatible charging standards than by inaccessible websites.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by unethical_ban on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:43PM (#33300363)
Personally, the ethics of law enforcement and our expectations of compliance scale with size. In many realms of law and regulation, this is recognized.

I expect Walmart to pay people a "living wage" more than I expect that of a small business owner with three employees.

I expect a clean kitchen with sanitization stations from McDonalds more than I do from a kid selling lemonade.

I expect a trillion dollar company, or a bank, to have an accessible website more than I expect it from an individual running a blog.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Gordonjcp on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:31PM (#33293263)
Interesting. I had an email from a Californian law firm, claiming that my website was not sufficiently accessible for vision-impaired readers and I could be sued in California because of it, and would I like to pay them for their legal assistance in making it meet ADA legislation?

I suggested they consider Arkell v. Pressdram, and haven't heard a cheep from them since. The site looks perfectly okay with javascript and styling turned off (it's a forum, it's all text, there are some photos), so I expect it'll be fine in any practical screen reader. The demographic for the forum (people who want to repair and operate very old Range Rovers) already probably doesn't really include partially-sighted people, who would not be allowed to drive anyway if their vision was so poor they couldn't read text on a screen with reasonable adaptations.

I don't expect I will ever travel to California anyway, so I'm certain I've heard the last of them.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by camillomiller on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:39PM (#33293327)
Currently in Germany there’s a wave of lawyers letters making the rounds. They claim a website violates the privacy of some dummy client when they accessed the website and their IP was transmitted to Google’s servers to download Google Fonts from the cloud. I’ve been putting in some extra hours this week to help scared clients localize their Google Fonts. The wave started after an half-assed sentence from a court in Munich back in January decided that Google Fonts server seeing a user’s IP number is a punishable privacy violation.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by slyall on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#33293446)
I have a small website that happens to be hosted in Germany since a German company donated a server.

We had to add an "Impressum" with our contact details to make sure we didn't get hit with a letter demanding money from one of the law firms that specialise in shaking down sites that are missing them.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by nicbou on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:40PM (#33295198)
You can just tell them to sod off. The Impressum requirement is for German commercial websites. If you are not bound by this law, you don't have to obey it.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by iggldiggl on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:31AM (#33318032)
1. The legal definition of what's "commercial" under that law and what's not isn't necessarily quite as straightforward as a layman might think. (For one, that law doesn't literally say "commercial" ("gewerbsmäßig"), but rather "geschäftsmäßig" ("business-like"), which apparently can be interpreted to not require an intent to make money, but instead to include anything you plan on regularly doing).

2. Assuming you're referring to the Telemediengesetz, there's a second law (Medienstaatsvertrag) which mandates an imprint for anything that's not strictly for "personal or family purposes". Depending on who you ask, those two terms also require a rather narrow reading, so anything beyond a strictly private family diary (careful not to make references to any outside persons or businesses, though, because those entities will then have a legal interest in being able to identify you in case you malign them!) or family pictures or your private Dropbox replacement (ideally all the above should be password-protected and therefore not accessible by the general public anyway) might again already be in a grey area.

2b. Additionally, blogs can enter another grey area where depending on what and how you're blogging about, they might be classified as a journalistic service offering and therefore require an extended imprint, too.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by BrandoElFollito on Saturday October 22, 2022 @05:17AM (#33296721)
So what could happen, in practical terms?

If you are not located in Germany and do not have business there (I mean monetary business, one you can draw money from) then good luck for them trying to get something from you.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by gigel82 on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:22PM (#33294002)
I mean... it is, isn't it?

Google is specifically known to be using their fonts for tracking users across the web.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by treeman79 on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:32AM (#33295868)
Never thought about that. And now my weekend plans have changed…
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by subroutine on Saturday October 22, 2022 @03:03AM (#33296176)
Source?
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by gingerlime on Saturday October 22, 2022 @08:44AM (#33297876)
I’m not sure this is the issue precisely. However there’s been rulings that ban using Google analytics simply because doing so means the user sends a request to Google, and the user IP address is considered personal data (look up Schrems II). The same applies to Google fonts or anything hosted by Google.

The interesting thing specifically about the fonts case is that, unlike other privacy regulation that defines only fines, and not compensation/damages (fines are levied by the data protection authorities). However in the font case there was a precedent that awarded damages to the claimant in the tune of 500€. Now we see a wave of ambulance chasing lawyers exploiting this ruling to shake up companies. Sad, but potentially useful for privacy. IANAL and all that jazz.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by subroutine on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:15AM (#33304757)
OP said "Google is specifically known to be using their fonts for tracking users across the web."

I mean... is it?

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by gigel82 on Saturday October 22, 2022 @11:46AM (#33299254)
Here's Google's 1st hit for "Google Fonts privacy", you can find more: https://www.brycewray.com/posts/2020/08/google-fonts-privacy...
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by subroutine on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:11AM (#33304739)
If you are going to cite an article, make sure it provides an answer to the prompt. There is nothing in this article that can't be inferred directly from the google fonts privacy policy.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by camillomiller on Saturday October 22, 2022 @07:25AM (#33297357)
Sure thing, which is why I always call fonts locally. The problem is how adequate is the compensation for the violation. Some law firms ask for amounts close to 500€, and that’s bonkers. Also, most of them automate the website visit with a spoof user, which is easy to prove and immediately discredits their request. Unfortunately nobody does because you need to hire a lawyer and it’s cheaper to just pay and be done with it.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by bmacho on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:36PM (#33294470)
Well you have a choice.

Give all of your users data to google, endanger them, and break the law for not a single cent benefit, or you don't do that.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by bmacho on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:53PM (#33294574)
Just put it in your GDPR disclaimer that you send all of your users online time, location, interest, activity on the site, and unique identifiers to attach these data with other data to a foreign countries company for no actual reason; and if they don't want that they cannot do anything about it, and you are fine. Also the GDPR law is only 6 years old I think if you say you've never heard of it, you can get away with that.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Ylpertnodi on Saturday October 22, 2022 @05:26AM (#33296752)
>Also the GDPR law is only 6 years old I think if you say you've never heard of it, you can get away with that.

"I'm sorry Officer, I didn't know I couldn't do that."

https://youtu.be/FclScfPoKes?t=595

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Schroedingersat on Saturday October 22, 2022 @06:21AM (#33297002)
...good? That's what google fonts is for.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ezoe on Saturday October 22, 2022 @12:24PM (#33299668)
Just like EU cookie law, it's a really stupid judgement. It's you, your computer and your web browser who download the fonts from Google server, not the web server in Germany.

All the web server do is presenting the URL to the google server. You should be responsible for the behaviour of your computer and the web browser run on top of it.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by pupppet on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:08PM (#33293515)
Would love to hear more about your defense, have a client in the same boat.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by hedora on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:10PM (#33293928)
See also, Scott Johnson. He files bogus shakedown suits over wheelchair accessibility throughout the state.

Happily, the first hit is this article:

https://www.cbsnews.com/sacramento/news/attorney-scott-johns...

It's nice to see karma at work.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by iancmceachern on Saturday October 22, 2022 @03:29AM (#33296272)
If I could invest in any abstract concept, it would be karma. We need more of it.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Linosaurus on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:42AM (#33296559)
Article from 2019, I wonder what came of it.

Seems trial date is January 2023. He’s still doing it, but possibly some pushback from the legal system regarding standing (do you really intend to come back there)

https://www.sanjoseinside.com/news/__trashed/

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by lupire on Sunday October 23, 2022 @08:28PM (#33311685)
> pushback from the legal system regarding standing

well that's just cold.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by pnw on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:22AM (#33306793)
That is nice karma. I hope the prison has an ADA accessible ramp.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by lupire on Sunday October 23, 2022 @08:26PM (#33311677)
He was punished only because he got greedy and under reported taxes on his legal grift.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by cma on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:19PM (#33294750)
Why doesn't the government instead subsidize an auto-captioning device or software for deaf users, so every site, even foreign and outside jurisdiction would work?
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by robocat on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:30PM (#33294804)
How is the law firm profiting?

As a New Zealander, I think only the government can enforce similar laws. I am unsure whether a private citizen could get representation here, or whether there could be any civil penalties.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by nicbou on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:42PM (#33295209)
They send an Abmahnung, which is similar to a cease and desist, but can include costs.

You can refuse the cost and prepare for a possibly expensive battle, or pay the costs and call it a day.

Usually, you are guilty of the minor crime you're accused of, so they have a case.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by robocat on Saturday October 22, 2022 @08:54PM (#33303557)
If you refuse, is there a second level of "extortion" from the lawyers?
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by nicbou on Sunday October 23, 2022 @12:45AM (#33304626)
They can take you to court. You can call their bluff if you believe that you have a case.

The problem is that your lawyer will never tell you "just pay them" if they can suggest that you have a chance in court. That's how they get paid after all.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by abigail95 on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:10PM (#33300088)
The NZ Human Rights Act provides the same mechanism for people to sue private companies that don't provide accessible services.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by devoutsalsa on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:46AM (#33296582)
Reminds me of an SF attorney who teams with a guy in a wheelchair to sue locations that don’t have ADA compliant facilities.

“Wheelchairs of Fortune”

https://web.archive.org/web/20220209194711/https://archives....