News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why America can’t build by germinalphrase on Monday June 27, 2022 @06:24PM (#31901671)
Which makes me wonder if putting state level structure around “militias” (open entry for anyone over 18, govern some aspects of sport shooting and training) would be an effective entry to reducing the number of semiautomatic weapons in circulation (though the numbers there are so staggering that it feels somewhat pointless).
Re:Why America can’t build by idiotsecant on Monday June 27, 2022 @06:34PM (#31901774)
FYI this isn't super different from how it's culturally done in certain circles in the US (although it's not universal). When I was a young teen I took a hunter's education course that covered ethical hunting, firearm safety, first aid, basic wilderness survival, etc. I would support making that sort of requirement for owning firearms universal, but I would anticipate that a lot of people would view this as a registry which is not a very attractive prospect for a lot of people.
Re:Why America can’t build by bluGill on Monday June 27, 2022 @07:50PM (#31902425)
There are a number of people who will use such a system as a registry they can abuse and once in a while they get political power.
Re:Why America can’t build by esrauch on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:08PM (#31902938)
This seems like borderline deranged paranoia to me; what do you expect these powerful people to do given the registry of automatic gun owners?

Are you expecting a WW2 French Revolution style situation where the moral resistance will be stronger because of the unregistered firearms?

Most of these guns are bought on credit or debit cards, so the information about big ticket gun buyers probably unregulated available through Palantir or whoever.

Re:Why America can’t build by coredog64 on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:29PM (#31903452)
It doesn’t take any paranoia. There’s been several instances of journalists using FOIA requests to get the names and addresses of firearm owners and then publishing them. It just happened again in California post the recent USSC decision: An LA journalist requested the names and addresses of current permit holders.
Re:Why America can’t build by esrauch on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:34PM (#31903470)
And then what bad thing happened?

And if FOIA is really the problem (not the government knowing) then the registry could be made legally exempt from FOIA. The government keeps databases including all of your income (IRS) and your religion (the Census) but random journalists can't get the information.

Re:Why America can’t build by elmomle on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @02:56AM (#31904924)
I believe the paranoia is misplaced. I'm not aware of a single instance in the whole history of the US where a citizen was targeted by members of the public primarily on the basis of their owning a gun (or holding a permit)--are you?
Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:00AM (#31904949)
Re:Why America can’t build by esrauch on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:49AM (#31905582)
What is they point of your link? The information was made public, but no one whose information was disclosed had any known negative outcomes of that happening.

It seems like evidence that a registry is fine: apparently even when a registry is public it didn't result in the owners being "targeted", so a private registry visible only to law enforcement would be surely even safer than that.

Re:Why America can’t build by idiotsecant on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:22AM (#31908895)
I think you're being disingenuous here. Having your name and address attached to a story about how damaging you are to society is not desirable, and if you can't acknowledge that I think you're not arguing from an honest place.

Imagine whatever opinion you might have that is controversial, even mildly so. Now imagine that a new story about how that opinion makes you dangerous to society also includes your name and address in it. I think the harm here need not be a physical attack on someone, intentional intimidation is a mild form of violence itself.

Re:Why America can’t build by esrauch on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @07:41PM (#31914546)
> attached to a story about how damaging you are to society

I reread the cnn link again and I still don't know about the article you're referring to; from the text of the CNN article it sounds like it was solely a map and all of the other quotes are from people worried about the potential harm like burglaries. The CNN article doesn't actually even say the names or specific addresses of the gun owners was published, it only describes a map with dots.

Overall I'm not sure that that map is actually more risky than a map of where the atheists live, and we don't stop collecting that info on the census. The census data has never been leak published to my knowledge.

So even if it is true that example of a published map was a horrible safety violation, that only means that the data shouldn't be available to journalists, which is different than saying the data shouldn't be allowed to be known by anyone in government. The census and IRS are examples of the government being able to maintain secrets, so I don't buy the idea that it would be inevitably leaked if a gun registry had similar legal protections.

And it doesn't seem to support some risk of evil powerful people who are going to do something nefarious with this data once they get into power, which is what the thread above is about.

Re:Why America can’t build by chasd00 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:19AM (#31905063)
It’s not paranoia doxing gun owners from a registry has already happened at least once.

https://edition.cnn.com/2012/12/25/us/new-york-gun-permit-ma...

Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @02:59AM (#31904944)
It's not paranoia. Canada created a "long gun" registry to "keep people safe". Then they started banning specific long guns. The registry let them know exactly who owned what.

It's the same reason why some European countries don't include race or religion in their national IDs. When the Nazi's took over, the existing governments registry of individuals made is real easy to track down all the people they wanted to eliminate.

Re:Why America can’t build by lozenge on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @06:41AM (#31906120)
So the registry allowed laws created under a democratic system to be implemented, and that's.. bad?
Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:15AM (#31907265)
Yes if your a person who believes those rights are unjustly being denied.

(The registry was eventually scraped because of non-compliance, less than 25% of estimated guns were never registered).

Re:Why America can’t build by germinalphrase on Monday June 27, 2022 @06:43PM (#31901885)
This is my experience as well. I grew up in a small midwestern town. I continue to shoot and do a little bit of hunting, but the temperature around firearms and gun ownership really took a turn in the 90’s. Lots of wild conversations happening down at the conservation club.

Edit: I guess my initial comment was more about a cultural/legal framework for reasonably reducing the number of semiautomatic weapons in the general populace.

Re:Why America can’t build by rjbwork on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:04AM (#31903950)
>but the temperature around firearms and gun ownership really took a turn in the 90’s

The damage to this country's social fabric done by the feds due to the Ruby Ridge and Waco massacres really cannot be understated. A LOT of people looked at that and said "ain't gonna be me, we'll kill em if they try that shit" and went and armed themselves, their families, and their neighbors to the teeth.

As they say, it's not paranoia if they're actually out to get you.

Re:Why America can’t build by chasd00 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:30AM (#31905135)
Ruby Ridge especially. I did a lot of writing on the subject freshman year English. I think it scared the crap out of a lot of people already suspicious of authority.
Re:Why America can’t build by germinalphrase on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:34AM (#31904108)
Materials we got from the NRA changed to.
Re:Why America can’t build by rjbwork on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:35AM (#31904119)
Indeed. And it infiltrated gun culture completely.
Re:Why America can’t build by Tool_of_Society on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:02PM (#31902509)
yeah the 90s is when the term "assault weapon" was pushed into the narrative in an attempt to blur the lines between a semiautomatic hunting rifle and an actual assault rifle.

So that's how we end up with people calling hunting rifles "assault rifles/weapons" or "military grade weaponry". It's like dude a freaking blunderbuss is military grade weaponry. The most popular hunting rounds in the USA were originally designed for military use.

Re:Why America can’t build by lmm on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:12PM (#31903677)
Your last point rather undermines your first. Turns out killing a deer-sized animal is a similar problem to killing a human-sized animal, who knew.

(Hasn't the US military actually moved away from fully-automatic weapons for regular troops in favour of three-round-burst? So it ends up as a very close convergence)

Re:Why America can’t build by int_19h on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:23AM (#31905443)
You're not wrong, but the rhetoric OP references goes much further than that - it specifically claims that .223, the caliber in which semi-autos like AR-15 are chambered is somehow more deadly than "normal" hunting calibers, and that is supposedly a big part of what makes it a "weapon of war" etc.

The actual story here is that regular hunting calibers tend to be significantly more powerful to maximize the probability of a humane (one-shot; ideally, instant) kill. In fact, many states don't allow hunting deer with .223 on the basis that it's not lethal enough. For similar reasons, most jurisdictions require hunters to use some kind of expanding bullet, whereas ARs are far more typically used with cheap military-style FMJ ammo.

Re:Why America can’t build by EdwardDiego on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @05:56PM (#31913579)
Spot on. I hunt red deer and while you _can_ use .223 / 5.56mm, a humane kill requires very precise shot placement. It's okay for smaller deer (fallow, whitetail, sika) and chamois, but not really for the reds, sambar, rusa or tahr.

I use .308 Win, probably the most common calibre for red deer hunting here, but you meet people using fancy powerful rounds like 7mm Rem Mag or .338 Lapua.

Re:Why America can’t build by germinalphrase on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:47PM (#31902819)
Right. There really isn’t a clear difference between the two, so attempting to draw that line is foolhardy.

That said, the lethality advantage of semiautomatic weapons over manually operated is obvious.

Re:Why America can’t build by pclmulqdq on Monday June 27, 2022 @11:23PM (#31903735)
There is a very clear distinction between the two.

Assault rifles have automatic (or select-fire) capabilities. One trigger pull can produce many bullets.

Semi-automatic rifles, which were later called "assault weapons," can only produce one bullet per trigger pull. What makes them semi-automatic is that they automatically reload after firing. Many other types of guns also do this (eg double-action revolvers) and many take minimal movement to reload (eg lever-action and bolt-action rifles).

This is a very big difference. A commercial semiautomatic rifle is only slightly more lethal than a bolt-action rifle. An assault rifle is much more lethal than both.

Re:Why America can’t build by germinalphrase on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:40AM (#31904159)
I didn’t downvote, but I don’t believe your chosen definition is widely accepted. Further, many elite soldiers will say that they rarely would put their weapons in full auto in a fire fight. I’m certainly not one of them and can’t speak to it, but I’ll take their word their semi-auto rifles are plenty lethal.
Re:Why America can’t build by pclmulqdq on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @07:20AM (#31906341)
If you look up the definitions in any source, that is what you will find. If there wasn't a big difference, then it wouldn't be the case that every single military in the world uses assault rifles with select-fire capability.

Also, if you watch videos of actual military operations, you will find the 3-round burst used very frequently because it is a lot more lethal than semiautomatic mode. Only special ops troops tend to use semiautomatic mode for fighting (since they are better marksmen and are concerned about noise). Police also only use semiautomatic weapons, because they don't have access to automatic weapons.

Re:Why America can’t build by idiotsecant on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:25AM (#31908934)
>Police also only use semiautomatic weapons, because they don't have access to automatic weapons.

It's pedantic but while regular officers don't deploy full-auto weapons, police departments certainly have them.

Re:Why America can’t build by bluGill on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:03AM (#31907141)
If you are in a real war and hit by a gun on automatic it is your own stupid fault. If you are killed by a gun using any form of semi-auto (including 3 round burst) it is just bad luck. Automatic guns are very useful in war, but the purpose isn't to kill it is to force the enemy to keep their head down (ie in a bunker) while you do something else.

For your average soldier a automatic gun is just a waste of bullets. Which is why elite soldiers never use full auto mode: it is never a useful mode for them. It is still useful, but you don't need much training to run a gun in full auto mode, so generals put the non-elite troops on the automatic guns. (though sometimes an elite soldier will volunteer for the automatic duty - it is kind of fun to chew threw tens of thousands of bullets in one trigger pull)

Re:Why America can’t build by Tool_of_Society on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @07:11PM (#31914302)
Yeah I've seen videos galore of people firing bolt action rifles as fast as any semi-auto. Youtube has tons of them and it's outright impressive.
Re:Why America can’t build by chasd00 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:26AM (#31905103)
You can see the change at gun shows too. Gun shows use to be 90% hunting or collectable/rare rifles. Now they’re ar15s and accessories as far as the eye can see.

I’m not sure what changed, maybe the ar15 patent expired, they’ve always been around just not that popular. Then, all of a sudden, they were everywhere.

Re:Why America can’t build by everforward on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:52PM (#31936041)
It's a combination of access to cheap military surplus ammo, light recoil making them approachable to beginners, a standardized platform, and rails for accessories. Plus a little bit of a "badass" effect from it being based on a military weapon.

Military weapons also generically have the advantage of having been tested for ruggedness, and not having to worry about being able to find parts or ammo in a decade.

Re:Why America can’t build by Tool_of_Society on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @07:13PM (#31914318)
The AR-15 is basically a gun version of legos. You can buy one AR-15 lower receiver (which counts as the gun) and then just swap out uppers depending on what you're hunting.
Re:Why America can’t build by idiotsecant on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:26AM (#31908951)
AR-15s are dirt cheap to manufacture, super modular and customizable, and are really just all around great guns. There's a reason they're so popular.
Re:Why America can’t build by chasd00 on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:22AM (#31905088)
Hunter’s Ed was included in my HS Agriculture class, we all received the little card that came with completion of the course too. In rural areas it’s pretty standard stuff.
Re:Why America can’t build by wahern on Monday June 27, 2022 @07:03PM (#31902070)
> Which makes me wonder if putting state level structure around “militias” (open entry for anyone over 18, govern some aspects of sport shooting and training) would be an effective entry to reducing the number of semiautomatic weapons in circulation

At least in the United States, sadly that ship has sailed as SCOTUS precedent repeatedly emphasizes the 2nd Amendment as a purely individual right. The so-called preamble discussing states and militias is now formally a dead letter.

Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:26PM (#31903064)
> At least in the United States, sadly that ship has sailed as SCOTUS precedent repeatedly emphasizes the 2nd Amendment as a purely individual right.

With the current court, yes, but that interpretation only dates back to 2008. It would be much less of a reversal than we just saw for a future court to find that Heller was decided in error, and unlike Alito’s pretense of research there’s far more historical precedent supporting the collective interpretation going back at least as far as what the people drafting the second amendment discussed when they did so, as well as two centuries of general agreement on that point.

Re:Why America can’t build by int_19h on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:39AM (#31905521)
The original interpretation is, quite frankly, largely irrelevant, because the entire BoR was written in the context where the chief concern was guarding the rights of states against the federal government. With 2A, they wanted to make sure that the feds couldn't suppress state militias, as the British tried to do. When it came to the rights of citizens against their respective state governments, that was what the state constitutions were supposed to protect.

But, conversely, the very notion that the federal government would even be able to ban state citizens individually from possessing arms would be just as alien to the authors - the constitution simply didn't grant that kind of power to it back then, not even close.

OTOH the notion that the right to keep and bear arms was widely perceived as individual by the American society as a whole has solid historical basis. Here's one simple thing anyone can do to verify this: go look up the list of 2A-like clauses in state constitutions, along with dates they were adopted:

https://gun-control.procon.org/state-constitutional-right-to...

You might notice that the earliest examples often specifically talk about individual rights, e.g.:

“The right of the citizens to bear arms in defense of themselves and the State shall not be questioned” (Pennsylvania, 1790; Kentucky, 1792)

Such language becomes rarer over time, though, until we get to the end of the last century.

Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @08:26AM (#31906778)
An important thing to remember is that the discussion was about state militias being able to resist a federal army. Being in the militia was both a privilege and a responsibility - they had problems with people skimping on equipment & maintenance in addition to training – and that has to be understood in the context of the Whigs’ concerns about standing armies full of property-less men. They wanted militias tied to the local community, with their own property at stake, which is a rather different starting point than the late 20th century maximalist “no requirements, no restrictions” position.

Here are two books which cover the period discussion and the structure of the militia in early America. It’s a surprisingly under-covered part of our history.

https://www.amazon.com/Citizens-Arms-Militia-American-Societ...

https://global.oup.com/academic/product/a-well-regulated-mil...

The other thing we have to remember is how much more powerful modern weapons are. At the time this was written there was no concept of some lone wolf being able to mow down a crowd - they’d be limited to a first volley with the loaded, not especially precise or long-ranged, weapons they brought with them before getting subdued. The founders were thinking in terms of armies because period firearms were most effective in large coordinated groups.

Re:Why America can’t build by dragonwriter on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:36PM (#31903137)
> and unlike Alito’s pretense of research there’s far more historical precedent supporting the collective interpretation going back at least as far as what the people drafting the second amendment discussed when they did so, as well as two centuries of general agreement on that point.

And, also, the prefatory clause of the text of the Amendment itself.

Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:03AM (#31904969)
Back when the Constitution was written, the militia was "all able bodies males" who could be called to service. It wasn't a formal organization like the military today. It was basically all male citizens.

So that actually aligns with it being an individual right.

Re:Why America can’t build by dragonwriter on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:49AM (#31909264)
> Back when the Constitution was written, the militia was "all able bodies males" who could be called to service

You are focussing on what the militia is (and erroneously pretend that it has changed over time; it still essentially the same thing, see, e.g., the codification in Title 10 of the US Code.)

But my point is about what the second amendment says the militia is necessary for, not what the militia is. Because that's the part that is relevant to the claim that the 2nd Amendment provides a right of the type that should be applied by the 14th Amendment to be protected against the states or rather than that explicitly has a role for the benefit of the states and to which the incorporation logic of the 14th Amendment does not apply.

Incorporation of rights protected against federal encroachment by the Bill of Rights against the states isn't universal (the requirement of indictment from the 5th Amendment is not incorporated, for instance), even for rights that are expressly individual rights. Incorporation is a separate question.

Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @08:32AM (#31906819)
This is leaving out a lot: the militia usually had equipment requirements, was often restricted to men of property, and had training requirements. It especially was not all male citizens - for example, even in the north where the militia didn’t do slave patrols there were often racial restrictions excluding free black men, and the Whigs were big on restricting it to property owners out of fear of groups of armed unattached men being swayed against the local community.

https://global.oup.com/academic/product/a-well-regulated-mil...

https://uncpress.org/book/9780807896419/citizens-in-arms/

Re:Why America can’t build by bluGill on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:07AM (#31907185)
True, but that eliminates people who belong to groups that we no longer recognize at all. We don't recognize slaves at all, so that slaves can't own guns doesn't matter. Nobody would complain about a law that makes it illegal for slaves to own guns: there are no slaves. Laws that blacks or women are somehow different and thus cannot own guns might be historically supported, but today we elevate those groups to the same level as white land owners, and so they get the rights of white land owners.
Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:13AM (#31907241)
Sure but we also interpret all other Constitutional rights as belonging to everyone regardless if they were unjustly restricted in the past.

Your argument sounds like “we denied black people rights in the past so there for the 2nd amendment right doesn’t apply to everyone.”

Weird argument.

Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:22AM (#31907360)
It only sounds weird because you reworded it to remove the main points: even if you ignore the portion about the groups of people who were excluded, you still have the militias being groups with rules and requirements rather than a free-for-all.
Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:10AM (#31908743)
Rules required to make sure the militia was “well regulated” (functioning properly). But the rules (other than race, money) only excluded those without equipment, everyone was still a part of the militia otherwise.
Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @06:44PM (#31914050)
You’re leaving out the other parts, most importantly the training and the concept that you were working in a group rather than acting as a lone wolf. Any remotely historical reading does not preclude safety standards and, indeed, American history is full of those and they were not considered controversial prior to 2008.
Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @10:47PM (#31915900)
I'm not sure you understand what the militias looked like during the time the Constitution was created. It was basically "calling all men to service". There was no standing army, membership was fluid and as long as you were able to fulfill the requirements of physical health, bring a weapon, be willing to follow orders.
Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:00PM (#31903290)
Yes: it would not take a legal genius to say “these words were included for a reason, here are period discussions confirming that and two centuries without serious question”.
Re:Why America can’t build by kelnos on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:06AM (#31903957)
> With the current court, yes

Given the ages of quite a few justices, the current court will remain mostly unchanged for decades to come.

Re:Why America can’t build by germinalphrase on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:41AM (#31904163)
Barring court packing.
Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:03AM (#31904974)
FDR got his pee-pee wacked by his own party for trying to pack the Supreme Court back in the 1930's.

It's a non-starter.

Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @08:41AM (#31906886)
That’s far from a given. The current court’s willingness to just ignore long-standing precedent to take away major rights, the stolen seat, and Thomas’ massive conflicts of interest (not just Ginny organizing the insurrection but also receiving money from groups going before the court) have permanently damaged faith in an institution which relies on authority granted to it on the trust that it not do things like that (note how much more limited the court’s direct constitutional authority is).

I think it’s quite plausible that there’d be significant public support for a reform package: pin the number of justices to the number of lower courts (we have 9 because that’s how many there were the last time that changed), add term limits for new justices, and adopting the ethics rules which other federal judges are required to follow.

Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:12AM (#31907227)
No, no, no.

You’re telling me the situation is more contentious than the 30’s when FDR was trying to pass his New Deal during the greatest economic collapse the US has ever known?

No. Your reply and your hyperbole suggest you don’t know much about the court’s history.

Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:55AM (#31907699)
I find it interesting that you’re talking about hyperbole but offering only emotional rhetoric.

If you want to do better, note that I was talking about the legitimacy of the court itself, which is critical to an institution with a great deal of inferred power which is not explicitly spelled out. The FDR-era court did not have a justice whose legitimacy was dubious. Similarly, you could look at the various New Deal rulings for examples which completely broke with long-standing precedent or relied on cherry-picked history if you want to argue that those rulings were not unusual.

Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:07AM (#31908699)
Not legitimate? It was seen as blocking some of the most progressive policies helping the desperately poor during the Great Depression.

If it was legitimate why would you need to stack the court. A legitimate court’s decisions would be accepted, not changed by adding judges.

And the reason why the idea to stack was defeated was because it was viewed as a run around judicial independence (e.g. making it less legitimate).

Re:Why America can’t build by acdha on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @06:58PM (#31914180)
Again, please note what we’re talking about: legitimacy of the court itself.

New Deal proponents didn’t like those rulings but there was no question that any of the judges hadn’t been properly appointed, nor was there a huge break with past precedent on the same issue.

We’re living in a time where a majority of the court are acting in blatantly politicized ways, interfering on behalf of their party to prevent fair elections and flipping alleged legal theories whenever necessary to produce their desired outcome.

That is incredibly risky for an institution which has considerable power on the grounds that it not play games like that.

Re:Why America can’t build by refurb on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @10:44PM (#31915885)
there was no question that any of the judges hadn’t been properly appointed

The same can be said today. Supreme Court appointments have always been political. Hell being "Borked" got its name from political games during Reagan.

Just because you don't think the process was "proper" doesn't change the fact they were all confirmed by the senate, as per the "proper" process.

Funny how many people complain about the politics of Supreme Court nominees only when it works against their own political views.

Re:Why America can’t build by idiotsecant on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:28AM (#31908972)
>the greatest economic collapse the US has ever known?

Jpow: Hold my beer.

Re:Why America can’t build by int_19h on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:40AM (#31905527)
It's not the 1930s. It's a very different country with different politics.
Re:Why America can’t build by jnwatson on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:28PM (#31903446)
Precedent itself took a beating on Friday.
Re:Why America can’t build by wahern on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @12:43AM (#31904175)
Yes and no. For several decades even liberal jurists have made a joke of Justice Douglas' now infamous "penumbra" explanation in Griswold v. Connecticut that undergirds a general right to privacy. I remember thinking as a law student that every chuckle, every eye roll, especially by liberal leaning students and professors, was another nail in the coffin of that whole line of jurisprudence.

Stare decisis is critically important, but when it comes to substantive law the fact is that historically decisions don't have staying power unless there's some internalization of the underlying legal logic. Liberal justices walked away from Douglas' phrasing almost immediately and were never able to replace it with anything.

I never had a problem with penumbras. It's as apt a description as anyone could conjure to refer to positive rights which exist by implication. And in fact usage of that term goes back to jurists far more esteemed than Douglas. Conservatives have long tried to use the 10th Amendment for similar effect, but that likewise has failed, and frankly as an analytic device "penumbras" works much better.

I used to think Kennedy's "dignity" reasoning in Obergefell v. Hodges was awkward, but upon closer inspection of broader legal theory he's actually drawing upon a vein of jurisprudence that could become a cornerstone of American legal theory in this area. It's much more well developed outside the U.S., but that doesn't mean it's not consonant with American jurisprudence. Yet I haven't seen many law review articles, let alone case decisions, try to further develop this principle. I think like penumbras, liberal jurists are inclined to roll their eyes at it, even though they haven't yet got to the point where they literally roll their eyes at it. I suspect Hodges will fall quickly, unless Gorsuch is able to refashion a theory based on sex discrimination much like he did for Title VII in Bostock v. Clayton County. (But that's a stretch as Gorsuch claimed to be using a plain text approach to statutory interpretation.)

Re:Why America can’t build by int_19h on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @04:49AM (#31905579)
The fundamental problem with "penumbras" is that once you allow that as a way of reasoning, pretty much anything goes. At which point the Supreme Court becomes an insanely powerful body for something unelected and with a lifetime tenure, and SCOTUS nominations become worthy of scorched earth mode of political warfare.

Thing is, we have the constitutional amendment process for a reason - it is supposed to be a living document, true enough, but it's supposed to be updated through political process, not judicial. The problem, of course, is that the bar for amendments is so high that they become impossible in practice; but it's also impossible to fix that without an amendment. Thus, so long as enough political forces believe that the status quo is preferable to other options, it'll remain that way, and we'll see increasingly contorted Supreme Court decisions to reach goals of whatever party controls it at any given moment.

That leads to another problem, which is that SCOTUS, and the system as a whole, rapidly lose legitimacy. At this point, it already doesn't matter much whether any given decision is legally sound or not - it will be supported or opposed consistently along partisan political lines. The same people will castigate the judges for "inventing" rights in one decision, then blame them for not buying into the rights "invented" by other judges. I don't know how much longer we have left, but this passage from Federalist Papers (#22) comes to mind:

"... two thirds of the people of America could not long be persuaded, upon the credit of artificial distinctions and syllogistic subtleties, to submit their interests to the management and disposal of one third."

Re:Why America can’t build by travismark on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @08:58AM (#31907083)
or just pass a bill
Re:Why America can’t build by Tool_of_Society on Monday June 27, 2022 @07:54PM (#31902454)
Unlikely as people are already producing semiautomatic firearms with consumer level 3d printer technology. There are even competitions out there already such as the Makers Match.

There are some firearms part manufacturers that utilize 3d printing for part production. The company that made the first fully printed .45 1911 handgun uses printers to produce parts for sale.

I grew up in the rural midwest so my firearm experience goes back to the single digits of age. It was expected I would take the firearms and hunter safety courses that the state provided. I believe that such courses should at the very least be the minimum required for anyone purchasing a gun.

Re:Why America can’t build by simon1ltd on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @07:17AM (#31906317)
I think the hunters safety courses should be a requirement for everyone, even those that aren’t buying a firearm — and should probably come around the age of 14/15 unless you’re going to be hunting earlier.
Re:Why America can’t build by idiotsecant on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @11:33AM (#31909042)
To be fair, it's only true that people are making firearms on 3d printers because what we consider the firearm in the US is unusual. In other places the portion of the machine that contains pressure is the firearm. In the US the portion of the machine that holds the trigger mechanism is considered the firearm. This leads to the easiest part of the machine to manufacture also being the only part that is illegal to manufacture in places where such a thing is illegal. It's exactly backwards from physics. Making a 3d printed firing chamber is exceedingly difficult, especially one that won't blow your hand off. Making a trigger - even a fully automatic one - is one notch above trivial.