Let's look at just the sidewalk versus road issue: if you could surreptitiously place GPS tags on random cyclists, the GPS system does not have the accuracy to tell whether the cyclist is on the sidewalk or road.
"If you click the link, you will find out exactly how the dataset was gathered"
It would have added the same value without degrading the conversation or being rude.
Thank you.
Also hacker news rules are to respond to the most charitable interpretation of the users point. Assume they are disagreeing in good faith and engage with the topic or disengage and down vote if you feel the users contribution is negative.
Sure, but ignoring a clear explanation of the methodology isn’t.
> Also hacker news rules are to respond to the most charitable interpretation of the users point
The most charitable interpretation is indeed that he’s trolling and not stupid.
"This paper examines self-reported prospectively collected data from 2038 adult transport and recreational cyclists from New South Wales (Australia) to determine exposure-based incident crash and injury rates."
That's just silly nonsense.
You could just jump straight to criticizing the dataset instead of pretending to not know how they could reach that figure.
> I just don't believe there is any way to obtain this sort of figure
Pretty sure an elementary school student could figure out how to obtain this sort of figure.