News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by sithadmin on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:30AM (#32069623)
Unsurprising. I've been told by a relative that worked in an Amazon warehouse that the camera systems overhead (not dissimilar to the type you see in Amazon Go / Amazon Fresh retail stores) are used to issue disciplinary warnings, and it's pretty easy to get issued a warning for completely normal exception-handling behavior.

For instance, the shelved/dry goods sections of Fresh warehouses are notorious for being a trainwreck, with items sort of strewn in the general area of where the inventory/pick list says they should be, rather than being neatly arranged. If an employee on picker duty stands around browsing a shelf too long to find the item they're supposed to grab (but can't find it, because it's been shuffled several feet down the shelf)...the cameras monitoring generates an automated warning that goes to your management. Mark the item as out of stock / missing from inventory instead? Get a warning when someone else finds it and scans it later that day, or when inventory is next reconciled. It's a no-win situation.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by Anderkent on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:15AM (#32071175)
Given that, are the warnings a serious issue? If management keeps getting those and knows the workers are not at fault in this particular warehouse, the only reason to act on the warnings is political. which yes, might well be an issue, but just the number of warnings issued is meaningless without knowing how they're acted upon.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by kitanata on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:31AM (#32071394)
Selective enforcement is one of the principal ways that workers experience discrimination in the workplace. Remember that Amazon doesn’t fire people for unionization, or because they are black or transgendered. They fire them for disciplinary reasons that are completely “normal” and “typical” as under-performers. This kind of system of “feedback” is a weapon and it is absolutely used to that affect in every place where it is implemented to the degree that Amazon does.

Can we please stop be apologists to giant profit-driven organizations and start maybe… just maybe… empathizing with people instead?

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by FooBarBizBazz on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @07:54AM (#32081419)
I love how, once you build a dystopian hellscape where robots punish people for breathing, the only critique our society is capable of leveling is, "yeah, but they might use the shock collars more on transgendered people!"
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by CodeWriter23 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:03PM (#32076920)
> Selective enforcement is one of the principal ways that workers experience discrimination in the workplace.

You point is moot in this case. Staten Island is in New York State, which is an at-will employment state. Employers in such states don't need a reason to fire anyone.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by Spivak on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:18PM (#32077513)
Nooooooope. This is so wrong it’s funny. Being an at will state does not in any way whatsoever grant you the ability to discriminate against people of protected classes. If someone complains to the labor board or files a lawsuit alleging they were fired because they were black or trans you better have some evidence that this wasn’t the case because they might have evidence that it was and civil suits are decided on who has the strongest case not “beyond reasonable doubt.”

Which is why Evil Inc. makes sure to classify everyone as an under-performer in some capacity so that can be used as the justification for furring and you can squash individual suits or complainants because no one wronged person has enough data to prove the pattern. Then waaaaaay down the line someone will do an analysis and figure it out but it will be an administrative complaint leading to some hand wringing, a change to some policy documents, and some new diversity metrics — much cheaper.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by bobkazamakis on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:04PM (#32078229)
>You point is moot in this case. Staten Island is in New York State, which is an at-will employment state. Employers in such states don't need a reason to fire anyone.

I've never read what at-will is and I've never missed it either!

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by Anderkent on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:20PM (#32072171)
I empathize with people working the tough jobs! That doesn't necessarily mean I think the jobs must be made less tough, even if I'd prefer they had better options to choose from.

A claim that the produced warnings are selectively used to fire black or unionizing workers would be much more interesting, but I don't see enough evidence to make it yet. It also doesn't really connect to the big headline of 13000 notices at one facility - if that was the purpose of the system, you'd hardly need so many.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by hourago on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:48PM (#32073441)
> That doesn't necessarily mean I think the jobs must be made less tough

Humans get injuries, psychological damage, and that translates to families and society.

To make jobs insufferable just because Amazon can is horrifying. And society will pay for it even if Amazon is the only one profiting.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by spoils19 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @05:22PM (#32075849)
Conservative towns have had tough jobs for decades and we're better aligned and more stable than many liberal towns who desire for easier jobs.

Sometimes it's better for people to suck it up and tough it out.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by feet on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @05:35PM (#32075987)
What the hell does it have to do with politics

Your statement is the definition of cucked by capitalism

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by JaimeThompson on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:28PM (#32077140)
Does everyone have equal rights to marry in a conservative town?
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by decremental on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:41PM (#32078800)
What a stupid question.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by feet on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @04:30AM (#32080244)
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by JaimeThompson on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @07:21PM (#32089962)
For many years the GOP platform has called for the end of gay marriage so asking that is valid.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by decremental on Friday July 15, 2022 @11:06AM (#32108931)
Obama campaigned in 2008 saying he was against gay marriage. The question is still stupid because a town can't declare that gay marriage is illegal.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by p_j_w on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @04:23PM (#32075164)
>A claim that the produced warnings are selectively used to fire black or unionizing workers would be much more interesting, but I don't see enough evidence to make it yet

That's because they've designed the system from the ground up to make collecting such evidence nearly impossible. Unless they're going to open up their books to you, how would you see such evidence?

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by treis on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:24PM (#32072222)
>Selective enforcement is one of the principal ways that workers experience discrimination in the workplace.

Amazon is creating an extremely detailed paper trail of their enforcement actions. It'd be trivial to show that, as an example, on average black workers got fired for 3 errors while white ones were fired for 5.

The warnings seem mostly fair too. Counting 19 items when there we 20 in a bin during inventory as an example. I can see why some look at this as dystopian but this sort of objective measurement is pretty darn appealing. If we had a programming equivalent I think it'd make my life better by weeding out the bullshitters and those that fake productivity by creating complicated solutions.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by skrtskrt on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:38PM (#32072442)
Yeah what could go wrong when technocrats try to completely remove subjectivity from the world and optimize everyone's life and work towards some completely arbitrary measure so that my shitty things can get delivered 0.002 seconds faster.

I'm not sure if you've ever had a job where you worked to specific metrics exclusively, but it make's everyone's life worse and it makes the product/service worse.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by treis on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:08PM (#32072891)
Because there's no objective metric for programmer productivity.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by Nasrudith on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:02PM (#32073594)
You prefer getting vaguer metrics to work towards? Sucky and misaimed metrics exist with the qualatative too. Blaming quantitative efforts is misplaced. Subjectivity is not your friend.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by Anderkent on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:50PM (#32072614)
pretty sure we've all been in school, and while it's not a great experience, you can work with it

i'm pretty sure amazon's optimizing the work more so that my shitty thing gets delivered at all, rather than 0.002 seconds faster. which is very valueable to me, as it happens

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by skrtskrt on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:37PM (#32073302)
As it happens your stuff still gets delivered when workers are unionized and treated like human beings
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by djbebs on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @04:51PM (#32075522)
If that's the case why are Amazon's competitors not as successful as Amazon?
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by yurishimo on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @06:29PM (#32076548)
Amazons competitors in America*

In Europe, Amazon has plenty of competitors found in regional companies (CoolBlue in NL/BE) and they seem to deliver within a day or two just fine.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by djbebs on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:09AM (#32096988)
I live in europe, I tried smaller competitors. I refuse to buy from them as a result of the experience.

I never had trouble with Amazon

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by specialist on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:23PM (#32078345)
Initially, Amazon benefitted from lower cost of capital. Because of tax holiday and persuading Wall St to prefer (long term) growth over (short term) profitability.

Now, AWS prints money, fueling Amazon's entry into new markets.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:16PM (#32072090)
Amazon as an organization doesn't care who you are or what demographic groups you belong to so long as the ROI of your continued employment is in the same ballpark as everyone else with your job title.

You remove the metrics and then anyone who has the authority to fire people for poor performance gains the ability to fire people for personal bias reasons while saying it's for performance reasons.

The whole point of the metrics is that it makes it harder to make decisions that are bad for the company (like firing otherwise productive people because you don't like them) under the guise of them being good for the company. Because of the metrics people with the authority to do influence hiring and firing at scale can't fire protected demographics without leaving an incriminating paper trail and getting told by legal to knock it off. Nor those people put their thumb on the scale fire non-protected demographics before some MBA sees what's going on and tells them to knock it off because they're leaving money on the table.

Literally none of the bad stuff you have described is made better by removing performance tracking and much of it is made worse. Go read about what working for BigCo was like for members of race/religious/political groups in the first half of the 20th century if you don't believe me.

Maybe think through your comment before you call everyone corporate apologists.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by galdosdi on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:45PM (#32073394)
You probably don't realize this, but (in the USA) it's very illegal (although unevenly enforced) to actively prevent your employees from unionizing. This is because there is a huge incentive to prevent it, because as an employer you can keep wages lower that way. Because of this, to use your own clinical language "the ROI of your continued employment" is very negative if you might help start a union. But it isn't actually legal to act on this information.

So yeah, Amazon is absolutely trying to play the same game many big companies do, which is hamper union formation as much as possible without actually getting in too much trouble. Having all employees officially have bad performance warnings (which can then be acted upon if you see them unionizing) is one great tool in the toolbox of the union suppressor.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by ckdarby on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @08:32AM (#32081737)
Having done consulting work for a company that does performance management software the thing I found funny was pro-union workers the model kept flagging as lower productivity compared to neutral or for non-union.

When I tried to look into it the model was scoring them lower because of "activities spent not increasing bottom line".

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by badRNG on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:04PM (#32073622)
Even if Amazon gets in trouble for union busting, it may be the case that the consequences of getting caught are outweighed by the costs associated with rising wages/benefits/conditions for labor under a union.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by feet on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @05:34PM (#32075977)
Okay? They're still doing a bad, actively harmful and illegal thing to their employees

Who gives a shit about their profit when their workers are being suppressed

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:30PM (#32077610)
>You probably don't realize this, but (in the USA) it's very illegal to actively prevent your employees from unionizing.

You need to do some thinking about what the phrase "ROI of your continued employment" actually means in practice.

Fines and fees are basically the same thing when they're being levied against huge sociopaths entities like BigCo. Naive "but that's illegal" appeals to emotion do not matter to these sorts of entities because responsibility is so diffuse and compartmentalized that they can't do anything but ruthlessly pursue the sum total of everyone's KPIs.

>Having all employees officially have bad performance warnings is one great tool in the toolbox...

And how is this any different than if you didn't have the metrics in the first place? If everyone has bad performance nobody does. My point isn't that Amazon isn't doing shady shit. Of course they are. All big organizations are. My point is that metric tracking is at worst a net neutral with potential to be positive. My secondary point is that both the person I initially replied to and yourself have failed to think critically about the situation. A metric that says everyone is under-performing isn't a pretext to dodge accusations of an illegal or otherwise not good pattern of firing anymore than not having the metric at all is.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by galdosdi on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:08PM (#32100229)
I think you are committing the common engineer's fallacy of examining a situation with Vulcan like logic, reaching a conclusion, and then applying it to a social process.

> A metric that says everyone is under-performing isn't a pretext to dodge accusations of an illegal or otherwise not good pattern of firing anymore than not having the metric at all is.

Just because you (and indeed I) think that way doesn't mean the actual social and institutional actors involved will. In any given hearing for a given matter impacting a single employee the data about all the other employees won't even be available to reach the conclusion you discussed. It would take a much bigger more well funded legal action to push the argument you are making. In fact, how do you even know that US law even allows the argument you are making? It very well may or may not.

It's not a perfect tool, but as I said, it's another tool in the toolbox to muddy the waters and make it more expensive and complex to challenge a dismissal.

I think the way you mentally model socioeconomic and legal processes in the human world is not very true to life. Pure logic is not any sort of big magical trump card. Humans are not rational actors.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by lalopalota on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:20PM (#32073818)
That is the whole point of the parent comment: if everyone gets a plethora of warnings for normal occurrences (poorly implemented performamce metrics), then anyone can be fired for non-discriminatory reasons (backed by data!!) when the real reason for firing is something else (unionizing, protected class, workplace politics, etc.). Selective enforcment allows for non-provable discrimination.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:39PM (#32077667)
If everyone is under-performing nobody is. Having a metric that basically everyone fails to meet is no more useful for dodging accusations of illegally discriminatory firing than not having the metric at all is.

Seems like everyone in this comment sub-thread is assuming that the legal professionals who go after this kind of thing are idiots and wouldn't see right through that.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by buck4roo on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @06:44PM (#32076727)
1000 times, this.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by incogitomode on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:19PM (#32073803)
Is your corporate apology coming from personal experience in Amazon or another "BigCo" where you can cite actual instances where a massive corpus of petty infractions has protected line workers from the malicious "people with the authority"?

Otherwise the parent commenter's conjecture as to how this surveillance system functions in reality is about as good and useful and thoughtful as your own. Maybe worth keeping in mind.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by sithadmin on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:17PM (#32072105)
From what I've been told, yes, they're serious. Accumulate enough warnings of a certain type, and you're automatically removed from the scheduled and queued for termination, from what I've been told. Local management isn't empowered to do anything about it, and as a warehouse employee you're basically relegated to making an appeal to an automated system.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by Anderkent on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:22PM (#32072203)
yeah, mid management being incompetent and not noticing that the metrics are fucked up for a location i can totally believe. hopefully after some time with outlier retention issues the facility would get some attention from someone competent? ;/
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by frou_dh on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:33PM (#32072378)
Maybe I'm imagining it, but I vaguely recall reading something about Amazon workers being fired in a fully automated fashion. So there is not necessarily always a human manager reviewing all the automated warnings and pondering their validity.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by toofy on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:02PM (#32073592)
we just had the news yesterday of the fairly large youtube channel that was automatically permanently closed due to false dmca claims.

it would be fascinating to see if anyone were thoroughly outraged by the automated failures in youtube’s dmca channel closure system yet defend amazon automating the firing of workers.

i’m guessing we’d find more than a few people defending one while being outraged by the other.

at the end of the day we need to consider that maybe we need to put more resources towards human intervention in certain areas where automation seems to be causing harm needlessly to quite a few people where the path to rectify the situation seems anything but clear.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by _fat_santa on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:34PM (#32072387)
Amazon seems to be hiring the wrong people for the job. They are hiring humans when they really are looking to hire robots.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by WillAdams on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @02:36PM (#32074014)
I dunno.

I worked part-time in an Amazon warehouse for over a year, then full-time for a couple of weeks in-between jobs.

Once, when rolling up to a bin full of non-descript boxes, I was able to choose one, flip it in hand for the six-sided box check, and scan it to determine I had the correct box, w/o having to consider any of the other boxes.

A trainer and a group of trainees nearby asked how I had done this --- it took a couple of minutes to break down the description from the scanner and compare it to all of the boxes and explain how the box I had selected was the only possibility based simply on a visual examination.

Given how many singles Amazon ships, I'm really surprised that they haven't gone to a standard of just packaging on receipt of product, then shipping the boxes by pulling them and slapping a shipping label on --- it would be far more automatable.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by CodeWriter23 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @06:34PM (#32076612)
> Given how many singles Amazon ships, I'm really surprised that they haven't gone to a standard of just packaging on receipt of product, then shipping the boxes by pulling them and slapping a shipping label on --- it would be far more automatable.

Because physical volume matters and directly correlates to all transportation expenses.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by Scalestein on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:52PM (#32072667)
You might say they are using humans as an MVP/POC test for what their robots should be like. Make the humans as robotic as possible to see what features are really needed in the robots they eventually use.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by panarky on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @01:05PM (#32072849)
You don't need fancy machine vision when you can just count events in a database.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by iLoveOncall on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:48AM (#32069886)
> For instance, the shelved/dry goods sections of Fresh warehouses are notorious for being a trainwreck, with items sort of strewn in the general area of where the inventory/pick list says they should be, rather than being neatly arranged. If an employee on picker duty stands around browsing a shelf too long to find the item they're supposed to grab (but can't find it, because it's been shuffled several feet down the shelf)...the cameras monitoring generates an automated warning that goes to your management. Mark the item as out of stock / missing from inventory instead? Get a warning when someone else finds it and scans it later that day, or when inventory is next reconciled. It's a no-win situation.

I would like to see any evidence you have to support any of those issues, because having visited an Amazon fulfilment center myself, I can guarantee you that the problems with picking items you mention literally cannot happen.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by gnatman on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:01AM (#32070079)
It's pretty easy to imagine both of these things being true, and the one fulfillment center you visited having substantially less than 13k disciplinary notices. I worked 7 years in industrial staffing for a variety of large distribution centers (not Amazon), and the automated discipline systems in place around voice-pick efficiency were borderline draconian.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by FreqSep on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:08AM (#32070189)
The real question is, are there any examples of companies achieving what Amazon is achieving at its scale, *without* employing these techniques? And if so what are they doing differently?
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by NineStarPoint on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:12AM (#32070239)
I think the closest you’ll get is Costco, but obviously their distribution model isn’t super comparable. (They do have some similarities though, especially in how they make a lot of their profit from a yearly subscription)
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by politician on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:15AM (#32070290)
That’s not the the real question. The real question is “what is the maximum amount of productivity that our culture will accept beyond which it considers the burden inhumane?”

For example, in antiquity, slavery was acceptable.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by mc32 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:27AM (#32070467)
Even more recently, Taylorism. I mean, yeah, it's good for robots but not for people.

When people design systems they should consider the humanity of such systems despite the issue of people knowingly and maliciously short-circuiting things.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by phantomathkg on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:07PM (#32071954)
What do you want to achieve? Inhumane world for the sake of tiny productivity gain?
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by giraffe_lady on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:47AM (#32070789)
Even if the answer is a clear "no" that doesn't make this case acceptable.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by iLoveOncall on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:47AM (#32070788)
I never said that the punishments are not possible, just that the processes in place and just the basic way Amazon FCs work prevents the picking issues from happening.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by sithadmin on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:20PM (#32072169)
There are TONS of videos and photos leaked by workers that demonstrate how much of a disaster some of the Fresh warehouses are, e.g. a particularly egregious example where there are dozens if not hundreds of products fallen from bins, smashed to bits in the aisle by picker foot traffic: https://www.reddit.com/r/AmazonUFF/comments/skmtto/so_disgus...
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by macNchz on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:14AM (#32071168)
I've never worked for Amazon but have worked in a couple of warehouses, I'm trying to envision any system that involves a lot of humans working as quickly as possible while still making it impossible to have out of place items...I'd love some more detail on how this works.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by dylan604 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:14AM (#32071166)
>I can guarantee you that the problems with picking items you mention literally cannot happen.

That's a very bold statement. Guarantee that something can't go wrong? Where do I put my money on this bet?

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by darksaints on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:10AM (#32071107)
I can assure you, as someone who has both visited multiple fulfillment centers as well has worked on the inventory systems that manage them, that this literally happens thousands of times per day.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by IE6 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:38AM (#32070638)
Both of your experiences are purely anecdotal but I would explain away the difference in your opinions as the difference being "someone I know who worked there" versus "I visited (a potentially curated) fulfillment center once".
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by iLoveOncall on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @10:50AM (#32070822)
To be more clear I visited an Amazon FC during the first week when I joined Amazon in one of their operations teams, in which I have then spent 4 years.

There are processes in place and physical things that are completely different from what the original commenter says and those things prevent the issues (having items on another shelf multiple feet below where they should be) from being possible.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by camtarn on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:02AM (#32071002)
Another ex Amazon guy here. I visited the Dunfermline FC, did picker training, and shadowed a picker for an hour. I also followed company email lists and FB groups for years. It became extremely obvious to me that what I saw in my curated experience was nothing like what I was hearing from the other FCs.

So, even though from my experience I can't see how items could be 'shuffled' out of their bin by mistake (other than falling on the floor and being chucked in an amnesty bin or onto a random shelf, but that seems like a rare case) I also wouldn't find it super surprising to find an FC which just uses a completely different way of organising stuff.

That said, I wasn't in ops. Perhaps you had a much better birds eye view of every single FC organisation scheme? More details would be greatly appreciated.

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by deepspace on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:33AM (#32071428)
A close family member worked in an FC for 3 years. They agree that what the original commenter said happens ALL the time. Maybe you were only shown a shiny new FC, but the older ones are often much less organized. Depends a lot on local management too.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by bastardoperator on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:06AM (#32071051)
The radio plays what they want you to hear...
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by beastcoast on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:01AM (#32070977)
Fresh warehouses are verrrry different than the robotic one you probably visited. I’m not surprised at all that a fresh building would have those problems.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by kristjansson on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:17AM (#32071209)
I’ve never been in one, but I’m imagining a Whole Foods without a front door or windows?
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by CodeWriter23 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:06PM (#32076947)
Some are hybrid plants. FBA in one section, Fresh in another. They recently opened a center in Huntington Beach that does both.
Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by pseudalopex on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @09:53AM (#32069947)
> the problems with picking items you mention literally cannot happen.

How?

Re:Amazon issued 13,000 disciplinary notices at single U.S. ... by MisterBastahrd on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @11:02AM (#32071005)
You're saying that you guarantee it?

Congratulations. The burden of proof is now on you. Please prove your claim.