News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by prvit on Monday July 25, 2022 @07:54PM (#32232528)
Come on, it’s clear that kazinator is deliberately trolling by pretending to be stupid. Nothing wrong with calling them out on that.
Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:22PM (#32256372)
That is not clear at all. They might simply disagree with the methodology and that is a legit topic to discuss. More importantly if you actually think he is trolling the best route to go is to disengage and downvote. This doesn't distract from the discussion or degrade the discussion into name calling.

Also hacker news rules are to respond to the most charitable interpretation of the users point. Assume they are disagreeing in good faith and engage with the topic or disengage and down vote if you feel the users contribution is negative.

Re:The Creepiest Cycling Condition: Shermer’s Neck by prvit on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:39PM (#32270902)
> They might simply disagree with the methodology and that is a legit topic to discuss

Sure, but ignoring a clear explanation of the methodology isn’t.

> Also hacker news rules are to respond to the most charitable interpretation of the users point

The most charitable interpretation is indeed that he’s trolling and not stupid.