News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by omginternets on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:49AM (#32251084)
I saw a rather comical sign posted in the first-floor window of a Philadelphia apartment. It had a silhouette of a German shepherd and text beneath, which read:

>I can get from the second-story floor to the front door in 1.2 seconds. Can you?

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by teekert on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:55AM (#32251185)
There are many variations, near my place there is a sign with a picture of dog saying: "I don't bite, I amputate." I also saw a sign with a picture of a Gun: "Forget about the dog, I rule here."
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by tacitusarc on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:34AM (#32251734)
In case this isn’t common knowledge, advertising you have a gun on premise makes you a more attractive target for burglaries
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:47AM (#32251925)
Specifically, because firearms are one of the highest value-for-portability, easy to move items burglars can steal, and America's gun culture is such that gun owners tend to have multiple guns, not take them all with them when they leave the home, and very often not have them effectively secured.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by googlryas on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:04PM (#32253097)
Is this actually true? It makes some kind of sense, but it is hard to guess at what percentage of thieves will be deterred, versus what percentage of thieves will be encouraged.

Perhaps we have a natural experiment, since California recently accidentally leaked a bunch of details about gun owners in the state: https://www.newsweek.com/gun-owners-personal-info-leak-outra...

Maybe in a year we can see if those owners experienced higher or lower than expected breakins.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by GuardianCaveman on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:11AM (#32260404)
A buddy got pulled over by a cop who gave him a warning and then told him he recommended for him to remove his sigsauer sticker because people will walk through a parking lot looking for trucks typically with weapons manufacturer names and break in looking for a weapon to steal.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by LinuxBender on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:22PM (#32253378)
This might vary from location to location. Everyone in my state is armed and about 2/3 of people are concealed carrying. Everyone here will look out for each other. Everyone in my area knows who lives where and what vehicles they drive. There is property crime but that also carries with it the added risk of justifiable homicide which sadly is not broken down in the homicide statistics as far as I know.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by oefnak on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:46PM (#32254776)
> justifiable homicide Killing somebody for breaking in...

Oh what a world.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by LinuxBender on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:08PM (#32255199)
It is a messed up world. Sadly people that have bad things going on in their lives get depressed and look for an escape. Here as in many places that escape is typically alcohol and/or meth. When people become addicted and overuse drugs their rational mind is overpowered by emotions and desperation. When in that state of mind one can not presume their intentions or how they will react when confronted. My own theory of which I have zero data to back it up is that on some level they want to leave this world but want someone else to do it for them.

As a pragmatic realist all I can do is work with the cards I am dealt. That is one of the many reasons I moved to a place I am allowed, encouraged and expected to defend myself, my family and my property. I do not consider myself or family to be replaceable. The best I can do otherwise is to mitigate getting into that situation in the first place by hardening my home but people will always find a way around it.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by exolymph on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:11PM (#32255251)
Stop valuing the acquisition of other people's stuff over your own safety and you won't have this problem :)
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by seoaeu on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:56PM (#32255969)
Stop valuing your stuff over other people’s lives and you won’t have this problem
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by collinvandyck76 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:16PM (#32258326)
The problem is that when someone breaks into your house, you have no idea what they are capable of. Are you willing to give someone performing a home invasion the benefit of the doubt? I'm not advocating for blindly firing away at anyone in your house, but I'm also not judging someone who has firearms in the house to protect their family.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by GuardianCaveman on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:15AM (#32260424)
This is an oversimplification. If someone is in your house and especially if you have kids you are going to do whatever you can to protect your kids not have a conversation with the burglar or warm him off with aiming a weapon. You don’t know if he’s armed and what he’s capable of, just that he’s in your house and potentially everyone’s life is in danger. I agree with you when someone steals a car from the front yard and the homeowner has legal basis to shoot that person over their car but in my home? It’s life or death.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by anamax on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:06AM (#32260380)
When someone steals from me, they're saying that they value my stuff more than they value my life.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by tristor on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:56PM (#32254982)
> Oh what a world.

Sounds pretty reasonable to me. In what world do you live in where someone can violate the sanctity of your home with impunity and you find that to be an acceptable outcome? Boundaries in society are ultimately always enforced with death as the final arbiter. You can put as many layers of abstraction as you want between that type of enforcement and the action that leads to it as you want, but it's always there.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by whiddershins on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:26PM (#32255496)
When someone breaks into your house while you are home you have no way of knowing what they plan to do. It is reasonable to assume the worst, burglars want to reduce risk and only break in when the house is vacant.

It is very explicitly threatening your life.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by kwhitefoot on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:25PM (#32255466)
"I've told you a million times not to exaggerate."

:-)

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by andrewl on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:12PM (#32254241)
Where do you live?
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by koolba on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:57AM (#32251226)
There’s also the classic: “Dont beware of the dog, beware of the owner”
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by jimt1234 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:31AM (#32251693)
My sister, who has 3 big dogs, always says: "They (the bad guys) might get into my house. But they're not leaving."
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by sandworm101 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:22PM (#32253372)
The job of big dogs is to bark, growl, run around and be so intimidating that no sane person would dare enter. If the burgler does choose to come inside, the dogs have failed.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by cbozeman on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:42AM (#32251848)
I feel this way too. If you're breaking into someone's home, you're asking to die.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by CorrectHorseBat on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:19PM (#32252430)
I don't like burglars, but a death penalty without trial is a bit much. And what about accidents and misunderstandings?
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:48PM (#32256722)
> I don't like burglars, but a death penalty without trial is a bit much. And what about accidents and misunderstandings?

I'm tired of this trope, repeated several times in this, that is used to excuse people breaking into houses.

Anyone breaking into a house while people are in it are not burglars, they're attackers.

It's perfectly okay to defend your family with lethal force.

Criminals breaking into the car in the driveway? No point in lethal force. Collect from the insurance.

Criminals breaking into the house your kids are sleeping in? No amount of insurance is going to replace them, so it is stupid to wait and see if the criminals will direct lethal force towards your kids before defending yourself.

I repeat, it is stupid to rely on the goodwill of attackers in your home to not harm your children!.

Stop trivialising attacks by calling it theft.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by jstanley on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:41PM (#32257385)
But you could say the same thing about random people in the street that you don't like the look of: it's stupid to wait and see if they're going to murder your kids, so the best thing to do is murder them first.

And no, someone who breaks into a house with the intention of burgling is not an attacker, they're a burglar, regardless of whether other people are in the house. Someone who breaks into a house with the intention of attacking people is an attacker.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:02PM (#32257614)
> But you could say the same thing about random people in the street that you don't like the look of: it's stupid to wait and see if they're going to murder your kids, so the best thing to do is murder them first.

No, you couldn't, because they did not use force to get into the space of your children.

> And no, someone who breaks into a house with the intention of burgling is not an attacker, they're a burglar, regardless of whether other people are in the house.

If they wanted to burgle they'd come when there was no one home. The fact that they came specifically when people are there is because they don't care about doing damage to the people (in which case, yes, they are attackers), or they came specifically for the people.

Really, if a burglar wants something, there's tons of opportunities when the house is empty.

> Someone who breaks into a house with the intention of attacking people is an attacker.

You only find out about their intention after they have done the damage (or lack thereof).

The only clear indication you have of their intent is that they deliberately waited until the people were home.

I am saying it is stupid to wait until after someone has killed your child to defend that child, especially when that person intentionally waits for people to be home.

It's hard to feel sympathy for attackers who wait for children to be home before they break in. If they didn't want to be dealt with as attackers, they should break in when no one is home.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by jstanley on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:43PM (#32268535)
> I am saying it is stupid to wait until after someone has killed your child to defend that child, especially when that person intentionally waits for people to be home.

But if you just preemptively murder anyone you want, you'll never know whether they were going to kill your child or not, and you'll think you're always right.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:15PM (#32268909)
> But if you just preemptively murder anyone you want, you'll never know whether they were going to kill your child or not, and you'll think you're always right.

Who said that I want to preemptively murder random people?

I'm only preemptively hurting attackers. If people don't want to be dealt with as attackers, they should not attack.

After all, if they're only there to take your stuff, they can do so when you're not home.

Your logic that people who attack you should be left alone is, quite frankly, weird.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by jstanley on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:26PM (#32269059)
You're only preemptively hurting "attackers", but you've redefined "attackers" to mean "anyone you want to preemptively hurt".

I expect in the vast majority of cases, if someone breaks into your home while you're inside, it's because they didn't know you were inside.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:40AM (#32274122)
> You're only preemptively hurting "attackers", but you've redefined "attackers" to mean "anyone you want to preemptively hurt".

No, I did not. How are you defining "someone who uses force to get to me"?

My definition of an attacker specifically requires that they force their way to me and my children.

You are on some insane mission to trivialise the danger from someone who is prepared to force their way to you. Why?

(I'm generally curious, btw - why is your expectation that someone who forces their way into a house is peaceful by nature?)

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by wheybags on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:41PM (#32257994)
Or maybe they didn't know anyone was home? It's not so hard to imagine many scenarios where someone just wanted to rob the place.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by sethammons on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:33PM (#32259410)
Let me introduce you to my mom's former landlord when I was a kid. Former rodeo cowboy who got into drugs. He broke into a house to steal shit to sell and when the homeowner came downstairs to investigate and the former landlord proceeded to smash in the homeowner's face with a ball-pin hammer to the point dental records could not be used to id the body. This guy had no history of violence. I'm sure the victim's wife would have preferred the cowboy being shot dead and keeping her loved one.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lmm on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:48PM (#32258072)
> No, you couldn't, because they did not use force to get into the space of your children.

Why is use of force the line? What about burgulars who enter without using force?

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by watwut on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:45AM (#32261825)
There are large parts of world, where this will get you to prison.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:00AM (#32263161)
> There are large parts of world, where this will get you to prison.

There is no country that I know off where defending your kids against a successful home invasion will send you to prison.

None.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by watwut on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:48AM (#32273575)
This is literally not true when defending involves killing. Self defense laws swings widely.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:42AM (#32274137)
> This is literally not true when defending involves killing. Self defense laws swings widely.

Can you name a jurisdiction where "defending your kids against a successful home invasion will send you to prison."?

I mean, that's specifically the scenario I started with, isn't it?

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by Handytinge on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:39PM (#32406565)
There are hundreds of examples if you google for "man jailed for killing home intruder".
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by omginternets on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:56PM (#32255971)
Those are obviously bad and efforts should be made to reduce them.

However, it's important to recognize the small proportion of events that started as a burglary and evolved into something much worse. With this in mind, it stands to reason that burglaries are no ordinary encounters, and that the criteria for lethal force in that situation ought to be relaxed relative to e.g. walking down a crowded street at high-noon.

Even in America, I don't know anyone who honestly thinks that shooting a burglar is prima facie proportionate. The claim is usually more sophisticated, and has two parts:

1. Pointing a gun at someone who has unlawfully entered one's home is a proportionate response.

2. One cannot rightly expect the home-owner to prioritize the trespasser's safety over his own, even in ambiguous situations.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by DennisP on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:36PM (#32254617)
In many states, it's a bit much for legality too. In mine for example, I have to be reasonably in fear for my life to shoot someone in my house.

That said, not everyone who breaks in is just after your stuff, especially if they come at night.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by cle on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:50PM (#32254850)
It's a tough line to draw. Personally, if someone has already demonstrated that they're willing to commit a felony (burglary), then I'm in fear for my life and the lives of my family. I get why some states don't consider that a justification for use of deadly force, but I also get why some states do.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by medstrom on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:36PM (#32252699)
In the USA, perhaps. Most of the world isn't that lethal.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by koolba on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:48PM (#32257474)
Having the right to defend yourself from home invaders with deadly force is a right that has existed long before the laws of man were codified. Hell, it’s a right even animals recognize.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by watwut on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:27PM (#32254477)
I don't know why this is downvoted. It is true.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by kolanos on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:13PM (#32255292)
I would assume people are tired of seeing this qualifier in every other HN thread? "It might be bad in the U.S., but in the rest of the world...." Especially when it is verifiably false. [0]

Of the ten most populous countries in the world, only China (2.114) and Indonesia (1.783) have lower peace indexes than the United States (2.337). Of the next ten, only four have lower indexes. In other words, two thirds of the twenty most populous countries in the world (of which the U.S. is third) are more violent than the United STates. Unless by the "rest of the world" we're going to ignore most of the people?

[0]: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-viol...

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by aussieshibe on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:26AM (#32261715)
My interpretation was that "the rest of the world" is meant to refer to "the rest of the countries in the world" not "the rest of the people in the world".

To say that the US has a worse peace index than the rest of the countries in the world is still hyperbole, but it's not so far off the truth.

The US has the 129th best peace index of 163 countries, right after Egypt, Zimbabwe, and Azerbaijan.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by kolanos on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:12AM (#32262030)
> My interpretation was that "the rest of the world" is meant to refer to "the rest of the countries in the world" not "the rest of the people in the world".

Even by that measure it is false. The only continents less violent than the one the United States resides are Europe, Oceania and Antarctica. The United States isn't even the most violent country in its own continent, that would be Mexico.

So really the unnecessary qualifier should be: "Well it might be bad in the U.S., but in Europe, Oceania and Antarctica..."

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by aussieshibe on Thursday July 28, 2022 @09:06AM (#32263745)
I wrote "countries", not "continents". I also have not claimed that the US is the most violent country.

By the metric you've presented as a yard stick for violence (Peace Index), there are only 33 countries which are worse off than the US.

Sure, those 33 countries mean the US has a worse peace index than ~80% of countries, not 100%. I concur that (based on this metric alone) the US is not the #1 most violent country.

Having said that: being worse than 80% of countries on any metric, in my opinion, is easily enough to be able to say "worse than the rest of the world" and have a reasonable expectation for that to be understood as hyperbole.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by ChadNauseam on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:29PM (#32259842)
In my experience, when someone says “the rest of the world” they’re usually referring to scandinavia
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by watwut on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:43AM (#32261814)
This attitude of "If you're breaking into someone's home, you're asking to die." is not worldwide universal one. It is very American one.

It does not imply necessary that America is worst country in the world overall.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by blowski on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:03AM (#32251324)
My labrador would run to the front door in 1.2s, but then roll over and demand to be stroked.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by IIAOPSW on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:23PM (#32253389)
I want to break into your apartment, pet your dog and leave without a trace.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by ushakov on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:09AM (#32251405)
a Golden Retriever would be happy to show you around and help you pack the loot
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by runjake on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:17AM (#32251506)
I say this tongue-in-cheek, here but I feel like you're being "breedist”, here.

I have a <1 year old male golden retriever and I was surprised to learn that he has a very strong guard instinct and will not STFU with his loud, deep barking any time he hears a strange noise, or some stranger is walking by.

That said, this is a feature, not a bug. "Early warning system" was in the top two features I was looking for in a dog.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by loloquwowndueo on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:29AM (#32251651)
Your dog may behave uncommonly for its breed but dog breeds exist precisely because of common and predictable physical and behavioural traits.

Great Danes are famously couch potatoes but mine could not stay still and demanded a ton of exercise - still it was the exception rather than the rule for that breed.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:38AM (#32251797)
Have owned four litters of labs and some goldens. They behave the way you train them, with one or two personalities being more "out there" than others. Ours were incredibly loving to new people, but barked at anyone that approached our house, attacked people who entered without us. One golden was so well trained we loaned him out as a therapy dog for people who were scared of dogs. He nearly attacked a mailman running towards us (sorry mailman!). One black lab in particular, Princess, she was a... well, a bitch, and kind of a bully. Animals have personalities too.

The myth of breed behavior is not good. It's the reason so many pitbulls are put down. They are absolute sweethearts until you abuse them and train them to fight.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by runjake on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:03PM (#32252187)
You're not wrong, but there are definitely breed dispositions to be aware of.

For example, you're going to need to train a Belgian Malinois or Pitbull much differently than a Golden Retriever.

And yeah, dogs have their own personalities (so do practically all other animals), and it confuses me that more people aren't aware of this. The world can be much richer once one realizes this.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:06PM (#32252237)
Good dog trainers train all breeds the same way. You may need to modify if one dog has a personality quirk, but not for anything breed-specific. It's all about the four quadrants.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by blowski on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:11PM (#32252320)
I’d say you’re both right.

A Labrador is more likely to have been trained to be a sociable, a Rottweiler to be aggressive. It’s reasonable to assume the breeds will behave in a particular way because they’ve probably been trained that way. Even when we don’t think we’re training them, our expectations cause them to behave in a certain way.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by runjake on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:45PM (#32252807)
I didn't think I was disagreeing with them, just pointing out breed dispositions. :-)
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by tomschlick on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:18PM (#32252419)
Can confirm. My 1 year old Golden got extremely protective of my wife when she was pregnant and is now protective of my son to the same degree. Large loud barking, defensive stance until we either greet the person or tell him its ok. Otherwise a normal dopey and chill golden.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by dsr_ on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:56PM (#32253961)
The Maine Coon brothers we have like belly rubs and sitting on or next to you.

They also have repeatedly cornered plumbers, electricians and HVAC folk. When we're expecting someone, we lock them up in the bedroom.

Maine Coons are cats.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by Veen on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:09PM (#32252287)
Same. My Springer Spaniel puppy would roll over and pee with excitement.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by sumo89 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:39AM (#32261790)
I grew up with 2 labradors that were huge attention seekers. One worked out how to open the back gate and if he escaped he knew we'd find him in a certain retired neighbours garden getting strokes and biscuits. That said, one time someone did break in to our house and the labs kept them pinned by the front door until the police arrived.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by copperx on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:31PM (#32252606)
Is the 1.2s timing standardized among breeds? Or is it a General Dynamics dog?
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by marcodiego on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:11PM (#32252327)
This one became famous in Brazil: https://g1.globo.com/mg/triangulo-mineiro/eu-amo-meu-pet/not...

It means "cute but ordinary".

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by runjake on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:55AM (#32252054)
It should be mentioned here that posting these kinds of macho signs are not a good idea. They may open you up to criminal and/or civil penalties, depending on your local laws and the whims of the judicial system.

“He was just looking to waste somebody!”

I cringe any time I read my local neighborhood watch Facebook group and some internet tough guy comments with “They (criminal) better not show up at my house!”

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by sumo89 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:45AM (#32261826)
Also if you have a Dangerous Dog signand your dog does then injure someone it's clear you knew the dog could cause damage. There was the case recently, Jacqueline Durand, who went to dog sit, opened the door and got attacked by 2 pitbulls. The owners tried to argue their dogs weren't violent despite the attack but the fact they had a sign up was one of the major points against them and was included specifically in the lawsuit.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by userbinator on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @08:08PM (#32258798)
I think it very heavily depends on where you live.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by runjake on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:18PM (#32268945)
Hence my wording: depending on your local laws and the whims of the judicial system.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by moomoo11 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:21PM (#32252464)
Boston Dynamics pupper: I’m behind you

Or it’s already locked in a precision drone strike on your location.