News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by mariusmg on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:28AM (#33176654)
>It's leaps and bounds ahead of VSCode

It's also paid vs free. For some reason, some people are very reluctant to pay for tools, even though they use them every day in their job.

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by rubyist5eva on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:40AM (#33176813)
Easy solution: make your employer pay for it. IntelliJ tools increase my productivity where saved time easily goes into days, it's easily justified from a cost perspective to an employer.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by dmitriid on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:31AM (#33176691)
> For some reason, some people are very reluctant to pay for tools, even though they use them every day in their job.

This also really baffles me. You can see it a lot in various discussions even here on HN.

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by HideousKojima on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:44AM (#33176858)
Because if your tooling is closed source (and if it's paid it almost certainly is) then your ability to maintain a project is dependent on some corporation's willingness to continue to support the tooling etc.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by lolinder on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:36AM (#33177626)
If the possibility of your tooling being discontinued is a real concern for you, paying for a Jetbrains license is your best bet. Their entire business is developer tooling: IntelliJ isn't going away until Jetbrains goes under, and they're not going under until people stop paying them. Microsoft, on the other hand, could decide to drop VSCode at any point as soon as the bean counters start questioning how it's benefiting the bottom line.

And if Microsoft decides to kill VSCode, I seriously doubt anyone is going to keep maintaining it at the place where it is now. Even if someone decides to continue maintaining the base editor, Microsoft abandoning it will pretty quickly dry up the plugin ecosystem.

"It's open source, so it will always be available to me" only really makes sense if your backup plan is to maintain it yourself. In the case of VSCode, you are relying on a whole ecosystem continuing to survive after the sponsor abandons it.

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by mike_hearn on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:51AM (#33177833)
It's worth noting that JetBrains has a long history of successfully competing against free IDEs, which were normally always more popular than IntelliJ. First there was NetBeans (bought and open sourced by Sun very early), then there was Eclipse (developed and open sourced by IBM), now there is VSCode. Heck there are probably others I don't know about. So, this is nothing new for them.

Usually what happens is that after enough years have passed, the company funding the free IDE starts to wonder why exactly they're spending so much money to give away the results. The original passion-project founders have moved on, leaving behind maintenance devs who aren't motivated to defend it. Eventually it gets stripped to a handful of devs and donated to Apache. In the meantime IntelliJ continues to develop new features.

The question VSCode users might wonder about is what's Microsoft's strategy here? They have plenty of money, but then again so did Sun/Oracle and IBM. Is there a long term commercial plan to let the VSCode team justify themselves.

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by vladvasiliu on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:04AM (#33178013)
> The question VSCode users might wonder about is what's Microsoft's strategy here? They have plenty of money, but then again so did Sun/Oracle and IBM. Is there a long term commercial plan to let the VSCode team justify themselves.

Exactly, especially since VSCode is also an "open-core" product, just like JetBrain's products (the community versions are open-source).

The difference is that the other parts are still free, as in beer. But this is precisely what makes the offer weird to me and makes me think there's a shady angle being played.

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by mike_hearn on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @11:33AM (#33178496)
Well, I doubt it's shady. Seems more likely they don't know what to charge for it and are incentivized to create user growth rather than revenue growth.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by frou_dh on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:55AM (#33177017)
Not really in the case of Jetbrains vs VScode, because if the fateful day came, it would simply be an inconvenience to have to set up the alternative, not the end of the world.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by kaba0 on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:58AM (#33177061)
Most of intellij is open-source.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by mrighele on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:29PM (#33180221)
As long as you can build the project with standard tools (e.g. npm for javascript, maven/gradle for Java etc.) you can survive your favorite IDE disappearing suddenly from one day to the other. It is more o less a requirement if you use CI/CD and a non issue anyway since any decent IDE can generate and synchronize a project using an external tools as a source of truth.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by fedorareis on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @01:26PM (#33180171)
It is precisely because I use it every day that I use VSCode. As much as I like some of the features of JetBrains IDEs I have also had more headaches with them than VSCode. For example at my previous employer our dev machines weren’t great and I routinely needed to have multiple projects open at once. If I tried doing that in IntelliJ it would make my computer basically unusable. When I gave up and used VSCode for all of my projects I was able to have all the projects I needed open without any issues and without really losing any productivity. If JetBrains IDEs were lighter on the system I would consider switching back to them, but honestly at this point I don’t see a benefit in switching back.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by sangnoir on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @02:06PM (#33180699)
> For some reason, some people are very reluctant to pay for tools, even though they use them every day in their job.

I used to pay Jetbrains annually, out of my own pocket. I continued paying fir a personal license even after my employer bought me another license. Jetbrains then made a stupid, greedy decision[1] (and walked or back within days), but I was done with them and canceled my subscription.

Since then, my experience/growth, languages tech stacks and codebases have connived to make Jetbrains superior discoverability moot (not using Java!), I found out other IDEs are good enough for me.

1. Some years back, they decided on an IDE-as-a-service path where they were going to brick your IDE the day your subscription lapsed. The fact that they thought this was acceptable and announced it means they cannot be trusted, IMO.

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by lemming on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:32PM (#33183657)
Some years back, they decided on an IDE-as-a-service path where they were going to brick your IDE the day your subscription lapsed.

No they didn't. This is a total mischaracterisation of how JB's subscription works.

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by mardifoufs on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:06PM (#33184961)
I think they did, but then walked back and announced that you will just fallback to the previous version of whatever IDE you were subscribed to if you cancel the subscription. I think the situation caused quite a backlash when they announced the original plans.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by sangnoir on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:55PM (#33185388)
I clearly mentioned they walked back the decision within days of the initial announcement.

I don't understand how you could possibly have read my comment as describing their current licensing practices, with the tenses I was using.

You can go read up on the disastrous announcement and the followup at https://blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2015/09/03/introducing-jetbr...

Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by lemming on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @08:18PM (#33185574)
Fair enough - I guess we will have to agree to disagree on whether that warrants never trusting them again.
Re:JetBrains invites developers to join the Fleet Public Pre... by ihateolives on Thursday October 13, 2022 @12:53AM (#33187374)
> I found out other IDEs are good enough for me.

IDEs as in plural, like several IDEs? What IDEs are you using now? I'm yet to find something that is as good for several languages as Idea Ultimate? Yes, for some languages Vscode plugin is superior, but overall as a polyglot I find Idea experience the best all things considered.