These apps seem to be trying to build a network of only high priority goods, which will never work. Their vehicles and workers spend most of their time moving with just a few items for just one customer. There's no way to make that cheap.
This was the main reason many delivery apps/startups went under during the first dot com crash. Lots of VC money floating around with too little common sense. I'm puzzled why companies think "Oh no, WE can make this work now!" and are trying pretty much the same thing.
I thought we all learned this wasn't a profitable business model some 20 years ago?
So for the upper 5% of Sao Paulo, this might fly.
A lot of places like that.
No one wants to do these gig jobs. The only people who do them are people who have no other option.
It was great during the pandemic when everything was shut. But now that factories and offices are open again, people are opting for actual full time jobs.
The labor model fails if the local economy is doing well.
It means it's at most a niche product, but it surely can work. There are plenty of people that transport only high-priority products. But yes, those companies promising to do it cheap will fail.
* There was a core of customers willing to pay super high delivery costs to pay for the lack of efficiencies in the network. In some markets, there are quite a large number of people prepared to pay substantial premiums for convenience.
* Or... When they had a decent core of business, they could do a merger with companies doing slower delivery and therefore have a network with a mix of goods priorities. For example, a merger/deal with USPS could have them deliver your '10 minutes' groceries, and at the same time have the same worker bring the mail for your house and for the rest of the street. That way the worker effectively isn't doing any more work than the USPS worker would have been doing anyway, although it is scheduled to happen at a time determined by the highest priority items (the groceries), and costs are dramatically lowered.
On an other note, depsite my start-up having failed Amazon is now rolling out a similar product: opening up FBA for third party marketplaces. They are not moving as fast as they used to, but still faster than anyone else. And they are moving a juggernaught. No idea how thatbstill works after all those years...
Like Uber - $33B in investor cash. $0 in operational profit.
The promise was always scale. Yet, now that it’s time to show profits, Uber has had to pull back from markets and reduce its scale.
Sure, they cut back on those investments. But they didn't otherwise make the changes needed to get Uber to profitability given that nothing else was going to fundamentally change. Wasn't the logical thing to ramp prices up and let the chips fall where they would in terms of ridership and viability in various markets?
I get that Uber brought a better taxi service to quite a few markets. But as an Uber board member, I wouldn't really care.
My impression is that they sort of staked things on a pivot to UberEats, though that looks like a bust too.
Indian ridesharing is in a weird place where both parties in the duopoly are unwilling to dominate the market. Uber is trying to exit, Ola is focusing its efforts on a (failing) e-scooter startup.
I'm visiting Southeast Asia right now and Grab is a popular service.
It seems to me you can order anything (reasonable) from Grab, but it seems 95%+ of the orders are for food
I think the other thing that makes delivery here simple (and I'm guessing, profitable) is the proliferation of scooters. They're everywhere and everyone has one. I suspect decent gas mileage and simple to park convenience makes them the obvious vehicle for instant delivery.
In the US when you have Taco Bell paying $15/hr, you would need to pay a fair bit more for someone with a clean driving record and a car. And at that point, is it really worth $20 to get a single toy from the store?
In a lot of Southeast Asia, personal service generally (drivers, full-time home help) is a lot more common generally for middle class-ish people than it is in the US or Western Europe.
But Grab Food, Grab Mart and so on are spectacular services, and I find them way better and faster than Uber Eats in many places.
Importantly, this kind of infrastructure quickly leads to bottlenecks because of hot zone times. Amazon with their 'overnight' delivery has got it right, having drivers do delivery in extreme early hours when they have to confront rather little traffic. Well, I guess it's good for everyone except the drivers who are forced to lead an unhealthy nocturnal lifestyle :(.
A lot of people would reject that focus on limitations and realism as "negativity" and maybe even get hostile. It's stupid, but it might have been how we got to where we are.
We would've had this the entire time if we didn't have minimum wage laws, that these companies are skirting.
They have to, to satisfy investors.
Investors have declared rapid delivery to be a winner-takes-all market, where the winner captures the customers through an app (customers can only have so many apps on their phone, and prefer to use a single app for their rapid delivery needs). So rapid growth is the only option. Grow or die. That's why we see so many of these startups going down.
The app experience has been standardized enough that I don’t really care what I use as long as I get the cheapest price.
What I am surprised we have not yet seen is "Trader Joes online". Not for Trader Joes to do it (they seem disinterested and very focused on an in-store experience/model). But for some startup or legacy company to make such an offering. Limited SKUs, terrific value, optimized for online ordering/storage/deliervy, etc.
This works by having fixed routes, known ahead of time, which optimise for local driver knowledge (it's supposed to be the same driver every week), and therefore can afford to be really quite cheap for delivery.
I like the model and I'd like to see it applied to more types of food delivery.
(disclaimer: work for DoorDash, but in an unrelated org)
Amazon Fresh is scheduled fairly large delivery windows, usually at least a day out. If you get super lucky there might be an available slot later the same day but not often if city.
It's about taking a massive wad of cash and using it to block other entrants into your marketplace. Keep out competition as long as possible, and then once no one is looking, raise prices.
(Honestly, it seems kind of short-signed to me.)
But, I was thinking a bit more about my statement last night; and I realized there are two directions to take: Build enough assets that, when the business fails, you can sell something off to whoever comes along with another wad of cash; or once you push everyone out and it's clear you don't have a sustainable business, rebrand so that everyone thinks you're a newcomer.
I personally wouldn't do it, but I'm too much of a nice guy to run a business.
Tampons, toilet paper, razors, diapers, etc. are also things people often need right now and can’t easily get them (any parent with young children knows how much it sucks to run out of something at a point where the child is asleep - do you wake them to go to the store?)
Even random stuff like home improvement items - it really sucks to be covered in paint and then realize you need some sandpaper or whatever - having to clean off and go to the store in the middle if a project is a real pain.
I am surprised, with all the notes / planning/ calendar/ reminder software being there along with incredible array of personal devices to store them, people can't combine these basic requirements with regular store trips.
To deliver products quickly, you need inventory close at hand, aka “dark stores”. To justify the massive upfront investment in dark stores, you need either need massive volume, or you need high average order value.
Massive volume doesn’t work because rapid delivery is niche and delivery fees means that people can’t use them as frequently. Plus, dark stores simply can’t carry enough inventory to do large volumes.
The only option is to increase the average order size. But because dark stores carry limited inventory, you can’t upsell much.
Especially in situations where you absolutely need something delivered immediately, the difference between 15-20 and 40-45 minutes is enormous.
https://web.archive.org/web/20160814085512/http://www.goavoc...
"Just in time life" is a bad idea.
How many people are going to pay $25 or whatever to get that sandpaper delivered?
Amazon did not solve this via technical means. Amazon relies on worker exploitation for this.
I suspect the reason it is so terrible to work at one is that designing a fulfillment scheduling algorthm that can handle 10% variance in human throughput is really hard. (The main complaints the workers have involve bathroom breaks!)
They realize they are running out of people they have not burned out yet, and are looking into fixing it before exhausting the entire US labor pool, so clearly they've created a massive quality of life issue for the workers.
They wouldn't be the first ones to do this either. IKEA had a similar model in Sweden.
Main issue is that from numbers perspective only the throughput matters. Not if it is in general sustainable in long run.
I'm guessing throughout spikes and troughs cause bursty behavior for the trucks leaving the warehouse, which causes alternating backlogs/idle time for the delivery drivers.
Also, how do you store big bursty backlogs of stuff that's already left the warehouse?
By making your offering "You can have anything" you draw in a load of customers who are ordering things that actually aren't that urgent, and therefore they have extreme price elasticity, whilst also making the problem you're solving the most expansive version of the problem possible. The second you start charging for the fast delivery they're just going to go elsewhere. You're just acquiring really shitty customers.
The thing to learn from is Amazon, Amazon don't make money on delivery, it was a differentiator to attract customers to their shop which makes money, and it was built on top of a difficult but possible technical problem - building a much more efficient warehouse.
In my view, there's only 1 area where people will pay a premium for time, and that's food delivery, and everything else people will settle for a longer wait (really, we're talking here 15mins vs 24 hours). The smart thing to do maybe is to find a way to utilize the non-peak hours of the food delivery companies to do grocery delivery in a less time-sensitive, but cheaper way.