News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ilikeitdark on Thursday October 20, 2022 @04:56PM (#33280566)
I'm living in Barcelona, I don't own a car (and hopefully never will need to) and I'm a fan of getting rid of cars in downtown areas. But there are few downsides. Horrible pollution while they are making them, due to street closures (I'm right next to a new one under construction and I've never experienced air pollution this bad in my 20 years here. It's horrible walking my kids to school. And it will be a 9 month construction job). Also once the superblocks are built, crime increases (no traffic ie witnesses) and rents increase (pedestrian friendly area!). This has happened in other superblock areas near me.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by RobertoG on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:06PM (#33280697)
Crime increase and rents increase? That's some surprising finding. What are those superblocks where that happened exactly? And where is the 9 month construction job?
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by judge2020 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:31PM (#33281665)
I can definitely see rents increase. A walkable city is one where you don’t need a car (you only need to rent one if you go on a road trip or you can fly/bus to wherever you like) NOR car insurance. Given that, if you’re an apartment management company, and your prospective tenants have an extra $100-500 a month in change, would you or would you not raise rents, given the demand for an apartment in a walkable city is huge?
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by jeffalyanak on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:42PM (#33281765)
I guess the surprise comes from the fact that there's a lot of supply as well.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by lmm on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:43PM (#33281782)
It's the idea of both at once that's implausible. Making it more walkable would gentrify it and raise rents? Sure, I can see that. But the idea that this would also somehow increase crime? Pedestrians are much more able to see or intervene in a crime than drivers are.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by TEP_Kim_Il_Sung on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:34PM (#33282266)
I wonder if using tools like https://communitycrimemap.com would help with city design. Just off the glances I've made: Most crimes happen in easily accessible areas with clear getaway routes, almost no crimes happen at the center cul de sac of a neighbourhood.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by lazyasciiart on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:47PM (#33282792)
Sounds like an explanation there - pedestrians see and are involved with more crime, reported crime rates go up?
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by weberer on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:05AM (#33286738)
Crime does tend to increase with population density.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by pessimizer on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:09PM (#33289594)
Muggers and burglars travel to gentrified neighborhoods to work, because it's a completely rational thing to do.

> Pedestrians are much more able to see or intervene in a crime than drivers are.

Pedestrians are easier to watch and carefully evaluate, also, and will not always be around; you can follow a target and wait until they are safe to rob. People in cars are a mystery, and near active streets a constant one.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by Atsuii on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:52PM (#33281885)
Given the state of rent prices globally in western countries I really have to question if the increases you're seeing are attributed to 'superblocks' or just general inflation. If the rent is increasing due to 'superblocks' it's going to be because people prefer living within them rather than traditional blocks, hence they can command more rent, not because there is suddenly spare change that was once spent on a car.

Also I don't think pollution is specific to this type of construction. Any type of full scale construction in urban environments causes terrible pollution and pest issues for the adjacent blocks.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by judge2020 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:09PM (#33282018)
I never said anything about current rents, just that superblocks and general walkability are in extremely high demand, so rents will reflect that.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by robswc on Thursday October 20, 2022 @09:37PM (#33283224)
Why can't it be both? By moving there, you're effectively signaling you don't have a car. Those without cars (all else being equal, not sure why it wouldn't be) will have extra money. If the place is desirable, what is to stop those with that new "extra money" from using that to outbid those with less money?

I don't at all doubt its also inflation at play. It seems perfectly reasonable tho that a place that generally has car-less renters would have higher prices as those without cars could afford that added price. To an extent of course.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by idlehand on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:58AM (#33284973)
So the problem is really that regulations have constrained the supply of housing to the point that rents are set as high as people can afford, rather than at the price of replacement.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by sokoloff on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:30AM (#33286516)
Rents in places where demand exceeds supply are like that (and probably always will be).
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by robswc on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:23AM (#33288273)
Well, how much more could realistically be built? I agree, not a fan of housing supply being kept artificially low... but as they say "someone has to have the beach houses."

If there's only 100 units in a car-less block and 500 ppl that want them, what could be done if you've reached the limit of what can be built?

I guess you could go up, making sky scrapers... but now I have to admit I'm out of my element. Not sure if that's viable.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by m463 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:01PM (#33281950)
re rent increase - I wonder if the future is becoming a giant hyper-efficient machine meant to extract maximum value from "consumers"? basically efficient rent-seeking in the literal sense

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking

I wonder what can be the counter to this?

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by judge2020 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:03PM (#33282500)
Zoning fixes and dense, walkable city planning is the solution. It's just that there would need to be some law from the top level of government, eg. on a national or state level, to force cities have a certain minimum amount of high-density development every year. Because, right now, these cities adhere to their constituents who all would prefer if the supply remained stagnant so that their property values can continue to increase well past whatever they're paying for their monthly mortgage payment.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by sokoloff on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:36AM (#33286558)
I’m staunchly opposed to a national or state government forcing a certain type of development onto cities.

Forcing the approval of some type of permits and permitting high density development in some amount/type of area is much more reasonable and executable. (If a city were falling short of the originally proposed mandated housing, what entity would have to make up the shortfall and how would you force them to build a development they’re not asking to build?)

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by eesmith on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:14AM (#33287657)
One of the zoning fixes along the lines judge2020 mentioned is to remove the parking minimum requirements, which already forces a certain type of development onto cities.

Another is to remove zoning laws preventing secondary suites / in-law apartments / granny flats / etc. These also force a certain type of development onto cities.

Another fix - not so much zoning though - is to move to 10' lanes instead of 12'. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-06/why-12-fo... , which again forces a certain type of development onto cities.

After decades of existing forced development, it too easily becomes the baseline of what is "normal."

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by sokoloff on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:21AM (#33287714)
I think that all of those examples are AHJs imposing restrictions on themselves, rather than someone else imposing restrictions on them from outside/containment.

I have no problem with cities imposing restrictions on cities, as that is amenable to democratic review by the voters in that city. Having a national imposition on a city would be objectionable to me on principle (and in the US, would very likely violate the 10th Amendment).

AHJ - authorities having jurisdiction, basically "whoever sets and enforces the codes"

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by judge2020 on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:53AM (#33287999)
My point is that nothing will ever change if this governing structure continues. By law, cities only protect their constituents, so any high-density development is going to encounter insane barriers since the increased competition within the area would drop values of nearby single-family homes, and cities will be made aware of this by the NIMBYs that show up at city hall meetings to push back against the development.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by sokoloff on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:46AM (#33288533)
I don't have a serious objection nor see a constitutional challenge to having a state impose restrictions upon itself or its cities. (The same thing done federally is the problem.)

That still leaves the problem in your original proposal of "how exactly do you plan to enforce the required level of high-density development if no one is asking to do it?"

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by eesmith on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:01PM (#33289495)
I regard your objection as naive.

The National 55 MPH speed limit shows the federal government, through the power of the purse, can have a strong influence on state traffic laws.

The history of zoning shows how the State Standard Zoning Enabling Act - a federal work - can influence the states to change.

There appear to be easy ways to tweak judge2020's proposal to make it better reflect demand, but I don't care to argue that issue.

> AHJs imposing restrictions on themselves

judge2020's point is that zoning laws support current residents, not future residents, so AHJs have a systemic bias against making these changes.

judge2020's proposal is to look towards the democratically elected bodies which have a wider scope.

As a concrete example, California recently made it easier to build mother-in-law units (ADUs in CA terms), by reducing the requirements cities and counties can enforce. See https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesfinancecouncil/2020/03/12... . This law is why I mentioned mother-in-law units as an example.

That change in California law has no constitutional issues like what you are opposed to.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by sokoloff on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:23PM (#33289789)
I agree (and said) that a state law has no such US Constitutional concern.

If CA voters can’t manage to do this for CA, it doesn’t seem like it’s going to be any easier to get it to pass federally.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by eesmith on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:14PM (#33291222)
I pointed to an example of a "this" they did.

Just because it isn't easy doesn't mean judge2020 isn't right.

You said you staunchly oppose a state government forcing a certain type of development onto cities, without explaining why you oppose it, nor stating if you support the current forced state of development.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by sokoloff on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:36PM (#33292173)
I don’t object to a state government setting restrictions on their cities’ zoning rules.

I do oppose states “[forcing] cities [to] have a certain minimum amount of high-density development every year” because it’s not at all obvious how to implement forcing development that is not supported or requested by developers.

I have no significant objections to the current level of state restrictions in my state of MA, in which no developers are forced to develop property against their wishes.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ajmurmann on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:40AM (#33289187)
The problem is that democracy doesn't seem to be working well on that level and is negatively impacting people outside that narrow scope as well.

If you poll people if we should build more in their city, you get a majority in favor. Then you get community meetings in which a vocal minority that can actually afford (typically better off and older) to go to community meetings and create pressure shoot down projects or cripples them.

On a larger scope you have folks who are denied economic opportunity due to housing policy that gets set by people who are already in, but kick away the ladder for everyone else. As a concrete example, I know lots of people who'd love to live (again) in SF in part due to the job market, but cannot or it would be super hard for them.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ajmurmann on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:30AM (#33289063)
Another one that's obvious to me: Removing unit-size minimums. In places like SF people are defacto already hacking around the minimum by having room mates. If nobody wants small units, the market will not provide them.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by weberer on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:11AM (#33286773)
Buy your own home. Refuse subscription plans. Refuse X-as-a-service offerings. Don't buy products that you're not allowed to resell (digital games, software, etc).
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by Bakary on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:29AM (#33287795)
Most of the 20th century has been a series of attempts to answer this question. We'll have another wave of attempts of a different sort over the coming decades.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by dirtyid on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:46PM (#33281813)
Wonder how much of rent increase is attributed to airbnb.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ajmurmann on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:51PM (#33281873)
I wonder if the crime increases in absolute numbers, but goes down per capita. This phenomenon frequently gives cities a bad rep, even though you might actually be safer.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by jeegsy on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:38PM (#33282303)
> I wonder if the crime increases in absolute numbers, but goes down per capita.

You might probably be right but its nevertheless amusing the way statistics can render things banal in a weird way

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by weberer on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:42AM (#33286975)
Nope, it goes up per-capita as well.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ajmurmann on Sunday October 23, 2022 @09:28PM (#33312036)
Ugh, I read a few days ago that per capita crime is lower in cities. Tried to find numbers about it and you are correct. Kinda concerning that you got a bunch of downvotes for being correct and I got upvotes despite being wrong.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by agilob on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:54AM (#33284653)
> Crime increase and rents increase? That's some surprising finding.

Same in the UK, rent is up all over the country, breaking in, flytipping, private and public areas devastation is up. Local media don't even care to report on knife attacks in major cities.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by rmason on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:31AM (#33284837)
I wonder if they've tried putting up cameras everywhere? It made a huge difference in downtown Detroit. First the billionaire Dan Gilbert bought up most of the empty buildings downtown and put cameras everywhere. Course he hired his own quick response security force to arrest and hold criminals until the DPD could arrive. I've personally walked the streets near Campus Martius at 2 am and felt personally safe.

It worked so well that the city and the DPD started the Green Light program. They worked with gas stations putting up cameras and put together teams of dedicated officers for a quick response. The result was that it drastically reduced car jackings and gas station robberies. Now they've done the same thing at liquor stores and are talking about expanding it to other cooperating merchants. Cameras only work if they are being monitored and the police respond quickly.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ls15 on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:06AM (#33285011)
Not everything that technically works should be done.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by sokoloff on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:39AM (#33286581)
True, but I can’t muster any concern in favor of car jackers, gas station, or liquor store robbers.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by Ekaros on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:33AM (#33285161)
I wonder how long that would work, and when they would start reducing resources to it to save money.

Critical part isn't the monitoring, but availability of enforcement. Having enough units just walking around would probably have similar effect.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by mantas on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:41AM (#33286594)
Crime follows money. Wether going to better-off city parts or even travelling internationally. Not only targets are more wealthy, but „you don't shit where you eat“ is important too. You don't want to accidentally rob a friend's friend's friend...

For example here in bum fuck eastern europe, after we joined Schengen, street crime dropped in no time. Lots of „street professionals“ went to much more wealthy Western europe. Some packed up and left. Others leave for tours and come back home to live on income from stolen stuff.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msoad on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:01PM (#33280638)
I'm not sure if chopped corners area a required feature of Super Blocks but man those are annoying zebra lines... You have to walk 10 meters more to use the zebra line on each intersection!
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by RobertoG on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:08PM (#33280716)
I assume you are talking about L'Eixample. That's the original design of that specific neighborhood and have nothing to do with the superblocks thing.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by Swizec on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:09PM (#33280735)
Scramble intersections can fix this. Let all pedestrians in every direction go first, then coordinate cars, then back to pedestrians.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedestrian_scramble

And I thought 2nd paragraph from Wikipedia offers an interesting insight on cultural priorities:

> It was first used in Canada and the United States in the late 1940s, but it later fell out of favor with traffic engineers there, as it was seen as prioritizing flow of pedestrians over flow of car traffic. Its benefits for pedestrian amenity and safety have led to new examples being installed in many countries in recent years

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by scrumbledober on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:13PM (#33280788)
I think they still do, but they at least used to have this in the SF Financial District, it was always fun walking out to lunch with hordes of people all crossing the street whichever way they wanted, including diagonally through the intersection.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by jlmorton on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:16PM (#33280843)
They really need to put down some "suggested path" markings.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ghaff on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:09PM (#33282016)
In big eastern US cities, there's been much more of a "whatever won't get you run down" approach to intersections than was historically the case out west. At least a couple decades ago, western cities had a reputation for ticketing pedestrians for crossing against lights that would have been laughable in e.g. NYC.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by borbulon on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:44AM (#33286608)
9 years ago when I worked in Downtown Seattle, crossing against the light could get you a ticket, even at 630 in the morning. Nobody was driving, and they still insisted that you wait.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by FpUser on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:52PM (#33281877)
We have this type of intersection in Toronto, Canada. Yonge & Bloor I think.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by SECProto on Thursday October 20, 2022 @10:30PM (#33283753)
> man those are annoying zebra lines... You have to walk 10 meters more to use the zebra line on each intersection!

Unless you are trying to cross perpendicularly, then you have to walk 10 meters less. Averages out to being similar (and isn't annoying to use in person).

Regardless, it shortens the crossing length, and puts crossing pedestrians at a perpendicular angle to turning drivers, both of which drastically increase pedestrian safety.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by frontiersummit on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:25PM (#33280974)
Superblocks seem like they would be super-fun for a 24-year-old single or someone visiting on holiday, but would be a logistical nightmare for a young family. Is this so? or am I a frog stuck in a car-dependency well?
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by diordiderot on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:30PM (#33281039)
Great for young families.

Some superblocks sometimes have parks or playgrounds, you never have to worry about your kids getting run over or thrown in the back of a van, more people hang out outside because it isn't sulfery or loud.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by tayo42 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:10PM (#33282550)
i never want to live around kids or playgrounds again though. right now families dump their kids into the streets after school. its a nightmare to live around. the noise is non stop
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by robswc on Thursday October 20, 2022 @09:39PM (#33283254)
Might be unpopular but completely agree. I once lived next to a dog park. I love dogs... but damn, lol. People yelling at their dogs. Dogs barking at other dogs. Dogs whining, dogs howling... it was awful.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by agilob on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:01AM (#33284694)
> it isn't sulfery or loud.

I lived in one super-like-block in Poland and noise was the reason I had to move out. About 200 flats facing each other, you need only one person to ruin day or night for everyone there. One party at night and you have 600 people who couldn't sleep. One specific neighbour was listening to music from loudspeakers literally all day causing echo in the block. She turned volume up when cleaning and vacuuming, she had to still hear the music WHILE vacuuming. Never want to live to such block ever again, not anywhere close.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by diordiderot on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:06AM (#33286749)
I'm confused as to how being in superblock changes that.

That's just living in a city _shrug_

If rather hear kids playing at 3pm than youths on ATVs or random mopeds at 3am

Edit: I think you may be misinterpreting the definition of a superblock

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by agilob on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:13PM (#33291204)
I live in a city now, but the closest supermarket is 6km away. I hear no loud noises, unless it's dogs barking, cats fighting or deer barking. Population density in this area is (probably) a 600x smaller, so I'm less at risk of hearing someones' music while they are vacuuming, losing my mind and not being able to work. Absolutely never going back to dense population and blocks with noise and crime.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by xapata on Saturday October 22, 2022 @02:46PM (#33300933)
> live in a city

> never going back to dense population

We have different interpretations of "living in a city".

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by xapata on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:46PM (#33281252)
You are stuck in a car-dependency well.

As the parent of a young child, I wish very much for more car-free space around my house. Otherwise I need to pack her in the car to get some running-around space.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by NegativeLatency on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:34PM (#33281697)
Once the environment is safe for kids you don't have to do as many logistics for your children.

You might be interested in this "Not Just Bikes" video about raising kids in non car dependent places: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHlpmxLTxpw

or this one about kids who bike to school in a group for safety: https://bikeportland.org/2022/10/13/portlands-bike-bus-featu...

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ideamotor on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:31AM (#33285478)
Ugh that youtube video made me so angry and is seriously making me reconsider my current job options (one is based in Europe), as I have a kid on the way. However, I feel that what is healthy for active people and kids is too demanding for, say, my elderly parents. This summer I spent a month in Europe and definitely observed very few elderly persons and many times where I had to walk or climb stairs.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by NegativeLatency on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:27PM (#33300226)
I’ve had similar thoughts. Not sure where you live but there are local groups in many cities you can join that do transportation advocacy and stuff.

The coverage of the bike bus stuff made me cry because it just felt so special and gave me hope for the future.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by dirtyid on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:49PM (#33281846)
Helps to not have harsh winters as well.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by NegativeLatency on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:57PM (#33281915)
Building and maintaining good infrastructure can easily overcome bad weather though: https://torontoist.com/2017/02/what-toronto-can-learn-about-...
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by dirtyid on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:29PM (#33282213)
One thing to build the infra but another to convince families to bike during Toronto winter.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:17PM (#33280862)
> I'm a fan of getting rid of cars in downtown areas.

I have two questions:

Do emergency services count as cars?

Do people who have to take call to provide emergency medical care still get to use cars?

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by diordiderot on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:34PM (#33281090)
> Do emergency services count as cars?

No

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Thursday October 20, 2022 @09:14PM (#33282991)
Object lesson in why you always ask one question:

If you ask two, people answer the less interesting one to the exclusion of the other.

So emergency vehicles can drive in. Can emergency workers drive out?

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by rdedev on Thursday October 20, 2022 @11:25PM (#33284137)
One solution to this is to have special vehicles to take emergency workers or doctors from their home to the hospital or where ever they need to be. It's also better than just them driving to the hospital. They don't need to worry about traffic and such
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Thursday October 20, 2022 @11:47PM (#33284293)
> One solution to this is to have special vehicles to take emergency workers or doctors from their home to the hospital or where ever they need to be. It's also better than just them driving to the hospital. They don't need to worry about traffic and such

That doesn't solve the problem, which is OK, in that I don't expect people here to understand how being on call works.

Basically, it's like a leash centered on the hospital: You can be anywhere, as long as you can get to the hospital in a certain amount of time when you get called in. This roughly correlates with distance, but not entirely: When my dad was on call in a town with a railroad track running through it, he had to stay on the right side of the tracks because a long coal train would blow his response time. (It was a small town.) The point is, though, they aren't fixed at home when they're on call, and being fixed at home would destroy their lives. My dad had to be on call fully 50% of the time when he lived in aforesaid small town, because he was 50% of that town's total anesthesia providers.

Therefore, unless you propose a chauffeur, they will be driving their own vehicles while they're on call.

On a deeper level, changing how being on call works would require changing how small of a town people are allowed to live in. This seems like a common problem: People come up with something that they might be able to make work in New York City, and think they've Solved The Problem, blissfully unaware of St. Louis, let alone Du Quoin.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by rdedev on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:16AM (#33284768)
I mean the topic is about places with dense residencies. You asked specifically what the rules could be for emergency vehicles/people working for emergency services. I wasn't proposing a solution for small towns.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:42AM (#33285931)
OK, I went off on a tangent there, but I figured the question I asked wasn't going to get an answer and I started talking about a larger trend I've noticed in this general space. (The other trend being people ignoring and downvoting questions they can't engage with without poking holes in their utopia.)
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by idlehand on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:03AM (#33284993)
Small towns don't have the problems that motivate the construction of super blocks.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by housingisaright on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:29PM (#33281029)
cars or other vehicles required to provide services prohibited. The aim is to make people use other modes of transportation than their cars in these areas.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ghaff on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:51PM (#33281867)
Pedestrian areas basically always allow vehicles for emergency services, deliveries, tradespeople, etc. where practical. And there can actually be a fair number of vehicles especially at certain times of the day.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by pjerem on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:30AM (#33284513)
You know that you can design pedestrians areas that can accept emergency trafic ? Most European city centers that are closed to individual cars still accept emergency vehicles, buses, and even delivery trucks (generally during a fixed span of time in the day) and taxis.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by diordiderot on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:36AM (#33285516)
> Do people who have to take call to provide emergency medical care still get to use cars?

It's 5pm Friday in NYC, you're 10 blocks from the hospital and get paged? You walk or ride a bike. Any city not built in the American car centric design, biking is faster

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by hourago on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:28AM (#33287784)
> Do people who have to take call to provide emergency medical care still get to use cars?

That is a good argument against shopping malls or high rise buildings, as they are bigger and vastly most inaccessible than superblocks. If shopping malls and similar structures are safe, superblocks are safer.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by anigbrowl on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:17PM (#33281531)
I envy you a bit. Living in an urban residential area i'm just now getting to the end of 2.5 years of poorly managed construction by the private landlord next to my own home. I got to the point of initiating legal action before they decided to cash out their investment and sell the property to a charitable foundation, who have been far easier to deal with.

I do feel you on the problems, but the idea of the construction job being complete in only a 9 month timeframe sounds like a luxury.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by andrepd on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:41PM (#33281761)
> Also once the superblocks are built, crime increases (no traffic ie witnesses)

No offense but this sounds like a classic reactionary anti-bike cliché, so would you mind sharing some sources?

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by godmode2019 on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:10PM (#33282025)
Would you rather your wife walk in a park during the day or night?

The OP is drawing some pretty common sense conclusions, they are essential turning busy streets into quiet alleyways.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by SECProto on Thursday October 20, 2022 @10:34PM (#33283779)
> Would you rather your wife walk in a park during the day or night?

Would you rather walk on a highway shoulder or a residential street?

Ears on the street is what matters, not cars on the road.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by lmm on Thursday October 20, 2022 @11:12PM (#33284047)
Much of the point of the idea is that you can fit more humans in the same street space by not having each one drag their own a living room around with them. And a pedestrian is in a much better position to notice (or indeed intervene in) a crime than a driver is.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by amusedcyclist on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:59AM (#33284684)
He asked for proof not for cliches
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by crote on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:25AM (#33285823)
No, they are replacing cars (who solely look at the road ahead of them) with pedestrians (who are actually using the space and looking around).

In fact, there will be more people on the streets. The lack of cars makes it possible to use the spare space for playgrounds, skate parks, outdoor restaurant seating, additional shops, et cetera. And the streets don't suddenly narrow: they are still 70 feet wide, they don't magically turn into tiny alleyways the second you remove car traffic.

I can tell you from experience that many well-designed parks are even very busy after nightfall. No reason to feel afraid when there are literally a hundred people within eyesight.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by TulliusCicero on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:43PM (#33282346)
> rents increase (pedestrian friendly area!). This has happened in other superblock areas near me.

This happens whenever you improve anything in a city. The solution is to make the improvements everywhere if you can. We obviously can't stop making nice things just because it makes some areas more desirable.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by epistasis on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:04PM (#33282505)
The Henry George Theorem states that when there are government improvements (which I would probably expand to any improvements), then the land rents increase at least as much as spending.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_George_theorem

The remedy (at least according to Henry George) is to not only continue improving, but also to tax away the land rents, and most likely distribute them equally to all residents.

This also means that whenever there's an improvement to, say, transit that is actually beneficial to the community, it can be more than self-funding by taxing land rents.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by TulliusCicero on Thursday October 20, 2022 @10:54PM (#33283902)
Yeah I'd love to see some value capture in the West.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by adv0r on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:39AM (#33284580)
crimes??
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by yosito on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:50AM (#33284925)
I'd be willing to bet that the air pollution from a 9 month construction job is outweighed by the air pollution from steady car traffic for years. And as someone who has been robbed in traffic multiple times, I don't think traffic witnesses stop crime. Pedestrian witnesses and good lighting might though. Yeah, property values and rent might go up, but that's hardly an argument against environmental improvements.