News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by capitainenemo on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:38AM (#32810998)
"Electric vehicles are estimated to emit 5-19% less PM10 from non-exhaust sources per kilometre than internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEVs) across vehicle classes. However, EVs do not necessarily emit less PM2.5 than ICEVs. Although lightweight EVs emit an estimated 11-13% less PM2.5 than ICEV equivalents, heavier weight EVs emit an estimated 3-8% more PM2.5 than ICEVs"

So. It depends. It's sometimes slightly better, sometimes slightly worse. But it doesn't really solve the issue.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:42AM (#32811078)
True, but these are all less than 20%, a change which is likely indistinguishable for any sort of risk factors, and likely well within the measurement error for something difficult to measure like this.

The true change we need to make is drastically reduce car use, to a tiny fraction of its current use. This is a hard social problem, however, particularly for the older generations who tend to wield power in most governments. Younger folks seem pretty excited to allow more biking and walking and rolling, though.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by cptcobalt on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:20AM (#32811682)
Willingness over your lifespan to reduce car use is not merely "because they're getting old", but rather directly correlated with a city's existing transit infrastructure. I've been able to spend a few weeks here and there in London or other transit-dense cities, and I just about never desire a car there, but I do in the states.

Government leaders in the states can't imagine this reality or, if so, can't imagine it changing sufficiently in their lifetimes to invest the political capital in. The US will never change.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:36AM (#32811929)
Well many government officials (especially those in the planning departments) can imagine that future, as can many younger elected officials.

And honestly, I take it back, there are nearly as many older folks punching for changes to city design to allow waking and bikes as young people. But in genera the older generations have the time and money needed for local political involvement in a way that younger generations do not, so we tend to get a future shaped by those who do not want change from the status quo (which is a radical departure from the eta of urban growth focused on cars).

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by capitainenemo on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:53AM (#32811232)
Interestingly the first article flagged ebikes as particularly problematic, which are a pretty common way to extend bike range. Although, they must surely be better than cars just due to mass.

Anyway. Cautiously in agreement with you, but it depends a lot on where you live. Western Europe, at least at present, is blessed with a fairly mild climate. Less so than North America which seems to alternate between harsh winters and hot and humid summers. And it's a bit much to ask everyone to move somewhere nice. We probably need to figure out how to make braking systems and wheels less polluting.

Quoted this Douglas Adams once on New York when this came up... "In the summer it's too darn hot. It's one thing to be the sort of life form that thrives on heat and finds, as the Frastrans do, that the temperature range between 40,000 and 40,004 is very equable, but it's quite another to be the sort of animal that has to wrap itself up in lots of other animals at one point in your planet's orbit, and then find, half an orbit later, that your skin's bubbling." [edit] (aside, my theory is the Frastrans live on an aging neutron star like in "Dragon's Egg" ;) )

And really the situation gets worse a few states down. :) To say nothing of Texas or Arizona.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by sdenton4 on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:58PM (#32816024)
Looking at the OECD report (possibly the wrong one?) I couldn't find any mention of bicycles except as an alternative to cars to mitigate the problem... Given the faaaar lower mass even of heavy bicycles, I would want to see the actual evidence before worrying too much about the bike contribution to particulate pollution.

(rider mass / vehicle mass is a lovely shorthand for vehicle efficiency, as it says a lot about how much acceleration you're 'wasting' on the vehicle. Braking, of course, produces a negative acceleration, so lower mass ratio ~> better efficiency. Aim for a ratio of < 1.0...)

https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/4a4dc6ca-en/1/3/2/index....

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by jfim on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:51AM (#32812134)
> Interestingly the first article flagged ebikes as particularly problematic, which are a pretty common way to extend bike range. Although, they must surely be better than cars just due to mass.

Only tangentially related, but I'd assume that most of the emissions from ebikes would be related to brakes, as stopping from higher velocity would wear down brake pads faster.

One interesting thing that hybrid and electric vehicles do is that they do regenerative braking, which ends up with less wear on brake pads (and emissions) from slowing down. Justin from Grin Technologies (an ebike part shop focusing on DIYers) has done a presentation on how that works on ebikes, and mentions that he's barely using brake pads now that he's using regenerative braking: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gYCj4asp9pE&t=970s

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:45PM (#32814009)
> Younger folks seem pretty excited to allow more biking and walking and rolling, though.

The difference may not be age; it may be having kids and dealing with the practicalities of that.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:18PM (#32814546)
The opposition is coming from people past child rearing years. Other parents like me are one of the strongest contingencies for getting rid of car-dependency. Cars are one of the greatest threats to kids in terms of death, disability, and maiming. And building cities around cars makes having kids a huge huge hassle, you have to drive them everywhere and they have zero autonomy.

Cars and kids are an absolute terrible combo.

I'm not sure if you've seen the huge rise of cargo bikes that I have seen, but they are nearly all parents with kid seating on the back in my town. We are trying to make do with terrible infrastructure and city planning, but it wouldn't take much change to make it all very much better.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by CalRobert on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:51PM (#32815912)
Hear hear - I want for my kids to be independent and for me to not be their damn taxi for 18 years. A car-dependent home is a prison for kids. If my 10 year old says "I want to go to the movies" I want to say "Awesome! Have fun! Who's going with you?" not "ugg I'm busy with work and can't drive you".
Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:23PM (#32814604)
Yep; we live where we do to maximise cycling. Here are the problems with that as a general rule:

- it's desirable, so property prices in places that enable this are higher, if there is even a location that could fulfill this

- expensive bikes aren't affordable by most people who also need a car

- there's a large window where kids are too big for a cargo bike, and still too young to go off freely

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by epistasis on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:29PM (#32814696)
I don't view any of these as a problem in the least. And sorry if it comes across as as a strong critique, I don't mean any of it personally, but have heard people say these same things but never from people that actually bicycle with their family.

We do all sorts of things that increase property value, why is it suddenly only a problem when bikes are involved? And the problem is only because we do a little amount of transition and not a lot? This is a completely fabricated concern in my estimation, the type of thing that people come up with instead of simply saying "I don't like this and don't want it."

Similarly, the concern about the cost of bikes is completely invalid, as bikes are always cheaper than a car, even brand new cargo e-bikes are only a few months of car expenses at most.

And I haven't seen that window where kids can't bike on their own or ride with another parent, and I know families that bike with kids of all sizes and ages.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:01PM (#32816076)
Okay. It appears that you haven't read what I wrote. I'll try just one more time:

> And sorry if it comes across as as a strong critique, I don't mean any of it personally, but have heard people say these same things but never from people that actually bicycle with their family.

As I already said, we have built cycling into our lives. Our kids (4 and 6) cycle to school with one of us. I cycle to work. And I am saying this.

> We do all sorts of things that increase property value, why is it suddenly only a problem when bikes are involved?

That is nothing to do with what I was saying. Property is finite; schools, clubs, and employers are too. A car is one of the few levellers that allows people to live somewhere cheaper and access places they need to get to. Places that are close enough to schools to cycle them to school and then cycle to work are expensive.

> Similarly, the concern about the cost of bikes is completely invalid, as bikes are always cheaper than a car,

That only works if you don't need a car. If you need both, which, see previous point, is extremely likely, then it's an extra expense, not an alternative one.

> even brand new cargo e-bikes are only a few months of car expenses at most.

An admittedly quick Google and I'm not seeing any for less than £2.5k. That's years' worth of car services, tax and MOT. On top of the cost of the car they almost certainly need.

> And I haven't seen that window where kids can't bike on their own or ride with another parent, and I know families that bike with kids of all sizes and ages.

Here's an example of what I mean: nursery is in one direction; school is another. How do we get our 4 year old to nursery and 8 year old to school? Should the 8 year old cycle on his own? Or is he in the window where he can't cycle far enough by himself, but too heavy to be safely steered on a cargo bike?

Broadly: if Facebook's taught us anything, it's the power of being in a social circle and thinking that must generalise to everyone, or even most people. Having a job where we can work from home, or rock up 20 minutes late, where we can afford to live in a nice location that has good access, and where we can afford expensive secondary transport, is all great. Wonderful, even. But having grown up in a reasonably deprived area, I believe that's not most people's experience.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by jemmyw on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @07:07AM (#32822763)
> Or is he in the window where he can't cycle far enough by himself, but too heavy to be safely steered on a cargo bike?

My wife cycled me around in her cargo bike, and a couple of other adults (not at the same time). I'm not a light chap, fairly sure I'd outweigh both your kids together. Steering on those things is pretty good, they're not light in and of themselves.

edit: we actually cycled both our kids to school in the cargo bike when they were 8 and 5. I'd forgotten, it was a few years ago.

Re:Cancer breakthrough is a ‘wake-up’ call on danger of air ... by robertlagrant on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:32PM (#32829835)
Fair enough. I might have imagined badly a situation where it's not easy or possible in terms of time using a bike for two separate children.

On the cargo bikes, I have thought about it but I'd probably steer clear til they have some safety standards attached (I think there's a German standard, but nothing else I've seen).