News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:29AM (#33201011)
> For at least some time. E.g. a few month of salary seems reasonable because a person has planned his future with you, now he needs to find a new job which will take some time.

I realize I speak from a privileged position as a software developer. But never since the first day that I stepped into an office as a professional software developer in June of 1996 did I “plan a future” with a company.

My plan was always to use where I worked as a stepping stone for my next job. I spent my first two years saving money and building my resume. I have spent most of my career “with my running shoes on”. Meaning I’m always prepared for a layoff or to leave when the pay/bullshit ratio is going in the wrong direction.

My employer owes me nothing besides to pay me for the hours I worked. When that arrangement isn’t working for either of us, we both have agency and the ability to terminate that arrangement.

> Unless it is another economical crisis and nobody is hiring?

I lived through both the 2000 crash and 2008-2011. The 2000 crash wasn’t bad if you had both skills and was working in many major cities in the US as just a regular old enterprise developer working for profitable non tech companies.

2008 was worse. But as a developer, you could find a contract somewhere if you had a network.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by matsemann on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:54AM (#33201167)
> But never since the first day that I stepped into an office as a professional software developer in June of 1996 did I “plan a future” with a company.

You're missing the point. It's that you're planning your future on having income from the company you currently work for. In Europe they can't pull the rug from under you and say "good luck with your mortgage, you're fired today". Instead they have to say "you are fired, but will receive 3 months of pay while you find something else". So yes, I disagree that they don't owe you anything more than pay for the hours worked. You have an ongoing deal, if that is changed you should get ample time to re-adjust.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:18AM (#33202519)
I am planning my future based on having marketable skills, an up to date resume, an up to date “career document”, and a strong network that I keep active.

> In Europe they can't pull the rug from under you and say "good luck with your mortgage, you're fired today".

I’ll take the tradeoff of much lower taxes and much higher pay any day.

> Instead they have to say "you are fired, but will receive 3 months of pay while you find something else"

Alternatively, I can save three to six months living expenses so that I’m not at the mercy of my current employer for my food and shelter.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by sebazzz on Friday October 14, 2022 @10:40AM (#33204146)
> I’ll take the tradeoff of much lower taxes and much higher pay any day.

Taxes are not (only) because of that. In fact, the employer needs to pay those 3 months often.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by matsemann on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:09AM (#33204573)
You're speaking from a position of privilege. I'd like everyone to have this safety. Not just people like me having a well-paid job.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:16AM (#33204670)
That safety net is a societal issue and should be handled by the government - not private industry
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:57PM (#33206075)
You’ve just argued against higher taxes. How should this safety net be funded?
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:07PM (#33206201)
Unemployment is funded on the state level via corporate taxes. I have no issue with getting rid of loopholes on corporate taxes.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:23PM (#33206390)
I think you’ve perfectly covered why such a protection is lacking.

Schemes someone else pays for sound great, but until people agree to pay them, they don’t happen.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:23PM (#33207069)
How is that whole depending on your employer for health care working out in the US?

Why would you want to depend on them for your long term financial stability?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:23PM (#33210348)
Healthcare in the US looks a disaster from where I am in a country with state provided healthcare.

I think I’ve been unclear - I believe taxes should pay for healthcare for everyone, and would happily pay more tax for better healthcare.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:51PM (#33210491)
No I didn’t misinterpret you. I agree healthcare in the US is a shit show and the idea of tying your health care to your employer is asinine.

I’m taking that same opinion to its logical conclusion. We already have employer funded state controlled unemployment insurance. Increase that, have companies pay more if necessary and along with untying health care from your employer, we are there.

Let private companies focus on their business.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by lostlogin on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:18PM (#33217210)
I misunderstood you. This is not that different to what happens where I am (except the taxes come from both the employer and the employee), though both need to be increased to improve unemployment benefits and healthcare.
Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:24AM (#33201667)
> I realize I speak from a privileged position as a software developer. But never since the first day that I stepped into an office as a professional software developer in June of 1996 did I “plan a future” with a company.

If you can acknowledge that you're in a more secure position, why then argue for the treatment of those less fortunate based on the security that's been afforded to you by your particular set of circumstances?

> 2008 was worse. But as a developer, you could find a contract somewhere if you had a network.

The economy consists of more than just developers. Unemployment spiked in 2008 and many people were unable to find work after having been fired.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:25AM (#33202575)
> If you can acknowledge that you're in a more secure position, why then argue for the treatment of those less fortunate based on the security that's been afforded to you by your particular set of circumstances?

If society thinks there should be a safety net, and I agree, then society should take responsibility in the form of insuring that safety net is available. I have no problem with company funded, state run unemployment insurance, I think that the idea of your health insurance being tied to your job is asinine, etc.

But at what point is it the individuals responsibility to save money for a rainy day?

But why should it be on the company?

> The economy consists of more than just developers. Unemployment spiked in 2008 and many people were unable to find work after having been fired.

And what were the companies suppose to do (like the one I worked for) that ran out of money? Most people that tying your health insurance to your company is ass backwards. So why tie more of your livelihood to your company?

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:56AM (#33205219)
> But at what point is it the individuals responsibility to save money for a rainy day?

It depends on what you mean by a rainy day. I don't think I'd judge most people too harshly in our current system. Circumstances can change in ways that an individual probably won't or can't foresee. Housing and other living expenses have grown to the point that a low wage worker can barely support themselves in many cities.

Personally I'd like to reach a point where society provides enough for a comfortable existence e.g. shelter, food, safety, healthcare, and a small disposable income for hobbies/leisure. At that point I think most people would be in a position where walking away from abusive employer is an actual option and not a punishing risk.

> But why should it be on the company?

It wouldn't need to be if social safety nets were strong enough. As it stands, losing your job has a much bigger impact on an employee than the employer.

Even with appropriate safety nets I think a case could still be made for discouraging companies from firing people lightly and requiring the effects to be cushioned due to the amount of upheaval finding a new job can cause both financially and socially.

> And what were the companies suppose to do (like the one I worked for) that ran out of money? Most people that tying your health insurance to your company is ass backwards. So why tie more of your livelihood to your company?

I view it as a failure of our current system that employee obligations aren't first in line when a company has to be liquidated. The employer/employee relationship is nominally one where the employee accepts a reduction in risk in exchange for giving up some of the value of your labour. Bankruptcy law in many places doesn't seem to respect this.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:48PM (#33205959)
> Even with appropriate safety nets I think a case could still be made for discouraging companies from firing people lightly and requiring the effects to be cushioned due to the amount of upheaval finding a new job can cause both financially and socially.

In the US, there is no stigma to losing your job via a reduction in force. As far as financially, I don’t have any moral objection to unemployment insurance being higher if we as a society choose for it to be higher.

> I view it as a failure of our current system that employee obligations aren't first in line when a company has to be liquidated

The VC funded company I worked for literal had no money when it was bought out for pennies. I was one of the people doing pitch decks to potential acquirers and in the room for the technical interviews with them.

Don’t get me wrong, this was 2012 and everyone from developers to tech support found a job quickly and we had plenty of warning.

The eventual acquirer laid almost everyone off immediately with a 1 month severance pay.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:24PM (#33206410)
> In the US, there is no stigma to losing your job via a reduction in force

Sorry, I could have been more clear here. I meant the loss of social relationships either at the company or by potentially having to move neighbourhood/city.

> The VC funded company I worked for literal had no money when it was bought out for pennies. I was one of the people doing pitch decks to potential acquirers and in the room for the technical interviews with them.

Most companies have at least some assets when they wind down. Putting employee obligations first simply means that any value derived from the liquidation is first used to settle that debt rather than other creditors.

If there were unpaid wages, then at some point the people running that company continued requiring their employees' labour despite knowing they couldn't keep their end of the contract. Some exceptions might be justifiable for smaller companies but I think we're far too lenient on people who knowingly steal from employees.

Most tech workers can deal with unpaid wages but I've seen it happen to bar and restaurant workers that aren't in as secure a position. The owners wind down the company and leave wages unpaid while immediately creating a new one in the same unit.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:30PM (#33207154)
> Sorry, I could have been more clear here. I meant the loss of social relationships either at the company or by potentially having to move neighbourhood/city.

Are you really going to put the onus on private companies to ensure that no one ever has to move from their hometown?

> Most companies have at least some assets when they wind down. Putting employee obligations first simply means that any value derived from the liquidation is first used to settle that debt rather than other creditors

A software companies only assets are the software and maybe a few laptops. These days many don’t even have servers.

Don’t get me wrong, we were guaranteed by our backers that we would be paid for every hour we worked and they kept their promise.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by Jochim on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:57PM (#33207473)
> Are you really going to put the onus on private companies to ensure that no one ever has to move from their hometown?

Not at all. I do think companies should be prevented from firing people without generous severance and/or good reason.

If there was a good social safety net then I'd be open to that being relaxed a bit.

> A software companies only assets are the software and maybe a few laptops. These days many don’t even have servers.

There's also IP but I think that's missing the point. Getting paid something is better than nothing and many companies do have assets that would cover some/all of their outstanding payroll. At the moment, as far as I'm aware, employee payroll is fairly far down the list of creditors. I believe it should be first.

> Don’t get me wrong, we were guaranteed by our backers that we would be paid for every hour we worked and they kept their promise.

I'm glad your backers treated you and your colleagues generously. My preference is usually to bake in desired outcomes like this rather than relying on individual generosity.

Re:Normalising Layoffs/Firing by scarface74 on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:04PM (#33208774)
> Not at all. I do think companies should be prevented from firing people without generous severance and/or good reason

It’s not a good reason that “we don’t have the money” or “we decided that our horse and buggy manufacturing division is no longer the direction we are going”?

A company is not a charity. The purpose of a company is to sell things at profit and they hire you with an understanding of exchanging labor for money.

> I'm glad your backers treated you and your colleagues generously. My preference is usually to bake in desired outcomes like this rather than relying on individual generosity.

So are you going to force investors to keep funding companies when they run out of money?