News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by CorrectHorseBat on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:19PM (#32252430)
I don't like burglars, but a death penalty without trial is a bit much. And what about accidents and misunderstandings?
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:48PM (#32256722)
> I don't like burglars, but a death penalty without trial is a bit much. And what about accidents and misunderstandings?

I'm tired of this trope, repeated several times in this, that is used to excuse people breaking into houses.

Anyone breaking into a house while people are in it are not burglars, they're attackers.

It's perfectly okay to defend your family with lethal force.

Criminals breaking into the car in the driveway? No point in lethal force. Collect from the insurance.

Criminals breaking into the house your kids are sleeping in? No amount of insurance is going to replace them, so it is stupid to wait and see if the criminals will direct lethal force towards your kids before defending yourself.

I repeat, it is stupid to rely on the goodwill of attackers in your home to not harm your children!.

Stop trivialising attacks by calling it theft.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by jstanley on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:41PM (#32257385)
But you could say the same thing about random people in the street that you don't like the look of: it's stupid to wait and see if they're going to murder your kids, so the best thing to do is murder them first.

And no, someone who breaks into a house with the intention of burgling is not an attacker, they're a burglar, regardless of whether other people are in the house. Someone who breaks into a house with the intention of attacking people is an attacker.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:02PM (#32257614)
> But you could say the same thing about random people in the street that you don't like the look of: it's stupid to wait and see if they're going to murder your kids, so the best thing to do is murder them first.

No, you couldn't, because they did not use force to get into the space of your children.

> And no, someone who breaks into a house with the intention of burgling is not an attacker, they're a burglar, regardless of whether other people are in the house.

If they wanted to burgle they'd come when there was no one home. The fact that they came specifically when people are there is because they don't care about doing damage to the people (in which case, yes, they are attackers), or they came specifically for the people.

Really, if a burglar wants something, there's tons of opportunities when the house is empty.

> Someone who breaks into a house with the intention of attacking people is an attacker.

You only find out about their intention after they have done the damage (or lack thereof).

The only clear indication you have of their intent is that they deliberately waited until the people were home.

I am saying it is stupid to wait until after someone has killed your child to defend that child, especially when that person intentionally waits for people to be home.

It's hard to feel sympathy for attackers who wait for children to be home before they break in. If they didn't want to be dealt with as attackers, they should break in when no one is home.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by jstanley on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:43PM (#32268535)
> I am saying it is stupid to wait until after someone has killed your child to defend that child, especially when that person intentionally waits for people to be home.

But if you just preemptively murder anyone you want, you'll never know whether they were going to kill your child or not, and you'll think you're always right.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:15PM (#32268909)
> But if you just preemptively murder anyone you want, you'll never know whether they were going to kill your child or not, and you'll think you're always right.

Who said that I want to preemptively murder random people?

I'm only preemptively hurting attackers. If people don't want to be dealt with as attackers, they should not attack.

After all, if they're only there to take your stuff, they can do so when you're not home.

Your logic that people who attack you should be left alone is, quite frankly, weird.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by jstanley on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:26PM (#32269059)
You're only preemptively hurting "attackers", but you've redefined "attackers" to mean "anyone you want to preemptively hurt".

I expect in the vast majority of cases, if someone breaks into your home while you're inside, it's because they didn't know you were inside.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:40AM (#32274122)
> You're only preemptively hurting "attackers", but you've redefined "attackers" to mean "anyone you want to preemptively hurt".

No, I did not. How are you defining "someone who uses force to get to me"?

My definition of an attacker specifically requires that they force their way to me and my children.

You are on some insane mission to trivialise the danger from someone who is prepared to force their way to you. Why?

(I'm generally curious, btw - why is your expectation that someone who forces their way into a house is peaceful by nature?)

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by wheybags on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:41PM (#32257994)
Or maybe they didn't know anyone was home? It's not so hard to imagine many scenarios where someone just wanted to rob the place.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by sethammons on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:33PM (#32259410)
Let me introduce you to my mom's former landlord when I was a kid. Former rodeo cowboy who got into drugs. He broke into a house to steal shit to sell and when the homeowner came downstairs to investigate and the former landlord proceeded to smash in the homeowner's face with a ball-pin hammer to the point dental records could not be used to id the body. This guy had no history of violence. I'm sure the victim's wife would have preferred the cowboy being shot dead and keeping her loved one.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lmm on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:48PM (#32258072)
> No, you couldn't, because they did not use force to get into the space of your children.

Why is use of force the line? What about burgulars who enter without using force?

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by watwut on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:45AM (#32261825)
There are large parts of world, where this will get you to prison.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:00AM (#32263161)
> There are large parts of world, where this will get you to prison.

There is no country that I know off where defending your kids against a successful home invasion will send you to prison.

None.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by watwut on Friday July 29, 2022 @01:48AM (#32273575)
This is literally not true when defending involves killing. Self defense laws swings widely.
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by lelanthran on Friday July 29, 2022 @03:42AM (#32274137)
> This is literally not true when defending involves killing. Self defense laws swings widely.

Can you name a jurisdiction where "defending your kids against a successful home invasion will send you to prison."?

I mean, that's specifically the scenario I started with, isn't it?

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by Handytinge on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:39PM (#32406565)
There are hundreds of examples if you google for "man jailed for killing home intruder".
Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by omginternets on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:56PM (#32255971)
Those are obviously bad and efforts should be made to reduce them.

However, it's important to recognize the small proportion of events that started as a burglary and evolved into something much worse. With this in mind, it stands to reason that burglaries are no ordinary encounters, and that the criteria for lethal force in that situation ought to be relaxed relative to e.g. walking down a crowded street at high-noon.

Even in America, I don't know anyone who honestly thinks that shooting a burglar is prima facie proportionate. The claim is usually more sophisticated, and has two parts:

1. Pointing a gun at someone who has unlawfully entered one's home is a proportionate response.

2. One cannot rightly expect the home-owner to prioritize the trespasser's safety over his own, even in ambiguous situations.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by DennisP on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:36PM (#32254617)
In many states, it's a bit much for legality too. In mine for example, I have to be reasonably in fear for my life to shoot someone in my house.

That said, not everyone who breaks in is just after your stuff, especially if they come at night.

Re:Fake Dog for Home Security by cle on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @02:50PM (#32254850)
It's a tough line to draw. Personally, if someone has already demonstrated that they're willing to commit a felony (burglary), then I'm in fear for my life and the lives of my family. I get why some states don't consider that a justification for use of deadly force, but I also get why some states do.