News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by maeln on Friday July 29, 2022 @10:27AM (#32277359)
You can really see the Paris-centric approach in France: From Paris you can reach almost any other major city in 4h, but on the other hand, all the other metropolis can barely reach 1/4th of the other major population center in 4h.

Compare this to Germany where almost any major metropolis can reach 80% of the country in 4h ...

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by OJFord on Friday July 29, 2022 @10:43AM (#32277571)
Infamously similar in the UK, even despite being smaller. Particularly East-West travel anywhere much North of London. Many inter-city routes are via London.

(I'm not complaining, j'habite à Londres ;))

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by xenocratus on Friday July 29, 2022 @11:57AM (#32278585)
> anywhere much North of London

You don't need to go that much North - I used to live in Oxfordshire, trying to get to Cambridge for work was a joke (I don't drive). It would take 3.5h+ for a 140km journey from Oxford to Cambridge because train journeys were only through London (+ a railway station change), and there was only one coach that stopped in every town along the way (and which has been axed into two separate legs since the pandemic, making it 4h+ now).

In the end I moved to London, so that's manageable now...

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by OJFord on Friday July 29, 2022 @12:26PM (#32278942)
I didn't mean much North! Heh, another of those BrE words like 'quite'.

Oxford/Cambridge is a classic example, yes. (For those unfamiliar, they're like two spokes right next to each other on quite a small rim where London is the hub. But large enough (or close enough spokes) that 'in and back out' seems silly.)

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by ErikCorry on Friday July 29, 2022 @12:36PM (#32279069)
This is actually being fixed. Someone put huge telescopes on part of the old line, but they are building a new one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_West_Rail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mullard_Radio_Astronomy_Observ...
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by AdamGibbins on Friday July 29, 2022 @07:31PM (#32282868)
That's being fixed in theory: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_West_Rail
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by nonethewiser on Saturday July 30, 2022 @01:33AM (#32284511)
Actually, it seems like the fastest driving route goes down to London as well.

In fact, since Oxfordshire isn't very far north of London it's kind of a bad example. Of course it goes through London.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by rjh29 on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:21PM (#32280192)
South West connectivity is fine, you can get from Plymouth to Exeter to Bristol to Birmingham and up to Edinburgh without going anywhere near London.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by midasuni on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:04PM (#32280620)
At an average speed that makes a horse blush, and a capacity that is barely more than a Vauxhall corsa.

Cross country routes are local trains masquerading as long distance, thus with ridiculous prices and the requirement to do split tickets. There’s nowhere near enough capacity on the line.

Penzance to Exeter takes 3 hours - half the speed of a drive. From Exeter to Birmingham it’s another 2h30 at just 60mph average.

A good line would be an hour faster on both legs.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by throwaway-blue2 on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:29PM (#32281989)
You’d be hard pushed to drive Penzance to Exeter in 1hr30, more like 2 hours really. And whilst the train is slow the journey is lovely along the Exe estuary and then along the coast. Having said that it is a bit silly that when going from London to Penzance most of the time is spent on the final third of the journey past Exeter.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by OJFord on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:52PM (#32282199)
The South West is er not at all 'North of London' though, last I was there (where I was 'born and raised').

We also don't really have any of the major cities I meant in that context, Bristol I suppose. How do you get from Bournemouth to Bristol for example - via Dorchester with a station change? How about Southampton to Exeter - via Bristol? It's by no means the worst region, and I claimed the opposite, but it still suffers in the same way (albeit on a smaller scale) really, NW-SE rather than W-E in the North, in both cases its opposing the 'spokes' into London.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by twelvechairs on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:48PM (#32279872)
Metropolitan france is 54% larger than Germany so its not a fair comparison
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by zwaps on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:47PM (#32280432)
Germany has more than twice the population density compared to France - and much less variance of it
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by quelltext on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:41PM (#32280377)
Huh?

How can metropolitan France be larger than the entirety of Germany?

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by samatman on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:45PM (#32280414)
Because Metropolitan France (note the capitalization) is how the European portion of France is referred to: compare with Overseas France, which includes territories in South America and Oceania, to be non-exhaustive.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by corrral on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:21PM (#32280783)
This is a difference in attitude between Americans and French when describing their countries: the French tend to regard overseas territories as more vitally part of their country than Americans do. Not sure why, possibly it was a deliberately-cultivated attitude by the government at some point, or maybe the difference arose organically. Meanwhile I think a lot of Americans kinda-unconsiously barely even consider Hawaii and Alaska really parts of America, let alone the numerous non-state territories.

Actually, now that I think about it, the sense of "Metropolitan France" is very similar to the term "the continental United States"

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by ryukafalz on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:39PM (#32280966)
American here, I’d disagree about Hawaii and Alaska but agree about the non-state territories. The non-state territories being unable to vote and not having representation in the legislature means that they don’t get as much attention in national politics, so they’re less top of mind. (Yes, both of those situations suck and I wish we would change them.)
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by hunterb123 on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:18PM (#32281880)
They don't have representation (in the US) and are unable to vote (in US elections) because they aren't US citizens and don't pay (US) taxes.

But if you're a US citizen living over there and you made money from sources other than from that territory, you would have to pay US taxes.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by mrgriscom on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:37PM (#32282052)
Residents of the US territories are US citizens with the exception of American Samoa
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by hunterb123 on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:52PM (#32282200)
Technically yes by the Jones Act, in a very limited sense... there are restrictions as well as tax exemptions.

So I wouldn't really consider citizens of US territories full US citizens.

So maybe it's more appropriate to say they aren't Americans, but they are US citizens.

But that is all semantics. My main point was the reason they don't have US representation is they don't have US taxation.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by SllX on Friday July 29, 2022 @10:13PM (#32283701)
The restrictions are tied to geography not persons.

A Puerto Rican in California is entitled to all the benefits of US Citizenship whereas a Californian in Puerto Rico is not. Mostly these are related to welfare and elections. This would be the case for the Californian or Puerto Rican living anywhere in the world outside the US.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by niij on Saturday July 30, 2022 @12:48PM (#32288201)
You retain voting rights of the last jurisdiction you lived in within the US (states or territories) after moving abroad.

So a Californian that moves to, say, Germany can still vote by mail as though they were in California.

---

You're mostly correct about the loss of welfare benefits, though. The only exception being that you do remain eligible for Social Security retirement, although some people may not consider that "welfare".

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by thaumasiotes on Friday July 29, 2022 @07:31PM (#32282863)
> My main point was the reason they don't have US representation is they don't have US taxation.

The District of Columbia has to pay US taxes without being allowed any US representation.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by SllX on Friday July 29, 2022 @10:14PM (#32283709)
A situation that could be happily resolved by returning the remaining DC territory to Maryland. I would be all for it.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by samatman on Saturday July 30, 2022 @04:44AM (#32285276)
It's remarkable that you said all of this, I'll be generous and say that someone else completely made up the part about the Jones Act and you just heard them and repeated it.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by nautilius on Tuesday August 02, 2022 @10:25AM (#32318876)
I would think many people on HN have US taxation without US representation. A bit ironic, really.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by davchana on Friday July 29, 2022 @09:16PM (#32283448)
So a regular (ie mainland) US citizen has to file taxes (& pay if earnings 108k+) of living anywhere in world. Does this stay true if same citizen lives in these territories you refered?
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by thaumasiotes on Friday July 29, 2022 @07:29PM (#32282857)
> This is a difference in attitude between Americans and French when describing their countries

I'm not sure that's true - it appears to involve a legal distinction. I see many references to Algeria having been an "integral part of France" where other French territory wasn't. But I don't actually know what the terminology means. Anyway, I'd begin by looking to the legal status France tended to give to overseas territories, rather than the attitudes of the French, to explain this.

> Meanwhile I think a lot of Americans kinda-unconsiously barely even consider Hawaii and Alaska really parts of America, let alone the numerous non-state territories.

And this is a perfect case in point; Americans do consider Hawaii and Alaska to be really parts of America, because they have the legal status.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by samatman on Saturday July 30, 2022 @04:42AM (#32285274)
I've lived in Hawaii, and this just ain't so.

What there is, is a blindspot about territories. Just look at the flag: that there are parts of the United States which aren't States kinda doesn't compute.

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by DanBC on Friday July 29, 2022 @02:45PM (#32280412)
"Metropolitan France" is the area of France that's in Europe, and that's 543,940 km².
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by cataflam on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:28AM (#32285657)
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by izacus on Friday July 29, 2022 @11:11AM (#32277956)
And then you have Brussels, center of EU which has a massive reach.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by rurban on Sunday July 31, 2022 @05:50AM (#32294476)
And then you have Lille, the logistic centre of the European train network. (Eurotunnel)
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by jobigoud on Friday July 29, 2022 @05:09PM (#32281807)
The asymmetry from my home town of Bordeaux in the South West is striking, towards the North I can reach Brussels, 763 Km away, but going South I can barely enter Spain which is only about 200 Km away!
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by dmurray on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:12AM (#32285894)
This isn't so much about France's network being Paris-centric, but the massive natural barrier to transport that is the Pyrenees.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by littlecranky67 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @06:31AM (#32285667)
The problem us that Spain uses a different track gauge than France, so connecting the countries is difficult.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by haspok on Saturday July 30, 2022 @07:58AM (#32286115)
Fun fact from Wikipedia:

> Since the beginning of the 1990s new high-speed passenger lines in Spain have been built to the international standard gauge of 1,435 mm (4 ft 8+1⁄2 in), to allow these lines to link to the European high-speed network.

(...)

> In general the interface between the two gauges in Spain is dealt with by means of gauge-changing installations, which can adjust the gauge of appropriately designed wheelsets on the move.

I didn't know that!

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by ianleighton on Sunday July 31, 2022 @05:00AM (#32294330)
I believe I’ve read this was also due to Iberian gauge high speed rail technology not really being existent at the time Spain started building HSR in a hurry for Expo ‘92? in Sevilla, and they’ve continued using standard gauge for it (to the benefit of the link with France).

However the huge investment in HSR (longest network after China, but low utilization), has also come at the cost of the local and regional train network (which still use broad gauge, yes there are gauge changing trains, but the broad gauge network is languishing).

Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by littlecranky67 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:36AM (#32286296)
The Talgo train with adjustable track gauges has been connecting france/spain for quite a while, but it is by no means designed for long-distance, high-speed travel so Spain kind of had to resort to switching to standard gauge which is also what other important neighbouring countries and possible destinations use (France, Germany, parts of Switzerland , Benelux, Italy).
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by darkwater on Friday July 29, 2022 @10:51AM (#32277681)
Or Spain with Madrid-centric approach.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by marcolussetti on Friday July 29, 2022 @12:05PM (#32278650)
At least Madrid is roughly in the center of the Peninsula, whereas London is quite a bit off that.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by flipbrad on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:39PM (#32280969)
Strasbourg seems fairly well-connected, too
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by cjrp on Friday July 29, 2022 @04:14PM (#32281310)
Presumably because it’s where the European Parliament is based
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by littlecranky67 on Saturday July 30, 2022 @08:15AM (#32286203)
I doubt it has to do with the EU institutions but rather the convenient location at the rhine valley. The section of the rhine valley between Mannheim (Germany) and Basel (Switzerland) is one of the busiest train routes in Europe for freight and passengers.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by aj7 on Friday July 29, 2022 @11:34AM (#32278271)
These are countries the size of Oregon.
Re:How far can you go by train in 5h? by umanwizard on Friday July 29, 2022 @11:40AM (#32278350)
France is way bigger than Oregon (it's about the size of Texas)