News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:06AM (#33200451)
Firing easily and hiring easily are two sides of the same coin. If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily. If companies can go down quickly, new companies can be formed in an instant.

In Europe where firing is almost impossible, hiring is a very tedious process. Companies are big and look financially stable because the little ones cannot survive or dont enjoy the same monopoly / legal protections.

If a company is not useful to society, it should go down. If you're not a good fit with the company, you should find your own way or a better company.

Don't idealize employment and companies. They are only tools on our path to wealth and freedom

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by tsimionescu on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:07AM (#33200852)
> In Europe where firing is almost impossible, hiring is a very tedious process.

I don't know where you got this idea, but, at least in tech, the most infamous 7 rounds of whiteboard interviews stories I've heard are from Silicon Valley, not Europe. The company I work for (a Romanian branch of a US company - and yes, Romania has all the same legal protections against t firing as most of Europe) typically does one tech interview and one HR interview and that's it.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:09AM (#33200867)
We shouldn't compare big SV companies with the rest of the world though. Of course companies that are in high demand have a lot of people applying at their job and have harder / longer interview processes
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by rob74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:23AM (#33200960)
So, in that case, getting hired is hard, but getting fired is just as easy as for less in-demand companies? And also, in an economic downturn, the companies are free to fire people, but getting a new job will become considerably more difficult. So I'm afraid I don't really see the "easy to get fired/easy to get hired" symmetry that you talked about in your first post...
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:32AM (#33201038)
Is it easy to get fired from a big SV company ? Anyway, I am not talking about one specific company, I am talking about society as a whole. Read the OP's fear about being fired
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by mathverse on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:26AM (#33200986)
Your perception is skewed because Romania is a hotspot for companies to outsource to. There's a lot of companies hiring in Romania and the employers are not as picky.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by oblio on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:54AM (#33201846)
His point was, and I can confirm this, in Europe companies generally have simpler interviews.

Frequently, especially for seniors, it's a technical chat. I have anecdata from about 6 European countries.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by tsimionescu on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:44AM (#33202250)
Having lots of options usually leads to more complex processes, to try to find the best candidate. It's when you have a position open for 2 months with no submissions that you typically start lowering your bar.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by AndrewThrowaway on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:34AM (#33200632)
This is just so wrong on so many levels.

> If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily.

Unless it is another economical crisis and nobody is hiring?

> In Europe where firing is almost impossible

It is called "job security" - if you hired somebody, you "promised" them to pay a wage. If they are not needed anymore, you need to keep on promise and pay a wage. For at least some time. E.g. a few month of salary seems reasonable because a person has planned his future with you, now he needs to find a new job which will take some time.

So it is not impossible in Europe. It is expensive at most because it only looks reasonable.

> Companies are big and look financially stable

Unless you count all the mom and pop cafes all over the Mediterranean? All the Scandinavian startups? And etc.?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by charlieyu1 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:19AM (#33200945)
There are definitely companies who spend more during economical crisis. Because everything costs less and it costs less to expand your business.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:17AM (#33201620)
> Because everything costs less and it costs less to expand your business.

What's become cheaper in the current economic crisis?

There are by definition, fewer jobs available in total during an economic crisis. More competition for those positions also makes it likely that living standards will decrease.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:55PM (#33206032)
> What's become cheaper in the current economic crisis?

Good point. In all the others I’ve lived though, something has, but not this time.

Shares have got cheaper and savings are being hit due to inflation being so high. It’s a good time to spend but what do you buy?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:29AM (#33201011)
> For at least some time. E.g. a few month of salary seems reasonable because a person has planned his future with you, now he needs to find a new job which will take some time.

I realize I speak from a privileged position as a software developer. But never since the first day that I stepped into an office as a professional software developer in June of 1996 did I “plan a future” with a company.

My plan was always to use where I worked as a stepping stone for my next job. I spent my first two years saving money and building my resume. I have spent most of my career “with my running shoes on”. Meaning I’m always prepared for a layoff or to leave when the pay/bullshit ratio is going in the wrong direction.

My employer owes me nothing besides to pay me for the hours I worked. When that arrangement isn’t working for either of us, we both have agency and the ability to terminate that arrangement.

> Unless it is another economical crisis and nobody is hiring?

I lived through both the 2000 crash and 2008-2011. The 2000 crash wasn’t bad if you had both skills and was working in many major cities in the US as just a regular old enterprise developer working for profitable non tech companies.

2008 was worse. But as a developer, you could find a contract somewhere if you had a network.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by matsemann on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:54AM (#33201167)
> But never since the first day that I stepped into an office as a professional software developer in June of 1996 did I “plan a future” with a company.

You're missing the point. It's that you're planning your future on having income from the company you currently work for. In Europe they can't pull the rug from under you and say "good luck with your mortgage, you're fired today". Instead they have to say "you are fired, but will receive 3 months of pay while you find something else". So yes, I disagree that they don't owe you anything more than pay for the hours worked. You have an ongoing deal, if that is changed you should get ample time to re-adjust.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:18AM (#33202519)
I am planning my future based on having marketable skills, an up to date resume, an up to date “career document”, and a strong network that I keep active.

> In Europe they can't pull the rug from under you and say "good luck with your mortgage, you're fired today".

I’ll take the tradeoff of much lower taxes and much higher pay any day.

> Instead they have to say "you are fired, but will receive 3 months of pay while you find something else"

Alternatively, I can save three to six months living expenses so that I’m not at the mercy of my current employer for my food and shelter.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by sebazzz on Friday October 14, 2022 @10:40AM (#33204146)
> I’ll take the tradeoff of much lower taxes and much higher pay any day.

Taxes are not (only) because of that. In fact, the employer needs to pay those 3 months often.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by matsemann on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:09AM (#33204573)
You're speaking from a position of privilege. I'd like everyone to have this safety. Not just people like me having a well-paid job.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:16AM (#33204670)
That safety net is a societal issue and should be handled by the government - not private industry
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:57PM (#33206075)
You’ve just argued against higher taxes. How should this safety net be funded?
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:07PM (#33206201)
Unemployment is funded on the state level via corporate taxes. I have no issue with getting rid of loopholes on corporate taxes.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:23PM (#33206390)
I think you’ve perfectly covered why such a protection is lacking.

Schemes someone else pays for sound great, but until people agree to pay them, they don’t happen.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:23PM (#33207069)
How is that whole depending on your employer for health care working out in the US?

Why would you want to depend on them for your long term financial stability?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:23PM (#33210348)
Healthcare in the US looks a disaster from where I am in a country with state provided healthcare.

I think I’ve been unclear - I believe taxes should pay for healthcare for everyone, and would happily pay more tax for better healthcare.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:51PM (#33210491)
No I didn’t misinterpret you. I agree healthcare in the US is a shit show and the idea of tying your health care to your employer is asinine.

I’m taking that same opinion to its logical conclusion. We already have employer funded state controlled unemployment insurance. Increase that, have companies pay more if necessary and along with untying health care from your employer, we are there.

Let private companies focus on their business.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:18PM (#33217210)
I misunderstood you. This is not that different to what happens where I am (except the taxes come from both the employer and the employee), though both need to be increased to improve unemployment benefits and healthcare.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:24AM (#33201667)
> I realize I speak from a privileged position as a software developer. But never since the first day that I stepped into an office as a professional software developer in June of 1996 did I “plan a future” with a company.

If you can acknowledge that you're in a more secure position, why then argue for the treatment of those less fortunate based on the security that's been afforded to you by your particular set of circumstances?

> 2008 was worse. But as a developer, you could find a contract somewhere if you had a network.

The economy consists of more than just developers. Unemployment spiked in 2008 and many people were unable to find work after having been fired.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:25AM (#33202575)
> If you can acknowledge that you're in a more secure position, why then argue for the treatment of those less fortunate based on the security that's been afforded to you by your particular set of circumstances?

If society thinks there should be a safety net, and I agree, then society should take responsibility in the form of insuring that safety net is available. I have no problem with company funded, state run unemployment insurance, I think that the idea of your health insurance being tied to your job is asinine, etc.

But at what point is it the individuals responsibility to save money for a rainy day?

But why should it be on the company?

> The economy consists of more than just developers. Unemployment spiked in 2008 and many people were unable to find work after having been fired.

And what were the companies suppose to do (like the one I worked for) that ran out of money? Most people that tying your health insurance to your company is ass backwards. So why tie more of your livelihood to your company?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:56AM (#33205219)
> But at what point is it the individuals responsibility to save money for a rainy day?

It depends on what you mean by a rainy day. I don't think I'd judge most people too harshly in our current system. Circumstances can change in ways that an individual probably won't or can't foresee. Housing and other living expenses have grown to the point that a low wage worker can barely support themselves in many cities.

Personally I'd like to reach a point where society provides enough for a comfortable existence e.g. shelter, food, safety, healthcare, and a small disposable income for hobbies/leisure. At that point I think most people would be in a position where walking away from abusive employer is an actual option and not a punishing risk.

> But why should it be on the company?

It wouldn't need to be if social safety nets were strong enough. As it stands, losing your job has a much bigger impact on an employee than the employer.

Even with appropriate safety nets I think a case could still be made for discouraging companies from firing people lightly and requiring the effects to be cushioned due to the amount of upheaval finding a new job can cause both financially and socially.

> And what were the companies suppose to do (like the one I worked for) that ran out of money? Most people that tying your health insurance to your company is ass backwards. So why tie more of your livelihood to your company?

I view it as a failure of our current system that employee obligations aren't first in line when a company has to be liquidated. The employer/employee relationship is nominally one where the employee accepts a reduction in risk in exchange for giving up some of the value of your labour. Bankruptcy law in many places doesn't seem to respect this.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:48PM (#33205959)
> Even with appropriate safety nets I think a case could still be made for discouraging companies from firing people lightly and requiring the effects to be cushioned due to the amount of upheaval finding a new job can cause both financially and socially.

In the US, there is no stigma to losing your job via a reduction in force. As far as financially, I don’t have any moral objection to unemployment insurance being higher if we as a society choose for it to be higher.

> I view it as a failure of our current system that employee obligations aren't first in line when a company has to be liquidated

The VC funded company I worked for literal had no money when it was bought out for pennies. I was one of the people doing pitch decks to potential acquirers and in the room for the technical interviews with them.

Don’t get me wrong, this was 2012 and everyone from developers to tech support found a job quickly and we had plenty of warning.

The eventual acquirer laid almost everyone off immediately with a 1 month severance pay.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:24PM (#33206410)
> In the US, there is no stigma to losing your job via a reduction in force

Sorry, I could have been more clear here. I meant the loss of social relationships either at the company or by potentially having to move neighbourhood/city.

> The VC funded company I worked for literal had no money when it was bought out for pennies. I was one of the people doing pitch decks to potential acquirers and in the room for the technical interviews with them.

Most companies have at least some assets when they wind down. Putting employee obligations first simply means that any value derived from the liquidation is first used to settle that debt rather than other creditors.

If there were unpaid wages, then at some point the people running that company continued requiring their employees' labour despite knowing they couldn't keep their end of the contract. Some exceptions might be justifiable for smaller companies but I think we're far too lenient on people who knowingly steal from employees.

Most tech workers can deal with unpaid wages but I've seen it happen to bar and restaurant workers that aren't in as secure a position. The owners wind down the company and leave wages unpaid while immediately creating a new one in the same unit.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:30PM (#33207154)
> Sorry, I could have been more clear here. I meant the loss of social relationships either at the company or by potentially having to move neighbourhood/city.

Are you really going to put the onus on private companies to ensure that no one ever has to move from their hometown?

> Most companies have at least some assets when they wind down. Putting employee obligations first simply means that any value derived from the liquidation is first used to settle that debt rather than other creditors

A software companies only assets are the software and maybe a few laptops. These days many don’t even have servers.

Don’t get me wrong, we were guaranteed by our backers that we would be paid for every hour we worked and they kept their promise.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:57PM (#33207473)
> Are you really going to put the onus on private companies to ensure that no one ever has to move from their hometown?

Not at all. I do think companies should be prevented from firing people without generous severance and/or good reason.

If there was a good social safety net then I'd be open to that being relaxed a bit.

> A software companies only assets are the software and maybe a few laptops. These days many don’t even have servers.

There's also IP but I think that's missing the point. Getting paid something is better than nothing and many companies do have assets that would cover some/all of their outstanding payroll. At the moment, as far as I'm aware, employee payroll is fairly far down the list of creditors. I believe it should be first.

> Don’t get me wrong, we were guaranteed by our backers that we would be paid for every hour we worked and they kept their promise.

I'm glad your backers treated you and your colleagues generously. My preference is usually to bake in desired outcomes like this rather than relying on individual generosity.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:04PM (#33208774)
> Not at all. I do think companies should be prevented from firing people without generous severance and/or good reason

It’s not a good reason that “we don’t have the money” or “we decided that our horse and buggy manufacturing division is no longer the direction we are going”?

A company is not a charity. The purpose of a company is to sell things at profit and they hire you with an understanding of exchanging labor for money.

> I'm glad your backers treated you and your colleagues generously. My preference is usually to bake in desired outcomes like this rather than relying on individual generosity.

So are you going to force investors to keep funding companies when they run out of money?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by atemerev on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:47AM (#33200709)
> If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily.

If there is another economic crisis and nobody is hiring, preventing companies to fire people will make the crisis even worse.

> It is called "job security"

An outdated concept of the XX century. No such thing in the post-industrial society.

> Unless you count all the mom and pop cafes all over the Mediterranean?

They are closing by thousands now, like in every other economic crisis. And Scandinavian startups — what Scandinavian startups? (Finland and Estonia are not Scandinavian countries, they have somewhat more business-friendly environment).

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by eCa on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:25AM (#33200976)
> An outdated concept of the XX century.

I guess that was suggested in the XIX, XVIII, XVII, etc centuries as well. But I quite enjoy my job security in the XXI century.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by atemerev on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:26AM (#33200991)
Yes, that's called a privilege.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:06AM (#33201935)
> If there is another economic crisis and nobody is hiring, preventing companies to fire people will make the crisis even worse.

Companies that know firing is difficult will hire less aggressively. They are also more likely to accept a deeper reduction in profits before laying people off. The result is a higher threshold of economic instability before the company lets people go. The US approach is like playing speed Jenga, you build something that will inevitably collapse.

Mass layoffs only serve to deepen an economic crisis. You remove a huge sum of disposable income from the economy which only contributes to more closures/layoffs. The result is an increased concentration of assets in the hands of those with the most access to capital during the crisis.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by atemerev on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:24AM (#33202088)
This is why there are so few growth-oriented startups in Europe, and so few chances to compete with large companies who can afford absorbing such losses. And (at least in tech) such low salaries, compared to US-based companies.

European economic model simply cannot compete. US domination in tech is growing each year.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:06AM (#33202411)
Frankly I don't think the US model is something we should be competing with for the same reasons I don't think we should be emulating sweatshops in China or India. Based on recent stock trends their value is largely hypothetical and based on both hype and the assumption that they're able to grow indefinitely. I'd be happier to exclude them from our markets entirely.

The growth-oriented model that's become popular in the US looks increasingly like a cancer that only serves to concentrate wealth. There were a few early successes but it seems far more common that these startups "succeed" by distorting a functioning market with external capital and destroying sustainable businesses operating in the sector through price dumping.

Once they've captured enough of the market they'll IPO and either collapse entirely when their business model proves to be entirely unsustainable without infinite VC funds or limp along providing inferior service and labour conditions to those available beforehand. Either way harm is caused.

The model is fundamentally incompatible with the concept of fair and healthy competition and ultimately makes success a function of who has the most money to burn.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ryandrake on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:19PM (#33206346)
It's helpful to think of the USA as a gigantic factory that produces billionaires. The manufacturing process runs off of energy ("money") provided by banks, investors and government, and the raw materials that get consumed and discarded are the lives and livelihoods of workers, and the end product that pops off the assembly line is "wealthy people".
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by atemerev on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:49PM (#33206673)
That’s what they told us in a Soviet primary school back in USSR. The alternative wasn’t compelling enough.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:40PM (#33207275)
The options aren't limited to authoritarian dictatorship and capitalist oligopoly.

In the same vein it isn't communist to suggest that billionaires should maybe remain slightly smaller billionaires in order to provide workers a decent quality of life.

Until fairly recently you could support a household on one income in most western countries. We're now seeing people struggling on two after decades of tax cuts and historically low tax burdens on the extremely wealthy.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:16PM (#33206313)
It’s interesting how your points could be right yet you will have disagreement over whether it’s a problem.

Growth at any cost is utterly toxic in my view.

You describe lower European salaries, yet minimum wage in the US is outrageously low.

What the US seems to have created us a system for creating wealth inequality.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by atemerev on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:25PM (#33206424)
“Minimum wage” is fiction. There are many countries (including European countries) that do not have minimum wage. It doesn’t have any base in reality, and people should not accept such ridiculous salaries. That’s what unions and labor negotiations are for.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:57PM (#33206743)
Those receiving such wages seem unlikely to be in a position to negotiate a lot better.

Regulation is a dirty word to many, but it’s a solution I support for minimum wage.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:09PM (#33206220)
Why is job security outdated? The ‘gig economy’ with flexible arrangements seems to suit exploitative employers great. Workers peeing in bottles and the workplace culture in such jobs seems Dickensian.

What is the point of a job? To me the point is to look after people (from both the employer and employee’s perspective).

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by atemerev on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:31PM (#33206487)
Because the entire economic structure that supported “jobs” has deteriorated and became unsustainable. It was only working in industrial society with tangible outputs. “Jobs” were a temporary development only suitable for a particular social structure: industrial capitalism. Now we still have capitalism, but no more industrial society.

See Alvin Toffler’s “Third Wave” for more detailed treatment.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:45AM (#33200704)
Most industries would deserve less barriers of entry and less legal protections, it would favor the little ones.

Of course employment is an exchange of promises between employer and employees to bring stability for less money and less risks. But if the exchange benefits both sides, there is no reason to forbid both parties to negotiate whatever they prefer. In Europe there are too many legal hurdles (called "protection" of course they're going to choose a positive word !)

If there is an economic crisis and you forbid firing, the only solution is to close companies. Societe re organizes itself at each crisis, so the people laid off need to find new ways

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:14AM (#33201989)
> If there is an economic crisis and you forbid firing, the only solution is to close companies. Societe re organizes itself at each crisis, so the people laid off need to find new ways

Firing isn't entirely forbidden for a start.

Secondly, if companies know that firing has a cost they're more likely to grow their headcount in line with what they're able to support. Making firing cheap only serves to encourage the type of behaviour that leads to instability in an economic crisis.

> Of course employment is an exchange of promises between employer and employees to bring stability for less money and less risks. But if the exchange benefits both sides, there is no reason to forbid both parties to negotiate whatever they prefer. In Europe there are too many legal hurdles (called "protection" of course they're going to choose a positive word !)

The vast majority of employee/employer relationships have a power balance that's vastly in favour of the employer. Even for those of us lucky enough to be in tech, we've seen that employers are more than willing to secretly conspire in order to drive employee wages below what would have been the market rate.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by acatton on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:26AM (#33200572)
> In Europe where firing is almost impossible

Assuming you mean the European Union by "Europe", this is 27 countries with 27 labour laws. I don't think this can be generalized. Only trade laws were unified in the EU.

The labour laws diversity is made even wider if you include non EU countries like Switzerland or the Balkans.

Just as an example Denmark follows the concept of Flexisecurity[1], easy to fire, but there is a good government safety net which prevents people from falling into poverty, while trying as hard as possible to find them a new income.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexicurity

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:47AM (#33200708)
No I meant the geographical area. The EU is called the EU, the two should never be confused.

Good for Denmark ! Generalizations are never true. Specialized descriptions with all the cases covered on the other hand, are never read.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lyricism on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:28AM (#33204840)
> Generalizations are never true. Specialized descriptions with all the cases covered on the other hand, are never read.

The wording of this struck me; is it better to lie than to go unheard?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:17AM (#33200515)
> If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily. If companies can go down quickly, new companies can be formed in an instant.

In New Zealand it is fairly easy to start a company (in the sense that the required paperwork isn’t too difficult). It’s easy to hire people, but firing is hard.

Why would ease firing mean ease hiring? Why would companies failing easily mean start ups are simple?

It’s not so much that companies need to be idealised, but that people need to be treated with a minimum level of care.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by emoII on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:30AM (#33200607)
If it's easy to fire you won't have to be as thorough when hiring because if the new employee doesn't fit - just waste him/her. If it's difficult to fire the company will put potential employees through hell before deciding. I don't think there's any country where the actual process of hiring someone is a legal nightmare
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by oblio on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:47AM (#33200705)
> If it's easy to fire you won't have to be as thorough when hiring because if the new employee doesn't fit - just waste him/her.

That's super bad for morale and companies generally don't do it unless high churn is normal (retail).

US companies have hiring processes which are HARDER to go through, not easier, on average, than European companies. For example background checks almost never happen, as well as reference requests.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by t43562 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:33AM (#33201042)
There's already probation - 3 months in the UK. It doesn't make us less careful though because we don't want to waste our time.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by louistsi on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:56AM (#33200779)
Hiring processes in American companies are still as arduous and drawn out as European hiring processes though. You're still looking at a 4-16 week process, you don't just snap someone up in a week if they're on the market.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Leherenn on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:24AM (#33200969)
It's not necessarily the process, but more the number/type of open positions. When it's difficult to fire, it's very common for people to start with a temporary contract or two before being offered an unlimited one. Likewise, I believe contractors are more common. Basically, anything that offers flexibility.

Also, companies are just more reluctant to open a position.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by captainbland on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:25AM (#33200982)
I'd say the UK has generally had a pretty good ratio of protection from firing and having reasonably sensible interview times. Although some companies do seem to have picked up longer interview practices more recently, this actually seems to be an import from the US in trying to emulate Google, etc.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by bobthepanda on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:27AM (#33200576)
usually the ease of hiring/firing bit is more of "hire the right person for the role", in the sense that a vacated spot can become available for another.

but also, there is a limited amount of capital in the economy, and so propping an "unhealthy" company up with debt will crowd out new, potentially successful businesses. If there are enough zombie companies around this is enough to paralyze an entire economy.

The general observation is that the US has less worker stability, but also bounces back faster than European countries. And the poster child for zombie companies strangling the economy by hoovering up all the credit is post-bubble Japan.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:56AM (#33200783)
Opening a company is not just the paperwork. We should praise companies falling down as they can create the path for new ones to get up

People do not need to be treated, they're not little babies

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by mola on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:14AM (#33200898)
No, not babies, they are fellow human beings. While Companies are not, they are just social tools.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:36AM (#33201060)
Exactly. They don't need help, they should help themselves like true responsible adults

  While Companies are not, they are just social tools
Agreed
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:47PM (#33205941)
What are your views on worker protections?

Companies failing is fine in my view, as long as people are protected. Workers need to be paid and they need sufficient notice of redundancy for protection.

Contracts need to be adhered to with enforceable penalties if broken.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by betwixthewires on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:42AM (#33200682)
It's east to hire anywhere. But is it easy to get hired? How much rigmarole does a company put you through to ensure they're not going to get stuck with dead weight? I'm guessing quite a bit, and the harder it is to fire you the harder they'll work to make sure you're worth hiring.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:32PM (#33205709)
For me it was a 1 hour chat over coffee. For the staff I hired it was similar.

From the moment the decision was made (an hour or so after the coffee), it is usually a month until they are working with me.

We do reference checks after picking a candidate.

The month delay is due to the notice period people are usually required to give their old employer. It could be more or less but is 4 weeks usually.

The process probably varies by industry a lot. If a profession requires a practicing certification you have a minimum standard already. If a profession is tiny, you have a fair idea about candidates before you interview.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by nata79 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:19AM (#33200944)
You can fire people in Europe and hiring is by no means more convoluted than in the US.

Typically here you have 3 to 6 months probation period where you can be fired at any moment. Then your rights increase with your tenure.

The other big difference is that when you leave a job, you usually have 1 to 3 months of notice period while in the US that tends to only last a couple of weeks.

Overall this gives people a lot more security and I think we have a much better balance because of it, at least in the tech industry.

Industries with higher turnover (like hospitality) typically only hire employees as contractors so they can fire them at any time.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by 6c696e7578 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:32AM (#33201035)
> In Europe where firing is almost impossible, hiring is a very tedious process.

France has good job security rules, from what I've heard. The UK, not so much.

Once you've completed two years, you are entitled to a consultation process if the company wants to make redundancies. Those positions cannot be filled for six months after a redundancy. HR departments can reword and change descriptions though so if they really wanted to fill the position, they could, but from what I've seen they mostly change it after six months anyway.

If you're unlucky and have just started a position, you can be dropped easily, no consultation, but the rules of redundancy above remain.

However, having spent some time on the other end, doing interviews, hiring is a lot more expensive than firing. One month of consultation vs delays to projects, training of new starters, retention of employees and talent are far more valuable than an easy firing process. Never doubt the value of your experience to a company, any employer who does ignore that value isn't worth working for as they're delusional and likely to fail soon.

Yes, hiring is a very tedious.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by alxlaz on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:37AM (#33201066)
> Firing easily and hiring easily are two sides of the same coin. If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily. If companies can go down quickly, new companies can be formed in an instant.

> In Europe where firing is almost impossible, hiring is a very tedious process.

This is, at best, an anecdote. I'm charitably saying anecdote to avoid calling it utter bullshit. The average hiring process at companies I'm familiar with -- in the UK, France, Germany, Finland, the Czech Republic, Portugal and Greece, so I guess it's a reasonably large sample -- is no more complicated than the hiring process at Google or Facebook. And, much like in the US, if you stay away from the big players -- like Google or Facebook -- the average hiring "process" is a technical interview + a short interview with the hiring manager and HR. Popular enough companies may do a phone screening but that's about it.

Firing someone for bad performance is not "almost impossible". I have, unfortunately, had to sign off on that a couple of times. What is almost impossible is firing someone for bullshit reasons and writing it off as "a bad fit".

Of course there are legal protection in place: if you are laid off and can't find work -- for example, because you relocated to stay with your current employer when they moved offices, and were promptly laid off afterwards, in a new town with somewhat uncertain prospects -- the solution you're offered, in most countries, is not stop being poor, lol, but various forms of social protection so you don't starve before your next interview. Consequently, yes, it's important to make it difficult to fire people because they don't bend to toxic management or poor working conditions, otherwise that'd just be sponsoring incompetent management.

> Companies are big and look financially stable because the little ones cannot survive or dont enjoy the same monopoly / legal protections.

That is not even an anecdote. Except for Eastern Europe, where the Iron Curtain interrupted the history of most businesses, there are plenty of small companies, in every country, that have been operating more or less without interruption since the 1800s (and usually the interruptions were on account of one of the World Wars). There are four of these within a ten-minute walking distance from where I'm staying.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by soptikha2 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:16AM (#33200514)
My experience is quite different in regard to working in Europe.

How exactly is hiring a very tedious process? Seemed quite fast and easy to me.

And btw, it's not that hard to fire a wrong hire. You have few months to do so basically for any reason at all, and afterwards, you can still do it, if you have a good reason to do so.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by acatton on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:23AM (#33200549)
Europe is 27 countries with uniformized trade laws. There was never any uniformization on labour laws.

GP made a huge generalization by saying "in europe" while talking about labour laws. It's like me saying "in asia, (something about the labour market)", there is no such thing.

Hiring/firing/Employee-rights are very different between Spain and Czechia.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Bayart on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:14AM (#33200891)
The spirit of the law is generally pretty uniform across the EU.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by mathverse on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:21AM (#33200952)
That might be but it is not a real single market. It is bunch of countries working with a similar framework.

Here i am waiting for more than 2 months for a legal contract because my employer is in a different country and does not have a legal entity in my country.

EU to a large extent is a failure to nurture talent and multiply capital.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by rypskar on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:39AM (#33200667)
>>Europe is 27 countries

No, Europe is 44 countries the subset of Europe that is EU have 27 members

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by junon on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:49AM (#33200730)
I think it's pretty clear they were referring to the EU. No need for semantics wars.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:49AM (#33201133)
Calling the EU Europe is made on purpose to conflate the two and make it obvious that all countries should unite into this political union. I think it is very useful to point that to people who conflate the two terms
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by junon on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:50AM (#33201814)
I think that's putting words into peoples' mouths.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:07AM (#33204549)
It's an ideology in favor of the European Union
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by junon on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:48AM (#33205119)
You're being pedantic. It's not an ideology.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by cassianoleal on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:02AM (#33201908)
Similarly, calling the USA "America" to conflate it with the rest of the continent in order to drive their idea of Latin America being "the back yard of the USA", or, more recently "the front yard".
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by oblio on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:46AM (#33201470)
Technically correct.

Russia is about 40% of the continent but few people want to go there, especially under current circumstances, and the remaining 16 countries are either EU associated (Switzerland & co), former members (UK), EU candidate countries, or countries frankly too small and/or poor and/or remote.

The EU is the elephant in the room.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:28AM (#33200581)
After the probation you need a really good reason and it costs a lot of money / paperwork / worker's right etc.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by sunderw on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:14AM (#33200893)
In France, for example, you have 4 months (and you can renew it 3 more months so 7 in total) probation period. If you need more then 7 months to realise you've made a wrong hire, then I think you can spend take a few more months to fire someone and not decide to fire someone at a whim.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:50AM (#33201137)
Yes, that makes my point. During probation hiring and firing is easy. After probation the hard choice is made (they can fire you easily right before the end) and firing is hard.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by rvense on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:49AM (#33200728)
Absolutely not true in Denmark. A good reason can be something like "we are eliminating this position for strategic reasons", and the only money it will cost you is the three-six months (depending on how long they've been at the company) that you have to keep paying them, during which they are required to work as normal and act loyally.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by abracadabra_ on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:24AM (#33200971)
That sounds similar to redundancy in the UK but much more generous.

It always possible to get rid of either an employee or a role. The problem comes when you're getting rid of a whole department or say 10% of your employees. There are a lot more rules around that.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by wincy on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:21AM (#33200955)
Isn’t that slavery with extra steps? What if I moved out of the country? This seems bizarre to me as an American. I’d do as little work as possible for that time and be resentful about it.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by rvense on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:51AM (#33201825)
> Isn’t that slavery with extra steps?

That's a pretty wild comparison?

> What if I moved out of the country? This seems bizarre to me as an American. I’d do as little work as possible for that time and be resentful about it.

Well, things are usually a little more relaxed during that period. The employer is also required to make accommodations for you to find a new job, e.g. allow time off to go to interviews. As for leaving the country or not showing up, sure, the company might have grounds to sue and they could certainly stop paying you in that case, but, y'know, generally people act like adults.

There are exceptions to this rule about notices, so a day-to-day firing is possible in extreme circumstances. Like if you're not showing up at all, or blatantly not doing your job, are violent etc., you can be banished from the workplace and not paid from that day. But the point is, if you've been doing your job and get fired, you have the option to be at least somewhat reasonable about it and in return you get three months to find your feet and move on. By far most people take this.

Also, in the converse situation, where it's you who wish to leave, the rule is that you give at least one month's notice. This is sometimes not what you want, of course, but I think most people view it as a fair and reasonable trade, especially in light of the rules about getting fired.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:51AM (#33200745)
Good for Denmark !
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by fredestine on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:48AM (#33201130)
europe is the worst of both worlds. there isnt really protection. and as the years go by it gets worse as our governments vote new law to reduce our protections. let me give you the example of france. when we join a company we can be fired during the first six months with very little real reason. when we want to leave the company we need to give a 3month notice (think about how happy is the new company knowing youll misss a quarter when some of those companies don't even plan their future well - just look GCP hiring freeze suddenly in the middle of a quarter while in a hiring spree one week before). when you get fired most of the time you will get unemployement. 55% of your salary (it is very good but when you plan your life around 100% salary it gets very very challenging to live on 55%). but only for the first 6 months (a new law that concerns mostly white collars...) then it will be degressive so that after a few months you out of luck. note that in europe you pay tax while you work so that you can be paid while unemployed... so the 6month degressive new law is pure stealing from the people and totally evil and because it hits only white collars workers most of the people don't talk about it because it concerns people that are 'well off' in the society while in reality policies like this are a total destruction of the middle class.

finding a new job you will compete with people that have this 3 month notice so most of the companies plan hiring around it. also if you are unemployed in europe it will look really bad during your interviews.

now compare that to USA. you give 2 week notice, job market is very fluid so you can likely find a new job 2 week after stay there a few months helping the company and then use that time to apply to a new job in a better company.

Obviously the french model might be better for low earners/blue collars that do not have a job security. but for everyone else it is really hard to move to another company, managers know that too so they dont need to carrot you into a raise or a promotion as much as they do in US.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by sofixa on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:21AM (#33201346)
It's up to 6 months (3+3 actually, max is 4) for the probationary period, and the notice is up to 3 months.

You're also missing that nobody is forcing you to quit to start looking for a new job, the protection is mostly that if the company wants to get rid of you they need to give you at least the same length of notice, giving you extra time on top of the unemployment to find something.

Furthermore, in the US model, if you quit you don't get unemployment.

Oh, and there's also RSA if you don't have revenues, which can provide some income when unemployment stops.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by fredestine on Thursday October 27, 2022 @08:19AM (#33356439)
if you quit you dont get unemployement in france either... and nobody is forcing you to quit but you still have the 3month period before leaving the company. if you dont respect it youll be blacklisted... we don't operate on a gigantic market like the us. being blacklisted is a bad in a smaller country
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by butterNaN on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:13AM (#33200487)
I have been in Europe for a few years now and my experiance is significantly opposite of what the parent comment claims.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by jfoster on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:16AM (#33200512)
That doesn't really make logical sense to me. Can you elaborate? If hiring is an irreversible decision for a company, why wouldn't consideration be required prior to any hire?
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by BlargMcLarg on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:26AM (#33200569)
The premise of it being irreversible is wrong and far more complex.

Case study. In my country, most individuals do benefit from a severance on a permanent contract. Getting a permanent contract happens after working for a year if you're lucky or in a high demand job. In other cases, companies will use their power to stall as long as possible where beneficial. Temporary contracts do not have the same severance benefits, just wait the year and they are gone.

Severance itself varies case by case. Younger people with permanent contracts aren't getting multiple years in salaries for getting fired. Most older employees don't, either.

The entire premise also requires a largely immobile workforce. Workforce mobility in The Netherlands is actually pretty decent, with most younger people switching jobs every few years. This inevitably means these people have temporary contracts for a large part of their career, with much weaker severance packages. Top comment also discounts the obvious, trying to get individuals to quit themselves through e.g. legal bullying or bad benefits.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by dnissley on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:53AM (#33200752)
What do these permanent and temporary contracts stipulate? Presumably they are quite different than the standard US employment contracts that basically just confirm at-will employment, etc.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by BlargMcLarg on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:00AM (#33200806)
In NL, you generally start with a fixed term of a year. After the year, the contract ends. Depending on relationships, supply/demand, field of expertise etc., the employer will either offer another fixed term or a permanent contract.

Permanent contract means the employer does not have the exit condition of "wait it out" to get rid of an employee. Additionally, permanent contracts tend to have bigger benefits attached to them, both legally and infrastructurally (e.g. getting a mortgage on a fixed term contract is nigh on impossible for most individuals).

Legally, employers can only offer so many fixed term contracts before they are forced to hire permanently or cut off the employee. In practice, you will see more exploitative companies look for ways to extend this (alternative legal structures), whereas fields with more balance in power (like IT) tend to present permanent contracts after a single temporary contract.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by mathverse on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:31AM (#33201027)
Oh yeah this is to prevent employers from keeping employees employed on a fixed term contract or through an agency indefinitely thus denying them some benefits and protection.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:33AM (#33200626)
We shouldn't normalise pushing people to quit via bullying of course. But bullying and bad benefits result from a company/employee mismatch, which changing jobs fixes easily
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by BlargMcLarg on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:52AM (#33200747)
And changing jobs means you now no longer have the vast amount of protection you used to and have to build them back up.

For the majority of countries, your entire point rests on the premise individuals are choosing to largely be immobile. Tenure length isn't that different from the US, all things concerned. Significant, especially given some countries, but not nearly as dramatic as "impossible to fire".

The moment you introduce mobility, most of the safety is gone for a large portion of time. What we are seeing, is that younger people are hit disproportionately since job hopping tends to be the far better choice, and younger people do not start at incomes that get them comfortable. It is primarily the elderly that benefit from the current structure.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:15AM (#33200901)

   And changing jobs means you now no longer have the vast amount of protection you used to and have to build them back up.
...unless you negotiate a better contract for the next job ?

   It is primarily the elderly that benefit from the current structure

Agreed :-(
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lmm on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:35AM (#33201055)
Interviewing practices have very little connection to logic in the first place, and to the extent they do there's probably more connection to the general employer/employee power balance than any such specific consideration. American companies make candidates jump through hoops because they can; European ones don't because they can't.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scott_w on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:52AM (#33200749)
Because it's not an irreversible decision. Most countries allow a probation period where you can let an employee go if they don't work out. These are typically anywhere between 2 weeks and 6 months (depending on the training time expected).
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Epa095 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:25AM (#33200561)
Because if you are slow at hirering the candidate has accepted a position somewhere else by the time you get back to them.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by meheleventyone on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:38AM (#33200660)
You can fire people pretty easily in Europe. There’s rules around layoffs but they are also common. All the companies I’ve worked for have hired and fired relatively freely.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by junon on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:48AM (#33200725)
Again, different countries, different laws. It is objectively NOT easy to fire people in Germany, for example.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by meheleventyone on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:28AM (#33201008)
Right but it’s still absolutely miles away from making hiring an irreversible decision.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Rubber8787 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:18AM (#33200932)
There is no such thing as "objectively easy".

In Germany very small companies can fire people at will. It's effortless and requires minimal bureaucracy. Same for firing people in their long trial periods.

In other cases, the difficulty depends heavily on the situation. The easiest way is to simply negotiate with the employee. The other options involve more work

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by snovv_crash on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:24AM (#33200555)
There's usually a considerable probation period where the firing rules are much more relaxed. Germany is typically 6 months, for example.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by thomascarney on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:42AM (#33200684)
Even after 6 months, typical compensation for being fired is 2 weeks of salary for every year worked. For most startup employees, this won't be a huge amount, given they have often only worked a few years.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:29AM (#33200591)
Doesnt that make my point ? You can easily be fired in a probation period :-) and right before the probation ends is when the employer wonders if they should keep you (really hire you for good)
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by mirchibajji on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:32AM (#33201032)
In theory, this is true. However, IME as a techie in the UK, those situations happen when there is a significant mismatch between the interview vs reality - from either side. Hiring based on referrals is one way to mitigate some of the unknowns.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by snovv_crash on Saturday October 15, 2022 @09:15AM (#33214495)
After 5 months of being embedded in a team, firing someone who management doesn't like but who is popular with other employees will cause major morale issues even if they are still technically in probation.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by kioleanu on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:30AM (#33200604)
It's not irreversible in any sense of that word.

First of all, you have a trial period of 3 to 6 months where you can fire someone without even giving a reason.

Second of all, you can have fixed-term contracts, like 1 or 2 years - also with the trial period.

Third, you can still fire people after the trial period, you just can't go Trump-yelling at someone "YOU'RE FIRED!!!" because of some small mistake or if you don't like their face. It's not an easy process, but also not impossible. I very much prefer it this way.

I'm seeing this at the company where a friend works. They have an american branch that completely changed the employee roster twice (!!!) in the last two years. Everything they do is a mess, every new person that comes brings a different point of view of how things should be done. In the end, they always end up falling back to implementing what their colleagues in Europe did. The europeans have been working together for 6 years now

PS: for my current job, where I have a permanent contract, the interview in-all took 55 minutes. About another 15 minutes of talking to HR on the phone and bam, here I am.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by hhmc on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:24AM (#33200554)
Having more protections than zero (at will) doesn’t make hiring anything as dramatic as ‘irreversible’
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by esteth on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:21AM (#33201647)
In the uk at least employers have a grace period of 3-6 months where they can fire you for any or no reason.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by vidarh on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:27AM (#33201000)
Firing without cause is "almost impossible" in Europe. Firing for cause or genuine redundancies are rarely a problem most places in Europe.

You have consultation requirements many places, to ensure that it's actually a genuine redundancy, but a company willing to offer a reasonably fair payout and who can demonstrate a genuine need to cut costs or a genuine lack of work for certain staff will generally not have much of a problem carrying out a redundancy most places in Europe.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by orwin on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:58AM (#33201527)
Firing for cause is easy. Firing without much of a cause too in most cases, but you will have to pay quite a bit.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by vidarh on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:24AM (#33201666)
Getting someone to leave without much of a cause is easy, certainly, if you're willing to pay enough. The being willing to pay bit tends to be the sticking point that makes employers who are used to US "at will" employment complain.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by serf on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:18AM (#33200927)
> If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily.

that would only ever be true in whichever fantasy world where the managers and people-in-charge made wise and just decisions.

Plenty of 'rare talent' that is near irreplaceable is fired every single day by managers that don't know any better, and their niche talents make it very difficult to find new job prospects.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by HL33tibCe7 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:29AM (#33200593)
> In Europe

Tell me you’re an American without telling me you’re an American ;)

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:50AM (#33200736)
I'm from western Europe :)
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by atoav on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:57AM (#33200788)
> In Europe where firing is almost impossible, hiring is a very tedious process.

Sure you need to vet your candidates more carefully, because you cannot fire them right away without reason (although these law vary within the 27 nations of the EU). But:

1. there are limited contacts. So if you don't wanna have the risk, you are free to make shorter contacts and pay people more so the good people are willing to take those. This has the downside that they are free to go to your competitor as well at the end of the contract. Everything comes with it's downsides.

2. Hiring random people and firing them a month later does not make it easier for the employers. If employers vet their potential employees more carefully, everybody wins. Sure, finding and selecting the right person is hard. But even if you could hire and fire villy nilly, that would waste your companies time. Every person you hire will take the company into a new direction, one bad person can poison the social climate, hurt your company etc. So hiring carefree is not a good idea in any case.

3. In hiring not just the employer takes a risk, the employee takes risks too. They might have to move, they might have to buy a bicycle, a car, a public transport ticket to commute, they plan their lives on the promised employment and wage. It is only fair that they get the time to reorganise if you let them go.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:12AM (#33200880)
I agree with all points ! Not sure how that helps OP's fears though :)
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by cm2187 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:31AM (#33200609)
Also the US corporate world has a good history of dealing with problems upfront, taking the pain and moving on, rather than living with their problems like it is done too often in europe. It seems destructive but the long term impact is a healthier economy and more jobs.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by alchemist1e9 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:16AM (#33200912)
GDP per capita is an interesting number and I was quiet surprised recently when I compared US and European cities and countries. For those who haven’t the spoiler is the US is significantly higher. Most pro-EU economic narratives are on pretty shaky ground even before recent developments.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by mola on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:29AM (#33201390)
What does gdp per Capita means when inequalities are very high?
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by cm2187 on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:06AM (#33201934)
I am not sure inequalities are that high in the US. They certainly are if you compare the absolute extremes of the distribution (Musk to a homeless drug addict), but beyond 2% percentile each side they are not that high.

There was an interesting talk on this topic [1]. What they argue is that the statistics used in the US to measure income inequality are misleading as they don’t account for taxes and benefits. The gap is greatly reduced if you do.

In any case, poverty is usually the issue, not inequality.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XL1DSo_gvK4

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by alchemist1e9 on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:11AM (#33201964)
I don’t have a reference handy but there was also recently sn analysis that concluded immigration significantly skews the numbers when comparing inequity to EU nations. The US has significant immigration on the bottom end and also on the top end.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by alchemist1e9 on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:13AM (#33201984)
What does equality mean if gdp per capita is very low?
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:16AM (#33200508)
> if you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily

And if you can find a job easily, you can credibly threaten to decamp for leverage. (Or, if your boss is a dick, just leave.)

I'm American. My bias shows. But I think an easy-to-fire, easy-to-hire model is far superior to the incumbency-biased systems which make hiring and firing an Olympic sport. We lack a strong-enough social net underneath it all, necessary to be humane and maintain social stability. But that seems an easier fix than reforming an entire commercial culture.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:20AM (#33200532)
> But that seems an easier fix than reforming an entire commercial culture.

Does it? To an outsider, workers rights seem to be regressing.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:18AM (#33200925)
Maybe we want less rights but more freedom and wealth
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Fiahil on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:27AM (#33200579)
> In Europe where firing is almost impossible, hiring is a very tedious process.

Europe is not a single country, anyway, here's what happen in France:

Firing is tedious, but not impossible. Hiring people is easy, but you enter into competition with higher salaries - like the US - for remote jobs.

> Firing easily and hiring easily are two sides of the same coin.

Not exactly, they diverge when firing is made more difficult.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:37AM (#33200652)
No they're the same coin. You didn't get me. When you make firing more difficult, you mechanically make hiring more difficult. There is no free lunch.

To fire in France you need a really good reason well justified, and prepare your company for the Prud'hommes trial. Of course you could say "but most companies are big and have HR teams and lawyers dedicated to this, whereas the employee is all alone", but that's also my point about big vs. small companies and legal protections

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by tgv on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:27AM (#33201001)
> When you make firing more difficult, you mechanically make hiring more difficult. There is no free lunch.

That operates under the idea that employees only change when fired. And that's patently not true.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by dnissley on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:57AM (#33200789)
Simply put: There are reactions for every action! The most optimal outcome is not easily legislated.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by peoplefromibiza on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:26AM (#33200992)
> When you make firing more difficult, you mechanically make hiring more difficult

or, depending on the law, you make mechanically easier to form new companies or create more contracting jobs etc

What you're missing is that in most European countries where firing is hard, it's only for medium to large companies

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by mola on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:32AM (#33201410)
But hiring in the US is not an easy process relative to Europe, atleast in tech context. There's much more ceremony involved in the US you have to meet a lot more ppl. your whole premis is imagined, but you refuse to acknowledge it. It's very baffling.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by randomsearch on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:26AM (#33200571)
> Firing easily and hiring easily are two sides of the same coin. If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily

Yes, like 1930s America.

I guess you mean “you can be easily hired” rather than “you will find a job easily”. Very different things.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:38AM (#33200661)
Could you elaborate the difference ?
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by shawabawa3 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:48AM (#33200723)
> "you can be hired easily"

Little bureaucracy/paperwork/barriers to starting work if a company wants to hire you

> "you will find a job easily"

There are actually companies that want to hire you

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Zagill on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:30AM (#33200603)
Except if too many companies are doing hiring freezes and mass layoffs, who's going to hire you? There's a limit to this and it's fair to be concerned about just how widespread these layoffs have been.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:23AM (#33200959)
You are comparing situations with different factors varying, I was talking in the general sense that the two actions of hiring and firing are linked together, and you're talking about the current economic situation.

Maybe the employee got in in the first place because hiring and firing were easy. If you made it difficult, the employee wouldn't have been hired in the first place. Then it doesn't matter if you have an economic crisis, the person is out of job anyway. We need to let companies fire employees to survive the crisis, and let newly fired people re organize their life and create the companies that will compete and destroy the current ones

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by peoplefromibiza on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:19AM (#33200941)
> In Europe where firing is almost impossible

Where exactly in Europe?

It's like saying "in Asia is almost impossible to do X"

Europe is a 750 million people continent formed by 51 different countries including Russia and UK

Be more specific please.

In Spain it's easy to fire, for example.

Their average salaries are 30% lower than the French ones, even though in France firing is hard, and their unemployment rate is almost double.

You theory has some flaws apparently.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by peoplefromibiza on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:18AM (#33200926)
> In Europe where firing is almost impossible

Where exactly in Europe?

It's like saying "in Asia is almost impossible to do X"

Europe is a 750 million people continent formed by 51 different countries including Russia and UK

Be more specific please.

In Spain it's easy to fire, for example.

Their average salaries are 20% lower than the French ones, even though in France firing is hard, and their unemployment rate is almost double.

You theory has some flaws apparently.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by ttoinou on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:28AM (#33201002)

   Be more specific please.
In most countries of Europe we have a lot of laws to "protect" employees and current companies, making it harder in the first place to even create companies and hire people. But that's also true for others places in the world

Yes generalizations are never true. Even talking about one country is a generalization and you will fail at making a statement about it. The best way to not make a mistake is to not say anything

  Europe is a 750 million people continent

There is no good reason to separate Europe from Asia, it's all one big continent. Your theory is also flawed :(
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by peoplefromibiza on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:17AM (#33201319)
> In most countries of Europe we have a lot of laws to "protect" employees and current companies, making it harder in the first place to even create companies and hire people

There's no such things as generally "harder to create companies" in Europe.

It's simply harder to create global multi billion conglomerates with an easy trigger for layoffs.

So generally, that's true, there are less multi billion global conglomerates with an easy trigger for layoffs than in the US.

But

USA has 2.2 companies registered per 1,000 people

Most European countries have more than that, Netherlands is at 7.1, UK at 7.4, Bulgaria 6.7, Denmark 5.2 etc.

> There is no good reason to separate Europe from Asia, it's all one big continent

Eurasia is a super continent, Europe is a landmass, which is either considered a continent in its own right or a subcontinent of Eurasia

Thanks for giving me the chance to explain this topic once again.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by orwin on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:08AM (#33201578)
If anything, it's easier to create companies. Since the market is fragmented, if your business isn't reliant on network effect, it's generally easier to get by.

The massive plumbing companies in the US do not yet exist in my country. I feel this is changing, but fair competition is still enforced at the local level, so i might be wrong.

Nobody really care about little entrepreneurs it seems (especially not those politicians who claims they do), but i have the impression that the weakening of local courts is a prelude to a change towards a more anglo-saxon model. Like i said, i might be pessimistic and hopefully wrong.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by anothernewdude on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:17AM (#33200922)
Hiring is most tedious in the U.S. Those massive pipeline processes are an American invention.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:12AM (#33201596)
> If you can be fired easily, you will find a job easily.

What happens in a recession? When tens of thousands of people are fired easily across an economy they're not going to find another job quickly.

Making firing more difficult puts a mandate on companies to be a little more responsible when growing their headcount. As a consequence they're less vulnerable to wild swings as a result of unforeseen circumstances.

> Companies are big and look financially stable because the little ones cannot survive or dont enjoy the same monopoly / legal protections.

Big companies are favoured in hundreds of ways. Leveraging other income streams to price dump their way into a dominant position and creative methods of lowering their tax burden being just two. The answer to this isn't to strip worker protections but to remove those loopholes and encourage competition rather than monopolisation.

Many laws around workers rights are already relaxed for smaller companies.

> If a company is not useful to society, it should go down.

Absolutely, but most societies wouldn't be able to function if this was the case. Most economies simply aren't resilient enough to allow large companies to go down. I feel like it's fairly intuitive that once companies in certain sectors grow large enough they can become an essential part of the nation's infrastructure. That only leaves a few options:

- Continue bailing them out

- Nationalise them

- Prevent them from reaching that size in the first place

I don't see how making it easier to lay people off would advance any of these. Instead it only encourages companies to engage in risky behaviour and grow beyond their ability to sustain themselves.

> Don't idealize employment and companies. They are only tools on our path to wealth and freedom

We've created a system predicated on the fact that not everyone can be wealthy. I don't think it's moral to then say that the solution to being treated poorly is to just become wealthy.