News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by donquichotte on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:40AM (#31929314)
Am I being cynic here or is this just another attempt at total surveillance? It solves a problem that does not exist, will likely be mandatory at some point and is executed by a defense company.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by scrollaway on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:54AM (#31929404)
Just because you don't see the problem it is solving doesn't mean the problem does not exist.

Some context: I'm French, I live in Belgium. I have two e-IDs cards: one french, one belgian. When I need to identify myself, depending on the government I have to deal with, I have to use either my "FranceConnect" credentials, or my Belgian e-ID card.

When using my Belgian eID, there is a government login called CSAM, but a lot of people here use a private company called "itsme" (https://www.itsme-id.com/). ItsMe does not support Linux. CSAM does, but not every service that supports or even requires eID login here supports CSAM.

FranceConnect is even more of a mess. French government has a plethora of online services, several with their own logins and not all support FranceConnect.

Making a digital wallet won't increase surveillance... surveillance is already possible on all of this, quite easily so. What it will do is greatly simplify life for people dealing with these systems; especially for expats and new arrivals into a country, who might get stuck in the loop of "You need a bank account to get your ID" "You need an ID to open a bank account"

Not to mention all the services that do their own shitty KYC and would be better served by using automated ID checking instead. Unless you think it's better and "more private" to email a photocopy of your ID and passport to somebody who will forward it three times, save it on their computer, and share it on Slack with the tech team because there's a problem with their shitty KYC system.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by _Algernon_ on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:41PM (#31938330)
>Making a digital wallet won't increase surveillance...

There is no reason to believe that. You are installing a government app on a gps device with a constant internet connection. Even if it doesn't send such data initially, there is no way for a regular user to know that some forced update in the future wont introduce it. At least before they would have to go through the courts to get a warrant to get it from google or apple.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by herewulf on Thursday June 30, 2022 @09:43PM (#31941155)
Disable the app's location permission?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by petre on Friday July 01, 2022 @12:02AM (#31942198)
Most of them don't even work without location. The location permission is also tied to the wifi because Google had the means to pinpoint your accurate location using wifi hotspots.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by vegai_ on Friday July 01, 2022 @07:41AM (#31945004)
Perhaps don't use Google products if privacy is at all important to you.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by judge2020 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:01AM (#31933253)
> a government login called CSAM, but a lot of people here use a private company called "itsme"

It probably doesn't help that the CSAM term has an overlap with another english abbreviation.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by scrollaway on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:27PM (#31934884)
Belgium is not an English speaking country.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:59AM (#31929447)
> Making a digital wallet won't increase surveillance... surveillance is already possible on all of this,

Sure, because a little minority of people has "the burden" of managing multiple IDs, lets tear down one firewall between citizenry and big-brother for the rest of us.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:05AM (#31929497)
What's the "firewall" in this case? eIDs already exist all over the place, as demonstrated in parent. They also clearly have their use, even though they are currently frequently broken.

Is the brokenness the firewall?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:10AM (#31929530)
The firewall is who is accountable, who is responsible to the electorate. "Broken" no, a feature yes, because exploiting technical flaws in a country's digital ID for an attacker becomes more troublesome if each country has a (an even slightly) different implementation.

Labeling it "broken" - we all are using the same password for every account anyways, aren't we?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:15AM (#31929557)
But we're talking about the EU here, the second largest democracy in the world. Of course they're accountable to the electorate. This isn't a dictatorship.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by jules on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:10PM (#31934606)
From my vote to this decision there are so many layers of abstraction that I wouldn't even begin to have a clue who to vote for and in which election if I do or do not want this E-ID.

At least in national elections there are parties campaigning with a platform and then I can decide which platform I like best. How often the platforms of the elected parties get translated into reality is another question, but it can at least plausibly be described as demos kratos. Maybe the EU is "democracy" in some modern sense of the word, but in the original sense of the word it is not. (I'm not even saying that's a bad thing. Maybe it is in fact better to have elites deciding.)

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by toyg on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:37PM (#31935830)
> At least in national elections there are parties campaigning with a platform and then I can decide which platform I like best.

I fail to see how you cannot do that in European Parliament elections. If anything, EUP elections are more democratic than average, by way of using a proportional-representation system that matches voters' preferences more closely than almost any European voting system.

And if you're saying, "but it's the Commission proposing laws!", they don't pull stuff out of thin air: the Commission effectively tries to implement an agenda that European Council members agree together. And who is EuroCouncil? National governments, whom you vote for. Also, the Commission doesn't work alone - directives are effectively drafted in concert with Parliament committees, because in the end they have to be approved by such Parliament.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by petre on Friday July 01, 2022 @12:09AM (#31942250)
It's usually the pirate party or the greens. They have no representatives in my country, so good luck with that.

Greece is a democracy, the EU is a bureaucracy.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:27AM (#31929641)
Totally democratic. Of course. Europeans love it.

From Berlin xHainers to Parissienne Bobos, from Munich Schwabing to Noord Amsterdam, there isn't a single citizen in the EU with discomfort of his vote becoming dilluted from a x-millionth to an x-hundredmillionth.

That's why Ursula von der Leyen is so popular.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @06:53AM (#31930831)
But thats just... yknow, how democracies work. More voters = less power/vote.

Are you just unhappy the electorate is so large? What would the appropriate size be? Mayoral? Households? That'd really maximize the power of your vote.

But then, how would we organize at the level beyond that? Warring tribes? Go back to when Germany and France were constantly at war?

I don't love vdL either. I think the EU is in need of reform. But I still think it's fundamentally a good idea and I think vote dilution is just inherent to a large democracy.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by potatototoo99 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:26AM (#31933778)
There's not much democracy in the EU, and that's by design.

I'm only surprised they haven't got rid of the ability of countries to secede the union yet. I'm guessing all these pushes for further integration are an attempt at de facto making it impossible to secede, even if not legally.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by timeon on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:57PM (#31935332)
> and that's by design.

And that design is there to keep sovereignty of membership countries - so it is strange that you are surprised that there is still the ability of countries to secede the union. Most powerful entities in EU are national governments of countries. Who is appointing Commissioners? Member states. Similar like national governments are appointing its ministers. Then there is veto and of course, who has last word in everything? Heads of states / prime ministers.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by rjzzleep on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:25PM (#31935659)
Ah yeah, just like how Von der Leyen, Macron said that they want to abolish the consensual vote, when Hungary didn't play along with sanctions being a landlocked country. Totally democratic and totally designed to keep sovereignty.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by toyg on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:43PM (#31935907)
Macron can say what he wants, he has not written any treaty yet. The Hungarian government is still free to act as they see fit.

This said, majority-rule can only increase in European mechanisms, because a continent cannot be paralized by the needs of a tiny minority on every possible choice. Does the US Senate (effectively the equivalent of EuroCouncil, with almost-equal representation for each US state) require unanimity on every choice? Obviously not, or it would never get anything done (and even like that, it struggles massively to approve anything these days).

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:51AM (#31934261)
> There's not much democracy in the EU, and that's by design.

[citation needed]. Please don't just throw out wild claims without any proof. As far as I'm aware, every single element of the EU is democratically legitimized in one way or another. Do you have any evidence to the contrary?

> I'm only surprised they haven't got rid of the ability of countries to secede the union yet.

Why would they? If you don't want to be on our boat, feel free to sink on your own. We don't need the dead weight.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by jokethrowaway on Friday July 01, 2022 @07:38AM (#31944978)
The appropriate solution would be to reduce the power of the institutions, ideally down to the individual level and allow corporations to provide the services citizens need.

Vote with your money, don't dictate the rest of the country with your wants.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Friday July 01, 2022 @10:30AM (#31946890)
The thing about voting with your money is that rich people get a lot of votes that way while the poor get neglected.

In other words, it's antidemocratic.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by illiac786 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:28PM (#31936517)
Diluted? EU has significantly more power than any single country. More than the sum of the power of each country taken individually. Hence, mathematically, your vote has more power in the EU.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by jokethrowaway on Friday July 01, 2022 @07:37AM (#31944964)
When your vote has a very large denominator it's worthless. You have no chance to influence anything.

Democracy is a scam, it's just an oligarchy.

The wealthiest will do media campaigns to manipulate the public into electing their people and then these people will do whatever the elite want.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by illiac786 on Friday July 01, 2022 @07:43AM (#31945026)
Large power of EU = very large nominator, more than compensating for the larger denominator.

That was my point above.

"Democracy is a scam" = trolling, please refer to the guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

"The wealthiest will do media campaigns to manipulate the public" => that I agree with, but this is really old and has always been like that, not only in democracies. I'd even say that democracies are the places where this is happening the least, compares to state-owned news like Russia or China.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mantas on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:03AM (#31929850)
Too many abstraction layers and too much happening behind closed doors withotu elected politicians present. As a citizen of EU member, I find it very hard to define EU as a democracy.

We need Swiss-style referendums-on-everything. Now it feels like oligarchy managed by lobby groups no matter what you vote for.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by scrollaway on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:06AM (#31929879)
> We need Swiss-style referendums-on-everything.

Ah, yes, nothing like asking 450M people for their opinion on something they know nothing about.

This is how Brexit happened, isn't it?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mantas on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:22AM (#31931040)
Do we want democracy? Or ruling by oligarchs, hoping that oligarch you like will end up ruling?

Obviously democracy needs educated citizens who don't take the responsibility lightly. That's why citizenship shall be a big privilege with even bigger responsibilities. We have to have a lively discussion. Otherwise it's people who cry loudest win.

I love Brexit as a democratical move. People voteds and government followed through. Now citizens will live out consequences, for better or worse. And they can make next decision accordingly. That's so much better than enlightened oligarchy guarding the masses from their own wrong feelings.

That's like raising kids. If you guard kids from their own painful decisions, they'll never learn. Eventually they'll be adults and they'll keep doing dumb decisions. You have to let them experience some pain to teach them a lesson.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by argentier on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:44AM (#31934137)
The EU is not a democracy. Its only democratic organ is toothless.

It is an association of democracies, led by an undemocratic executive that is increasingly out of control. At the moment it is busily destroying its own economy in a way that is baffling to many of its citizens.

If it doesn't evolve into something more democratic it probably hasn't long to go.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:52AM (#31934293)
The executive is appointed by democratically elected officials. Y'know, the same way the US president is elected by electors, or Prime Ministers are elected by parlaments. Most democracies work this way.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by argentier on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:08PM (#31934570)
In fact it's quite different.

The US president campaigns before a democratic election. The people know who they can choose before they vote. Same with the UK.

There is no democratic vote, with or without proxy, before the appointment of the Commission.

Why the downvote btw? This isn't reddit.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by M2Ys4U on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:01PM (#31935383)
>There is no democratic vote, with or without proxy, before the appointment of the Commission.

Err, yes there is. The directly-elected European Parliament first elects the President of the European Commission, and then has to vote to appoint the entire Commission.[0]

And before they do they they hold hearings with each of the different commissioner-nominees to evaluate their suitability for the role, demanding that people are replaced or given different portfolios if they are not suitable.

Nominations for the role of President must take in to account the results of the election,[0] and the European Council nominates somebody from the largest party in Parliament. I wish that Parliament had stuck to its guns in 2014/2019 and rejected the nominees that weren't spitzenkandidaten but hopefully the new proposals tabled by Parliament creating transnational lists for Parliament will change this.[1]

[0] Article 17(7) of the Treaty on European Union

[1] https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20220429IP...

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by raverbashing on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:04PM (#31935418)
> with or without proxy, before the appointment of the Commission.

Of course there is. The commission is chosen by the countries elected representatives (and confirmed by the directly elected EU Parliament)

The downvotes are justified

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by teh64 on Friday July 01, 2022 @07:57AM (#31945170)
I the US, the electoral college could vote for someone completely different, who might not even be part of the campaign: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faithless_elector

The chances of it happening are low, but the vote of the people might not be upheld.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by kabes on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:17AM (#31929575)
What do you mean itsme does not support linux? It's a phone app, you don't need to install anything on your linux machine...

However, it's not a good situation that a private company gets such a central role. In fact, Belgian government yesterday announced they're going to make their own implementation. Surely there's already eID login, but that's too cumbersome compared to itsme because it's from the pre-smartphone days.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by scrollaway on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:42AM (#31929730)
Are you talking about this?

https://www.brusselstimes.com/belgium/246070/federal-governm...

The Belgian government already has an implementation: https://www.csam.be/en/egov-profile.html

I don't use itsme, only CSAM, because itsme does not support Linux: I can't log in with Firefox or Chrome on Linux with my eID. But CSAM is not universally supported. Example of a site that does not support it: https://www.proximus.be/ - Major ISP in Belgium)

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by kabes on Thursday June 30, 2022 @06:08AM (#31930538)
> Are you talking about this?

Yes, that's what I'm talking about, although brusselstimes seems to report it weirdly (sounds like they want to extend itsme). https://www.standaard.be/cnt/dmf20220627_97617861 -> They want to replace itsme with something build by the government.

> The Belgian government already has an implementation: https://www.csam.be/en/egov-profile.html

You're confusing a couple of things here. CSAM isn't an identity provider. It's like a gateway/umbrella to multiple identity providers like eID and itsme. You can have eID authentication without CSAM and vice-versa.

It doesn't make sense to claim itsme doesn't support linux. It's only a phone app, you dont need desktop software. I can login to proximus.be using itsme on linux.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by throw10920 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:17PM (#31934719)
> It doesn't make sense to claim itsme doesn't support linux. It's only a phone app, you dont need desktop software. I can login to proximus.be using itsme on linux.

I think you're seriously confused. It's perfectly reasonable to claim that itsme doesn't support Linux. Phone have operating systems too, you know - and some phones run a Linux userspace (e.g. the Pinephone and Purism).

"Does not support Linux" means "itsme can't run on a Linux userspace" (as opposed to a Linux kernel but Google userspace, which is what Android is).

The author explicitly says this: "I don't use itsme, only CSAM, because itsme does not support Linux: I can't log in with Firefox or Chrome on Linux with my eID."

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by sam_lowry_ on Thursday June 30, 2022 @08:16AM (#31931432)
The worst part af all this government id story that no one talks about is that Belgian government lost control of its Root Certificate Authority.

It is now handled by Digicert, a US company.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by fazgha on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:52PM (#31938461)
Do you have any source for this ? I know that current root certificates are self signed. [0]

[0] https://repository.eid.belgium.be/certificates.php

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by sam_lowry_ on Friday July 01, 2022 @04:16AM (#31943732)
You have to look for trusted store updates, here is the first link I googled in 5 sec.

https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1335253

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by fazgha on Friday July 01, 2022 @09:52AM (#31946376)
I read the thread and they were discussing about "audit" made by the Belgium government. I double checked the certificates used for ID cards in [0] and all are self-signed. I don't see any link or ownership to "DigiCert". Perhaps the discussion were related to government's websites.

Example for Belgium Root CA2 in [0]

Certificate: Data: Version: 3 (0x2) Serial Number: 3098404661496965511 (0x2affbe9fa2f0e987) Signature Algorithm: sha1WithRSAEncryption Issuer: C=BE, CN=Belgium Root CA2 Validity Not Before: Oct 4 10:00:00 2007 GMT Not After : Dec 15 08:00:00 2021 GMT Subject: C=BE, CN=Belgium Root CA2

The Belgium Root CA2 in Mozilla discussion is different.

Certificate: Data: Version: 3 (0x2) Serial Number: 04:00:00:00:00:01:41:a1:e1:34:ba Signature Algorithm: sha1WithRSAEncryption Issuer: O=Cybertrust, Inc, CN=Cybertrust Global Root Validity Not Before: Oct 10 11:00:00 2013 GMT Not After : May 12 22:59:00 2025 GMT Subject: C=BE, CN=Belgium Root CA2

[0] https://repository.eid.belgium.be/certificates.php?cert=Root...

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by sam_lowry_ on Friday July 01, 2022 @04:32PM (#31952444)
The root message is about adding Belgium Root CA to the CRL..

Is there a Belgium Root CA in Mozilla, Windows, Android or iPhone trust stores now?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by fazgha on Saturday July 02, 2022 @01:14AM (#31956461)
That's I wanted to say. Belgium Root CA and its intermediates are never used for web connection (TLS) (perhaps used internally in gov intranet). I use my Id card for PDF signing. I presume CAs are added to the trused list of Adobe.

You said DigiCert owns those root CAs and I wanted more information about this.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by sam_lowry_ on Sunday July 03, 2022 @04:33AM (#31966119)
They were. Now, DigiCert CA is used instead.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by sam_lowry_ on Thursday June 30, 2022 @05:50AM (#31930436)
Itsme is an authentication token, like eID.

You can login to CSAM protected websites on Linux with Firefox or Chromium and with Itsme token running on Android or iPhone.

You can also login on Linux with Firefox or Chromium and with your eID card inserted in a properly configured card reader such as ACR-38U.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by seszett on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:30AM (#31933868)
I'm not sure because I don't use itsme anymore (it stopped working on jailbroken devices a while ago, so I just switched to TOTP auth with CSAM) but if I remember correctly the initial setup of itsme doesn't work on Linux, as it requires a browser plugin for the card reader that doesn't run on Linux. CSAM uses a different browser plugin that does work on Linux.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by scrollaway on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:44AM (#31934139)
Yes that’s exactly right.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by sam_lowry_ on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:45PM (#31937607)
I set up itsme on my android phone using linix. This was a couple years ago, so things likely changed for worse since then.

P.S. If you use a JB device, you should also use Magisk and be ready to troubleshoot.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by ploum on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:30AM (#31933874)
Worth mentioning that itsme is a private consortium of several banks and phone operators which explicitely says that data collected will be used for marketing purpose and "research".

That you can’t even think of using it if, like me, you are not using a phone operator or one of the few banks which are part of the consortium.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by seszett on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:32AM (#31933913)
That's not true, in my experience you can even use it if you only have a French phone number and no Belgian bank.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by ploum on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:10PM (#31937120)
Indeed, they added the ability to create an account with your eid. It was not the case a couple of years ago.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by thepangolino on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:34PM (#31937447)
Now you're nitpicking. https://www.proximus.be/ might not support itsme but it does allow login with user name and password.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mariusor on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:49AM (#31929769)
Is it so difficult to conceive that are people out there using phones that run something else instead of Android or iOS? Even linux.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by TacticalCoder on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:48PM (#31936806)
> When I need to identify myself, depending on the government I have to deal with, I have to use either my "FranceConnect" credentials, or my Belgian e-ID card.

That you even have to identify yourself as often as you do in the EU is a problem the EU countries created. So basically they create a problem (people needing to identify for basically everything: vaccine, going to the restaurant, going to nightclubs, maybe going to the toilet in the future, etc.) and then come up with a solution: "Look, it's going to get easier to identify yourself!" and everybody applauds.

But, wait, why do I need to be identified all the time yet?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by scrollaway on Thursday June 30, 2022 @06:25PM (#31939478)
Yeah. No. I identify myself when I log in to my utilities providers, my bank, when I do my taxes or handle some other government related stuff.

I have no idea what you’re on and I’d love to know where I can get some.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by drawfloat on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:35PM (#31937459)
This might shock you but none of those things need ID in most EU countries.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by silversmith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:23AM (#31929621)
You just have a very US centric view. Here's the situation in Latvia: Full, searchable (by government institutions) digital registry of citizens. Your income is being recorded for tax purposes. There's centralised data on what vehicles you own, and firearms are registered too. Medical data is also being centralised, to handle prescriptions digitally, and share test results between labs and doctors. Any criminal offences are centrally registered too. The information is there, and most likely being cross-referenced already.

What this would add is a more comprehensive log of where proof of identity has been used. In my case, the last non-digital, non-already-trackable request to display proof of identity was last summer, when I was trying to buy a case of beer with a mask, sunglasses and a hat completely obscuring my face. Guess the police will now know I visit grocery stores.

What's more, that's already been sort of centralised, with a single identity broker latvija.lv being run by the government, that then relies on other "blessed" identity sources such as banks or digital signature providers. The logs on who requested the identity verification and who got verified are surely there. If they cut the banks out of the loop, I see that as a net positive.

As for me, I'm not overly bothered by this. I trust the government to not wilfully abuse the data far, far more than I trust any for-profit entity.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mrtksn on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:19PM (#31935600)
> I trust the government to not wilfully abuse the data far, far more than I trust any for-profit entity.

The prime difference between American/British world view and continental European one and I'm loving it.

Sure, it's very nice to think that the government doesn't track you and doesn't know where you live. Then they build these giant systems to covertly track everyone and listen to everything.

Essentially, everything that the Americans believe that the government wants to do to them is already being done - just clandestinely.

On the European approach, we assume that the government is competent enough and is ours, therefore we give them the information needed to provide services and security. If the governments misbehave we will simply burn their palaces and drag them on the streets.

IMHO, both approaches have merits and I'm happy that they exist at the same time. It kind of keeps the institutions on track as scandals happen and fixes are implemented in attempt of self preservation.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by maxwell on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:27AM (#31933802)
> You just have a very [U.S.] centric view. [...] I trust the [Latvian/EU] government to not wilfully [sic] abuse the data [sic] far, far more than I trust any for-profit entity.

If unclear why no one in the U.S. trusts federal, state, or local governments:

* The U.S. federal government now mostly acting in service of for-profit entities, due to legalized bribery of elected officials (Citizens United) and inadequate representation (the Judiciary Act of 1869 for the Supreme Court and the Permanent Apportionment Act of 1929 for the House).

* History defeating the most powerful empire in world history, emerging as the first nation to ever overthrow a colonial oppressor.

* U.S. law enforcement officers extrajudicially killing more Americans than mass shooters in 2019 and police departments across the country taking in billions USD every year in unconstitutionally seized assets.

* More Black Americans in the "justice" system in the 2020s than were enslaved in the 1860s.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by tzs on Thursday June 30, 2022 @09:26PM (#31941006)
> More Black Americans in the "justice" system in the 2020s than were enslaved in the 1860s.

What do you mean by in the system? I would have guessed it means incarcerated, but there were around 3.9 million slaves in 1860 which is much higher than the number of people incarcerated in the US which is around 2.3 million (Federal, state, and local) of which around 1 million are black.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by maxwell on Friday July 01, 2022 @09:49AM (#31946333)
I was slightly misciting Michelle Alexander, author of The New Jim Crow (2010), from a presentation she gave in 2011:

"More Black men are in prison or jail, on probation or parole than were enslaved in 1850, before the Civil War began"

https://www.laprogressive.com/law-and-the-justice-system/bla...

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by raverbashing on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:06PM (#31935443)
Americans love complaining harshly whenever someone mentions "contry-wide" ID like it's literally the thing of the Devil while ignoring that every other place illegally uses their SSN as an ID number
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by RalfWausE on Saturday July 02, 2022 @02:05AM (#31956661)
This is the problem: You have to trust the government.

I, as a german trust Scholz only as far as i can throw him... and as i am a pencil necked hacker this isn't far

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:06PM (#31934549)
What if Russia were to overtake Latvia in the coming months via direct force or through installing a puppet regime? Trump in 2024 for our American counterparts. Would you be okay with the new masters having all this data and history on you?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mrtksn on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:33PM (#31935787)
Europeans have a rich history of bad regimes and their removal. It's not like the puppet regime would be like "Oh no, we can't do anything about this person who tweets nasty things about us because we can't look him up in the central registry". It's going to be like "hey Twitter give us the ip address of this person or you loose your money and access to our market" and then they will phone the ISP and tell them to give the ID and address of the user with that ip address.

So in reality, central registry of information doesn't really protect you from anything but saves the bad actor a few phone calls. On the other hand, it saves you a lot of phone calls and office visits every time you need to deal with the government.

If Russians install a puppet regime, the existence or lack of central registry wont actually change much. It will require popular uprising to make a difference, which Europeans are actually accustomed to.

Riots and protests happen all the time everywhere and taking down the governments is a thing too. Of course it depend on the specific country but in general governments in European countries resign all the time and when the refuse to resign despite popular demand they end up removed by riots.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:48PM (#31937631)
Indeed they do have a rich history of bad regimes. That's kind of the point.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mrtksn on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:34PM (#31938219)
So they also have bad history of greedy private enterprises on which they don't have a say.

The idea is that there's a value in having an enterprise(the government) with centralised record keeping because they own that government and have the power to change managers on predefined reviews(elections) and they have a history of forcefully changing managers who try to stick around despite not being wanted.

What do you do when a private enterprise misbehaves? Mind you, the governmental duties are often monopolistic by nature. What do you do then? Sniper the CEO?

It's much more socially acceptable to riot against the government and burn government building than assaulting company HQ.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by M2Ys4U on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:21PM (#31939996)
We've also learned from our history, and created institutions like the ECHR to enforce a minimum standard of human rights against the state, and list more things than "Speech and guns good" like the US.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by ciupicri on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:33PM (#31934982)
If Russia takes over any country, it's game over anyway like it was after WW2. The lack of an ID won't protect you from rape, robbery, murder, a trip to gulag, etc.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by silversmith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:33PM (#31938211)
Russia is indeed the main threat in our neck of the woods. And with the regimes they tend to run, lack of easily accessible digital registry is not something that will save you from falling down the stairs and accidentally landing on couple of bullets with the back of your head.

More importantly, we already have these registries! There's already a digital identity verification service in place that, according to our law, is sufficient to identify a person to the same degree an ID card / passport would in person. It's there, I've used it as an end-user, I've set up integrations with it for my clients. The issue is that if I want to identify myself to a German institution for whatever reason, the only way I know of involves burning a whole lot of dead dinosaur juice to get to Berlin, standing in an orderly queue for a while, and presenting my passport in person. And probably filling out couple forms along the way somewhere.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:13PM (#31939922)
Yeah but do you want this thing linked to every click, like, page view, search, post, purchase and so on? Required for entry, to buy and so on? Very easy for it to go that way. That's the fear behind those who are saying pause.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by radicalbyte on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:58AM (#31929440)
I'm involved in a group who come into contact with this. It's not about surveillance, it's about providing European governments, European economy and citizens with electronic ID in all situations without having to rely on Google/Apple/Facebook. So you can have a secure way to login to websites, with many personas, without having to share your GAF (and thus be tracked by GAF / share GAF data with yet another party).

Thales on the other hand are not what I would describe as a good actor but rather one of the "usual suspects".

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by closewith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:06AM (#31929498)
Providing governments with a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every citizen is inherently providing the means to surveil, though.

I also wonder how this will be regarded in countries like Ireland, which doesn't have a national ID card and where a recent attempt to make a similar digital ID system mandatory was ruled unlawful (PSC/MyGovID).

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by herbstein on Thursday June 30, 2022 @09:27AM (#31932086)
> Providing governments with a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every citizen is inherently providing the means to surveil, though.

But this suggestion ain't it. Most EU countries already have a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every resident.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by closewith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:40AM (#31932933)
> But this suggestion ain't it.

What's your basis for this claim? From the declared strategy, it seems perfect for abuse as a surveillance tool.

> Most EU countries already have a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every resident.

As stated elsewhere, my country (Ireland) does not. It's attempt at a mandatory electronic ID (MyGovID/Public Services Card) was ruled as unlawful (it's still available, but cannot be required to access government services).

Strategy link: https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/euro...

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by radicalbyte on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:14AM (#31929556)
The regulation will have to make that illegal - there are several countries who would block the regulation it if it wasn't.

So the situation will be better for us than today - there will be more options providing the ID (and wallets), including highly privacy-preserving tech based on modern encryption techniques. That will make it much harder to be tracked by commercial players and much harder to be tracked legally by governments.

For the blackhat / illegal security agencies: you might make it a little harder because the US-compromised companies (FAANG + MS) aren't (always) involved.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by slartibardfast0 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @05:40PM (#31938987)
Ireland can't really do a national id scheme without mutual agreement with the UK due to the common travel area & mutual residence rights (including voting at parliamentary level upon taking residence) that are dealt with in an ad-hoc manner for many reasons. due to this, Ireland has default opt-out on justice & home affairs issues.

however, as an EU citizen, I can see immediate advantages to a cautiously administered digital id. as it is, many states within the EU demand a national tax id on registration for services as simple as bike rental, such a digital id would presumably supersede such nonsense and help further the single market everyone is working towards.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by radicalbyte on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:01AM (#31929465)
Personally I have a dim view of the companies working in this area / the working groups because so far they've not delivered anything yet have been working on it forever. You'd expect there to be a vibrant community on Github sharing Open Source implementations. Or at least speaks. Or at least something.

Also there are so many bullshitters and snake-oil merchants in this field; makes you think that most of the "security" industry is a confidence game.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by cmroanirgo on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:11AM (#31929533)
...and yet because there's only Apple and Google providing hardware that's used by the masses, exactly how is this going to work? If the environment we're using is completely contained (pwned) then how will this not be a draconian system of control?

What happens when I buy debian mobile? I presume it will not be accepted because there will be no safe app. No app, no identity? No identity means you're suddenly locked out of society.

What phone theft? Most people's phone security is almost non existent.

What about luddites who have no mobile at all?

It seems like it's 100% about control of people. And that's a privacy matter. My body, my life, my choice.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mdp2021 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:48AM (#31929755)
> mobile

In theory, you should be able to go on using a passport for your actual needs. In practice, it is to be seen whether this initiative will cause or not cases where "options" become "constraints".

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mdp2021 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:27AM (#31929639)
> without having to rely on G./A./F. So you can have a secure way to login to websites

Said perspective is insanity: for those websites relevant to an anagraphic identity it would be dramatically abnormal to use any supposed private company related account. It would be sheer absurdity to suppose a "need" for accounts with private entities to log on to nominal services.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by Asooka on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:47AM (#31933024)
The number of websites where I would willingly use my real id is no more than five. I almost never want to have anything I write online attached visibility to my actual public identity. Anonymity is the whole point of the internet!
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:59AM (#31934433)
Any functioning society needs anonymous dissent, especially a democracy.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:57AM (#31934379)
If that's all it is then fine. But it seems to be just the first step to what many fear will become a system tied to digital currency, speech and social credit.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by cm2187 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:04AM (#31929492)
Every time you create an entry into a log file you have surveillance. It doesn't matter whether someone is currently watching the CCTV in your bedroom if it's all on tape.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by davidhbolton on Friday July 01, 2022 @06:52AM (#31944653)
Or spend non-cash money - i.e. debit or credit cards. You can buy prepay credit cards that you top up with cash but I wonder how long those will exist?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:03AM (#31929483)
> So you can have a secure way to login to websites, with many personas, without having to share your GAF

Let's manage the beloved and accountable Eurocrats in Brussels our private Auth-infrastructure, because its not like this problem would be solvable otherwise:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31836922

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by hourago on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:10AM (#31929527)
> accountable

That's the key. European politicians are accountable to European citizens. Big corporations are not. This seems a step in the right direction.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:16AM (#31929569)
> European politicians are accountable to European citizens.

That joke made my day. I'm guessing Ursula von der Leyen is a real people's champ then.

> * Big corporations are not. This seems a step in the right direction.*

So let big corporations develop the technology? Especially those that are intertwined with the state? In otherwords, entitites where the state has created plausible deniability for itself? Great, what could go wrong?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:13AM (#31929548)
This might be a shock to you, but people here would rather have their democratic government in charge of identity than some unelected, for-profit foreign company in a country that specifically does not have any privacy protections for non-citizens.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:20AM (#31929589)
This might be a shock to you, but people in Europe already have their democratic government - you may google "national elections" ;-)

And again, FIDO is an open standard, that by definition isn't run or dependend on the servers of "for profit private companies".

But gee, I must be total noob then. Open-Source can be bad, as can be accountability.

For the greater good I guess.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by yaantc on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:01AM (#31929846)
FIDO allows to authenticate to an identity, which ideally is securely stored in a token and cannot be cloned or stolen. This identity is only an large, arbitrary number and that's all. This is not enough here.

The example provided (bank account, university registration) make it clear that we're talking about authenticating against a person real, legal entity here. It's not needed in all cases, and when it's not FIDO is fine, but when it's needed in the end the root of trust in Europe is one's national state anyway.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:06AM (#31930921)
> This might be a shock to you, but people in Europe already have their democratic government - you may google "national elections" ;-)

People in Europe don't. People in the various countries do. This is just a level above, just like you don't say "oh why do we need the german government, can't the mayors do everything?".

Different levels of organization need different democratic governments. Tribalism is not the solution.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by argentier on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:58AM (#31934398)
What is democratic about the European Commission?

Having an executive made up of people selected by other politicians for political reasons is all very well as long as they understand that they do not have much legitimacy.

JC Junker, for all that he was a bit of an old sot, understood this very well.

Von der Leyen, either because of her immensely privileged background, or because of her inability to communicate in any diplomatic way, has revealed the undemocratic abomination at the heart of the European Project.

Her press conference with Stoltenberg (and Belgian nonentity Michel) at the outset of the Ukraine war deprived the EU of any room for manoeuvre in relations with Russia. She unilaterally committed hundreds of millions of people to a diplomatically absolutist position. Furthermore, she actively spun against attempts by Macron and Scholz to moderate that position.

The EU cannot continue like this: already I'm quite dubious as to whether it will survive the winter, with double digit inflation and mass industrial layoffs in prospect.

If Putin wants to play divide et impera with Russian fossil fuel supplies, she has certainly created the ideal conditions for him to do so.

She is corrupt (see Pfizer SMS) and unaccountable.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#31934497)
The commission is appointed by democratically elected heads of government, the same way the US president is appointed by democratically elected electors or the Prime Minister of the UK is appointed by democratically elected MPs.

Are all of those undemocratic, too?

> Her press conference with Stoltenberg (and Belgian nonentity Michel) at the outset of the Ukraine war deprived the EU of any room for manoeuvre in relations with Russia.

Russia's war of aggression on our neighbor deprived us of any room for manouvre. We've seen what appeasement brings in the 30s, no need to play that game again.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by denton-scratch on Friday July 01, 2022 @12:41AM (#31942456)
>Prime Minister of the UK is appointed by democratically elected MPs

That's not quite correct; the PM is appointed by the Queen.

In the event of a revolt by the parliamentary party of government against their leader, then the party gets to appoint a new leader, who then becomes PM. But that choice is reserved to the MPs of the majority party - hardly democratic.

But in the general case, there's a General Election, and the leader of the winning party becomes PM.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by argentier on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:13PM (#31934651)
Not every enemy is Hitler: not every attempt at a diplomatic settlement is appeasement. That's childishness, and lamentably common at the moment.

The game we are playing is resulting in mass death and destruction in Ukraine, and slowly throttling the European economies. What's the point?

Perhaps if you expanded your frame of historical reference you might see more clearly.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:19PM (#31934765)
Not every enemy is Hitler, but the one trying to find more Lebensraum for his völkisch ideology certainly is :-).

Perhaps if you educate yourself more about the era you might see the parallels more clearly.

You say "slowly throttling the economies", I say finally giving us a reason to accelerate investment in renewables before climate change kills us all.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by Asooka on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:49AM (#31933047)
I would rather not have online identity at all.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by fvdessen on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:24AM (#31933747)
Then don't use the system ?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:02PM (#31934477)
It's telling that both you and I opted to choose a username that is somewhat anonymous on this system. We both saw this as preferable.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:29PM (#31937354)
This system isn't designed for writing comments on Hacker News.

It's designed for things like filing your taxes or applying for a passport.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:49PM (#31937649)
Won't be hard to use it for everything, especially purchases. That's the main issue.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:18PM (#31938012)
It would be hard from an operational and customer satisfaction perspective.

Does the grocery store ask you for your passport? If not, why should the online store ask you for your online passport?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:15PM (#31939937)
Some did actually in the height of the vax pass craze of 2021-22. The online store would get use it by way of the linked digital wallet.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by blitzar on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:09AM (#31929520)
Let's give the beloved and accountable Google / Facebook / Microsoft in the US of A our private Auth-infrastructure, because its not like this problem would be solvable otherwise, and its not like they have ever done anything with our data before that would make you wonder if they can be trusted.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:13AM (#31929550)
FIDO is an open standard, that by definition doesn't store your data at GAF.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by blitzar on Thursday June 30, 2022 @08:07AM (#31931359)
I look forward to being able to pick up the phone to Google / Facebook / Microsoft, talk to a human and have them troubleshoot why they have locked me out of everything in the world.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mordae on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:53AM (#31929394)
> Am I being cynic here or is this just another attempt at total surveillance?

I don't think so. The idea is to make the wallet offline.

> It solves a problem that does not exist,

I does exist. Automatically checking identity is hard. Some counties apparently issued certificates to their citizens and enabled them being verified by anyone, simplifying several online businesses patterns.

> will likely be mandatory at some point

More like fast lane. But eventually (30 years) probably yes.

> and is executed by a defense company.

Every country is responsible for their own part. There are going to be ETSI standards for interoperability.

The actual trouble here is that (at least in my country) the officials responsible believe that rooted phone is higher security risk than automatic updates from Chinese government.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by closewith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:08AM (#31929516)
> Automatically checking identity is hard.

This seems like a feature, not a bug.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by stubish on Thursday June 30, 2022 @05:25AM (#31930277)
Every single non-cash transaction you make every single day needs to check your identity. Currently it is outsourced to banks, multinationals like visa, thousands of different government departments providing trusted docs (usually a few different ones per country). And a lot of fraud happens because we do a bad job at it. Or for-profits, doing 'good enough' where 'better' isn't profitable, because they get to pass on the trauma of identity theft to the victims.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by kabes on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:52AM (#31929385)
It does solve a problem that exists. In fact the use cases are listed in the article: filing tax reports, opening/accessing bank accounts, etc. Basically the stuff where in the offline world you would've needed to show your ID.

However, many (all?) EU members already have developed their own national system. So this tries to unionize those systems so dealing with other member nations becomes easier. Today I often have to mail a bunch of documents if I want to prove my business ownership to foreign companies.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by TurkishPoptart on Friday July 01, 2022 @06:54PM (#31954062)
Doesn't Estonia have its own E-Estonia X-road system that already does these things, using cryptography for verification and non-repudiation?

So why do we need this newer, more expensive, dystopian stuff made by some private company? How do I vote against this? Oh wait, it's the EU...so I can't.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by sathishmanohar on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:54AM (#31929403)
and eventually those tax reports and credit ratings will be tied to super market checkout systems. So governments can pick and choose which tax payers can eat what.

Any data that is aggregated is open to abuse by the aggregator and it will be definitely abused if the aggregator is a government body.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by dane-pgp on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:28PM (#31938136)
> tied to super market checkout systems

Norway is one step closer to that:

https://www.lifeinnorway.net/norway-to-track-all-supermarket...

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:07AM (#31929507)
I'd much rather have my government have info about me than Facebook.

Even in your contrived dystopia, I'd rather have a democratic government be the Big Brother than some unelected tech CEO.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mdp2021 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:00AM (#31929834)
Why do you have to bring FB into the equation? It seems you are mentioning it as a relevant alternative - what is that?

When somebody says "This may be controversial // Well, much better than being crushed under a rock", the latter is supposed to be rhetoric, here somebody seems to treat it like a real alternative, as if you went into the current events to avoid that!

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by closewith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:10AM (#31929525)
That's a false dichotomy. We can create a world where our right to privacy is respected by both governments and the private sector.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:17AM (#31929570)
It doesn't change the fact that our government is voted in, while private CEOs are moneyed in.

I trust the former more to have my best interests in mind.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by jiveturkey42 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:49AM (#31933043)
The user consents to using a product, but not being born into a particular location
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:03AM (#31933302)
[dead]
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @06:57AM (#31930850)
Could you please elaborate your argument instead of just doing drive-by insinuations?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by cm2187 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:03AM (#31929486)
Most of the examples mentioned in the article already require your identity (opening bank account, tax return, etc).

Others are outright creepy. You can't access medecine without verifying your ID? That locks lots of people out of access to healthcare (illegals, tourists, etc). Age verification? So porn websites will store the real id of all their visitors (or alternatively a central EU age verification system will be notified every time you visit such a website)?

In France for instance it is illegal to identify people by their social security number in a system (at least it was 20 years ago). That's a safeguard to prevent it from making it too easy to correlate an identity across many systems. This ID scheme will go around that. To be honest I think that law was passed at a time where surveillance was still considered evil. I think governements of most liberal democracies today are actually entertaining stasi-style surveillance as a greater good.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by M2Ys4U on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:11PM (#31934620)
>Others are outright creepy. You can't access medecine without verifying your ID? That locks lots of people out of access to healthcare (illegals, tourists, etc).

Does it not make sense that prescription medication can only be picked up by somebody who has been prescribed that medication (or somebody who has been delegated that authority by the prescribee)? As long as there's an offline mechanism available for verification I don't see the problem here.

>Age verification? So porn websites will store the real id of all their visitors (or alternatively a central EU age verification system will be notified every time you visit such a website)?

Presenting a token verifying that one is over 18 is not the same thing as presenting one's entire identity so that the service can verify one is over 18.

The way it could work is this: You try and access an age-restricted service (ARS). It returns a request for age verification including a unique ID. You then pass a hash of that request to the age verification service (AVS), and get back a token which is signed by the AVS. That token is then presented to the ARS, which validates that the signature and that the hash of their request are valid.

Boom, you have just verified that you are over 18 without leaking your identity to the ARS and without leaking the ARS's identity to the AVS.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by cm2187 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:29PM (#31935727)
All you have done is to move the juicy log file to the AVS, haven't you?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by M2Ys4U on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:57PM (#31936105)
All the AVS knows is that you're asking for an age verification token for something, but it doesn't know what the token will be used for as that information was collapsed in to a hash by you.

I'm sure there could be some sort of more elaborate protocol that would preserve privacy in the case of a log breach, the one I sketched out just shows that (assuming logs remain private and there's no collusion) that the ARS doesn't need to know the user's identity and the AVS doesn't need to know the ARS's identity in order to validate the user's age.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by wewxjfq on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:49AM (#31929766)
Age verification already works with the current digital IDs and it's made in a way that doesn't leak your personal data. In general you get to see what personal data is being requested before you agree to transmit it. The IDs can also create pseudonyms, so different systems don't know that you are the same person.

I opted out of the digital functions of my ID, but I plan to have them activated, because it's better than video identification or uploading scans of my documents. That being said, I hope that only serious processes will adopt this.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by zeeZ on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:50PM (#31935225)
In the context of German ID cards, this is mostly correct.

For age verification requests, the service provider can set the amount of years, and the ID card will simply answer with a yes or no.

The pseudonym isn't created, but calculated from the ID's private key and the service provider's public key, so even a new card means new pseudonym, which makes it slightly less useful for login long term.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by asdajksah2123 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:40PM (#31935087)
It's surveillance to the extent any ID system is surveillance.

This is a digital form of all the IDs you get from the state already.

There are genuine concerns about the scale at which digital IDs can potentially be exploited and/or the scale of monitoring this can enable, but in functional societies and governments you can build laws and systems to mitigate such issues.

The alternative are low quality ad hoc systems that offer convenience, but have no incentive for privacy and/or security.

For example, consider the massive Experian hack in the US. A credit score is basically required if you want to be a functioning member of American society. And yet they barely got a slap on the wrist and continue with their pathetically poor security practices. And it's not like they (or any US entity, for that matter) will not make their data available to the government.

In fact, with a government controlled DB the voters can have far more say on what the govt can do with that data, as opposed to Apple or Google owning that data (which is what's happenign in the US with Apple providing digital ID for states, and I'm sure Google will get into that as well), which becomes their private data and as a member of society you have no say on what can be done with that.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by ekleraki on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:10AM (#31929529)
I live in Denmark, I have an "easyID" (NemID), along with a social security number that allows me to connect to all government websites. The system allows people to use physical passcodes mailed to people, or send a push notification to their phone, to trigger the NemID application to approve or disapprove the entry.

As others have mentioned, similar stuff exist in other countries as well.

So to me, I'd rather have a single common, shared and opensource system for both Denmark, and all of EU.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by the_biot on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:15PM (#31935556)
Of course it is. Note this line from TFA:

Something the customer is (fingerprint, iris, face)

Right there, trying to normalize the idea that the government needs our fingerprints, iris etc. And that ship has sailed, lots of laws getting passed that will require this from citizens.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by threeseed on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:54AM (#31929396)
I can't see much of a difference compared to a passport or driver's license.

The quiet explosion in CCTV cameras across Europe is far more a threat than some unique identifier.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mdp2021 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:12AM (#31929906)
> passport or driver's license

Physical documents. This is an electronic system, with potential for issues as you (in this crowd) should suspect.

> is far more a threat

Which definitely concerns us in its own turn - who the daughter is dating will take its own slot.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by isbvhodnvemrwvn on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:52PM (#31936863)
The data on the document is just a snapshot of the data in electronic systems. These systems are used every single day when you use physical documents in healthcare or any other government-related scenarios to double-check on that physical document.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mdp2021 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:02PM (#31937820)
> The data on the document is just a snapshot of the data in electronic systems. These systems are used every single day

The issue is not with the governmental database, taken for granted. It is with the consequences brought by the electronic system on the user side.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by snypox on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:51AM (#31929381)
It solves on problem for me. Since the introduction of Apple Pay I hate taking my wallet anywhere and 95% of the time I don’t. But my ID and driver’s license is in there and it’s needed sometimes. This gets me closer to the goal.

Let’s say, travelling to a different country without a wallet would be amazing to me.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by nix23 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:01AM (#31929467)
>just another attempt at total surveillance?

Well yes, have you seen what europol can do now? Safe and analyze data even from unsuspected people.

German:

https://www.heise.de/news/Europols-Mandat-zur-Massenueberwac...

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by Poppys on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:15AM (#31929558)
The problem of digital identity theft/fraudulent identities exist very much, you can't get rid of crime by individuals or nations. So it seems that this would be a solution.

Most EEA countries issue physical identity cards already, so a digital one would seem a logical step.

Not that I don't disagree with the concerns about it.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:48AM (#31929360)
I'm guessing more like a/multiple "recently privatized" ex-national telecommunications provider (ie blue chip company with the state as majority stakeholder). You know, "plausible deniability" and stuff…

Edit: I stand corrected, with Thales writing this article, we can expect conglomorates such as Thales or Siemens to build this as well (corporations that due to their long standing national prominence are de-facto state-entities, although not de-jure).

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by ccbccccbbcccbb on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:17AM (#31933609)
You're being straight up realist here.