News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by radicalbyte on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:58AM (#31929440)
I'm involved in a group who come into contact with this. It's not about surveillance, it's about providing European governments, European economy and citizens with electronic ID in all situations without having to rely on Google/Apple/Facebook. So you can have a secure way to login to websites, with many personas, without having to share your GAF (and thus be tracked by GAF / share GAF data with yet another party).

Thales on the other hand are not what I would describe as a good actor but rather one of the "usual suspects".

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by closewith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:06AM (#31929498)
Providing governments with a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every citizen is inherently providing the means to surveil, though.

I also wonder how this will be regarded in countries like Ireland, which doesn't have a national ID card and where a recent attempt to make a similar digital ID system mandatory was ruled unlawful (PSC/MyGovID).

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by herbstein on Thursday June 30, 2022 @09:27AM (#31932086)
> Providing governments with a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every citizen is inherently providing the means to surveil, though.

But this suggestion ain't it. Most EU countries already have a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every resident.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by closewith on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:40AM (#31932933)
> But this suggestion ain't it.

What's your basis for this claim? From the declared strategy, it seems perfect for abuse as a surveillance tool.

> Most EU countries already have a de facto mandatory electronic ID for every resident.

As stated elsewhere, my country (Ireland) does not. It's attempt at a mandatory electronic ID (MyGovID/Public Services Card) was ruled as unlawful (it's still available, but cannot be required to access government services).

Strategy link: https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/euro...

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by radicalbyte on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:14AM (#31929556)
The regulation will have to make that illegal - there are several countries who would block the regulation it if it wasn't.

So the situation will be better for us than today - there will be more options providing the ID (and wallets), including highly privacy-preserving tech based on modern encryption techniques. That will make it much harder to be tracked by commercial players and much harder to be tracked legally by governments.

For the blackhat / illegal security agencies: you might make it a little harder because the US-compromised companies (FAANG + MS) aren't (always) involved.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by slartibardfast0 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @05:40PM (#31938987)
Ireland can't really do a national id scheme without mutual agreement with the UK due to the common travel area & mutual residence rights (including voting at parliamentary level upon taking residence) that are dealt with in an ad-hoc manner for many reasons. due to this, Ireland has default opt-out on justice & home affairs issues.

however, as an EU citizen, I can see immediate advantages to a cautiously administered digital id. as it is, many states within the EU demand a national tax id on registration for services as simple as bike rental, such a digital id would presumably supersede such nonsense and help further the single market everyone is working towards.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by radicalbyte on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:01AM (#31929465)
Personally I have a dim view of the companies working in this area / the working groups because so far they've not delivered anything yet have been working on it forever. You'd expect there to be a vibrant community on Github sharing Open Source implementations. Or at least speaks. Or at least something.

Also there are so many bullshitters and snake-oil merchants in this field; makes you think that most of the "security" industry is a confidence game.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by cmroanirgo on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:11AM (#31929533)
...and yet because there's only Apple and Google providing hardware that's used by the masses, exactly how is this going to work? If the environment we're using is completely contained (pwned) then how will this not be a draconian system of control?

What happens when I buy debian mobile? I presume it will not be accepted because there will be no safe app. No app, no identity? No identity means you're suddenly locked out of society.

What phone theft? Most people's phone security is almost non existent.

What about luddites who have no mobile at all?

It seems like it's 100% about control of people. And that's a privacy matter. My body, my life, my choice.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mdp2021 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:48AM (#31929755)
> mobile

In theory, you should be able to go on using a passport for your actual needs. In practice, it is to be seen whether this initiative will cause or not cases where "options" become "constraints".

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by mdp2021 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:27AM (#31929639)
> without having to rely on G./A./F. So you can have a secure way to login to websites

Said perspective is insanity: for those websites relevant to an anagraphic identity it would be dramatically abnormal to use any supposed private company related account. It would be sheer absurdity to suppose a "need" for accounts with private entities to log on to nominal services.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by Asooka on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:47AM (#31933024)
The number of websites where I would willingly use my real id is no more than five. I almost never want to have anything I write online attached visibility to my actual public identity. Anonymity is the whole point of the internet!
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:59AM (#31934433)
Any functioning society needs anonymous dissent, especially a democracy.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:57AM (#31934379)
If that's all it is then fine. But it seems to be just the first step to what many fear will become a system tied to digital currency, speech and social credit.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by cm2187 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:04AM (#31929492)
Every time you create an entry into a log file you have surveillance. It doesn't matter whether someone is currently watching the CCTV in your bedroom if it's all on tape.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by davidhbolton on Friday July 01, 2022 @06:52AM (#31944653)
Or spend non-cash money - i.e. debit or credit cards. You can buy prepay credit cards that you top up with cash but I wonder how long those will exist?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:03AM (#31929483)
> So you can have a secure way to login to websites, with many personas, without having to share your GAF

Let's manage the beloved and accountable Eurocrats in Brussels our private Auth-infrastructure, because its not like this problem would be solvable otherwise:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31836922

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by hourago on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:10AM (#31929527)
> accountable

That's the key. European politicians are accountable to European citizens. Big corporations are not. This seems a step in the right direction.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:16AM (#31929569)
> European politicians are accountable to European citizens.

That joke made my day. I'm guessing Ursula von der Leyen is a real people's champ then.

> * Big corporations are not. This seems a step in the right direction.*

So let big corporations develop the technology? Especially those that are intertwined with the state? In otherwords, entitites where the state has created plausible deniability for itself? Great, what could go wrong?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:13AM (#31929548)
This might be a shock to you, but people here would rather have their democratic government in charge of identity than some unelected, for-profit foreign company in a country that specifically does not have any privacy protections for non-citizens.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:20AM (#31929589)
This might be a shock to you, but people in Europe already have their democratic government - you may google "national elections" ;-)

And again, FIDO is an open standard, that by definition isn't run or dependend on the servers of "for profit private companies".

But gee, I must be total noob then. Open-Source can be bad, as can be accountability.

For the greater good I guess.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by yaantc on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:01AM (#31929846)
FIDO allows to authenticate to an identity, which ideally is securely stored in a token and cannot be cloned or stolen. This identity is only an large, arbitrary number and that's all. This is not enough here.

The example provided (bank account, university registration) make it clear that we're talking about authenticating against a person real, legal entity here. It's not needed in all cases, and when it's not FIDO is fine, but when it's needed in the end the root of trust in Europe is one's national state anyway.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:06AM (#31930921)
> This might be a shock to you, but people in Europe already have their democratic government - you may google "national elections" ;-)

People in Europe don't. People in the various countries do. This is just a level above, just like you don't say "oh why do we need the german government, can't the mayors do everything?".

Different levels of organization need different democratic governments. Tribalism is not the solution.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by argentier on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:58AM (#31934398)
What is democratic about the European Commission?

Having an executive made up of people selected by other politicians for political reasons is all very well as long as they understand that they do not have much legitimacy.

JC Junker, for all that he was a bit of an old sot, understood this very well.

Von der Leyen, either because of her immensely privileged background, or because of her inability to communicate in any diplomatic way, has revealed the undemocratic abomination at the heart of the European Project.

Her press conference with Stoltenberg (and Belgian nonentity Michel) at the outset of the Ukraine war deprived the EU of any room for manoeuvre in relations with Russia. She unilaterally committed hundreds of millions of people to a diplomatically absolutist position. Furthermore, she actively spun against attempts by Macron and Scholz to moderate that position.

The EU cannot continue like this: already I'm quite dubious as to whether it will survive the winter, with double digit inflation and mass industrial layoffs in prospect.

If Putin wants to play divide et impera with Russian fossil fuel supplies, she has certainly created the ideal conditions for him to do so.

She is corrupt (see Pfizer SMS) and unaccountable.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#31934497)
The commission is appointed by democratically elected heads of government, the same way the US president is appointed by democratically elected electors or the Prime Minister of the UK is appointed by democratically elected MPs.

Are all of those undemocratic, too?

> Her press conference with Stoltenberg (and Belgian nonentity Michel) at the outset of the Ukraine war deprived the EU of any room for manoeuvre in relations with Russia.

Russia's war of aggression on our neighbor deprived us of any room for manouvre. We've seen what appeasement brings in the 30s, no need to play that game again.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by denton-scratch on Friday July 01, 2022 @12:41AM (#31942456)
>Prime Minister of the UK is appointed by democratically elected MPs

That's not quite correct; the PM is appointed by the Queen.

In the event of a revolt by the parliamentary party of government against their leader, then the party gets to appoint a new leader, who then becomes PM. But that choice is reserved to the MPs of the majority party - hardly democratic.

But in the general case, there's a General Election, and the leader of the winning party becomes PM.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by argentier on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:13PM (#31934651)
Not every enemy is Hitler: not every attempt at a diplomatic settlement is appeasement. That's childishness, and lamentably common at the moment.

The game we are playing is resulting in mass death and destruction in Ukraine, and slowly throttling the European economies. What's the point?

Perhaps if you expanded your frame of historical reference you might see more clearly.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:19PM (#31934765)
Not every enemy is Hitler, but the one trying to find more Lebensraum for his völkisch ideology certainly is :-).

Perhaps if you educate yourself more about the era you might see the parallels more clearly.

You say "slowly throttling the economies", I say finally giving us a reason to accelerate investment in renewables before climate change kills us all.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by Asooka on Thursday June 30, 2022 @10:49AM (#31933047)
I would rather not have online identity at all.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by fvdessen on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:24AM (#31933747)
Then don't use the system ?
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:02PM (#31934477)
It's telling that both you and I opted to choose a username that is somewhat anonymous on this system. We both saw this as preferable.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:29PM (#31937354)
This system isn't designed for writing comments on Hacker News.

It's designed for things like filing your taxes or applying for a passport.

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:49PM (#31937649)
Won't be hard to use it for everything, especially purchases. That's the main issue.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by malermeister on Thursday June 30, 2022 @04:18PM (#31938012)
It would be hard from an operational and customer satisfaction perspective.

Does the grocery store ask you for your passport? If not, why should the online store ask you for your online passport?

Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by swader999 on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:15PM (#31939937)
Some did actually in the height of the vax pass craze of 2021-22. The online store would get use it by way of the linked digital wallet.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by blitzar on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:09AM (#31929520)
Let's give the beloved and accountable Google / Facebook / Microsoft in the US of A our private Auth-infrastructure, because its not like this problem would be solvable otherwise, and its not like they have ever done anything with our data before that would make you wonder if they can be trusted.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by woodpanel on Thursday June 30, 2022 @03:13AM (#31929550)
FIDO is an open standard, that by definition doesn't store your data at GAF.
Re:EU Digital ID wallet is coming by blitzar on Thursday June 30, 2022 @08:07AM (#31931359)
I look forward to being able to pick up the phone to Google / Facebook / Microsoft, talk to a human and have them troubleshoot why they have locked me out of everything in the world.