News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by Shorel on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:24AM (#33104676)
I think it is properties again. And harder this time.

Except this time it is worse. It's not about the rising prices of properties, but the idea that there isn't something else more profitable than real state long term that makes me feel the economy is stuck in a bad place.

Cryptocurrencies are noisy news-makers, but their total value is still very small compared to basically anything else.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by imtringued on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:43AM (#33105171)
If you own land you own a piece of the planet. How much is permanent ownership over a given plot of land worth? Millions? Billions? Trillions? Infinite?

Why would any sane person even run a business if the government pays massive subsidies (public services) to make your land more valuable? Just buy more land.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by axiolite on Thursday October 06, 2022 @03:04AM (#33105321)
> How much is permanent ownership over a given plot of land worth?

> the government pays massive subsidies (public services) to make your land more valuable

Most of us have to pay taxes on property we own every year, pay for many of the public services (water, sewer, trash, etc.), and the benefits returned from taxes (like roads and police) are generally not worth the amount paid in a strict sense.

If you think a plot of land is oh so valuable, may I suggest you invest in some remote plots in Nevada, as there is no shortage, and they are quite inexpensive...

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by neilparikh on Thursday October 06, 2022 @06:33AM (#33106601)
> Most of us have to pay taxes on property we own every year, pay for many of the public services (water, sewer, trash, etc.), and the benefits returned from taxes (like roads and police) are generally not worth the amount paid in a strict sense.

If you don't think the benefits aren't worth it, why do you keep owning the property? Choosing to continue to own the property implies a revealed preference that the benefits outweigh the costs.

The biggest benefit from owning property is the right to exclusive use of a certain location for infinite time [0]. And the value of this right is proportional to how desirable living there is, which is made up of factors like economic liveness, proximity to nature, government services etc. The thing to note here is that while not all of these are due to government subsidy, all of these are the result of "other people's work"; you can just sit there and if other people do good work, the gains go to you.

Also, as a sidenote, most local services are not funded exclusively by property taxes: there's usually funding from things like sales and income taxes (either from that area, or transferred from higher levels of govt).

[0] - Minus property tax of course, but property tax is rarely equal to the benefit you get; if it was, the purchase price of the property would be 0.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by foobarian on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:35AM (#33107973)
I think you two are not on the same page about what the cost function is.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by andromeduck on Thursday October 06, 2022 @03:50AM (#33105636)
It's not the land that's valuable but the lands proximity to goods and services - in that sense, it's not fair that the value created by those goods and services is accrued by a private property that did not pay a proportionate fraction of the revenue sustaining it as the bulk of revenue is raise from other means.

This is where the Georgist idea of land value tax comes in.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by nopenopenopeno on Thursday October 06, 2022 @05:11AM (#33106181)
Georgism now
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by MrPatan on Thursday October 06, 2022 @03:20AM (#33105420)
Because land is very easily taken away, so very easy to tax
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by neilparikh on Thursday October 06, 2022 @06:47AM (#33106686)
In theory, yes, but the last few decades show the opposite is happening: property tax rates are limited in many states (CA prop 13 being the prime example), and income taxes and sales tax fund more and more.

For example, the federal govt's total revenue is 6 times the total property tax collected in the US (and this ignores state income/sales taxes).

In California specifically, just the personal income tax alone is more than the property tax collected. Once you add in the other sources, property tax revenue is half of non-property tax revenue.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by quonn on Thursday October 06, 2022 @04:08AM (#33105751)
It's not that easy to arbitrarily raising land taxes without doing a lot of economical damage. But you have a point: The land is inside a country and the country make all kinds of rules.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by francisofascii on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:56AM (#33107636)
> Because land is very easily taken away

Really? Are you referring to eminent domain? Unless you are going up against a highway, landowners have a ton of protections, in the US anyway.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by dredmorbius on Friday October 07, 2022 @05:16PM (#33126964)
Tax liens are a thing.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by throwaway290 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:05AM (#33104919)
I think it's scarcity (or to be precise scarcity mentality, which would probably extend into post-scarcity). The very reason for trying to find profit in the first place, real estate crypto or whatever, arises from wanting to outcompete someone else for resources.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by eftychis on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:31AM (#33105078)
That is the definition of an economy.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by imtringued on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:48AM (#33105203)
In theoretical microeconomics people's marginal utility per unit of effort is so low at some point that the marginal cost of additional effort exceeds the marginal utility and they stop working.

The expectation that every individual is trying to swallow the economy whole is actually impossible and the only reason why any individual would even consider pursuing that path is because for some reason the marginal cost of effort to obtain more utility is zero. In other words there is infinite demand for freebies but not infinite demand for things that require effort.

There is no such thing as a cost of zero, someone else will have to pay for it. It turns out the government offers a lot of free services that scale up with how much property you own and other people without property have to pay taxes to pay for those services.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by throwaway290 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:36AM (#33105110)
That's a weird definition of economy you have, but you do you.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by stuxnet79 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @05:30AM (#33106279)
It is hardly a "weird" definition. Economics and "the economy" as a whole fundamentally deal with scarcity.

Figuring out the most appropriate use of a good or service given that its scarce and has a multitude of "other" uses is the core problem that capitalism tries to solve.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by powerapple on Thursday October 06, 2022 @06:19AM (#33106528)
That's the definition of value storage. The economy works on greeds, realization of greeds, and creation of new greeds. Scarcity would lead to the greed of owning it.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by peteradio on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:07AM (#33107178)
Intro economics class our teacher posed a question "Would economics exist if everyone had a magic wand that could get them whatever they wanted?" I said "ya, cause someone would magic other peoples wands away then there would be an economy to restore peoples wands or grant wishes on behalf of people." Apparently that wasn't the answer they were looking for, but he said I might have some point. I think people just like messing with other people and that is inalienable.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by powerapple on Thursday October 06, 2022 @10:30AM (#33108643)
In developed world, we already have all the goods we want and need, we spend a lot money on services. It is kind of like the world your teacher described :)
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by throwaway290 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @10:35AM (#33108735)
Ultimately though resource scarcity and more importantly scarcity mentality is still here.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by throwaway290 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @07:58AM (#33107093)
Do you assume scarcity of resources is required for there to be a scarcity of products and especially services? You may still want to have someone cook you dinner without there being a scarcity of food. There is still art and stuff, live performances you may want to see. But no scarcity of resources, no need to fight for survival, the motivation to always optimize for profit at the expense of everything else
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by tjr225 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:28AM (#33104698)
Property is intrinsically limited. Property in desirably places is especially intrinsically limited. You’re basically lucky if you own any property at all at this point.

Just take a gander and how much property in Hong Kong or Amsterdam costs and you’ll start to think it is cheap in the US. It’s only going to get worse. Do you think that people are going to desire living in Santa Monica or Queen Anne less over the next few hundred years?

Our planet is getting smaller relative to the amount of people that live on it and relative to the habitable places that exist.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by kortilla on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:55AM (#33104849)
> Do you think that people are going to desire living in Santa Monica or Queen Anne less over the next few hundred years?

Milwaukee and Detroit were pretty desirable not that long ago. Cuba was quite nice 80+ years ago. Hong Kong was desirable globally just 10 years ago. What is “desirable” changes from many other factors so property investments absolutely aren’t a given.

Land in the middle of nowhere barely beats inflation and has varying degrees of ongoing costs depending on the jurisdiction.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by peteradio on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:14AM (#33107247)
I doubt arable farmland has generally gone down over the long view.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by mickdeek86 on Saturday October 08, 2022 @02:02AM (#33130171)
The campesinos may disagree about Cuba being "quite nice" 80 years ago, what with all the slavery and rape. But yes, a seemingly good real estate investment for foreigners.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by silisili on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:47AM (#33104794)
> Property in desirably places is especially intrinsically limited.

Yes...but property values are way up all over. Boise, Phoenix, Nashville...even middle of nowhere Kansas.

El Paso is having it rough. They've always had super cheap houses to the point of unbelievable...what most would consider a decked out mansion for 300k or so, and a 3+ percent property tax. Guess what's happening now that everyone's regular ol 150k house is now worth 400k?

Valuable property will always have value, but the vast majority of US property is not so desirable. It's already stalled, and it's going to be a bloodbath next year.

The real question is what happens when all the buyers of the last 3 or so years are underwater? We either end up in 2008 again, or tons of bailouts which just pushes inflation further towards the houses being worth it again.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by francisofascii on Thursday October 06, 2022 @07:43AM (#33106992)
Boise, Phoenix, and Nashville are all very desirable, actually. Just not top tier desirable like the Bay Area, NYC, Austin, DC, and Seattle.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by silisili on Thursday October 06, 2022 @12:53PM (#33110787)
I didn't mean to insult those cities per se, I just meant their specific location isn't special. Near-ocean land in California can't really be built forever, nor elsewhere. Whereas, many cities like those I listed (and Austin you listed) don't really have anything inherently special about them, landwise.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by DSingularity on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:18AM (#33104996)
Why would they sell? They live there now.

Why also would builders not keep prices high buy produce less?

2008 was bad loans coming to head. I don’t think it’s going to be the same.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by silisili on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:35AM (#33105106)
> Why would they sell

In many cases, they don't, they just walk away.

Would you stay in a 500k 2000sqft house that you have no equity in, when a 300k 2000sqft house was for sale next door? In a non-recourse state?

And even for principled people, when you lose your job or fall behind on something you overpaid for, it's really easy to just walk away.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by yawnr on Thursday October 06, 2022 @03:52AM (#33105647)
Because you have a 2.5% mortgage and your monthly payment is still smaller than than 300k house at current rates. This is going to be the main issue to me. People are just going to sit in all these houses with bloated prices because the rates they pay are so low, and prices are going to have a very hard time returning to anything close to what they were with inventory so low.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by tjr225 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:15PM (#33116280)
This is the situation I’m in. I’m in the Seattle metro and the mortgage on my 3 bedroom ranch is less than a 1 bedroom apartment in Seattle. I can commute if I need to but why would I ever give this up? I have 0 other debts which makes it extra compelling.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by thebradbain on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:47AM (#33105197)
Even in non-recourse states, walking away from your mortgage will decimate your credit score and preclude you from getting a mortgage on a cheaper property in practice, even if theoretically it pencils out on paper.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by DSingularity on Thursday October 06, 2022 @06:34PM (#33115000)
You will never get approved, unless you have workarounds. Even if you did that 7% interest rate will make it all even out for most people.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by ReptileMan on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:44AM (#33104785)
Except why is no one asking the question why so few places are desirable and doing something to alleviate it.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by lmm on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:17AM (#33104987)
Because housing policy is set up so that homeowners in desirable places are the ones who have control over whether more housing gets built there, and unsurprisingly they vote to enrich themselves at the cost of everyone else. The only way to fix it is to set planning rules strictly at the national level, but who's going to vote for that?
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by DocTomoe on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:32AM (#33105081)
And - in all fairness - enriching yourself only is the side-effect, the major other output being "there now is a (more) desirable place".

People want to live at increasingly more desirable places, and that is true even more so for people who cannot afford to: If such desirability was no object in their quest, Detroit would be full of people, the Bay Area wouldn't have so many issues with housing, and housing prices would be a non-issue.

If the alternative is "everywhere sucks equally", which is the likely outcome of a national-level central planning, I doubt you will find many takers.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by lmm on Thursday October 06, 2022 @10:29PM (#33116763)
I live somewhere with national-level planning rules and it's brilliant (indeed it's the most populous metropolitan area in the world, and I don't think that's coincidence).
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by DocTomoe on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:06AM (#33117948)
Without going too deep in Japanese real estate planning laws, iirc most I am aware of are more a "national guideline" and are frequently overridden by prefectures and cities. That's hardly on the level of actual national-planning, communist-style 5-year-plans.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by prottog on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:47AM (#33108097)
> The only way to fix it is to set planning rules strictly at the national level

You don't even need centralized planning. Just implement a proper land value tax [0] so that the desirability of a plot of land has to be commensurately paid for by the owner.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by socialismisok on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:52AM (#33104838)
Plenty of folks are, but if the thing you want to do about it is decommidify housing you get a whole lot of people saying, "that'll never work!" Without actually engaging with the ideas.

Plenty of ideas and people trying out there, just not much interest from the every day person.

Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by tjr225 on Thursday October 13, 2022 @02:01AM (#33187763)
Most of the time it’s because you get to live in a city and then also get to drive an hour and go hiking/skiing in the mountains or go to the beach. It isn’t very complicated.
Re:Charles Mitchell and the 1929 stock crash by just_boost_it on Thursday October 06, 2022 @12:36PM (#33110483)
I think when people forget that the crisis in 07/08 wasn't just a dip in property values. The entire financial system had managed to get itself propped up on extreme leverage against the single bet that mortgages would almost never default. That extreme leverage put the whole system in a highly unstable state, and it took just a little stress to pull the whole thing down. It collapsed the entire risk management systems of banks, funds and companies across the entire economy. That meant that there was nobody in the market that could lend, and everyone needed to borrow to try and plug the gaping hole that was ripped in their balance sheets.

The financial system just isn't completely levered to housing that way today. Today, an economic slowdown might lead to a dip in property prices, but to find an event that would cause widespread and long-lasting damage to the financial system I think you're going to have to look elsewhere.