News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:17PM (#33280862)
> I'm a fan of getting rid of cars in downtown areas.

I have two questions:

Do emergency services count as cars?

Do people who have to take call to provide emergency medical care still get to use cars?

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by diordiderot on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:34PM (#33281090)
> Do emergency services count as cars?

No

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Thursday October 20, 2022 @09:14PM (#33282991)
Object lesson in why you always ask one question:

If you ask two, people answer the less interesting one to the exclusion of the other.

So emergency vehicles can drive in. Can emergency workers drive out?

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by rdedev on Thursday October 20, 2022 @11:25PM (#33284137)
One solution to this is to have special vehicles to take emergency workers or doctors from their home to the hospital or where ever they need to be. It's also better than just them driving to the hospital. They don't need to worry about traffic and such
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Thursday October 20, 2022 @11:47PM (#33284293)
> One solution to this is to have special vehicles to take emergency workers or doctors from their home to the hospital or where ever they need to be. It's also better than just them driving to the hospital. They don't need to worry about traffic and such

That doesn't solve the problem, which is OK, in that I don't expect people here to understand how being on call works.

Basically, it's like a leash centered on the hospital: You can be anywhere, as long as you can get to the hospital in a certain amount of time when you get called in. This roughly correlates with distance, but not entirely: When my dad was on call in a town with a railroad track running through it, he had to stay on the right side of the tracks because a long coal train would blow his response time. (It was a small town.) The point is, though, they aren't fixed at home when they're on call, and being fixed at home would destroy their lives. My dad had to be on call fully 50% of the time when he lived in aforesaid small town, because he was 50% of that town's total anesthesia providers.

Therefore, unless you propose a chauffeur, they will be driving their own vehicles while they're on call.

On a deeper level, changing how being on call works would require changing how small of a town people are allowed to live in. This seems like a common problem: People come up with something that they might be able to make work in New York City, and think they've Solved The Problem, blissfully unaware of St. Louis, let alone Du Quoin.

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by rdedev on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:16AM (#33284768)
I mean the topic is about places with dense residencies. You asked specifically what the rules could be for emergency vehicles/people working for emergency services. I wasn't proposing a solution for small towns.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by msla on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:42AM (#33285931)
OK, I went off on a tangent there, but I figured the question I asked wasn't going to get an answer and I started talking about a larger trend I've noticed in this general space. (The other trend being people ignoring and downvoting questions they can't engage with without poking holes in their utopia.)
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by idlehand on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:03AM (#33284993)
Small towns don't have the problems that motivate the construction of super blocks.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by housingisaright on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:29PM (#33281029)
cars or other vehicles required to provide services prohibited. The aim is to make people use other modes of transportation than their cars in these areas.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by ghaff on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:51PM (#33281867)
Pedestrian areas basically always allow vehicles for emergency services, deliveries, tradespeople, etc. where practical. And there can actually be a fair number of vehicles especially at certain times of the day.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by pjerem on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:30AM (#33284513)
You know that you can design pedestrians areas that can accept emergency trafic ? Most European city centers that are closed to individual cars still accept emergency vehicles, buses, and even delivery trucks (generally during a fixed span of time in the day) and taxis.
Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by diordiderot on Friday October 21, 2022 @03:36AM (#33285516)
> Do people who have to take call to provide emergency medical care still get to use cars?

It's 5pm Friday in NYC, you're 10 blocks from the hospital and get paged? You walk or ride a bike. Any city not built in the American car centric design, biking is faster

Re:Barcelona-style “superblocks” could make cities greener a... by hourago on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:28AM (#33287784)
> Do people who have to take call to provide emergency medical care still get to use cars?

That is a good argument against shopping malls or high rise buildings, as they are bigger and vastly most inaccessible than superblocks. If shopping malls and similar structures are safe, superblocks are safer.