Indeed. If someone claimed that Ethereum is a scam and Vitalik Buterin is a scammer I would need them to substantiate that claim.
https://teddit.net/r/Bitcoin/comments/x0i8ts/just_traded_all...
- Governments were pretty late to the party with regulations/law enforcement because they understandably didn't know if it was serious. This meant your average person who lost in a scam probably had no justice.
- The volume of scams made it seem that all of this was normal - best case was you did some research that found out before you put money in. This is partly because of governments but also there's no central authority from the crypto side to say what is safe and what isn't. "Buyer beware" with an every day currency/payment system doesn't really do you any favors in terms of adoption.
- People lost substantial real money to complicated technical issues on top of the scams
- All of this meant you had to do your research to fundamentally use the thing safely, which turned it more into an investing chore than payment convenience.
So it's actually pretty reasonable if someone has this impression
Everything else...literally everything else in the space appears to be pump and dump, get rich quick scams: ICOs, NFTs, new coins appearing constantly, etc.
Kudos to Ethereum for pulling off the merge. There's a lot of people heavily invested in mining that this move threatens and they're going to scream about it. IMO Eth2 is the future core of everything in the web3 space.
0. In the beginning we had no legitimacy, so we courted regulators and current financial types in as a means of legitimacy by proxy.
1. Those financial types and regulators who had open minds joined, shenanigans ensued, and we saw a replaying of all the dirty tricks that were outlawed in traditional markets like front-running.
2. Then fast forward to where we are now; industry types who came in early are making a killing and funding legislation like New York's BitLicense, which pushes toward centralization by outlawing participation for 'unaccreddited' types like the nerds who built this whole shindig.
For folks like me who just want to build distributed systems and tackle issues like consensus, it's hard to be taken seriously, because we're all just trying to do our work but we're trapped in this casino where there's starting to be more pinky rings than poker chips and it's only getting worse.
I don't know if you ever argued against that massive energy footprint as "FUD". But I do find it pretty hilarious to see a crypto proponent now use that as a positive. "We're not wasting country-sized amounts of electricity anymore!"
FWIW, I don't think most crypto-critics (yours truly included) argue that it's not technically interesting. We argue that it's tech in search of a (mostly) non-existent problem, that has a whole host of very negative externalities.
Given crypto isn’t going to die tomorrow, it’s good to see Ethereum has sunset the combustion engine for the EV (Proof of Work -> Proof of Stake). Even if you hate Ethereum, reducing electricity usage of the network by 90%+ is admirable.
The power dynamics were always there, though, just obscured by additional requirements of some level of technical competence.
There has to be a goal insight, otherwise it's just technical virtuosism for the sake of nothing. Nobody likes technical virtuosism for the sake of nothing otherwise guitar players who can play at 2000 bpm would dominate the billboard.
Blockchain is not a young technology it was conceived in 1996, almost 30 years later the usecase it's still obscure, except the only usecase has been to create a casino in disguise.
Making regular daily tasks less painful is a goal which if it was ever there has been abandoned post the first BTC run from 1$ to 127$
Until you bring up crypto.
But 2, there are liquid markets for crypto. So, while you might feel good typing out how you value crypto —- it simply doesn’t matter. Put your money where your mouth is. Short it.
Every person that took equity in a startup that then went out of business would love to talk with you. Believing bitcoin will be valuable for some people isn't really any different than believing pets.com will be successful or that tesla will actually be able to make electric cars and taking equity instead of cash for compensation.
All the more, we shouldn't cede financial power to Joe Shmoe and his pre-mined L2 chain.
Speak for yourself, noob.
PoS has been the clear future for better than five years and huge credit to the ETH team for making this happen.
It's easy to worship engineering as some kind of pure endeavor divorced from the real world, and admire cleverness for its own sake. But things that actively make the world worse should not necessarily be praised, no matter how clever they are.
The total market cap of ALL crypto is about 1 trillion today. So money laundering at a thousands of billions scale cannot use crypto.
Blame both.
USD is by far the most popular currency used for crime. It has stable price, accepted everywhere, and lacks a public ledger.
The internet got its start as a government weapon in the Cold War?
With The Merge, that no longer the case, and this is good for Ethereum and for cryptocurrency community.
https://decrypt.co/66411/cia-bitcoin-surveillance
> Michael Morell, who was previously the CIA’s acting director, said in ‘An Analysis of Bitcoin’s Use in Illicit Finance’ that “blockchain technology is a powerful but underutilized forensic tool for governments to identify illicit activity and bring criminals to justice.”
> Tracking illicit Bitcoin transactions is therefore easier than tracing illegal funds moved across borders using “traditional banking transactions” and “far easier” than trying to follow cash, according to the report.
> One source in the report was quoted saying that “if all criminals used blockchain, we could wipe out illicit financial activity.”
TL;DR cash is a better tool for crime according to an ex CIA director
If you want to talk about actively making the world worse look at most web2 "algorithms" and how the push to the extremes is tolerated by "but numbers go up."
You're right, it's an impressive piece technology that's been growing through questionable use cases. But that's not the fault of the underlying technology, but of the actors involved.
As long as blockchains are treated as a second class citizen, governments choose to ostracize it, financial oligopolies lobby against it, things won't change.
But imagine what could be accomplished if governments decided to embrace and properly regulate it, and what it could empower in our society in terms of a more open and acessible socio-economic environment.
Let's not blame the technology.
That sounds like something people say to defend guns, nukes, and crypto. Why wouldn't you blame a technology whose primary use is malignant?
It's not like the crypto hellscape we have now was an accident of its evolution. It was the inevitable and predictable outcome of a decentralized and poorly regulated system built atop complex code that the average person has little chance of properly evaluating.
From all appearances, this is exactly how they were designed and exactly the point, to extract money from fools and funnel it to a select few crypto bankers. That's not a good thing.
Don't count your chickens before they hatch.
This is what happens when startups become cool and the people who would have otherwise gotten an MBA and tried to find work at a major bank are now the ones on HN.
It’s the biggest wealth producing opportunity of the next decade or two and HN doesn’t get it at all.
It’s basically become a forum for your average developer. I’d bet a lot of folk who don’t understand crypto at all are web developers or something where innovation is a new JavaScript framework.
Not saying anything bad about that, but people here don’t seem to have innovation in mind. I mean r/Ethereum on Reddit is better than HN to discuss these topics. It’s just wrong. HN has become counter futurism.
Help me understand where that wealth comes from. Because as far as I can see the only wealth that gets generated is from people who got in earlier selling their bags to people who got in later.
Look into Uniswap, Balancer, Curve, Compound, MakerDAO. Read what Vitalik Buterin has written on his blog and watch some podcasts with him.
For people outside of the art world the narrative around NFTs is “it’s all fraud / it’s all silly pictures of apes”.
This is demonstrably untrue but its hard to show this to the hive mind here since they want to believe that it is true. But a lot of folks in the digital art world will tel you that NFTs have been a godsend.
Basically you are looking at tokens (99% of which are a scam) instead of looking at applications (99% of which are also a scam). The fundamental problem with crypto right now is the lack of regulation - without regulation it’s become a free for all for all kinds of scams and ponzis. If you were a criminal today the best way to make money is crypto. There is no regulation. You have to separate the wheat from the chaff but the chaff is humongous due to the lack of regulation. This gets a lot of people confused and they just end up dumping the whole space (unfortunate but understandable).
And you can be a great developer and still misunderstand crypto. But I really struggle to see how you can be a great innovator and fail to see cryptos potential at this point.
The average developer doesn't use Rust
It HAS been the biggest wealth producing opportunity of the LAST decade , along with Bitcoin.
They are now both priced for world changing paradigm shift and perfect execution doing so. Which means that there is no wealth producing opportunity at all considering that you need everything to pan out great just to mantain the current valuation.
Also everything is an S-curve and once you arrive to 750bn (or whatever they crypto-marketcap is) there is physically nowhere to go to from there.
Already multiple huge apps such as: Uniswap, Opensea, MakerDAO, Compound, Balancer, Curve. A lot of small stuff that could grow like Opulous. Lots to be built. Huge field of opportunity.
You can't make money by betting on something with a valuation of 800bn which is the cryptospace.
The cryptospace as a whole you cannot make money from anymore, the only thing you can make money from is betting that the marketcap of old coins such as BTC will flow into new coins such as ETH.
But that if you are gonna do that, then it's better to just do it on the stock market, by betting on new companies replacing old companies and taking their marketcap
The time to invest and also build is when new people and new money are coming into the game , not when everything is cooling down and the early winners enjoy their lead.
2014 was not the time to build a social media company, it was the time to build a social media presence.
The merge is freaking incredible. Switching the engine of a $60 billion financial network in-flight. Permanent power savings the scale of a country. An incredible coordination between a huge number of diverse parties all over the world. Everything open source. And all we get is a rehash of tired old arguments against cryptocurrencies.
This was originally a forum for hackers, makers and entrepreneurs. It does not seem like that anymore.