News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by bmitc on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:09PM (#32216592)
Bicyclists seem, to me, to be a very certain and peculiar breed of obsessives.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by SoftTalker on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:21PM (#32216695)
You find them in any sport. Weightlifting is another one that's easy to see. Go to any gym for a few weeks, you will pretty quickly identify a handful of people who seem to live there.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by freetime2 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @05:37PM (#32218009)
Being a low-impact endurance sport means that cycling is conducive to really large training volumes relative to other sports. I recall reading that pro cyclists will spend 30+ hours a week on the bike.

Triathletes are even more crazy, though.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by asdff on Sunday July 24, 2022 @05:51PM (#32218130)
Honestly after a week or two riding a bike you will get to that point. You crank out 30 miles in two hours and you will go "well that felt like a jog lets do another 30 miles right now"
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by freetime2 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:42PM (#32218962)
30+ hours a week? Did you read that right? To put it in perspective, Jonas Vingegaard averaged well below 30 hours a week at the Tour de France this year. (He rode at a pretty impossible pace, but still… it’s the Tour de France!) That would be an enormous amount of time for anyone to spend on a bike - especially anyone with a full time job and other obligations to attend to.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by asdff on Monday July 25, 2022 @05:00PM (#32230848)
Well I was commenting more on the very large training volume versus 30 hours a week. For running, most people out of shape get gassed and probably puke in about 5 minutes running around the block, and when you are in great running shape its not like you are really running for hours either unless you are endurance training. With biking, you end up with the endurance to ride for an hour or two or longer in one stint pretty fast because its such an efficient vehicle. If the goal is to burn calories before work, a bike is pretty sucky for that unless you are doing hill sprints because its going to take too long compared to running or other activities that can burn the same calories in a fraction of the time.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by midoridensha on Monday July 25, 2022 @08:32PM (#32232818)
Enormous? It doesn't sound like that much. Any cycling commuter probably spends at least 5 hours a week on a bike, and that's just a regular person. Throw in a weekend ride and that's 10 hours. Obviously, 30 is 3 times 10, but we're talking about endurance athletes here, compared to regular people just going to work and getting groceries.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by freetime2 on Monday July 25, 2022 @09:44PM (#32233308)
According to this article, pros typically train 20-30 hours per week, and will only typically do 30+ hours per week early in the season when building up their aerobic base.

https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2021/11/30/how-many-hours...

So even the top world tour cyclists are only doing 30+ hours per week for a fraction of the year. Compare that to professional marathon runners who are probably doing roughly 15 hrs/week at their peak. It's a lot... seriously.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by sva_ on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:24PM (#32219248)
I think 4+ hours per day isn't too bad. I cycle 2-3 hours per day and I'm not even a professional by any means.

The Tour de France isn't really useful for this comparison, as the riders have to perform at top speeds for several weeks so the riders have to not overdo it and risk not being able to perform well in the following days.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by freetime2 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:57PM (#32219430)
Does your 2-3 hours per day average include rest days and HIIT workouts? I think when you factor those in, 30+ hours a week really is a lot of cycling. And absolutely not something that somebody will jump right into after one to two weeks, which the parent claimed.

To be clear I am not saying that the average person couldn’t build up to 30+ hours a week of cycling. Much the opposite - the point of my initial post was that it’s relatively easy to rack up long hours on a bike, especially if you go at a slow pace. But rather that most people do not have the time or the motivation to spend that many hours on a bike, unless they race professionally.

Looking through Strava, there is nobody in my area who has averaged more than 15 hours a week over the last 4 weeks. My weekly average is well below that. Do you log your workouts in Strava or some other app? What is your actual weekly average time spent?

I think the TdF comparison is useful because it gives a rough idea of the sort of distance you can cover in 30 hours/week. Something on the order of 3000 km per month, which again I just don’t ever see any amateur riders doing in my area.

If you’re really riding that much, or even half of that, then kudos to you. I would love to be able to put in those kinds of numbers. But I still think it’s really rare for amateurs, and requires an obsessive dedication to the hobby.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by sva_ on Monday July 25, 2022 @03:42AM (#32221588)
> And absolutely not something that somebody will jump right into after one to two weeks, which the parent claimed.

Yeah, of course not. I didn't catch that part.

I don't use a tracking app, but I pretty much always take the same route to some mountains. Getting there takes around 45-50min. Then there's an ~800m climb with up to 20% incline. How long that takes me really depends on my form that day, and I don't really care about the competitive aspect. On some days I'll cycle a bit deeper into the mountains to get to the next peak, but that's really stretching it and I'd usually need to bring some extra calories (I do this on an empty stomach usually).

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by doliveira on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:37PM (#32219325)
Try a year or two, and even that is quite a stretch.

I don't think you quite realize how uncommon your level of fitness is

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by asdff on Monday July 25, 2022 @05:04PM (#32230895)
Just try it out biking and see how far you get before you feel absolutely cooked, you'd be surprised at how much mileage you just covered. Charity bike rides usually have the lowest mileage at like 15-20 miles or so and you can do that in any shape, they advertise that distance route as such, then they might have a 50 mile one that does take some training and will probably leave you cooked, then the more serious ones.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by doliveira on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @09:14AM (#32237809)
I used to cycle to work (about 3 miles away from my place) and after 6 months I still felt absolutely cooked after the uphill trip back, and the inclination wasn't even that accentuated.

So unless you live in a cold and flat-as-a-pancake area there's really no way to classify 15 miles as easy for anyone but seriously fit people. Even then, it's not something a non-athlete (amateur or otherwise) can just pick up in two weeks.

[dead]
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by Sentino on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:21PM (#32216698)
Srsly?

How often are they a problem?

Also it's legal and expected

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by zdragnar on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:39PM (#32216877)
It depends on the local culture. You've gotta be pretty dedicated to ride a bike in the metro near me on some streets, because the layout isn't very friendly to bikers.

Those that do seem to rarely obey traffic laws- the number of near-miss incidents alone caused by bicyclists who run red lights or weave in and out of lanes, up onto sidewalks, then back down into traffic is too damn high, to borrow a meme.

The city would be a whole lot better off somewhere in the middle- more room for dedicated biking, and more enforcement of safe behavior.

It's not just the roads either, unfortunately. There's a shared walking and bicycling path that runs around a lake in the city. It's fairly popular, but I've never been more than twice because I find walking there is unpleasant. You can only get nearly clipped by bikers flying past, not staying in their lane, just so many times.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by egypturnash on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:56PM (#32217055)
To be quite honest, it is very useful for cyclists to behave this way when they have to constantly fight traffic because it makes drivers give them a wider berth. You don't know what that bike's about to do, so you stay the fuck away instead of blazing by too close.

On the other hand, people who can't bother to get a bell for their bike and zoom past pedestrians are dickheads.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by michaelmrose on Sunday July 24, 2022 @05:43PM (#32218056)
Honestly no bike belongs mixing with pedestrians any more than any other vehicle bell or no bell. A pedestrian is meandering along at 1-3MPH a bike is comparatively racing at 10-20.

Even at only 10MPH you are closing on a slow walker by at least 13 feet per second. If they notice you 60 feet behind they have less than 5 seconds to react. If they don't notice you and you don't maneuver you'll hit them. If you maneuver and they also try to get out of the way you might still hit them.

I've had multiple bikes zip by with very little space where a slight step to the side would have let to disaster. Honestly anyone caught biking on the sidewalk ought to have their equipment impounded and sold.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by NegativeLatency on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:16PM (#32219180)
Biking on the sidewalk is legal in most places. Not saying those people weren’t being dumb but I’d much rather that that getting hit by a car
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by kazinator on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:40PM (#32220021)
If you ride on a sidewalk, it's harder for cars which approach from side streets, alleys and driveways to see you.

Doubly so if you ride opposite to the traffic direction, thinking that it's okay because you're off the road; drivers don't expect something to be coming down the sidewalk at 20-30km/h from the wrong direction, where less of their attention is focused.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by michaelmrose on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:36PM (#32220008)
It's legal in only half the country and its stupid everywhere.

"The overall crash rate for cyclists was 0.29 per 1000 cycled kilometres and 6.1 per 1000 cycled hours. The crash rate for cyclists riding on pedestrian paths was 26.4 per 1000 h, which was considerably greater than other road environments. For example, the risk was 8.8 on shared pedestrian and bicycle paths, 5.8 on cycle lanes and 4.7 on roads."

https://etrr.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s12544-021-00...

I understand it may be preferable from the cyclists perspective to injure a pedestrian rather than risk getting hit by a car but your unilaterally risking them to procure a benefit for your self. Morally you are fucking them.

Furthermore some are more vulnerable to serious or permanent injury than others and they don't have an option not to be on a sidewalk especially in the city.

If you have access to a car and are cycling for your health or to achieve a warm fuzzy for saving the earth and hypothetical and mostly fictional people while actually risking, injuring, or killing existing people because actually biking on the street is too dangerous you should probably bike on the street like an adult or turn the key in your car.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by kazinator on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:57PM (#32220089)
> The crash rate for cyclists riding on pedestrian paths was 26.4 per 1000 h

I'm amazed that whoever cooked up this figure is sure it isn't 26.3 or 26.5.

(I suspect that riding on the sidewalk is unsafe, at least serious riding by grownups; not four-year-olds on kid bikes. I just don't believe there is any way to obtain this sort of figure.)

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by prvit on Monday July 25, 2022 @05:34AM (#32222280)
It clearly states that in the dataset they were studying the crash rate on pedestrian paths was 26.4 per 1000 h. That’s just a simple fact, not a “cooked up figure”.

> I just don't believe there is any way to obtain this sort of figure

Pretty sure an elementary school student could figure out how to obtain this sort of figure.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by kazinator on Monday July 25, 2022 @10:09AM (#32224523)
There is no way to gather such a data set. There is no mass surveillence system which tracks where cyclists are cycling, and how many hours.

Let's look at just the sidewalk versus road issue: if you could surreptitiously place GPS tags on random cyclists, the GPS system does not have the accuracy to tell whether the cyclist is on the sidewalk or road.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by prvit on Monday July 25, 2022 @11:09AM (#32225453)
Are you ok? If you click the link, you will find out exactly how the dataset was gathered. I have a hard time believing that a person capable of navigating to HN and producing somewhat coherent sentences is too stupid to figure this out.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by michaelmrose on Monday July 25, 2022 @06:49PM (#32231990)
This is not an acceptable way to speak here. When you find yourself adding emotional content including insults before your statements take a breath and delete everything but the factual statements. For example you could have simply said

"If you click the link, you will find out exactly how the dataset was gathered"

It would have added the same value without degrading the conversation or being rude.

Thank you.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by prvit on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:54PM (#32232528)
Come on, it’s clear that kazinator is deliberately trolling by pretending to be stupid. Nothing wrong with calling them out on that.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:22PM (#32256372)
That is not clear at all. They might simply disagree with the methodology and that is a legit topic to discuss. More importantly if you actually think he is trolling the best route to go is to disengage and downvote. This doesn't distract from the discussion or degrade the discussion into name calling.

Also hacker news rules are to respond to the most charitable interpretation of the users point. Assume they are disagreeing in good faith and engage with the topic or disengage and down vote if you feel the users contribution is negative.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by prvit on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:39PM (#32270902)
> They might simply disagree with the methodology and that is a legit topic to discuss

Sure, but ignoring a clear explanation of the methodology isn’t.

> Also hacker news rules are to respond to the most charitable interpretation of the users point

The most charitable interpretation is indeed that he’s trolling and not stupid.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by kazinator on Monday July 25, 2022 @11:50AM (#32226138)
That particular figure is from a referenced paper by a R. G. Poulos (at al), whose data comes from self-reporting.

"This paper examines self-reported prospectively collected data from 2038 adult transport and recreational cyclists from New South Wales (Australia) to determine exposure-based incident crash and injury rates."

That's just silly nonsense.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by prvit on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:24PM (#32228720)
ok? It’s not like someone tried to mislead you about the source of that figure, it was clearly stated. Why are you pretending to be stupid?

You could just jump straight to criticizing the dataset instead of pretending to not know how they could reach that figure.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by zdragnar on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:45AM (#32221248)
I don't agree that you should intentionally endanger the safety and lives of others to get some extra elbow room.

The most important thing you can do on a road (aside from situational awareness) is be predictable- that others have an idea of what you're going to do.

If you're behaving erratically or crossing into pedestrian crosswalks so it doesn't look quite so much like you're running a red light, you're seriously increasing the odds of colliding with a vehicle or person.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by Sentino on Sunday July 24, 2022 @04:23PM (#32217315)
On one side it's expected from a biker to drive straight etc. And then it's expected to drive around plenty of obstacles on the bike lane.

But yes we should rebuild cities to accommodate bikes first and then see if cars still have space.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by _dain_ on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:23PM (#32216712)
"car roads"? there is no such thing, aside from motorways, on which cyclists are banned by law.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by egypturnash on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:56PM (#32217064)
There are definitely roads where bikes are allowed, maybe even with a designated lane, that are not safe ones to cycle on.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by Moru on Sunday July 24, 2022 @05:55PM (#32218158)
But in no case is it the bikers fault.

If the road is allowed for bicycles, the cars have to take care not to run them over. Most roads are perfectly safe for bicycles, it's the cars that isn't safe for them. Best is to plan a city so you can bicycle wherever you need to, this leads to less cars in the city which is good for you that need your car to get home.