News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gwypaas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:05AM (#32808894)
Or get 3-4x as much bang for the buck building renewables.

Source:

https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by samatman on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:22AM (#32809090)
Renewables make grid reliability worse, especially wind, because the grid has to maintain a frequency, which is ultimately done with the inertia of huge rotating chunks of iron.

That's fine, as long as there are huge rotating chunks of iron. Nuclear can rotate the chunks, as can hydro and geothermal. Everything else emits carbon.

Europe is pretty tapped on hydro and geothermal, that leaves nuclear, or some very handwavey ideas of building a bunch of flywheels using resources which could be contributing to primary generation.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:33AM (#32809176)
Your info is out of date:

Inverters are solving grid issues at fraction of cost of spinning machines

https://reneweconomy.com.au/inverters-are-solving-grid-issue...

> Ian Christmas, head of engineering at Edify Enegy, told a Clean Energy Council large scale solar forum last week that the inverter tuning at four key solar farms – Whitsunday, Daydream, Hayman, and Hamilton – would address recently declared system strength issues in that part of the grid at one twenty-fifth of the cost of installing a synchronous condenser.

> He also said it could be done in a fraction of the time – around four months compared to fourteen months or longer for the alternative. “It’s significant enough (in terms of price and time) that it is a no brainer,” Christmas said.

Also note, synchronous condensers which you seem to believe are vaporware are a fine solution, just not as cheap.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by belorn on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:04PM (#32813227)
Give everyone equal subsidizes under contract to deliver a set amount of energy on demand, with massive fines for contract breach. The market will then determine which ideas are economical viable, and which ideas aren't.

This is what my government (Sweden) is actually doing, with one difference. Rather than a liability contract, if the investment fail the government will simply repay the investors regardless if it managed to deliver energy. The government intention is that regardless if energy projects succeed or not, the energy sector shall have any money they say they need as long they continue to invest and build more capacity. That is how desperate the situation is.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:42PM (#32813963)
This particluar tangent isn't about delivering energy. Most people seem to have accepted renewables have already won that price competition.

But there's various grid services which aren't just about delivering energy. There's a weird assumption that steam generator tech is automatically better at these things than modern inverter-based technology, but I'm not aware of any case where that is actually true.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by belorn on Monday September 12, 2022 @06:06PM (#32817652)
> Most people seem to have accepted renewables have already won that price competition.

The big question that the crisis seems to highlight is if price competition is relevant. What people want is energy on demand when people want it, and the supplier want to demand as much money as the market can take. What energy cost to produce doesn't influence either of those two unless there is an overcapacity with multiple producers competing for the chance of selling.

When customers pay 10-100 times the production cost, and are happy to do so over the alternative of not having heating or open factories, then the issue that energy politics is trying to solve is not about finding the optimal technology that in theory is cheapest or best. Any technology that can solve either short term or long term is desired technology as long they actually get implemented.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by redeeman on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @10:03AM (#32824416)
> Most people seem to have accepted renewables have already won that price competition.

is that why they still get outrageous subsidies to be any kind of desirable to build?

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:21AM (#32825482)
Which specific subsidies and country are you talking about?

Offshore wind (which is more expensive than onshore or solar PV) is now built subsidy free:

https://www.offshorewind.biz/2022/08/02/subsidy-free-offshor...

UK offshore is currently paying a negative subsidy, a little bit earlier than this was predicted to happen:

https://renews.biz/62009/uk-offshore-wind-to-cross-negative-...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by rcxdude on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:57AM (#32809452)
Short-term energy storage like the inertia on the grid is the tiniest problem with grid stability at 100% renewables. The energy in the spinning hunks of iron is tiny compared to even a small grid-scale battery, and the inverters on those batteries can provide a far better response to changes in grid frequency than the synchronous generators ever could. It's basically the one thing which is 100% not a concern with a renewable grid.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by johnchristopher on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:59AM (#32809483)
For what it's worth: France has 56 nuclear out of wich 28 were down on august 15th. https://www.rts.ch/info/monde/13306968-la-moitie-des-reacteu...
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by delroth on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:15AM (#32809653)
Because the European grid usually has less demand, more supply in summer and more demand, less supply in winter. This leads to EDF scheduling most maintenance and refueling for nuclear power plants in summer. This year was particularly bad because the normal summer maintenances were accompanied by 1. a bunch of delayed maintenances that didn't happen due to COVID-19; 2. a potential issue with welds in a safety cooling system which was found in 12 of the more recent reactors and required some unplanned shutdowns to investigate and (sometimes) repair.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ohgodplsno on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:04AM (#32809525)
For what it's worth:

it took a worldwide pandemic slowing down the rate of schedules maintenance along with a rare, unexpected potential failure along with the consequences of 30 years of not investing in training new people in the nuclear sector for it to happen, and France is still doing just as well/bad as neighbouring countries (actually, Germany with their full renewabls push is doing much worse). It's relatively safe to say that it's not exactly a common thing.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by doikor on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:17AM (#32809683)
And to add to that the country saving Germany and France from this mess is Sweden with its nuclear + hydro + wind (mostly nuclear+hydro though)

(and Norway too with its massive hydro capacity)

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by jakewins on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:29AM (#32809150)
> which is ultimately done with the inertia of huge rotating chunks of iron.

Not "ultimately", "incidentally". How do you think microgrids work without giant spinning masses? There's no technical reason wind or PV can't provide inertia, just need to program the inverters to help maintain frequency rather than just follow it.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gwypaas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:35AM (#32809200)
Synchronous condensers as mentioned in the other grid solves for you, but there's loads of interesting research currently looking into running large scale grids without any synchronous components.

https://www.pv-magazine.com/2022/06/08/new-model-for-grid-fo...

Other options include this where they demonstrate that they can switch between synchronous condenser and generator mode. Allowing a Power 2 X plant to provide system stability when it is not needed.

> 2011: first synchronous condenser conversion, from a 473 MVA generator to a +360/-210 MVAr synchronous condenser, making it possible to change between generator and synchronous condenser mode, depending on the season;

https://www.modernpowersystems.com/features/featurege-synchr...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by gwbas1c on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:57AM (#32809464)
> which is ultimately done with the inertia of huge rotating chunks of iron

Grid-scale batteries are fabulous for maintaining frequency, and handling the inconsistency of renewables.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by formerly_proven on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:25AM (#32809114)
Synchronous condensers do just that, but they're essentially the same as a turbogenerator of the same VA rating, except with no input shaft.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by samatman on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:34AM (#32809197)
Those are the flywheels I was referring to, yes.

Metals are energy intensive and we can't afford to build generator-equivalent machinery that doesn't generate.

A lot of other replies are deluded about the scale at which inverters can operate, but what else is new.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by formerly_proven on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:00AM (#32810365)
Synchronous condensers and grid flywheels are two different things, the former is synchronous, hence rpm locked to instantaneous grid frequency. These provide very short term stability, and are not energy storage (due to the small acceptable variance in grid frequency), and are normally used for dynamic grid-scale PFC. Flywheels are asynchronous and inverter-driven.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Mrdarknezz on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:16AM (#32809026)
You can't replace Nuclear with intermittent energy, they serve different function. So far the cheapest and the largest deployment of green energy has come from Nuclear and Hydro.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pydry on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:53AM (#32809389)
Solar and wind is ~4-5x cheaper than equivalent nuclear power. Complementary pumped storage to account for the intermittency is ~2x cheaper than nuclear power. Combined pumped storage+solar+wind ends up being about ~3/4 of the price and being able to do load following.

Nuclear power's output stability isnt worthless but it requires some pretty impressive mental calisthenics to convince yourself that it's worth quintupling the price tag when you can just build a battery.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by _-david-_ on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:40AM (#32811978)
How much storage are you going to build? 1 week worth? 2 weeks? A month? What happens when the storage runs out? You don't have that issue with nuclear which justifies the increase in cost.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pydry on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:40PM (#32812888)
https://reneweconomy.com.au/a-near-100-per-cent-renewables-g...

7 hours is apparently enough 99% of the time.

Overproducing a bit and turning it into windgas would probably work for the rest.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by fi358 on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:25PM (#32813620)
7 hours of storage might work in a country like Australia, but not necessarily in some other countries. For example, in Finland winter is several months long and during that time PV will produce almost no electricity. During winter there may also be relatively long periods with only a little wind.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by euroderf on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @12:56AM (#32820793)
As I understand it, Finland needs nuclear for the long midwinter spells where there is no wind to speak of and the sun is too low to generate much solar. It's a textbook case of gaps in renewables.

That being said, Finland has a wild excess of solar energy in the summer, and I'd like to see the gov't get serious about nationwide schemes to store up that energy for wintertime use. Air-water heat pumps, sand batteries, it's a start... capture that summer heat and squirrel it away.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pydry on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @11:59AM (#32826030)
Winter is when their wind turbines will be producing hardest.

Periods with low wind and low sun do happen but theyre rarer and shorter than people think. It's much more common that availability of wind and sun anticorrelate (even in winter), which is why the storage needed to get to 99% is normally measured in hours rather than days.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pydry on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:13PM (#32814465)
Finland also has a lot of hydro which countries drenched in sunshine usually do not.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:38PM (#32814822)
Finland only has 60 hydro power stations over 10MW, only ten of those are over 100MW and they all are under 200MW.

It’s nowhere enough and there aren’t any places to build more.

For reference current energy production is 7500MW in Finland.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by _-david-_ on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:20PM (#32814567)
With draughts becoming more common due to climate change, why should Finland rely on a solution that is going to be less reliable going forward?
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by paganel on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:20AM (#32809075)
With the mention that Hydro is not at all environmental-friendly, quite the contrary. It helps with decreasing the quantity of CO2 we generate, but in many other aspects is pretty bad (and in many cases an existential threat) when it comes to the local environment.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by dghughes on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:36AM (#32809212)
Hydro is bad for the environment especially those who live near it. A buildup of methylmercury in sediment is caused by hydro dams. There are lawsuits here in Canada by First Nations who live near dams.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:59PM (#32813142)
Hydro has been superceded by battery storage and Green Hydrogen production, for economic reasons.

Existing ones, particulalry those built for multiple functions (water supply, recreation) still have some use but mostly you just want to be rolling out solar and wind until you run out of fossil fuel generation to displace. Only then do you really need to start comparing whether building storage would cost less than more renewables and interconnects and hydro is unlikely to be the lowest cost option unless you're going to build the dam anyway for other reasons.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:31PM (#32814725)
“Hydro has been superceded by battery storage and Green Hydrogen production, for economic reasons.”

I’d be really, really be interested in primary sources for the above claim.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:54PM (#32816810)
It's mostly just costs.

See Figure 1.2 Global weighted average LCOEs from newly commissioned, utility-scale renewable power generation technologies, 2010-2021

https://irena.org/-/media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publication/202...

Hydro costs are going up, solar and wind going down. Hydro is still less than fossil fuels, which is great, but that's not the target to beat anymore, and renewables are lower and trending even lower.

And that's before the more extreme geographical constraints for siting, with good locations already used, the project sizes and the longer lead times and investment paybacks compared with renewables.

But Hydro also has flexibility, which is really useful for balancing renewables and nuclear. It's important to switch existing Hydro into this mode to make the most of it. But again, for new build, since the raw power is more expensive than renewables, the flexibility would need to be cheaper than the equivalent flexibility provided by more renewables plus batteries to win back that lost ground. And it isn't.

Same story for pumped storage. Here's a worked example for the Snowy 2 project:

https://www.solarquotes.com.au/blog/snowy-2-vs-battery-stora...

The key thing is, energy production is cheap these days. So storing energy has to compete against just building even more production and a small amount of storage. This applies to batteries as much as it does to hydro. But batteries scale down better.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @02:54AM (#32821367)
The links provided are neither primary sources nor do they support your original statement.

”The key thing is, energy production is cheap these days.”

This is immaterial if cheap energy is unavailable when needed. See: winter (season)

“So storing energy has to compete against just building even more production and a small amount of storage.”

This is incorrect. More production is useless if the output is zero. Zero times a large number is still zero.

Again, see: winter (season)

”This applies to batteries as much as it does to hydro. But batteries scale down better.”

The problem with batteries is that they don’t scale up.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:27AM (#32821877)
Batteries do scale up, it's just not as cost effective as scaling out and distributing them. EVs effectively provide grid storage for free (or negative price) which is hard to beat.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @05:39AM (#32822228)
Batteries have a hard scaling limit, i.e. global battery production.

Using EVs as batteries is neither free nor always available.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by cpursley on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:28AM (#32809136)
Yeah, Hydro is terrible for river ecosystems and one of the reasons they started removing them in the Pacific NW (USA) - trout migration.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by timellis-smith on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:33AM (#32809178)
They are pretty major producers of methane

https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2016/nov/06...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by AdamN on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:55AM (#32809426)
Hydro is not green at all. Nuclear is much better for the environment than hydro.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by bbarnett on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:04AM (#32809529)
Hydro is incredibly green, nothing is greener, and statements otherwise, are why people are in this mess.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Mrdarknezz on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:21AM (#32809771)
Nope Nuclear is the cleanest form of energy production https://unece.org/sed/documents/2021/10/reports/life-cycle-a...
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by bbarnett on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:01AM (#32810380)
I call your view of this report into question. The hydro section is replete with "Highly variable" as an assessment of impact. One of the largest variables, is "transport of material to remote site"... and if you look at figure 32, this accounts for perhaps 65% of overall "environmental cost", when the bars are averaged.

This can drop to almost zero, if you build a dam near a location with preexisting cement plants, or, in an area where you snap build your own cement plant.

Even steel transportation ; is it local? Is their train? Is there a waterway, which ships can transport steel to you on?

Hydro is so clean, it isn't even funny.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gud on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:47AM (#32811142)
Hydro screws up the local ecosystem. Admittedly cleaner than fossil fuel powered plants, it’s still not great for the environment.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by bbarnett on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:26PM (#32812680)
It doesn't screw up anything. The ecosystem is changed, yet this happens all the time.

Rivers naturally shift on their own. In North America, the land is still rebounding from the last ice age.

And it's not like the land is rendered hostile to life. A river becomes a lake.

And as there are beaver dams which can be seen from space, I'd have to say Beavers impact rivers far more than our measly few hydro dams.

It's normal, natural for rivers to be dammed.. it happens in nature all the time, unless you believe beavers are unnatural?

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gud on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:48PM (#32812987)
You make a good point.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by nicolaslem on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:15AM (#32809016)
Why not both?
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pfdietz on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:23AM (#32809105)
Nuclear and renewables are like oil and water: they don't mix well. When renewables are built out they push the price of electricity down too often for nuclear to earn the good average price it needs. When prices spike, dispatchable sources (or dispatchable demand) move in and snipe the peaks, so nuclear can't make up for it then.

These days, it's looking like renewables + storage could supply "synthetic baseload" more cheaply than nuclear in most places (maybe not Finland, yet; that part of the world is one of the worst for renewables), so there's not much place left for nuclear. If your energy system has variable demand it will need storage even with nuclear, which tilts the game toward renewables even further (their need for storage is partially covered by the storage one needs anyway to level the load; said storage can level supply and demand at the same time, to some extent.)

Nuclear also has the problem that it's not going to survive very well as a niche technology, as that would likely not cause enough construction of new power plants to keep the industry from seeing negative learning effects.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by adev_ on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:36AM (#32809213)
> When prices spike, dispatchable sources (or dispatchable demand) move in and snipe the peaks, so nuclear can't make up for it then.

That is not true. Nuclear power has been used as a dispatchable / regulative source of power to compensate solar and wind power intermittency for decades in France.[1]

> These days, it's looking like renewables + storage could supply "synthetic baseload" more cheaply than nuclear in most places

And that's gross bullshit.

- Never storage of electricity has been deployed successfully at scale needed for a mid size country. Pretend that it is, today, a solution is highly hypocritical or plain gross bullshit.

- Even on the most optimistic (and untested) scenario, the cost plan of RE+Storage is (at best) on part with Nuclear energy (Pumped-storage) and or way more expensive (battery, power2gas). [2]

> maybe not Finland, yet; that part of the world is one of the worst for renewables

That is even more bullshit. Finland has pretty large hydro reserves. Renewable does not stop to solar. [3]

[1]: https://hal-edf.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01977209/document

[2]: https://www.powermag.com/how-much-will-hydrogen-based-power-...

[3]: https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/FI?solar=false&remote=t...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pfdietz on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:55AM (#32809421)
> Never storage of electricity has been deployed successfully at scale needed for a mid size country

Remember folks -- according to nuclear defenders, nothing can ever happen for the first time. At least, when it comes to renewables, that is. Except for all the times new milestones are reached, I guess.

There is no valid technical reason you can point to that would prevent a 100% renewable grid from operating. And the cost of all the components have been falling rapidly as demand pushes them down their experience curves. I might forgive you for ignoring that, as a good experience curve is sadly not something nuclear has had, in general.

Also:

https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=983...

> With every iteration in the research and with every technological breakthrough in these areas, 100% RE systems become increasingly viable. Even former critics must admit that adding e-fuels through PtX makes 100% RE possible at costs similar to fossil fuels.

(since nuclear is not available at a cost similar to fossil fuels, this implies renewables would be less costly than nuclear)

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by adev_ on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:08AM (#32809566)
> Remember folks -- according to nuclear defenders, nothing can ever happen for the first time.

That is sophism and what-aboutism and irrelevant.

> There is no valid technical reason you can point to that would prevent a 100% renewable grid from operating.

There is and it is named Energy Storage.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ohgodplsno on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:06AM (#32809548)
Remember folks: building one of the most complicated projects humanity has ever had to do, with resource costs that would overshadow pretty much anything else in the world is super easy to do for the first time. At least, when it come to renewables, that is.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pfdietz on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:08AM (#32809574)
Ah yes. An energy system to supply the entire world has to be trivially easy or else it's impossible.

A renewable energy system to power the world would be an enormous undertaking. It's just that it would be less expensive than a nuclear system to do the same.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:22PM (#32815436)
Alright then, let’s try something easier then.

How much energy storage can we buy for 20 billion right now?

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pfdietz on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:22PM (#32816355)
Energy storage capacity? About 2 GW-years worth of hydrogen storage in salt formations. Charging and discharging (power related costs) are separate, though.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:59PM (#32816873)
Fine, 20 billion gets you a nice salt cave you can store hydrogen in.

Where in Finland are suitable sites?

What are the costs per MWh to store and release energy from it?

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gwypaas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:50AM (#32809354)
> That is not true. Nuclear power has been used as a dispatchable / regulative source of power to compensate solar and wind power intermittency for decades in France.[1]

You take the most expensive energy source and run it at a lower capacity factor leading to even higher costs per delivered kWh. That is the issue.

Say you run Hinkley Point C [1] at a capacity factor of 50% because renewables crowd it out of the market half the time and assume marginal costs of running the plant at ~€20/MWh. [2]

€(120 - 20) * 2 + 20 = €220/MWh.

That would be expensive even by Putin energy crisis standards, that is the issue with mixing nuclear and renewables.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_...

[2]: https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by adev_ on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:03AM (#32809524)
> Say you run Hinkley Point C [1] at a capacity factor of 50% because renewable crowd it out

Very bad projection because:

- Hinkley Point C, Olkiluoto 3 and EPR Flamanville are all prototype. Their CAPEX cost are not representative of industrialized Nuclear. As example, the production cost as expressed by the French ARENH is around 42-1€/MWh [1]

- Electricity price skyrocket when weather conditions make production of renewable impossible. This is where this kind of plant make a profit. [2] Your projection just fit a worst case scenario.

- At the current electricity price due to the Russian conflict, Some EPRs including the French ones are predicted to be cost effective in only few years.

[1]: https://www.enerdata.net/publications/daily-energy-news/fran...

[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-16/german-po...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by doikor on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:28AM (#32809870)
> €(120 - 20) * 2 + 20 = €220/MWh.

No idea about Hinkley Point but TVOs 2 earlier reactors have costs in the 15 to 20€/MWh range with average market prices around 30 to 40€/MWh they are making healthy profits with the reactors (and have for decades now). Once OL3 is running their target combined operational costs of all the reactors are around 30€/MWh. It will be tight but they should be able to make it profitable especially as they don't have to sell all the production at day ahead spot prices but higher fixed rate contracts far into the future. Obviously nuclear also produces at the moments when wind does not and the price spikes.

(https://www.tvo.fi/material/collections/20210713150018/7Rllf... scroll down to page 7)

edit: And TVO does not actually sell anything on the open markets but instead at production costs to its owners based on the % of investment into each reactor. Those can then either sell it or use it themselves.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pfdietz on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:47AM (#32812058)
> No idea about Hinkley Point but TVOs 2 earlier reactors have costs in the 15 to 20€/MWh range

That is simply the operating cost. Yes, nuclear can be quite competitive if your reactor is provided for free by the Nuclear Fairy.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by doikor on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:16PM (#32814508)
Those 2 reactors have had the costs to build them paid a long time ago with the money they generated. So that is truly all the costs left to operate then and thus what TVO bills the share holders or that reactor to buy the electricity from them.

So in this case the nuclear fairy is the market buying the electricity just like for all forms of electricity it should be.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by pfdietz on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:04PM (#32815208)
And that's fine. If the question being asked is "should we shut down these reactors", then operating cost is a good metric to look at (at least until major maintenance is required, then that has to be added.)

But if the question being asked is "should we build more nuclear reactors", then construction and financing costs must be included.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by doikor on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:19PM (#32815400)
The number I gave includes both capital and operational costs.

here is a newer one from Q2 this year https://www.tvo.fi/material/collections/20220713160120/7aj2c...

On the page 8 in the graph you can see the cash costs (operational costs) in blue and capital costs in purple (pink? dunno I'm quite badly color blind). Still with both of those the total costs of all 3 reactors is projected to be sub 40€/MWh. Obviously 40€/MWh is not ideal as the market every now and then is under that but they should be able to cover that during the moments when the price is high (it averages out they hope). Basically as long as the squiggly price line is above the colored solid area at the bottom profit is being made.

Also to the owners of the plant a easily predictable price is more important then the lowest so they can better predict operational costs of their billion euro+ paper pulp factories etc.

This report is based on their financial reporting to their share holders so I doubt they are lying.

You can find more at https://www.tvo.fi/en/index/investors/financialpublications....

edit: The math is quite simple for example 2021

14 414 000 MWh produced at the cost of 19€/MWh and average market price of 72.2€/MWh gets you 1 040 690 800€ of sold electricity at the cost of 273 866 000€ and capital costs of 220 000 000€ (OL3) giving them a profit of (well value made to their share holders who they sold the electricity to at cost of production) 546 824 800€

Not exactly like this as OL1 and OL2 do not have the exact same investor(s) and the split as OL3 but in the ballpark.

Could the investors have made a better profit by putting that 5.5 billion a decade ago in some random index fund or building wind mills? Maybe? But this is the gamble they took and seems to be profitable. Obviously not necessarily the most profitable investment as that is impossible to know at the moment you make the investment.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by doikor on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:15PM (#32816273)
> Nuclear and renewables are like oil and water: they don't mix well.

Funnily enough TVO (the owner and operator of Olkiluoto the site where his new reactor is at) also owns a bunch of hydro (and a little bit of wind). Though the hydro mostly exists as their own private backup generator. It has direct lines to the nuclear site so in the case they need to shutdown all the reactor and can't receive electricity from the grid to run the cooling systems they can get the electricity from that (they obviously also have onsite diesel generators too)

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by rcxdude on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:26AM (#32809122)
Because they don't really complement each other: nuclear + renewable grid has basically the same holes as a pure nuclear or a pure renewable grid, nuclear doesn't like dealing with peaks in demand (you'd need to massively overbuild nuclear to supply the peaks as well), and renewables might deal with peaks in demand but the dips in supply are a problem (for which again, you'd need to massively overbuild). For both you want to pair them with either storage or flexible generation (and the most economical and scalable flexible generation is gas, the only renewable options are hydropower and geothermal, both of which are limited in capacity by geography). So you're going to be over-building capacity and building lots of storage whatever mix of wind/solar/nuclear you build, so why not build the cheapest (and faster) mix which tends to exclude nuclear? (now, you might in principle need less storage and overbuilding with nuclear than with renewables, but the difference has to somehow overcome the 3x-4x price premium on nuclear).
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by probablypower on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:16AM (#32809018)
How do you define "bang for buck"?

Would love to see a source stating that renewables are 3-4x more effective in the context of energy security and grid stability.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:21AM (#32809085)
You seemed to have just made this up as a ridiculous straw man, but it's probably actually true.

They paused their other nuclear plant build because of worries that the nation they were building it with would be able to mess with their electricity supply.

And grid forming inverter based tech is the new best option. Distributed inverters can provide all sorts of grid services cheaper than old centralised tech.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by cromka on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:17AM (#32809036)
> Would love to see a source stating that renewables are 3-4x more effective in the context of energy security and grid stability.

Why are you asking for a source over a statement which op didn't make?

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Msw242 on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:11AM (#32808956)
How are you going to deal with base load?

We can save money on nuclear but reducing the amount of bureaucracy and increasing the volume for economies of scale.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by jakewins on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:20AM (#32809072)
"Base load" is word invented by coal power operators to argue for their extended existence, it is not a real thing.

See Table 1 in this review paper from June for a summary of grid simulations from 10 separate models running 100% renewables at various time step resolutions: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=983...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:25AM (#32809117)
More precisely, it was the coal and nuclear equivalent of the "duck curve". It was costly/inefficient for these techs to be flexible, so they seperated the flexible load out into gas and hydro to work around the limitations of the inflexible tech.

Now its a rallying cry for some reason.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ohgodplsno on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:36AM (#32809206)
Watch out, ideology is blinding you. Base load is very much a real concept: how much you need to have available at all times for your society to function. Your industry to run, your critical services, etc. You can make multiple layers (just running the government, industries, having heating available at all times, etc), and they vary over the year, but base load is absolutely a real thing.

Additionally, I would recommend you read the remarks of Table 1, where half of them either make a gigantic portion of electricity needs disappear (not counting livestock needs lol), or assume that 10000TWh (or much more) will be covered by fossil fuels or nuclear. Hm, that sounds like a lot like a base load. It does not either cover how much you need to build (current best case scenarios are that you need to build 2.5x worth your needed consumption for it to be available at all times. Hope you're ready to cover Texas in solar panels you need to replace every ten years), or assume that you can just... transfer electricity through ? Yeah, sure, if we had a worldwide grid that just delivers energy where it needs to be without loss, but we don't.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by rcxdude on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:47AM (#32809319)
Base load is not what you're describing. You're describing total demand. 'Base load' is the minimum in the demand curve over some multi-day time period. It is not a 'real' curve you see anywhere except in a split of how different energy producers vary their output, and generally applies to nuclear and coal only. It's not something you 'need to address', you can meet the total demand curve without having any producer look like 'base load'. (And if you're thinking of some hypothetical minimum energy usage at which society could still function, but at a lower level, you'll find that this curve is also not flat over time and is not base load).
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ohgodplsno on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:12AM (#32809609)
No, this is exactly what a base load it. What do we need to build so that, should all of our intermittent energy sources stop and we could not import energy anymore, we could still have the country exist and function. Where you put the line on intermittency is up to you (is hydro intermittent ? After all, you could technically run out of water in your lake. Is nuclear ? You could run out of fissile material. Is wind ? You could have clear skies with no wind all day long)

You can also provide a base load with just solar. You just need to spread your panels all over the country to make up for the fact that sun is not always shining everywhere, but the idea stays the same: can we produce 100TWh over a year with our installation, no matter what ?

Energy isn't produced for the fun of it. Base load is related to total demand, at all times. Some of that demand is so you can run your USB powered coffee cup, some of it is to run foundries. You pick what you fit in that, but whatever you pick must be covered by that base load.

Needless to say, with sources as intermittent as wind and solar, making any kind of plans except "we're going to produce X over this month" is pretty much impossible, and you need to compensate by building tons of storage to smooth things out, otherwise you get brownouts.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by rcxdude on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:27AM (#32809855)
I don't know how to respond to this other than to reiterate that you seem to be using different definitions of terms to everyone else. Obviously supply need to equal demand at all times in order for the grid to work. The main idea I'm objecting to is that there needs to be some magical flat line somewhere in the breakdown of how that demand is supplied (This is what most people refer to as 'base load'). Yes, the conclusion of how you meet demand with a bunch of intermittent supply is you build more supply than you need on average, you distribute it geographically and increase how much energy you send long-distance through the grid, and you build lots of storage (and think about what you're going to do with all the leftover energy when potential supply exceeds demand). But this solution does not contain anything which resembles what most people mean when they refer to "base load".
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gwypaas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:41AM (#32809251)
Base load exists on the demand side, it does not exist on the producer side. Base load on the producer side is simply a made up term because the most inflexible power plants of the 1970's were also the cheapest, and thus matched it.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by simonmales on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:54AM (#32809403)
Interesting. Not debating the definiation of base load, I always thought we got used to base load.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by markvdb on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:21AM (#32809081)
The general strategy that will get you quite far:

- improve interconnects

- overdimension production

- CHP [0] with biomass fuel

- hydro storage

- increase demand flexibility

- generate carbohydrates for seasonal storage

- lower consumption

Technological improvements and breakthroughs are nice extras.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cogeneration

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by AdamN on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:59AM (#32809485)
If the problem with nuclear was just bureaucracy, China would be building 100 of them right now. These are complicated machines and even the second most powerful country in the world is only building 17 currently.
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Msw242 on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:38PM (#32816577)
>China is planning at least 150 new reactors in the next 15 years, more than the rest of the world has built in the past 35.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-11-02/china-cli...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by rcxdude on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:16AM (#32809028)
you deal with baseload with renewables. It just doesn't make sense to seperate 'baseload' from 'peak' with renewables (in fact this is one reason why nuclear and renewables don't complement each other, in fact renewables will tend to destroy nuclear economically without a bunch of subsidies in place), you just step back and think about how you're going to match supply and demand when both fluctuate over time. (And the answer is a combination of over-building renewable capacity and storage. Funnily enough if you ask how you'd supply a grid with nuclear power you get the same answer, just with longer lead times and a higher price tag).
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:29AM (#32821554)
Unless you mean hydro when you say renewables, you aren’t going to deal with baseload in the winter with renewables.

Not that hydro is enough for baseload in itself.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:14AM (#32808995)
In Finland, Hydro combined with wind should take care of baseload.

They've also been importing cheap electricity to avoid burning expensive fossil fuels for about a decade, so they probably want to continue with that.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by doikor on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:44AM (#32809282)
> In Finland, Hydro combined with wind should take care of baseload.

Nuclear and hydro are the baseload generation in Finland at the moment and will be far into the future. Hydro is also used to handle peaks. Imports are mostly hydro too.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by gojomo on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:21AM (#32809083)
Where will they "import cheap electricity" from if none is being exported?
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by oldgradstudent on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:25AM (#32809837)
Supposedly from northern Sweden, according to a Swedish friend. Take this with a grain of salt.

They have a lot of power generation in the north, but not enough transmission capacity to transfer it to the population centers in the south, so they have to sell it cheaply to their neighbors, and buy expensive electricity from their neighbors in the south.

This all worked fine when they could buy cheap electricity from their southern neighbors. But now they have a problem.

A few weeks ago there was 10X or more electricity price difference between north and south Sweden.

Take a look at:

https://www.svk.se/en/national-grid/the-control-room/

Pick, for example, August 26, 2022, at 11:04. Prices up north are 14 euro per MWh, and 750 euro per MWh in the south.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by gojomo on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:54AM (#32812174)
Very interesting! Do you know if Sweden's northern generation surplus via something robust against gas-shortages, like say local hydropower?
Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gwypaas on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:53PM (#32816804)
Loads of hydro [1], the energy mix in Sweden is usually 45-50% hydro depending on the year. Sweden currently has extremely chaotic electricity prices. Whenever the export capacity is maxed out the prices drops to €10-30/MWh and then instantly recovers to the gas based prices of Europe when it's not.

With the recent chaos at the French nuclear plants Sweden became the largest exporter of electricity in the EU. [2]

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_hydroelectric_power_st...

[2]: https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/sweden-tops-france-e...

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gwypaas on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:18AM (#32809046)
Well, if it's a wartime economy measure why care? As long as the average is good enough and you keep the most important consumers running.

If we're talking peace time, then there's loads of strategies. For Finland, Sweden and Norway there's immense possibility of hydro power to simply switch it to be used in a more dispatchable manner than baselod. For less hydro equipped countries see this research.

> *B. Dealing With Variability and Stability*

> Much of the resistance towards 100% Renewable Energy (RE) systems in the literature seems to come from the a-priori assumption that an energy system based on solar and wind is impossible since these energy sources are variable. Critics of 100% RE systems like to contrast solar and wind with ’firm’ energy sources like nuclear and fossil fuels (often combined with CCS) that bring their own storage. This is the key point made in some already mentioned reactions, such as those by Clack et al. [225], Trainer [226], Heard et al. [227] Jenkins et al. [228], and Caldeira et al. [275], [276].

> However, while it is true that keeping a system with variable sources stable is more complex, a range of strategies can be employed that are often ignored or underutilized in critical studies: oversizing solar and wind capacities; strengthening interconnections [68], [82], [132], [143], [277], [278]; demand response [279], [172], e.g. smart electric vehicles charging using delayed charging or delivering energy back to the electricity grid via vehicle-to-grid [181], [280]–[282]; storage (battery, compressed air, pumped hydro)[40]–[43], [46], [83], [140], [142], such as stationary batteries; sector coupling [16], [39], [90]–[92], [97], [132], [216], e.g. optimizing the interaction between electricity, heat, transport, and industry; power-to-X [39], [106], [134], [176], e.g. producing hydrogen at moments when there is abundant energy; et cetera. Using all these strategies effectively to mitigate variability is where much of the cutting-edge development of 100% RE scenarios takes place.

> With every iteration in the research and with every technological breakthrough in these areas, 100% RE systems become increasingly viable. Even former critics must admit that adding e-fuels through PtX makes 100% RE possible at costs similar to fossil fuels. These critics are still questioning whether 100% RE is the cheapest solution but no longer claim it would be unfeasible or prohibitively expensive. Variability, especially short term, has many mitigation options, and energy system studies are increasingly capturing these in their 100% RE scenarios.

https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ohgodplsno on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:44AM (#32809288)
No biggie, just overbuild 3 times your capacity, replace all cars with electric cars (including the current ones that do not have this capacity), build storage (on the scale of which has never been seen before), make a miraculous, worldwide, no loss grid and use methods which have absolutely dreadful energy efficiency (P2G2P ? Hydrogen. Cool. I like losing 70% of my energy too)

Needless to say, the sheer need for resources to build all this will make the current state of global warming and climate change look like child's play compared to earth after.

Holy shit, how hard is it for zealots to understand and accept that our best, realistic solution to electrifying as much as possible is through a combination of nuclear and renewables, something that literally every competent actor has said time and time again ?

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ZeroGravitas on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:16AM (#32809667)
Quite a lot of the things you list apply to nuclear electricity too.

But you seem to be implying that those are renewable problems that nuclear doesn't have, and that adding nuclear to the energy mix will improve them.

Can you explain how?

Like, "pink hydrogen" is hydrogen made by electrolysis with nuclear power. You had a little rant about Green Hydrogen, so how does nuclear change that?

What's wrong with EVs charged from nuclear?

Does nuclear mean you don't need grid interconnects? Why do France and Germany trade energy back and forth then?

I like nuclear as a tech. It's you that I have doubt about actually supporting it as it seems to just be a hippy-punching shibboleth for you. Are you really just arguing for fossil fuels?

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ohgodplsno on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:49AM (#32812093)
Problem: we are using too many resources and causing climate change on a scale never seen before

Solution: Build renewables on a scale never seen before, then do it again two more times, as well as once every ten years to replace the ones that failed.

Do you see the slight problem? We do not have the resources for that. We cannot afford that. Is nuclear perfect? No. We have spent fuel (that hopefully we can figure out how to reuse, but for now, it's just waste buried deep), it's big, it's unwieldy. But it's reliable. Resources are both plentiful and we don't need that much. A whole lot of concrete (still much less that we would need to put wind turbines), fissile material that can be found pretty much anywhere, and a good bunch of pipes and various metals (infinitely less than what we'd need for solar or wind).

I said green hydrogen was shit for storing energy, and so is pink hydrogen. But if that can make you happy, I'm more than willing to use whatever surplus we get from renewables to make hydrogen. I'd just rather we waste 70% of a small production, rather than 70% of all.

What's wrong with EVs charged from nuclear? Everything. The only green car is a car that isn't manufactured. For most people (especially in europe), an EV will pretty much take 10 years before it offsets its CO2 emissions. Should we stop selling ICEs? Yes. Should we replace millions of existing cars with EVs? Absofuckinglutely not.

Nuclear means you're less dependent on those interconnects. Which, you know, is a useful thing to be as a sovereign country. See: Europe and its dependency on gas.

> Are you really just arguing for fossil fuels?

Considering how happy fossil fuel companies are about renewables because it allows them to sell gas when it inevitably doesn't work for a day and you need something else to make up for it, you would do well to rethink your mindless support. Every 100% renewables plan is the equivalent of a spherical cow in a vacuum. We cannot mine that much. We cannot find that much space in ideal locations, nor maintain it. There is not a single mine in the world able to get the resources we need. Ignoring reality is all fun and games, and if we had infinite time in front of us, I'd be all okay with going full intermittent power. But we both know it's not the case. Pretending anything else is ignorance and optimism at best, and malice at worst. You need to learn compromise, and as it stands, we cannot afford not to.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @03:37AM (#32821596)
Even overbuilding 3 times isn’t enough. Zero times a big number is still zero.

Finnish winter crushes solar and wind generation. No sun and wind still days.

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by Gwypaas on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @04:12AM (#32821778)
It is windier in the winter months, so what is needed is geographical decoupling through interconnections. Then overbuilding and curtailment definitely is a workable solution.

The Baltic sea is also definitely workable for off-shore wind. Not to the level of the north sea but not that far off.

https://globalwindatlas.info/

Re:Europe's Newest Nuclear Reactor Eases Finland's Power Pro... by ftth_finland on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @05:44AM (#32822250)
Geographical decoupling is neither cheap nor easy. Africa is far away and not exactly chock-full of stable countries.