In retrospect, I should have paid a lot more attention when Patric Collison told me he was spending his days reading up banking regulations. Eh, too boring, I thought, what could possibly be in there that a little code couldn't paper over? That mistake cost me the opportunity to be an early hire at Stripe.
Your customers want to be innovative and do things they can't easily do today. On the other side is your financial network that has shut down the three previous attempts to do that exact thing because it causes a random transaction clearing server in France to burst into flames. You are now left holding the bag with both sides upset at you.
The happy fact of the matter is that the vast majority of actors in the economy seem to be pretty well-behaved. The scary thing is that the system seems to depend on this.
That's mainly because, in most countries, to become a participant in a regulated financial system, you have to meet the 'fit and proper' criteria of qualification [https://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs47c4.pdf].
There are continuous audits and enforcement/disciplinary actions taken to ensure regulatory compliance. Also, digitisation has enabled tech based regulatory/supervisory tooling to reduce the burden of regulatory/supervisory activities.
And, as newer/faster tech based mechanisms/rails have gained adoption older more cumbersome rails are getting retired. This is leading to effective regulatory simplifications.
Only I'm guessing it doesn't take half as much to create crumble the banking system.
As someone who doesn't, I'd love to hear more.
Any part of this process that is modernized still has to emulate the old...
I'm glad I quit that job. The only problem is when I tell people how the bank actually move money they don't believe me.
Not only that, but getting a meeting with someone who understands how banking actually works under the hood is nearly impossible. In fact, even finding such a person is nearly impossible. Not only do the front-line people in banks not understand how their industry works, they don't even know who does understand.
There is also a huge disconnect between banking and IT. I once had half a million dollars go missing for two weeks because of a wire transfer snafu. No one could figure out where the money was. The only reason it was recovered is that the person to whom the money had been wired incorrectly noticed and sent it back.
It felt like if Clippy had an addon to it's expert system from Saul.
=> https://www.mybanktracker.com/checking/faq/rules-deposit-100...
Moving $20k fully electronic (eg:ACH) doesn't have that requirement.
But lots of systems have limits based on risk windows.
That would be noticed. It's called "structuring" and is itself illegal. Banks watch for this stuff.
The bank typically has a rather simplistic set of rules to decide to investigate transactions (because they need to be able to explain how the rules work in a meeting with the government whenever their rules miss someone). Things like "Transaction was over $1000 to a new payee or the reference contained the word 'bitcoin'". The investigation will typically involve a human calling the customer, and sometimes asking for more evidence of what the transfer was for - for example, please send us the receipt for the car you said you bought. It's quite an expensive process for the bank.
So, when someone via the API sends tens of thousands of transfers, the bank is spending lots of human hours verifying some/all of those. "My script sent $55 to some stranger because I won a fully automated bet on the weather" is far harder to verify with documentation too. And when some slip through the cracks, they get in trouble with the regulator.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contaminated_currency
[2] https://cipherblade.com/blog/tainted-bitcoin-isnt-what-you-t...
Cops have used cocaine residue as "cause" to rob people of cash: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkeS_0NQUZs
I learned the other day that the name on account means shit, because scammers often give $account_details + $catfish_name and receive the money to $bank_details + $real_name.
I don’t see how splitting to 1000 transactions and sending money to yourself helps with money laundering or undercover money sending.
Banks rely on a fixed set of rules to trigger an investigation for money laundering. One of these rules is the value of the transaction. I worked in retail whilst at Uni in the UK and we often had people who had lot's of money in their accounts unable to make large purchases due to these checks. Their payment would be automatically blocked and you would get a phone number they had to call to be able to make the payment. It was for example when buying a £5000 kitchen (I worked in the equivalent of home depot in the UK). If they could have split that transaction down to say 10 payments of £500 it wouldn't have triggered anything on the bank side.
Overall these banks process a lot of transactions and so heavily rely on these rules to keep them within the law. They don't always work as can be seen here and the bank noticed that users were able to circumvent their crappy ruleset by split big transactions down to lots of small transactions.
Not sure about sending money to yourself I suspect they mean transferring money between two accounts you control which is different in the banking for from sending money to yourself. If you are in control of both accounts you are laundering the money by transferring it to another account when you secretly control both. It's a basic way people like the mafia and such have laundered money for decades. They will do it through facade companies or suchlike. So they have one of the gang be legit and "clean" setup a shop who deposits cash into their bank account from "sales". The shop is a real place that you could technically buy stuff from. They then transfer their profits to this other account that is the gangsters account. The gangsters is part owner and they are receiving money as they "own" the shop and the shop has made money from sales. The sales though are actually the gangster giving money to his own shop and them claiming that as sales to the bank. The bank doesn't know that the money is actually from selling drugs or robbing stores or w/e illegal stuff they have done. The result is that you have taken "dirty" money i.e. money that has came from some illegal activity and with this strange process you have made it into "clean" money that's come from some legal activity.
So basically all money laundering will be transferring money to "yourself" but it will be via a third party that probably takes a small cut for helping. It's worked like this for years and is super common.
The fixed set of rules they have in bank is because it used to be that making money movements was hard so the criminals would transfer say £250k in a single transaction as sales revenue. So banks could easily spot this and take action. Making money movements easier means they can bypass this check.
Mostly, yes. But there are hundreds of those rules.
>One of these rules is the value of the transaction.
That happened, but I doubt that is the most important rule now. From what I've seen in my experience way bigger focus total value of transactions compared to various metrics.
Very large number of transactions on personal accounts is also one of those rules.
>Their payment would be automatically blocked and you would get a phone number they had to call to be able to make the payment. It was for example when buying a £5000 kitchen (I worked in the equivalent of home depot in the UK). If they could have split that transaction down to say 10 payments of £500 it wouldn't have triggered anything on the bank side.
That sounds like fraud, not money laundering rule.
> Very large number of transactions on personal accounts is also one of those rules.
Yes I suspect 1000's of trx on the accounts is what flag the whole thing to the bank.
> That sounds like fraud, not money laundering rule.
You have to take what I've said in context with the whole comment and not take a single part out of context.
As I said for money laundering you'll get consistent large transactions that don't make sense (say £250k each week from a pizza shop). Banks already know how to spot these large weird transactions so a method to hide them is to split them down into smaller transactions. My example with paying the kitchen was to show that the banks wouldn't notice the £500 transactions rather than the single £5000 transaction.
What is the source of the funds to launder and how/why is it already in the bank?
Money mules; you offer some influentiable kid some money to deposit cash into their account and send it on to someone else. Or an old lady. I'm sure part of the Nigerian prince thing is money laundering.
Second one that is very prevalent is physical stores that never seem to get any customers, e.g. in my neck of the woods there's these mobile phone companies everywhere. I'm sure they sell phones, simcards and accessories on occasion, but I can't see how it would cover the cost of rent, let alone make a profit. Unless once a month someone comes in with a few thousand in cash that then gets added to the books over time.
Oh, there actually was an article on HN about that recently, that was "american" candy shops in london: https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/london-news-american-...
To be honest, I don't think money laundering is real, or significant. I see most money laundering rules as hidden or mislabeled sanctions on other countries, group of individuals or institutions.
E.g. here the nonsense is why money that you already have in a bank account needs to be sent to someone else via 1000s of random small transactions. At best that would add a layer of confusion, but you still have the money laundering problems for the sending and final receiving person.
What happens is that banks are trying to cover their ass and please regulators so they don’t get fined.
Of course all regulation does is add complexity. You still have the most common way to launder money: know the top-banker and have connections inside the bank. With the right amount of money you can buy all the KYC you need.
Which means all this regulations is either malicious or plain ignorant. I think it’s malicious.
It's just that you and I aren't big enough fish for the banks to look the other way, if we do it.
Gotta be a Mexican drug cartel, or a Russian oligarch to succeed in money laundering.
Heard it all now time for me to get off this site I think.
More likely scenario is increase will partner with some chartered bank and try to expose this api functionality. They will soon realise the constraints they need to be under to not allow crazy things like this.
The other type of transaction they mention in 4.16.13.4 also involves cash payments in the course of a trade or business.
Everything else is what someone might do to try to conceal structuring, but if cash isn't involved, it's not structuring, because there's no covered reporting requirement.
This is great insight though re: money laundering. Something I'd have never expected would be the result of an API.
The guy assigned to my case retired. As did the next guy. And now there is a lady assigned to the case, but she has been out of the office for all of the last 3 years...
Every time I call, I get told they can't discuss cases over the phone, but that they will send me a paper letter as an update... And it isn't a template letter either... But it always just says I need to keep waiting and there is no action I can take to speed the process up...
They got a default judgement, but still couldn't actually collect the amount owed.
So they ended up filing a foreclosure on the actual building - and it worked! The foreclosure went through, and the company almost lost their brick and mortar store.
Took years for the process, but it was nice to see that the courts can and will defend an individual. This all took place in TX IIRC.
The threat was enough to fix the failed transaction. The manager was able to call someone and issue a check, rather than have their branch auctioned off.
I don't see how that's the same problem? They are clearly separate, distinct problems.
There are obviously both advantages and disadvantages to both crypto and banking. As someone who lives in a country that has been through a lot of bullshit, I highly value the fact that the bank can't just take away my money.
The only difference is that crypto fraud is irreversible, and that the blame will be put on you.
Fraud is huge industry, the fraud models and attack vectors in the fiat world is different than in the crypto world. In the end wherever there is enough money, there will be fraud as well.
If you don't trust "the system" as a whole then you are right, I can't argue with mistrust.
https://ask.fdic.gov/fdicinformationandsupportcenter/s/?lang...
https://www.helpwithmybank.gov/file-a-complaint/index-file-a...
Had fun ideas of improving the finance sector with ideas like this, that for any other industry would be at worst : 'TODO's to fix later.
Finance sector taught me a lot about security, but also about standards.
Standards are a real PITA to code for, from HTTP to PCI payment compliance. They're so worth it in the end though.
Think about what it teaches children when they hear it? What kind of a world view does it instill? By saying the phrase you are explicitly communicating the idea that it is (at least is some sense) better to not do good deeds.
Kind of like "life's a bitch, and then you die", it's not meant to be taken too seriously.
I know this isn't a forum where we are endangering children by writing stuff like this, but it strikes me as a bizarre sentiment to express (of all the things one can say in an unfortunate situation - to choose summarize the whole scenario with that sentence).
There are too many evil people to willfully ignore the dangers of helping others. You should always, always be aware of the risks you’re putting yourself in any situation. In life, in work, in family, it doesn’t matter. And yes, that’s worth teaching children.
As long as the positives outweigh the dangers, it's worth doing.
Strangers should be distrusted by default, which is a lesson taught to children. It shocks me that some adults forget something so simple. This applies to teachers, cops, and anyone else you can think of. Trust is earned and should never be offered freely.
It's really not that big of a deal. Smart kids will realise they're wading through a sea of bullshit and the rest are already predisposed to whatever bullshit pleases them.
> "I think this is one of the most unfortunate memes that people for some reason still continue to share."
Even more unfortunate is that so many humans go out of their way to prove it true… Growing up in a small town, I was raised on more wholesome "memes" like "deep down, everyone wants to be a good person" and "sharing is caring" and other such silly lies, but having been out in "the real world" now for several decades, I've learned the error of that sort of thinking (at least here in the USA). The vast majority absolutely do not want to be good. They want to use and abuse everyone around them, and push others down into the gutters of life until they're filled with hatred for humanity. They want to beat every shred of goodness and decency out of everyone they meet, and that's just how life on Planet Earth is… It's a side-effect of having built a society around the idea that money is literally more important than anything else (including even life itself). Humans are mostly monsters and don't even realize it. I'm only happy that we're sure to kill ourselves off as a species before we escape this planet and infect the rest of the Universe with our evil greedy self-centered uncaring ways.> "Think about what it teaches children when they hear it? What kind of a world view does it instill? By saying the phrase you are explicitly communicating the idea that it is (at least is some sense) better to not do good deeds."
I wish I had been taught that most people cannot be trusted, instead of the foolishness I was taught. I'd have had a much easier life than the ongoing "waking nightmare" that I currently live. A more realistic world-view would have protected me from much / most of the abuse and backstabbery I've suffered in this life. And the worst of it for me is knowing that as bad as my life has gone South on me, I've still got it "lucky" compared to those humanity abuses the worst (those in nations where people cannot even protect themselves against the most vile abuses humanity can perpetrate against other humans). I mean, sure, I'm not able to afford the medical care that I need to get back to a semi-"normal" existence, but at least I'm not starving to death or being worked to death in mines somewhere, barely able to live another day.
Technically known as smurfing, and (as you learned) quickly leads to account bans.
Governments take AML/KYC pretty seriously. Just ask TornadoCash.
i mean i am talking from an indian POV where every banking customer is KYC approved from the get-go. you send someone money or receive money, there is a proper trail to their identities.
I'm interested in learning more about this. Do you have an example of a bank with a cash flow management API I could take a look at?
One example i can think of right off the top of my head: INTEGRATIONS Integrate Increase APIs Modern Treasury’s powerful REST API is the easiest way to integrate your Increase bank accounts with your application for payments, reconciliation and reporting. https://www.moderntreasury.com/integrations
And
"Improve Cash Flow
Managing cash flow requires looking at receivables and payables, accessing liquidity and making accurate forecasts. Cash management APIs improve every facet of the treasury operations." https://www.chase.ca/en/support/insights/six-ways-payment-ap....
and the developer portal:
https://developer.jpmorgan.com/
Other big corp banks have similars. A lot of these TMS platforms just integrate into these banks APIs and ERP systems (Oracle Cloud, SAP, etc) and glue workflows together.
TL;DR my understanding is that if you host a banking API you are going to get a lot of scrutiny on who your customers are.
And you can expect an increasing level of compliance regulations heading your way to help regulate and prevent the problems described in the parent.
The API allowed you to see balance, transaction history, and make payments.
Before long, the API got quite popular, and lots of people were using it to make lots of payments automatically.
You know what makes money laundering super easy... a banking API so you can split the million dollars you want to launder into 1 million 1 dollar payments. And an API client which lets you treat each login cookie and account as an object in python.
Before long, the API and all users who had ever used it were perma-banned from the bank, because it was determined they posed too high a fraud/money-laundering risk.
I'm still salty because, after spending a week of my life building and refining that API, they banned me and 6 years later still claim they can't return the $350 that was in the account because they are still 'investigating'.