News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by camillomiller on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:39PM (#33293327)
Currently in Germany there’s a wave of lawyers letters making the rounds. They claim a website violates the privacy of some dummy client when they accessed the website and their IP was transmitted to Google’s servers to download Google Fonts from the cloud. I’ve been putting in some extra hours this week to help scared clients localize their Google Fonts. The wave started after an half-assed sentence from a court in Munich back in January decided that Google Fonts server seeing a user’s IP number is a punishable privacy violation.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by slyall on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:57PM (#33293446)
I have a small website that happens to be hosted in Germany since a German company donated a server.

We had to add an "Impressum" with our contact details to make sure we didn't get hit with a letter demanding money from one of the law firms that specialise in shaking down sites that are missing them.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by nicbou on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:40PM (#33295198)
You can just tell them to sod off. The Impressum requirement is for German commercial websites. If you are not bound by this law, you don't have to obey it.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by iggldiggl on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:31AM (#33318032)
1. The legal definition of what's "commercial" under that law and what's not isn't necessarily quite as straightforward as a layman might think. (For one, that law doesn't literally say "commercial" ("gewerbsmäßig"), but rather "geschäftsmäßig" ("business-like"), which apparently can be interpreted to not require an intent to make money, but instead to include anything you plan on regularly doing).

2. Assuming you're referring to the Telemediengesetz, there's a second law (Medienstaatsvertrag) which mandates an imprint for anything that's not strictly for "personal or family purposes". Depending on who you ask, those two terms also require a rather narrow reading, so anything beyond a strictly private family diary (careful not to make references to any outside persons or businesses, though, because those entities will then have a legal interest in being able to identify you in case you malign them!) or family pictures or your private Dropbox replacement (ideally all the above should be password-protected and therefore not accessible by the general public anyway) might again already be in a grey area.

2b. Additionally, blogs can enter another grey area where depending on what and how you're blogging about, they might be classified as a journalistic service offering and therefore require an extended imprint, too.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by BrandoElFollito on Saturday October 22, 2022 @05:17AM (#33296721)
So what could happen, in practical terms?

If you are not located in Germany and do not have business there (I mean monetary business, one you can draw money from) then good luck for them trying to get something from you.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by gigel82 on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:22PM (#33294002)
I mean... it is, isn't it?

Google is specifically known to be using their fonts for tracking users across the web.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by treeman79 on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:32AM (#33295868)
Never thought about that. And now my weekend plans have changed…
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by subroutine on Saturday October 22, 2022 @03:03AM (#33296176)
Source?
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by gingerlime on Saturday October 22, 2022 @08:44AM (#33297876)
I’m not sure this is the issue precisely. However there’s been rulings that ban using Google analytics simply because doing so means the user sends a request to Google, and the user IP address is considered personal data (look up Schrems II). The same applies to Google fonts or anything hosted by Google.

The interesting thing specifically about the fonts case is that, unlike other privacy regulation that defines only fines, and not compensation/damages (fines are levied by the data protection authorities). However in the font case there was a precedent that awarded damages to the claimant in the tune of 500€. Now we see a wave of ambulance chasing lawyers exploiting this ruling to shake up companies. Sad, but potentially useful for privacy. IANAL and all that jazz.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by subroutine on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:15AM (#33304757)
OP said "Google is specifically known to be using their fonts for tracking users across the web."

I mean... is it?

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by gigel82 on Saturday October 22, 2022 @11:46AM (#33299254)
Here's Google's 1st hit for "Google Fonts privacy", you can find more: https://www.brycewray.com/posts/2020/08/google-fonts-privacy...
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by subroutine on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:11AM (#33304739)
If you are going to cite an article, make sure it provides an answer to the prompt. There is nothing in this article that can't be inferred directly from the google fonts privacy policy.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by camillomiller on Saturday October 22, 2022 @07:25AM (#33297357)
Sure thing, which is why I always call fonts locally. The problem is how adequate is the compensation for the violation. Some law firms ask for amounts close to 500€, and that’s bonkers. Also, most of them automate the website visit with a spoof user, which is easy to prove and immediately discredits their request. Unfortunately nobody does because you need to hire a lawyer and it’s cheaper to just pay and be done with it.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by bmacho on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:36PM (#33294470)
Well you have a choice.

Give all of your users data to google, endanger them, and break the law for not a single cent benefit, or you don't do that.

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by bmacho on Friday October 21, 2022 @08:53PM (#33294574)
Just put it in your GDPR disclaimer that you send all of your users online time, location, interest, activity on the site, and unique identifiers to attach these data with other data to a foreign countries company for no actual reason; and if they don't want that they cannot do anything about it, and you are fine. Also the GDPR law is only 6 years old I think if you say you've never heard of it, you can get away with that.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Ylpertnodi on Saturday October 22, 2022 @05:26AM (#33296752)
>Also the GDPR law is only 6 years old I think if you say you've never heard of it, you can get away with that.

"I'm sorry Officer, I didn't know I couldn't do that."

https://youtu.be/FclScfPoKes?t=595

Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by Schroedingersat on Saturday October 22, 2022 @06:21AM (#33297002)
...good? That's what google fonts is for.
Re:Thanks to the Israeli accessibility law, I have to delete... by ezoe on Saturday October 22, 2022 @12:24PM (#33299668)
Just like EU cookie law, it's a really stupid judgement. It's you, your computer and your web browser who download the fonts from Google server, not the web server in Germany.

All the web server do is presenting the URL to the google server. You should be responsible for the behaviour of your computer and the web browser run on top of it.