News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by londons_explore on Monday July 18, 2022 @07:13AM (#32136847)
Delivery networks operate most efficiently with a mix of priorities of goods. That way, every time a truck moves, it is guaranteed to be full.

These apps seem to be trying to build a network of only high priority goods, which will never work. Their vehicles and workers spend most of their time moving with just a few items for just one customer. There's no way to make that cheap.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by at-fates-hands on Monday July 18, 2022 @12:09PM (#32139919)
>> Their vehicles and workers spend most of their time moving with just a few items for just one customer.

This was the main reason many delivery apps/startups went under during the first dot com crash. Lots of VC money floating around with too little common sense. I'm puzzled why companies think "Oh no, WE can make this work now!" and are trying pretty much the same thing.

I thought we all learned this wasn't a profitable business model some 20 years ago?

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by AzzieElbab on Monday July 18, 2022 @11:15AM (#32139333)
Additionally, these startups play the good old game of "who has enough cash to stay afloat the longest" against each other since none have any technological or logistical advantages
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by jollybean on Monday July 18, 2022 @09:27AM (#32138110)
It can be 'cheap' in places with very high inequality and slack labour.

So for the upper 5% of Sao Paulo, this might fly.

A lot of places like that.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by mikeyouse on Monday July 18, 2022 @09:52AM (#32138377)
Sure, there are probably pockets in the Bay Area and NYC where this would make sense as well, but then you wouldn't get multi-billion dollar fundraises and decaunicorn status.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by ghaff on Monday July 18, 2022 @10:00AM (#32138453)
Right. Certainly there are pockets where a fair number of people are willing and able to spend thousands of dollars a year for personal services that they don't strictly speaking need. (And it's actually pretty easy to get into that range.) But it can be hard to translate that into more than a mom-and-pop business, and certainly into a highly scalable VC business.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by dwater on Monday July 18, 2022 @11:30AM (#32139504)
Yeah, when I visited Cairo a while back, the corner markets usually had a boy that would deliver whatever you wanted for a tip, but they were never going more than a couple of blocks, you could only buy what they had in the shop, and if the boy was out you'd have to wait.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by spaceman_2020 on Monday July 18, 2022 @11:24AM (#32139433)
Here in India, these startups are running into a problem with lack of labor.

No one wants to do these gig jobs. The only people who do them are people who have no other option.

It was great during the pandemic when everything was shut. But now that factories and offices are open again, people are opting for actual full time jobs.

The labor model fails if the local economy is doing well.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by marcosdumay on Monday July 18, 2022 @12:13PM (#32139966)
"There's no way to make that cheap" doesn't lead to "will never work".

It means it's at most a niche product, but it surely can work. There are plenty of people that transport only high-priority products. But yes, those companies promising to do it cheap will fail.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by drw85 on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @07:32AM (#32150104)
The problem is that none of these things are actually of a high priority. So customers wanting some chips or ice cream will not pay a high enough price to actually be profitable without heavy subsidizing.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by CoastalCoder on Monday July 18, 2022 @09:12AM (#32137938)
Assuming you're correct, it's painful to consider the amount of effort and money that was wasted simply because investors missed this basic insight.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by londons_explore on Monday July 18, 2022 @09:28AM (#32138112)
Investors didn't miss it. They were betting that:

* There was a core of customers willing to pay super high delivery costs to pay for the lack of efficiencies in the network. In some markets, there are quite a large number of people prepared to pay substantial premiums for convenience.

* Or... When they had a decent core of business, they could do a merger with companies doing slower delivery and therefore have a network with a mix of goods priorities. For example, a merger/deal with USPS could have them deliver your '10 minutes' groceries, and at the same time have the same worker bring the mail for your house and for the rest of the street. That way the worker effectively isn't doing any more work than the USPS worker would have been doing anyway, although it is scheduled to happen at a time determined by the highest priority items (the groceries), and costs are dramatically lowered.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by robbiep on Monday July 18, 2022 @10:38AM (#32138917)
Using USPS is a terrible example for a otherwise good hypothetical VC M&A/Partnership roll up
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by hef19898 on Monday July 18, 2022 @10:57AM (#32139125)
Amazon did ramp down Prime Now and Fresh in a lot of German cities. I don't kniw, but if Amazon tried two different approaches for eCommerce fulfillmebt and wasn't utterly convinced with either one it is telling you something.

On an other note, depsite my start-up having failed Amazon is now rolling out a similar product: opening up FBA for third party marketplaces. They are not moving as fast as they used to, but still faster than anyone else. And they are moving a juggernaught. No idea how thatbstill works after all those years...

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by spaceman_2020 on Monday July 18, 2022 @11:20AM (#32139392)
Its going to be fun when people dissect this era of tech.

Like Uber - $33B in investor cash. $0 in operational profit.

The promise was always scale. Yet, now that it’s time to show profits, Uber has had to pull back from markets and reduce its scale.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by ghaff on Monday July 18, 2022 @11:35AM (#32139560)
The thing with Uber that I don't really get is this. Once it became obvious to pretty much everyone that it wasn't already obvious to that door-to-door autonomous driving wasn't going to happen in an economically interesting time horizon, why didn't Uber's board do something about it.

Sure, they cut back on those investments. But they didn't otherwise make the changes needed to get Uber to profitability given that nothing else was going to fundamentally change. Wasn't the logical thing to ramp prices up and let the chips fall where they would in terms of ridership and viability in various markets?

I get that Uber brought a better taxi service to quite a few markets. But as an Uber board member, I wouldn't really care.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by marcosdumay on Monday July 18, 2022 @12:42PM (#32140307)
My impression (from very far away, I don't have any kind of contact with them) is that Uber is based on a fundamentally bad informatics structure that has a very high operational costs. Those now can only be reduced by the same kinds of competent decision-making that would have lead to an structure with low operational costs at the first time.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by bobthepanda on Monday July 18, 2022 @11:52AM (#32139745)
Uber has quit a few markets like China and SE Asia that it was losing money hand over first in. And prices have been increasing.

My impression is that they sort of staked things on a pivot to UberEats, though that looks like a bust too.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by spaceman_2020 on Monday July 18, 2022 @01:03PM (#32140562)
Its an open secret in the Indian startup space that they’ve been looking to exit India as well.

Indian ridesharing is in a weird place where both parties in the duopoly are unwilling to dominate the market. Uber is trying to exit, Ola is focusing its efforts on a (failing) e-scooter startup.

Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by ricudis on Monday July 18, 2022 @02:26PM (#32141602)
Uber in SE Asia mostly lost their game to Grab and Gojek, the premier local competitors. They fare quite well, even now. Especially in Singapore, where ridershare services allow many car owners to recoup a part of the extremely high costs of owning a car there.
Re:The speedy downfall of rapid delivery startups by MomoXenosaga on Monday July 18, 2022 @01:12PM (#32140673)
Uber had a really good innovation with their app but other taxi companies started to roll out their own and at that point Uber had to compete on cost.