This just reinforces my feeling that a major driver behind VSCode's popularity is that people just don't know better [1]
1. Download WebStorm (or IDEA) and write some React in it. And Typescript. Refactor. Move code around. Use suggestions. It's leaps and bounds ahead of VSCode
2. Open settings, navigate to plugins, type in Prettier. Oh look, there's the plugin. An official plugin from JetBrains
What if my employer has N repos and several other languages, and JavaScript is just one of those.
VSCode allows me to stay with the same interface across multiple different repos.
Yes, if I’m doing Ruby or Java or C# I might choose a _different_ IDE for certain tasks in that language. But with a few plugins you can get a reasonably good generalist tool in VSCode, and even a pretty full featured one for certain languages
It certainly used to be (and I believe its still the case) that the "major" language plugins besides JS are only usable in their specific IDE or in IDEA Ultimate (which can run all of them) (i.e. PHP w/ PHPStorm, Ruby w/ RubyMine and Python w/ PyCharm)
You should try paying for an IDE. VSCode is great but if you're an engineer getting paid anywhere close to a Silicon Valley wage (or you can expense devtools), you deserve better :)
From the WebStorm page on JetBrains:
> WebStorm The smartest JavaScript IDE WebStorm is an integrated development environment for JavaScript and related technologies. Like other JetBrains IDEs, it makes your development experience more enjoyable, automating routine work and helping you handle complex tasks with ease.
Sure, some things are organized a bit differently, but basically, if you want to use multiple languages, just get IntelliJ, and you'll be set. It's cheaper than buying several other products, too.
The only one that seems a bit different is CLion, in that it does things that IntelliJ doesn't, and vice-versa.
So the answer to, "what if my employer has a repo of language X and then a different repo of Y?" is: it's very likely not a problem, because the IDEs are not as specialized as you're clearly imagining them to be.
At least when I last did this about two years ago, it wasn't. There are a ton of edge cases. For example, only CLion supported stepping through Rust in a debugger.
For highly specialized development teams I guess it makes sense, but for me it'd just be a waste of money.
That's why I use Sublime Text, since it's the only (good) editor that's compatible with anything I need it to do. An alternative like Fleet is very interesting, but it's still too early to make a fair comparison (Also that Adobe-esque "toolbox" app isn't winning it any points)
I open polyglot projects in whichever IDE is the closest superset of the languages it uses. Which normally means whatever language the service is written in, and plugins for other languages.
For example (and if I remember correctly), Webstorm doesn't support a project with different modules, so if you want to split it in two or more parts you have to either create it with Idea and "import" it in Webstorm, or manually edit the project file.
Other than that, IntelliJ is as universal as it gets.
I pay for the All Products Pack purely out of convenience - If I wanted to spend a ton of time tweaking my IDE, I'd go back to Emacs!
It's also paid vs free. For some reason, some people are very reluctant to pay for tools, even though they use them every day in their job.
This also really baffles me. You can see it a lot in various discussions even here on HN.
And if Microsoft decides to kill VSCode, I seriously doubt anyone is going to keep maintaining it at the place where it is now. Even if someone decides to continue maintaining the base editor, Microsoft abandoning it will pretty quickly dry up the plugin ecosystem.
"It's open source, so it will always be available to me" only really makes sense if your backup plan is to maintain it yourself. In the case of VSCode, you are relying on a whole ecosystem continuing to survive after the sponsor abandons it.
Usually what happens is that after enough years have passed, the company funding the free IDE starts to wonder why exactly they're spending so much money to give away the results. The original passion-project founders have moved on, leaving behind maintenance devs who aren't motivated to defend it. Eventually it gets stripped to a handful of devs and donated to Apache. In the meantime IntelliJ continues to develop new features.
The question VSCode users might wonder about is what's Microsoft's strategy here? They have plenty of money, but then again so did Sun/Oracle and IBM. Is there a long term commercial plan to let the VSCode team justify themselves.
Exactly, especially since VSCode is also an "open-core" product, just like JetBrain's products (the community versions are open-source).
The difference is that the other parts are still free, as in beer. But this is precisely what makes the offer weird to me and makes me think there's a shady angle being played.
I used to pay Jetbrains annually, out of my own pocket. I continued paying fir a personal license even after my employer bought me another license. Jetbrains then made a stupid, greedy decision[1] (and walked or back within days), but I was done with them and canceled my subscription.
Since then, my experience/growth, languages tech stacks and codebases have connived to make Jetbrains superior discoverability moot (not using Java!), I found out other IDEs are good enough for me.
1. Some years back, they decided on an IDE-as-a-service path where they were going to brick your IDE the day your subscription lapsed. The fact that they thought this was acceptable and announced it means they cannot be trusted, IMO.
No they didn't. This is a total mischaracterisation of how JB's subscription works.
I don't understand how you could possibly have read my comment as describing their current licensing practices, with the tenses I was using.
You can go read up on the disastrous announcement and the followup at https://blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2015/09/03/introducing-jetbr...
IDEs as in plural, like several IDEs? What IDEs are you using now? I'm yet to find something that is as good for several languages as Idea Ultimate? Yes, for some languages Vscode plugin is superior, but overall as a polyglot I find Idea experience the best all things considered.
I am very happy that VSCode is mostly just editor.
If you have Fleet license (paid, for example) there are no criteria checks at all, just the license verification with your JetBrains Account. And we plan to support offline usage similar to how it’s done for IntelliJ IDEA-based IDEs now (offline license keys, floating license server.)
Right now Fleet is in the EAP, and there are no licensing checks at all, they are not yet implemented, and we are not yet done with the verification workflow design.
The info in the link provided addresses the only concrete portion of your comment, which is that, yes, most Russian employees have moved elsewhere.
What about Gitlab, or some other repo such as gitlab.gnome.org? This seems like it's ripe for edge cases.
gitlab.gnome.org - I'd expect it to be all open source, right? Open source program should cover such cases.
The best-case scenario I can imagine is that I have to enter a public URL into the editor that JetBrains can then `git clone` from their server.
I can’t imagine “JetBrains curates a list of all public git servers” ends well. (As a Tildegit user.)
The issue is marked "shelved" while consistently active. Do you have any ability to run this up the flagpole, please? I and many others would be very grateful.
Does the front end stack of Fleet allow one to run it in a browser when using a remote back end? The same way you can run the back end of VS Code or JupyterLab on a server and render the front end in a browser tab?
I understand you can run the front end locally on your desktop and the back end configured as a remote on a server, but the rendering of the front end in a browser is what I need for the dev environment I need to use at work[1].
https://code.visualstudio.com/docs/getstarted/telemetry
You can also dump all possible telemetry events at the command-line.
Source: https://www.roboleary.net/tools/2022/04/20/vscode-telemetry....
> Next, I wanted to see what would happen when I disabled telemetry. After some activity, I checked the log, and found no events were logged. That is good.
> The absence of logged events doesn’t mean that data is not being sent though! A more accurate way to see what is being sent out is to monitor your outgoing network traffic and analyze the packets.
But unfortunately the author doesn't do that
A bit further down they say
> It looks like you cannot shut telemetry off 100%. These settings will opt you of most data sharing scenarios; but not all data sharing scenarios
And even VSCodium doesn't take it all out
> Even though we do not pass the telemetry build flags (and go out of our way to cripple the baked-in telemetry), Microsoft will still track usage by default.
If you're really trying to win VS Code users, such a flexible rule may scare them away.
I have looked into source codes of some and were horrified, but well, some people actually like Java and like that sort of stuff. Maybe I looked into wrong ones.
VSCode plugins seems to be easier to write, but maybe that’s because I know JavaScript already.
What made me switch to VSCode is that it’s generally snappier, IDEA has the “Indexing” mode that always takes forever
Fleet seems like a new lighter architecture. Which is fantastic. My hope is they can actually bring the tools from their other platforms into this.
Otherwise... they might as well just sell a IDE plugin architecture for VSCode.
ALSO I just noticed this but can someone (ideally from JetBrains) explain what this line means: "Requires login and periodic connection to JetBrains servers to verify the project" (specifically the last 3 words of that sentence). Quite frankly this line is extremely alarming, are you saying that you're scanning my project to make sure it's not a "professional" project? I'm going to assume this line means that they are checking the IDE and not your source but I won't be using this product until I get an explanation for this. You can find this at the very bottom in the licensing and pricing section.
[1]: https://prettier.io/