News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Chess World by not_kurt_godel on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:07PM (#32989203)
> Also, clever cheating devices have been found in over the board chess competitions

The most convincing candidate for such a device I've seen is an Illuminati Thumper Pro hidden in Hans's shoe: https://illuminati-magic.com/products/thumper. If you watch the footage of him getting scanned before his match with Alireza (and, crucially, before Magnus announced he was dropping), there are a couple of subtle things that are consistent with this theory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIulWkTHuu0:

1. He swallows (seemingly nervously) at 4 seconds shortly before his left shoe is scanned.

2. As the left shoe is being scanned, there are 2 beeping noises that at least to me, sound like they are coming from the wand, but are seemingly ignored by the wander. The same beeps do not repeat when his right shoe is scanned (that is, it's not just metal parts built into the shoes themselves). Two caveats to this part: First, I've heard differing opinions on whether the thumper will trigger metal detectors. Second, it's possible (even if unlikely IMO) that those beeps are not from that wand and it's just a coincidence that another wand or object beeped - since we can't see the wand in frame.

3. At 1:17 he starts nervously fidgeting with the credit card as the RF scanner gets close to his left foot and noticeably slows down when the scanner switches from his left foot to the right foot, and appears to stop completely as soon as the scanner is moving up away from his right foot. The RF scanner, to my understanding, would only detect devices that are actively transmitting which the thumper shouldn't need to do at all if Hans were using purely to receive engine moves/hints during the but the fact that it theoretically could transmit would explain why he'd be nervous about getting scanned anyway.

Of course none of these observations are proof but they sure look suspicious to me.

Re:Dear Chess World by walrus01 on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:32PM (#32989472)
You don't need something that transmits if you're searching for bug-like devices or any general integrated circuits with a nonlinear junction detector:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonlinear_junction_detector

I am very far removed from anything related to Chess, but if they want to get serious about this they should hire people who specialize in the federal-contracting adjacent field of TSCM (technical surveillance countermeasures).

https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=tscm+tech...

I also think that people putting a lot of focus into shoes or other clothing articles underestimate the motivation and capability of people to use the traditional "prison wallet" method of concealing things.

Re:Dear Chess World by gpm on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:00PM (#32990203)
That's a fascinating device.

Wouldn't putting the electronics inside a conductive case hide them from it? Maybe it's hard to get an antenna out if you do that though?

Re:Dear Chess World by Tostino on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:17PM (#32990312)
The wiki said that it doesn't work against shielded electronics, however who knows how accurate that actually is. I really enjoyed the anecdote about the US embassy in Moscow having diodes embedded in the cement throughout to make finding actual bugs much harder.
Re:Dear Chess World by palmetieri2000 on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @06:25PM (#33014025)
>I also think that people putting a lot of focus into shoes or other clothing articles underestimate the motivation and capability of people to use the traditional "prison wallet" method of concealing things.

I felt silly for even thinking this, but seeing as you've mentioned it. It would be so hilarious if true considering he has offered to play naked[1] to prove his innocence!

1. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-09-07/rising-chess-star-off...

Re:Dear Chess World by deusum on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:08PM (#32990257)
With that nest of hair I wonder maybe he disassembles the device and puts small parts in various locations, the most detectable in the shoe or "the pocket".

Someone familiar with slight of hand could comfortably scratch here and there while dropping pieces in a 'build' pocket.

Re:Dear Chess World by jallen_dot_dev on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:25AM (#32991542)
You've seen the film The Man with the Golden Gun ? A cufflink here, a pen there, that pack of chewing gum... assembled together could be a cheating device.
Re:Dear Chess World by grouchomarx on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:25PM (#32990362)
of all the whacky theories I've heard so far this one stands out. Don't get too swept up in it
Re:Dear Chess World by chongli on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:30PM (#32991288)
I love it. The idea that someone would undergo training as a magician in order to cheat at chess is just hilarious! It’s not totally absurd though, given the history of cheating (as well as espionage) in sport.

The tricks people have pulled to cheat in baseball and (NFL) football are similarly amusing!

Re:Dear Chess World by thih9 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @06:05AM (#32993422)
My favourite, "Apple Watch and Cheating in Baseball": https://blog.watchdoctor.biz/2018/10/29/apple-watch-and-chea... .

If anyone has other examples, I'd love to read about them; it gives me similar satisfaction as learning how a magic trick works.

Re:Dear Chess World by avgcorrection on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @10:31AM (#32995700)
Doesn’t seem absurd at all to me. There might not be as much money in chess cheating as other scams but someone could be motivated to just become known as one of the best chess players.
Re:Dear Chess World by deusum on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:16PM (#32990937)
The first paragraph was mostly facetious.

The second merely suggests an unusually clever, yet plausible methodology.

[dead]
Re:Dear Chess World by mattnewton on Monday September 26, 2022 @09:38PM (#32990763)
That was a joke reddit post.
Re:Dear Chess World by Consultant32452 on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:22PM (#32990970)
lol can't believe I fell for that one. Thanks!
Re:Dear Chess World by cowmoo728 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:52AM (#32991654)
correction: twitch comment
Re:Dear Chess World by mattnewton on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @10:39AM (#32995818)
I believe this is the source reddit comment, though it was riffed all over twitch and Twitter afterwards: https://www.reddit.com/r/chessmemes/comments/x8217h/the_real...

Here's a link to the original comment, since removed: https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/x77n0h/comment/inazu...

Re:Dear Chess World by IIAOPSW on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:41AM (#32992161)
Jokes about Buttfish (a play on the chess engine stockfish) are surely older than both.
Re:Dear Chess World by mellosouls on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:42PM (#32990446)
You miss the vitally important point: they weren't needed in the game in question, so we don't even get to the point where fanciful theorising is relevant.

Magnus didn't play particularly well and Hans played ok. This was not an example of a superhuman intelligence passing hints to overcome Magnus at his best.

Re:Dear Chess World by matai_kolila on Monday September 26, 2022 @09:05PM (#32990576)
Understated part of Magnus’ play is that he may have been playing a worse line that should have pushed Hans out of theory, but apparently didn’t.

I don’t totally buy Hans didn’t prepare the weird line, but it’s worth calling out; it’s at least marginally possible that Magnus out himself in an unwinnable position on purpose, but couldn’t convert it.

Re:Dear Chess World by notshift on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:58PM (#32990540)
> Magnus didn't play particularly well and Hans played ok.

Everyone says this, but do you really know? Those statements are after-the-fact observations of engine evaluations. They don't speak to the amount of mental work that Hans would have had to put in to play optimally (or 'ok' as you say) in those positions.

You might find yourself making the same remarks when looking at the post-game analysis of any top player against an engine. Everyone crumples eventually against perfect play.

Re:Dear Chess World by kennyloginz on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:30PM (#32991283)
Yah, even to club level players, Magnus played a bad game. Hans had nowhere close to perfect play ( I think the stock fish analysis says it’s close to 70% best moves, which is equivalent to Hans rating ). As a club level player, it blows my mind how many people are siding with Magnus. : edit, typo
Re:Dear Chess World by WastingMyTime89 on Monday September 26, 2022 @09:03PM (#32990568)
> They don't speak to the amount of mental work that Hans would have had to put in to play optimally (or 'ok' as you say) in those positions.

Yes, they do. When Magnus makes poor choice - not giving himself an advantage or playing moves giving black an advantage - it makes it easier for black. That’s the whole point.

Re:Dear Chess World by inimino on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @06:29AM (#32993547)
No, that is not how that works. An engine evaluation saying that a position is better for black does not mean that it is easier for a human to play that position. Easy to play and winning for an engine are orthogonal concepts.

Putting your opponent in positions that are better according to the engine but only with engine-like perfect play is a strategy at the highest levels of chess. Because the move is objectively worse, it won't be played, because it's not played, your opponent won't know it, because they don't know it, you'll play it better, then you win.

Re:Dear Chess World by lupire on Monday September 26, 2022 @09:58PM (#32990855)
Magnus letter explained that he claimed to notice Niemann's odd behavior during the game. That may have distracted him.
Re:Dear Chess World by camjohnson26 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:02AM (#32991700)
Even better, in that video he has a pack of gum that sets off the sensor, the security guard takes it, finishes the scan, and then gives it back! Obviously not proof of cheating but how hard would it have been to hide a device in that pack of gum?
Re:Dear Chess World by Freeboots on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:53AM (#32992228)
Now I want to watch the tournament footage to see if he ever chews gum...
Re:Dear Chess World by entropicdrifter on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:59PM (#32997999)
He chews pretty much the whole game
Re:Dear Chess World by roflyear on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:25PM (#32989402)
Now analyze a video of Magnus being wanded!
Re:Dear Chess World by Bud on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:41PM (#32989557)
Why? Has Magnus admitted to cheating on multiple occasions in the past? No. He has not.
Re:Dear Chess World by Dylan16807 on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:58PM (#32989712)
As a control.

You want to look for evidence that such an intense level of scrutiny is too good at finding signs of ill intent.

[dead]
Re:Dear Chess World by bombcar on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:06PM (#32989787)
Now I’m waiting for the big reveal when it turns out Carlson has been three PC Jrs stacked on top of each other all these years.
Re:Dear Chess World by swyx on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:31PM (#32989455)
is there any thinking on how many bits of information do you need to cheat, and how many can be communicated via thumper?

e.g. is the bit of information "move the knight" aka theres only about 4 bits of info, or is it "move the knight to E6" which is a good deal more bits, that could be lossy/error prone.

just on the surface of it, i dont see how this thing could give enough info but i suppose with a loooot of training you could improve the info transfer rate?

Re:Dear Chess World by rococode on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:46PM (#32989600)
Here's a relevant quote from Magnus regarding cheating:

"I would just needed to cheat one or two times during a match, and I would not even need to be given moves, just the answer on which move was way better, or here there is a possibility of winning and here you need to be more careful. That is all I would need in order to be almost invincible."

Even just 1 bit - an indication to be careful - would be enough to boost the strength of a GM. An accomplice coughing in the background to let you know there's something to watch for. For a strong player - and there's no doubt that Niemann is a strong player, the question is just how strong - that's all they need to avoid making mistakes. GMs can solve insanely hard puzzles, because they know it's a puzzle and has a specific solution. Same thing with 1 bit of info.

Of course, realistically they could simply use Morse code instead of "bits" and transmit two squares (just 4 Morse "letters").

Re:Dear Chess World by swyx on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:54PM (#32989688)
yes but against magnus, who is supposedly two levels above Hans, this is not just a one move cheat, he'd have to cheat + have a continuous absence of mistakes, which is an awful lot of information to transmit.

i dont have a horse in this race i just like thinking about things in terms of information theory since this is a remarkable applied case

another way to decide this - have them play blitz (where the moves are way too fast for info transmission to happen), and see if the skill level scales accordingly?

Re:Dear Chess World by chongli on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:36PM (#32991318)
have them play blitz (where the moves are way too fast for info transmission to happen), and see if the skill level scales accordingly?

Not a fair contest. There are plenty of top classical chess players who are weaker in blitz and vice versa. It’s a different skillset. Classical is all about preparation for the opening followed by some deep thinking in the midgame. Blitz is all about pattern recognition and the ability to simplify down to an ending where you can blitz out the exact solution from a database.

Re:Dear Chess World by vintermann on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @06:08AM (#32993432)
It's true that some people are worse at blitz, but if Niemann's OTB blitz rating is as good as his OTB rating at slower time controls, that's evidence against him cheating ... at least in ways that materially affect his rating. I guess it would be possible to cheat with an engine tuned to your actual rating just to make it less stressful.
Re:Dear Chess World by Taek on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:27AM (#32991550)
Well, even endgames with as few as 5 pieces on the board are beyond what a human can solve with memorization. I don't disagree that blitz is mostly pattern recognition and rapid tactical thinking, but that applies all the way down to the end.
Re:Dear Chess World by jquery on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:34PM (#32991025)
Two levels if he isn't cheating. If he is, perhaps 3 or more. Recently magnus played hans on the beach: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T1OBEY99inw

magnus completely destroyed hans in two games, as black. I think the ease with which magnus took hans apart in these beach games, presumably added to his suspicion when hans played so much better in the Sinquefield cup.

Re:Dear Chess World by Taek on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:31AM (#32991568)
Eh casual play has so many factors. I wouldn't put much weight on how badly a gm loses on the beach. For example, drugs could have been involved.

I do think Hans is cheating, but I think the proof will lie in statistical analysis of his games and demonstrating that he has an unusual (>3200 rated) propensity to clutch out specific moves. I think everyone suspects at this point that if Hans is cheating, its only a handful of moves per game.

Re:Dear Chess World by cool_dude85 on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:54PM (#32990166)
>this is not just a one move cheat, he'd have to cheat + have a continuous absence of mistakes

Blunders are exactly what a device like the one described would seriously help with. If the buzz means both "there is an only move here and it's not immediately obvious" and "at least one of the natural moves here is a blunder or very inaccurate" then you need to just send a buzz and you've probably cut inaccuracies significantly. That said, a very simple communication device like this is probably badly hurt by a 15 minute delay.

Re:Dear Chess World by SamBam on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:33PM (#32991019)
> at least one of the natural moves here is a blunder

Interesting, I'm not sure if a computer has the ability to recognize something as a "natural move but also a blunder." It would require a very human-like way of thinking about moves, which computers don't generally have.

Re:Dear Chess World by fizx on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:33AM (#32991818)
Anyone 1500+ can recognize the natural move--that's what makes it natural.

Probably the easiest case of "natural move but blunder" is anything that is a top 3 engine move when looking 3-5 moves deep, but losing significantly on deeper evaluation.

Also, this sort of categorization is at the heart of how chess puzzle collections are automatically assembled. A good chess puzzle contains an unnatural move that wins--the exact opposite of the natural but blunder. Chess sites scan their online play databases for these all the time, and serve them up as puzzles.

Re:Dear Chess World by SamBam on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @08:49AM (#32994643)
> Anyone 1500+ can recognize the natural move--that's what makes it natural.

Any human 1500+ can recognize the natural human move. The way the computer thinks about moves is different.

I really don't believe that Stockfish can tell you "this move is tempting, but wrong."

I'm sure you could build something in that might kind of work, but until I see it I'm skeptical.

Re:Dear Chess World by folli on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:51PM (#32991387)
In any case, you would need a human operator who is a very strong chessplayer himself.
Re:Dear Chess World by cuu508 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:52AM (#32992221)
Magnus Carlsen has commented that Hans' mentor Maxim Dlugy "must be doing a great job"

https://youtu.be/c50PJmOj2-U?t=83

Re:Dear Chess World by asimpletune on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:44PM (#32990087)
Carlsen has broken 3000 in blitz before... Unfortunately he's too good for it to mean anything I think.
Re:Dear Chess World by derefr on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:50PM (#32990131)
> he'd have to cheat + have a continuous absence of mistakes, which is an awful lot of information to transmit.

Perhaps a top-level player can jump to a higher level if they can stop worrying about coming up with brilliances in the macro strategy, and instead focus entirely on making their micro-level play spotless.

Re:Dear Chess World by CrazyStat on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:28PM (#32991275)
This is the opposite of what a computer-assisted player would do. Computer chess engines (generally speaking, somewhat less true of the latest generation) are not great at high level strategy but will never miss a tactic (micro level play).
Re:Dear Chess World by Taek on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:28AM (#32991553)
That's outdated, now that we have deep learning the machines are great at high level strategy too.
Re:Dear Chess World by WastingMyTime89 on Monday September 26, 2022 @09:06PM (#32990582)
> two levels above Hans

What does that even mean?

ELO gives you a statistical evaluation of how likely victory is for one of the player. Hans rating means he has non insignificant chance of winning against Magnus.

Hans can win without cheating as this last game proves. There is not a shred of evidence against him after all.

Re:Dear Chess World by mcv on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:03AM (#32992684)
Sounds like not just the players need to be checked for cheating devices, but the audience too. Or the players have to play in a faraday cage without an audience.

It's not going to make the game more fun, but it's probably necessary.

Re:Dear Chess World by noitpmeder on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:51PM (#32989660)
From what I understand you only need one bit. The assistance doesn't need to be "move piece P to square S", but "this position is critical, if you spend extra time exploring here you will find a winning move".

As these players are on timers there is a race against a clock. So if you know where to focus your time/effort you can easily gain an advantage.

Re:Dear Chess World by squeaky-clean on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:03PM (#32989756)
Just "e6" would likely be enough context in most situations. Sometimes only one piece can legally move there. Sometimes it's obvious which piece should move there once the position is pointed out.
Re:Dear Chess World by jasonwatkinspdx on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:13PM (#32989845)
I watched the livestreams of Andrea Botez's games in Vegas. Something I was really struck by is even though she's not a GM strength player, her mental board visualization skills are way up there. She did post game debriefs on the streams where she went rapid fire through hundreds of variations with her cohost just verbally. She'd go through them faster than the host could click to show chat at times.

Now imagine what people like the Super GMs are capable of.

Re:Dear Chess World by lysp on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:52PM (#32991103)
I saw a video a while ago.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eC1BAcOzHyY

They put a number of mid-game positions on the board, and Magnus was able to guess the players, tournament, game number, who won, what the next few moves were. Who was playing on the table next to him. What their moves were.

Re:Dear Chess World by fizx on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:35AM (#32991837)
Half the reason people believe Hans was cheating is cause he couldn't do this for the game in question.
Re:Dear Chess World by roflyear on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @11:05AM (#32996256)
Yeah. This is why I think those people are full of shit.

First, those people should look at his YouTube. Obviously he's capable of analyzing games. To think he'd be incapable of analyzing a game he just played? What? It makes no sense.

To think that someone, even if they were cheating in every game, was not a 2600ish rated player and to perform like Hans is just ridiculous. Every 2600 player can out analyze anyone who is a 2100 player (Botez).

The argument doesn't stand up at all.

Re:Dear Chess World by Raidion on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:18PM (#32990322)
You don't have to imagine, check out any post match press conference or when players discuss over the board after the game.

They remember all the variations they consider, and they've considered most of the variations their opponents have calculated, so the variations aren't new branches, they're just pointers to spots in the game tree both players have in their heads.

Re:Dear Chess World by deadfoxygrandpa on Monday September 26, 2022 @10:04PM (#32990887)
just watch this https://youtu.be/pUgvAoTzWBA and you will see what super gms are capable of
Re:Dear Chess World by viraptor on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:50PM (#32989645)
At their level it's pretty much known what location / piece they're thinking about. For key moments, it may be enough to transmit the piece name only. And have some follow up for destination if they really need them.
Re:Dear Chess World by pdpi on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:31PM (#32990397)
One move is 12 bits at most. 3 bits each X/Y, two XY pairs for source and destination.
Re:Dear Chess World by philsquared_ on Monday September 26, 2022 @08:40PM (#32990440)
You would only need one set of coordinates. The destination coordinates. Any high level chess players would only need that information to dominate.
Re:Dear Chess World by TakeBlaster16 on Monday September 26, 2022 @09:12PM (#32990621)
Honestly I think all you'd need is the piece. There are 6 pieces, so that's 3 bits of info with room to spare.
Re:Dear Chess World by Bud on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:43PM (#32989573)
Not many at all. For instance it takes a maximum of 6 bits to encode a given destination square on the board. This is probably sufficient, or very close to it.
Re:Dear Chess World by kQq9oHeAz6wLLS on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:37PM (#32989521)
I would think a shorthand code would be employed
Re:Dear Chess World by swyx on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:52PM (#32989669)
we're dealing with bits of info here, thats the shortest hand there is
Re:Dear Chess World by kQq9oHeAz6wLLS on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:37AM (#32991591)
Sure, but the number of bits is what I meant
Re:Dear Chess World by fbnlsr on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @05:02AM (#32993035)
If chess TO are that scared of cheaters, they should just take each player measurements and provide them with their own clothing/accessories.
Re:Dear Chess World by xxs on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @06:06AM (#32993426)
you missed the beads in the butt story
Re:Dear Chess World by Ekaros on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @06:31AM (#32993563)
Deep cavity search livestreamed before match.

Or lock them in transparent cube for week before match naked... So many solutions that specially person like Carlsen should be open to.

Re:Dear Chess World by thatguy0900 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @12:43PM (#32997784)
Mandatory prematch laxatives
Re:Dear Chess World by maxbond on Monday September 26, 2022 @06:29PM (#32989440)
It's interesting speculation, I wouldn't say I was convinced but I did see what you meant.
Re:Dear Chess World by lupire on Monday September 26, 2022 @09:55PM (#32990842)
Tangent: any hack magician that uses that device deserves to lose their career.
Re:Dear Chess World by jansan on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @01:47AM (#32991894)
As opposed to chess, magic is about lying and cheating. Everybody knows it and everybody is fine with it in magic, as you can see here in Dary's legendary ambitious card routine:

https://youtu.be/w4iu5FMaR2o?t=71

Edit: At the grand finale at 7:51 he says it again: "I haven't cheated yet, but it's coming up."

Re:Dear Chess World by morelisp on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @05:19AM (#32993144)
Nonetheless there's a rough ranking of "acceptable lies", and a thumper - anything with a secretly complicit audience member, really - ranks near the bottom of that.