News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by killjoywashere on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:59AM (#32810348)
Before getting too excited about the experimental prevention they used, IL-1B blockade, let me say that blocking the innate immune system to prevent cancer seems ill-advised. The innate immune system is with us for very good reasons. This would be roughly equivalent to preventing table saw accidents by prophylactically removing all fingers.

Yes, table saw accidents are terrible, but there is a straightforward electromechanical solution (SawStop), and fingers are useful for many other things.

Yes, lung cancer is terrible, but there is a straightforward electromechanical solution (energy from renewables + nuclear), and the innate immune system is useful for many other things.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by sdenton4 on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:17AM (#32810660)
Well I read the article and got excited about eliminating internal combustion engines...
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by capitainenemo on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:34AM (#32810936)
https://www.brusselstimes.com/news/business/145130/fine-part...

That won't necessarily solve this problem.

[edit] One more source. There are tons though. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/4a4dc6ca-en/index.html?i...

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:37AM (#32810983)
Exactly right, tire and brake dust are still awful with EVs, though contra the slight implication in the headline, it's no worse than the current situation with ICE vehicles. And the brake dust aspect may slightly reduce due to regenerative braking.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by capitainenemo on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:38AM (#32810998)
"Electric vehicles are estimated to emit 5-19% less PM10 from non-exhaust sources per kilometre than internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEVs) across vehicle classes. However, EVs do not necessarily emit less PM2.5 than ICEVs. Although lightweight EVs emit an estimated 11-13% less PM2.5 than ICEV equivalents, heavier weight EVs emit an estimated 3-8% more PM2.5 than ICEVs"

So. It depends. It's sometimes slightly better, sometimes slightly worse. But it doesn't really solve the issue.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:42AM (#32811078)
True, but these are all less than 20%, a change which is likely indistinguishable for any sort of risk factors, and likely well within the measurement error for something difficult to measure like this.

The true change we need to make is drastically reduce car use, to a tiny fraction of its current use. This is a hard social problem, however, particularly for the older generations who tend to wield power in most governments. Younger folks seem pretty excited to allow more biking and walking and rolling, though.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by cptcobalt on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:20AM (#32811682)
Willingness over your lifespan to reduce car use is not merely "because they're getting old", but rather directly correlated with a city's existing transit infrastructure. I've been able to spend a few weeks here and there in London or other transit-dense cities, and I just about never desire a car there, but I do in the states.

Government leaders in the states can't imagine this reality or, if so, can't imagine it changing sufficiently in their lifetimes to invest the political capital in. The US will never change.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:36AM (#32811929)
Well many government officials (especially those in the planning departments) can imagine that future, as can many younger elected officials.

And honestly, I take it back, there are nearly as many older folks punching for changes to city design to allow waking and bikes as young people. But in genera the older generations have the time and money needed for local political involvement in a way that younger generations do not, so we tend to get a future shaped by those who do not want change from the status quo (which is a radical departure from the eta of urban growth focused on cars).

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by capitainenemo on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:53AM (#32811232)
Interestingly the first article flagged ebikes as particularly problematic, which are a pretty common way to extend bike range. Although, they must surely be better than cars just due to mass.

Anyway. Cautiously in agreement with you, but it depends a lot on where you live. Western Europe, at least at present, is blessed with a fairly mild climate. Less so than North America which seems to alternate between harsh winters and hot and humid summers. And it's a bit much to ask everyone to move somewhere nice. We probably need to figure out how to make braking systems and wheels less polluting.

Quoted this Douglas Adams once on New York when this came up... "In the summer it's too darn hot. It's one thing to be the sort of life form that thrives on heat and finds, as the Frastrans do, that the temperature range between 40,000 and 40,004 is very equable, but it's quite another to be the sort of animal that has to wrap itself up in lots of other animals at one point in your planet's orbit, and then find, half an orbit later, that your skin's bubbling." [edit] (aside, my theory is the Frastrans live on an aging neutron star like in "Dragon's Egg" ;) )

And really the situation gets worse a few states down. :) To say nothing of Texas or Arizona.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by sdenton4 on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:58PM (#32816024)
Looking at the OECD report (possibly the wrong one?) I couldn't find any mention of bicycles except as an alternative to cars to mitigate the problem... Given the faaaar lower mass even of heavy bicycles, I would want to see the actual evidence before worrying too much about the bike contribution to particulate pollution.

(rider mass / vehicle mass is a lovely shorthand for vehicle efficiency, as it says a lot about how much acceleration you're 'wasting' on the vehicle. Braking, of course, produces a negative acceleration, so lower mass ratio ~> better efficiency. Aim for a ratio of < 1.0...)

https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/4a4dc6ca-en/1/3/2/index....

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by jfim on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:51AM (#32812134)
> Interestingly the first article flagged ebikes as particularly problematic, which are a pretty common way to extend bike range. Although, they must surely be better than cars just due to mass.

Only tangentially related, but I'd assume that most of the emissions from ebikes would be related to brakes, as stopping from higher velocity would wear down brake pads faster.

One interesting thing that hybrid and electric vehicles do is that they do regenerative braking, which ends up with less wear on brake pads (and emissions) from slowing down. Justin from Grin Technologies (an ebike part shop focusing on DIYers) has done a presentation on how that works on ebikes, and mentions that he's barely using brake pads now that he's using regenerative braking: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gYCj4asp9pE&t=970s

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:45PM (#32814009)
> Younger folks seem pretty excited to allow more biking and walking and rolling, though.

The difference may not be age; it may be having kids and dealing with the practicalities of that.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:18PM (#32814546)
The opposition is coming from people past child rearing years. Other parents like me are one of the strongest contingencies for getting rid of car-dependency. Cars are one of the greatest threats to kids in terms of death, disability, and maiming. And building cities around cars makes having kids a huge huge hassle, you have to drive them everywhere and they have zero autonomy.

Cars and kids are an absolute terrible combo.

I'm not sure if you've seen the huge rise of cargo bikes that I have seen, but they are nearly all parents with kid seating on the back in my town. We are trying to make do with terrible infrastructure and city planning, but it wouldn't take much change to make it all very much better.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by CalRobert on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:51PM (#32815912)
Hear hear - I want for my kids to be independent and for me to not be their damn taxi for 18 years. A car-dependent home is a prison for kids. If my 10 year old says "I want to go to the movies" I want to say "Awesome! Have fun! Who's going with you?" not "ugg I'm busy with work and can't drive you".
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:23PM (#32814604)
Yep; we live where we do to maximise cycling. Here are the problems with that as a general rule:

- it's desirable, so property prices in places that enable this are higher, if there is even a location that could fulfill this

- expensive bikes aren't affordable by most people who also need a car

- there's a large window where kids are too big for a cargo bike, and still too young to go off freely

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:29PM (#32814696)
I don't view any of these as a problem in the least. And sorry if it comes across as as a strong critique, I don't mean any of it personally, but have heard people say these same things but never from people that actually bicycle with their family.

We do all sorts of things that increase property value, why is it suddenly only a problem when bikes are involved? And the problem is only because we do a little amount of transition and not a lot? This is a completely fabricated concern in my estimation, the type of thing that people come up with instead of simply saying "I don't like this and don't want it."

Similarly, the concern about the cost of bikes is completely invalid, as bikes are always cheaper than a car, even brand new cargo e-bikes are only a few months of car expenses at most.

And I haven't seen that window where kids can't bike on their own or ride with another parent, and I know families that bike with kids of all sizes and ages.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:01PM (#32816076)
Okay. It appears that you haven't read what I wrote. I'll try just one more time:

> And sorry if it comes across as as a strong critique, I don't mean any of it personally, but have heard people say these same things but never from people that actually bicycle with their family.

As I already said, we have built cycling into our lives. Our kids (4 and 6) cycle to school with one of us. I cycle to work. And I am saying this.

> We do all sorts of things that increase property value, why is it suddenly only a problem when bikes are involved?

That is nothing to do with what I was saying. Property is finite; schools, clubs, and employers are too. A car is one of the few levellers that allows people to live somewhere cheaper and access places they need to get to. Places that are close enough to schools to cycle them to school and then cycle to work are expensive.

> Similarly, the concern about the cost of bikes is completely invalid, as bikes are always cheaper than a car,

That only works if you don't need a car. If you need both, which, see previous point, is extremely likely, then it's an extra expense, not an alternative one.

> even brand new cargo e-bikes are only a few months of car expenses at most.

An admittedly quick Google and I'm not seeing any for less than £2.5k. That's years' worth of car services, tax and MOT. On top of the cost of the car they almost certainly need.

> And I haven't seen that window where kids can't bike on their own or ride with another parent, and I know families that bike with kids of all sizes and ages.

Here's an example of what I mean: nursery is in one direction; school is another. How do we get our 4 year old to nursery and 8 year old to school? Should the 8 year old cycle on his own? Or is he in the window where he can't cycle far enough by himself, but too heavy to be safely steered on a cargo bike?

Broadly: if Facebook's taught us anything, it's the power of being in a social circle and thinking that must generalise to everyone, or even most people. Having a job where we can work from home, or rock up 20 minutes late, where we can afford to live in a nice location that has good access, and where we can afford expensive secondary transport, is all great. Wonderful, even. But having grown up in a reasonably deprived area, I believe that's not most people's experience.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by jemmyw on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @07:07AM (#32822763)
> Or is he in the window where he can't cycle far enough by himself, but too heavy to be safely steered on a cargo bike?

My wife cycled me around in her cargo bike, and a couple of other adults (not at the same time). I'm not a light chap, fairly sure I'd outweigh both your kids together. Steering on those things is pretty good, they're not light in and of themselves.

edit: we actually cycled both our kids to school in the cargo bike when they were 8 and 5. I'd forgotten, it was a few years ago.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:32PM (#32829835)
Fair enough. I might have imagined badly a situation where it's not easy or possible in terms of time using a bike for two separate children.

On the cargo bikes, I have thought about it but I'd probably steer clear til they have some safety standards attached (I think there's a German standard, but nothing else I've seen).

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by dilyevsky on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:21AM (#32811711)
Slightly? I barely use the brakes ever. Whoever is out braking in their EV all the time should have their DL revoked
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by buran77 on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:07PM (#32813289)
Some drivers rely too much on one pedal driving only to brake in a panic when they realize it will not stop the car in time. This creates a very uncertain environment for other participants in traffic and I can't tell you how many times I had to step back from a crossing because a driver clearly misjudged the breaking distance of their car using regen braking. It creates a bit of complacency where the expectation is that "the car will take care of it" and one pedal driving does not give the same control over braking as it does over acceleration (or as the regular brake pedal does).

Other drivers assume max regen settings will bring max benefits and end up taking more out of the battery to accelerate only to get far less back (regen braking is ~70% efficient in any EV) when the car regen-brakes, when braking was not really required. Many times coasting is far more efficient than regenerating regardless of what pedals you're using.

Last but not least, all regenerative braking systems are combined with hydraulic braking at low speeds because the torque applied to decelerate is not enough in any of them. So at low speeds the car will actually combine it with friction braking and eventually not regen at all. Take the Zoe where there's no regen at all below 15km/h (9 mph). Emergency braking from high speed is the same. City driving will see a lot of those situations.

So whether you realize it or not, when you are coming to a standstill you use the hydraulic brakes. There may be options to break at low speed with no friction at all but they will not be called regenerative because they will inevitably use energy to do it.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by giraffe_lady on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:46AM (#32812045)
Where I live residential neighborhoods have 4-way stops at every intersection so preferably everyone would be braking all the time, yes.

They obviously are not and cruising through stop signs (and sometimes killing children!) is the norm. If EVs encourage this driving style that is another strong point in favor of "electric cars can't solve the problem of cars."

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:28PM (#32812701)
>They obviously are not and cruising through stop signs (and sometimes killing children!) is the norm. If EVs encourage this driving style that is another strong point in favor of "electric cars can't solve the problem of cars."

You reap what you sow. A grid of 4-way stops where the traffic flow is not appropriate for them is a textbook perfect way to train drivers to habitually roll stop signs.

I swear sometimes it seems like urban planners are hellbent on re-learning everything they learned in the 1920s.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by bobthepanda on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:45PM (#32812951)
I mean, the real issue is that American traffic engineering is usually loathe to put anything other than a 4-way stop. Americans do not properly yield at yield signs, roundabouts take too much room, and we haven’t figured out how to routinely build speed bumps or raised crosswalks for less than six figures.

Also, it is a stretch to call some of that planning “learning” or “science.” As a general example, parking regulations for uses tend to be arbitrary, oversized and wildly out of date; most US retail parking lots are not full even on major shopping days like Black Friday before the advent of online, and now online is making all that space even more wasted.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by cjrp on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:58PM (#32816020)
Roundabouts don’t have to take up more room than a stop-signed junction. We call them mini-roundabouts, and they’re often just painted on the ground and slightly raised so that you can still drive over them.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by bobthepanda on Monday September 12, 2022 @06:01PM (#32817599)
Unfortunately, US civil engineering is very dogmatic, so if it isn’t approved by AASHTO it won’t be done.

The civil engineers also like absurdly wide turn radii to accommodate 53 feet trailers and large fire trucks even in residential streets, so you end up with comically wide roads even for dead end suburban streets. https://thumbs.dreamstime.com/b/suburban-street-2779407.jpg

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @06:06AM (#32822379)
I agree it's stupid but can you imagine how HNers would react if a trailer so much dragged an outside dual on their shrubbery. The hand wringing would probably start a fire.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by bobthepanda on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:46PM (#32826772)
Fortunately for traffic engineering, they often remove those too, to maintain a “clear zone” for road safety. (The clear zone is intended for keeping cars at high speed from killing their occupants when they decelerate into stationary objects.)
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by josephcsible on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:54AM (#32812192)
EVs can regenerate almost all the way to a stop, and only need to apply the brakes to hold the vehicle stopped.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:38AM (#32811954)
I would like to see the numbers on this to quantify it. Because the places where EVs still do use brake pads is when they come to full stops at lights and stop signs, which tend to be far closer to people.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by bryanlarsen on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:48AM (#32812077)
Brakes aren't necessary to stop an EV nor to hold a car at a stop on an incline.

The only time a Tesla needs to use brake pads are for emergency stops and for the parking brake.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by vladvasiliu on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:58PM (#32813131)
That may be the case for a Tesla (never driven one) but the ride-share Smart EVs we have around Paris absolutely need brakes to come to a stand-still. They will decelerate fairly quickly to 20-25 kmph, but after that, the deceleration rate slows down, and it actually will never stop by itself.

For some reason I can't understand, they tried to imitate ICE automatics that don't stand still if you don't have your foot on the brake pedal.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by mikestew on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:12PM (#32816233)
For some reason I can't understand, they tried to imitate ICE automatics that don't stand still if you don't have your foot on the brake pedal.

Even more annoying, as an owner of a Nissan Leaf that does this, is that the behavior is what I consider to be a bug in automatic transmissions. Manual transmissions don't do that, and there's no good reason for automatics to do that (and a hundred really good reasons for them not to). It's an artifact of the viscosity of the fluid it turns in, and it annoys me that my EV is bug-for-bug compatible with a device the car doesn't even have (a transmission).

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by zelos on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:42PM (#32813964)
Pressing the brake pedal doesn’t mean the physical brakes are being used, though.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by josephcsible on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:22AM (#32811733)
EVs hardly generate any brake dust due to regenerative braking. It's not just a "slight" reduction and certainly not "awful" with them.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by giraffe_lady on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:43AM (#32812008)
The source says 5-19% reduction which is solid but pretty far off from "hardly any" in my view.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by josephcsible on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:53AM (#32812168)
Isn't that number for the total particle emissions, rather than just for emissions from the brakes?
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by giraffe_lady on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:06PM (#32812397)
No, "PM10 for non-exhaust sources per km" and then the following line has more info about about pm2.5. Please just go read the thing it's not our duty to quote it at you piece by piece to disprove your assumptions about how good EVs are especially when the article is right there and not even long or very technical.

If you have trouble reading or understanding english then I apologize and of course please continue to get the information this way if that is best for you. I mean this seriously and not as an insult. I had a TBI once and had a hard time parsing information like this for a couple years after.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by treis on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:20PM (#32812585)
You should be less snarky when you're wrong. Non-exhaust sources also include tires and roads.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by reducesuffering on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:36PM (#32812818)
Go back and actually read your parent comment and then tell us who (still) really has the reading comprehension problem…
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:48PM (#32814063)
They weren't saying that. They were just saying go read it for yourself and decide.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by giraffe_lady on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:49PM (#32816740)
Well I have autism and brain damage what's their excuse?
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by killjoywashere on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:15PM (#32828964)
I would expect the brake dust component to go down significantly for full EVs with Tesla-grade regenerative braking. Source: Model S owner. I can go whole trips without touching the brakes. Based on what I've seen, I suspect the FSD would be even more likely to make full trips without using the disk brakes.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by abraae on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:04PM (#32815205)
> And the brake dust aspect may slightly reduce due to regenerative braking.

This might be underselling it. I hardly use the brakes on our EV at all. In a journey yesterday of 180km, I only touched the brakes at the end, when pulling into a car park.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by CalRobert on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:04PM (#32812373)
All the more reason to design cities where cars are only needed occasionally and walking, cycling, and public transport serve most people's needs.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by Tade0 on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:16PM (#32812532)
I'm having trouble believing such findings because even in the most congested of cities PM counts are generally low as long as other sources (like heating) are kept in check.

NOx emissions kick in as the main pollutant much earlier in such places.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by Sayrus on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:17AM (#32811646)
The Brussels Times uses this exact report from the OECD iLibrary as a source.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by marricks on Monday September 12, 2022 @05:53PM (#32817511)
Yeah, it feels like society loves coming up with ways to “handle” problems but never actual solve them.

The future will likely be upper middle class folks walking around in habitat bubbles with VR suits across a toxic desert of miasma.