Now I have stored the whole disk image in the cloud (BackBlaze), let see in 2043 if I can still access it!
I do really wish there to be a type of storage medium that I could record, store somewhere, and forget about. And then when I need it years later, it would still be perfectly readable. Optical discs are indeed kinda that, but their reliability is hit or miss.
I also have some external magnetic HDD that is now already ~10 years old, stored in the same conditions as the aforementioned CD, let see how it fares in 2032 :)
But either way, you won't be paying more in rent and/or utilities for having an extra box in your closet.
The average rent per square meter is about $20/month (more in Copenhagen, less outside the big cities).
I suspect I can not store 144TByte in the cloud for $20/month.
You might argue that I do have that many DVD's. But then I do have many small corners and shelves that is not much use for anything else. And it would be even more unlikely to be able to store say 14 TByte in the cloud for $2/month.
Google Archive storage is $0.0012/month (3x cheaper than Amazon Glacier, which surprised me). 144TB would be $173/month, so 9x cheaper to keep in your home.
I think your estimate of how many DVDs you can put in a given space is a bit optimistic: you're assuming no protection between discs and that a floor-to-ceiling tower is stable. If instead we imagine putting them in cases that double their thickness and putting collections of them in boxes that add 10% to the total height, though, it's 4x cheaper to keep them in your apartment. But if you use Blu-ray instead of DVD it's 20x cheaper!
https://www.amazon.com/Verbatim-DVD-R-4-7GB-UltraLife-Archiv...
Archaeologists have read engraved stones after thousands of years of neglect!
Whether the format it was written in is still comprehensible could be a more pertinent question.
It could be a case of using the original drive to read the media, versus some cost-cut version that’s on the market these days.
For my photo history I prefer to keep PAR files next to it. On a running mechanical disc I haven't seen issues when running the repair. I do expect to see some errors in the future and as long as it stays under a certain percentage, things will be fixable.
I started doing this long time in the past, when harddisks were awful. I would often lose mp3 files due to damage. With mp3 you can easily hear it. With jpeg images you can often see damage as well.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_correction_code#Forward_...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reed%E2%80%93Solomon_error_cor...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross-interleaved_Reed–Solom...
I have long since moved away from optical media, really for anything, but especially archival. Long term storage to me looks like an array of magnetic disks held together with ZFS.
The earliest CDs I had were from 1994 or so, though most were from early 2000s. They were mostly cheapest CD-Rs you could buy back then, so I was expecting most of them be completely unusable.
But most of them still read perfectly. I had maybe half a dozen (out of hundreds) that were completely unreadable, mostly due to peeling, about a dozen that were functionally unreadable, because there were so many unreadable files I couldn't save anything complete out of them, and maybe 10% that had less than 10 unreadable files on them.
I was surprised. I was really expecting almost all the early ones to be dead.
(And bizarrely, they did seem to make excellent ones)
http://fileformats.archiveteam.org/wiki/Outlook_Express_Data...
[1] https://sourceforge.net/projects/ol2mbox/
EDIT: mmh looks like it's now `libpst` and it's actually in the Debian/Ubuntu repos...
Really good archival optical media isn't susceptible to the same cosmic ray it magnetic fade while reducing the chances of disc rot or delamination.
Cosmic rays will eventually destroy anything that doesn't have an active repair process, including archival optical media, but the time scales are longer than when the Sun is predicted to swallow the Earth.
See also my comment yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33116760
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/stg/structur...
I got to live again some >20 years old memories, pictures of younger me with my friends. stupid things you would save as a late nerd teen with access to the Internet and a ton of emails in Outlook Express format (guilty!) that I could not open yet. I guess the format is probably not super-hard to parse (most of the content is plain text actually) but since I'm here, if you know of something already existing to convert it to mbox/maildir it would be cool!
[1] https://www.gnu.org/software/ddrescue/