News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by ikt on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:25AM (#32042098)
Why would he be associated with bogus science?
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by iratewizard on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:44AM (#32042167)
Purely a guess, but a lot of people whose pride stems from understanding complex subjects are the same people who will gatekeep that subject. Sagan, making astronomy more accessible to lay people, would be a grave offense to someone like that.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by adastra22 on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:48AM (#32042676)
This is true (source: worked at NASA and heard other astronomers opinion of Sagan). The other chief aspects were (1) some had professional disagreements with Sagan and resented that he still won academic battles for mindshare just by being Sagan, and (2) resentment of his success by academics who were just as good but didn’t get fame and the grant wins or lucrative work that came from it.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by ShamelessC on Sunday July 10, 2022 @08:08AM (#32043951)
This sort of stuff makes me happy I worked on open source research rather than try to get a PHD. Same thing is playing out with LeCun. The excessive, perhaps egotistical need for attribution in academia is in strict opposition to what I consider “good science”.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by gwf on Sunday July 10, 2022 @11:08AM (#32045446)
I don't think this comparison is fair to LeCun. He has literally been at the forefront of ML for over 40 years, starting with his PhD thesis and continuing to the present, and his public fame is entirely a byproduct of the awareness of the impact of his work. (Disclaimer: I've known Yann for decades and worked down the hall from him during his NEC years.)
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by ShamelessC on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @04:33AM (#32067052)
To be clear, I’m not accusing LeCun of trying to “hoard credit”, rather I’m accusing others of having petty squabbles (often surrounding his published works) around who was “first” and thus “actually” deserves credit. To them, I say “Get over yourself” - progress doesn’t tend to be made when we’re busy trying to win imaginary races for “mindshare”. And LeCun has done more than enough to prove himself in the field (with all the hard work that entails) to have to deal with that sort of thing.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by gwf on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @01:16AM (#32079239)
Well said. (cough, cough, Schmidhuber, cough.)
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by ad404b8a372f2b9 on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:49PM (#32046353)
Neither of the things described in the parent comment have to do with ego, they have everything to do with career opportunities and outcomes.

The ability to have your research funded is a practical and existential problem for scientists. And I find it quite natural having issues with someone being able to achieve better outcomes through marketing and fame rather than through the quality of their work.

It's something I find aggravating with Google, OpenAI, and cie in the field of machine learning for example. The amount of marketing they benefit from, before their papers are even published, is unfair and anti-meritocratic. I don't want to have to do SEO to be able to stand on even ground with these people.

(And that's not to say Sagan wasn't a good scientist, or that his work communicating science wasn't useful.)

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by sokoloff on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:14AM (#32043648)
Ref #2, I wonder if scientists feel similarly to Neil deGrasse Tyson today.

He doesn’t seem likely to be wildly better as a scientist than his peers, but being wildly better as a communicator has incredible differentiating value (and likely has a tailwind for the other scientists in terms of public support for science when it’s something they feel is almost within their grasp).

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by andrepd on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:59AM (#32043889)
I find Neil deGrasse Tyson to be a terrible science communicator, especially since a few years back. Just look at the man's twitter. Putting him and Carl Sagan in the same sentence is almost insulting x)
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by ConstantVigil on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:24AM (#32045048)
Not to mention that I am fairly certain I've caught him being horribly wrong more than once. But for the life of me, I cannot seem to remember which times it was. I'm sure I'll come across those videos again sometime though, and when I do; I'll be sure to edit this comment. Knowing my luck, it will be in the next few days time.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by vladTheInhaler on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:38PM (#32047525)
Tyson once said on twitter “An airplane whose engine fails is a glider. A helicopter whose engine fails is a brick.” Now it's not at all obvious why that's not true. But that's why it's important to be humble about what you do and don't know.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by mrexroad on Sunday July 10, 2022 @04:10PM (#32048488)
In case anyone else is interested in the not-at-all-obvious-answer [1], I’ll save you the google: autorotation

> Autorotation is the ability of a helicopter to in some situations have its rotors powered by the flow of air rather than the engine. In short, as the helicopter descends, the upward directed flow of air pushes through the rotors, makes them rotate faster, which in turn provides lift.

[1] https://www.highskyflying.com/can-helicopters-glide/

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by mixmastamyk on Sunday July 10, 2022 @05:19PM (#32049163)
Still, isn’t it more likely for the occupants to survive when a plane lands without power, assuming a decent landing spot?
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by fsckboy on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:31PM (#32050337)
a helicopter can "glide down" just like an airplane. if your engine fails, with the aid of the rotor as you descend you can turn the potential energy of being up in the air into forward motion, and that forward motion will generate lift over your rotor blades. You practice these techniques as part of getting a license.

see the "dead man's curve" which relates to having an engine failure with insufficient height or lateral speed (helicopters shouldn't hover in place unless a good ways up) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_height%E2%80%93velo...

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by mixmastamyk on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:00PM (#32061757)
Agreed, however forward motion works for a plane landing with wheels. A helicopter with "skis" sounds less effective.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by adastra22 on Monday July 11, 2022 @03:00AM (#32053116)
I don't want to speak for all scientists, but I find Neil deGrasse Tyson utterly insufferable and cringe almost every time he makes a public statement. Like him or loath him, Carl Sagan was a scientist that wasn't afraid to apply scientific thinking to social and political issues. His positions were particularly reasoned and defensible with data and logical arguments.

Neil deGrasse Tyson, on the other hand, is an edgelord with a PhD. He takes contrarian positions for the sake of generating controversy, often without understanding the underlying issues or forming a cohesive, reasoned argument. He appeals to emotion rather than logic, and is politically partisan and divisive rather than unifying.

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by whywhywhywhy on Sunday July 10, 2022 @11:03AM (#32045395)
>I wonder if scientists feel similarly to Neil deGrasse Tyson today.

Find it hard to imagine anyone taking him seriously after seeing his Twitter account.

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by NikolaNovak on Sunday July 10, 2022 @11:40AM (#32045718)
I suppose I'll need to check it out, I am not on Twitter so don't frequent it.

At the same time... If twitter existed back then, how would the famed scientists and communicators come out? Einstein, Feynman, Asimov, Clarke have all had pretty damming (defined at minimum as "unacceptable by modern cultural standards") behaviour come to light. Respected scientists and philosophers of 70s who are still alive have similarly gotten themselves into serious hot water on social media more recently.

Never meet your heroes and all that...

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by adastra22 on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:06AM (#32052758)
NGT posts some pretty cringe science takes too, though. The kind of stuff you would expect someone in his position to put even the slightest bit of research before speaking.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by KerrAvon on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:52AM (#32045296)
Keep in mind that some of the youngest generation of scientists have been influenced by his Cosmos revival. Source: have one such in my household.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by adastra22 on Monday July 11, 2022 @02:08AM (#32052763)
I will never criticize something which sparks an interest in science in someone else.

But show them the original Sagan version. The CGI may be dated, but the material is far more thought provoking.

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by emsign on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:49AM (#32042429)
The Apple engineers' unwillingness to back down but even pushing things further with their insulting second code name shows a degree of arrogance that's astonishing.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by xbar on Sunday July 10, 2022 @09:46AM (#32044726)
My memory is that the average 90's Silicon Valley engineer was arrogant. It was not at all astonishing.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by JKCalhoun on Sunday July 10, 2022 @11:48AM (#32045782)
Arrogant is a strong word and I think carries too fine a point.

The industry was interesting (bizarre) at the time in that the engineers were more or less left to run their domain. Upper management might give the overall direction of what to work on but beyond that there was not a lot of middle or lower management that could tell engineers how to do that.

This left a lot of the responsibility (and authority if you will) in the hands of engineering to accomplish what the company wanted. And so engineers chose code names. To be sure too they were not meant for (sanitized by) the PR department — they were strictly at the whim of engineering.

Engineers don't want to have to put on a "marketing hat", or get marketing to sign off on a codename (for chrissakes).

That one of those code names leaked somehow and caused bad publicity for the company — that was management's/marketing's problem, not the engineer's.

We're in a more modern era now where the balance has shifted to a much more top-down model — diminishing the broader role engineers used to have.

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by Redoubts on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:36AM (#32045152)
I don’t think people outside the company should get a say over internal code names at all

To think otherwise is a much stronger arrogance

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by dahfizz on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:49AM (#32045261)
Is there a word for this kind of logical fallacy?

GP asserts that what the engineers did is wrong. They didn't say that the public should get to decide what codenames to use or anything like that. They simply pointed out the arrogance of the engineers, and they are right.

It's like a straw man, but specific to issues of morality.

"X is wrong".

"Oh, so you want to jail every offender of X? You want to completely regulate Y in case it leads to X?"

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by Redoubts on Friday July 15, 2022 @11:57AM (#32109439)
> Is there a word for this kind of logical fallacy?

You just don't know what a fallacy is.

> Oh, so you want to jail every offender of X?

This is not what I'm saying. I'm disagreeing, and putting forward a stronger, opposite claim.

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by somat on Sunday July 10, 2022 @03:35AM (#32042621)
Not sure about this case, but in general I find it to be the opposite, people love to teach others about the subjects they care about and have taken the time to learn in depth.

I am the same way, I tend to self censer because who wants to hear about the subtle intricacies of the bgp system. until they start to show interest, then you can't shut me up.

Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by JohnJamesRambo on Sunday July 10, 2022 @01:57AM (#32042225)
Imagine thinking you are superior to Carl Sagan because you made a beige box.
Re:When Carl Sagan sued Apple twice (2014) by temac on Sunday July 10, 2022 @08:08AM (#32043945)
Ironical from people working at Apple in the 90s.