News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by gumby on Sunday June 26, 2022 @08:22PM (#31889347)
I think it's shortsighted to think of it as an alternative to conventional aviation. People send freight (and themselves) by plane because it's fast; in the case of cargo it's goods that are so expensive that the speed is worth it.

If you're not in a hurry you can use ships, which are quite cheap.

The value, IMHO, is in landlocked areas without rail links like Africa and central Asia. These are areas that mostly skipped the landline and went straight to wireless. Airships would be an analogous transition for them possibly even for passengers, though I think of freight.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by PaulHoule on Sunday June 26, 2022 @08:40PM (#31889451)
Everything else equal, fast = cheap

The Hindenberg could cross the Atlantic in about two days

https://simpleflying.com/cruise-ships-of-the-air/

If we average that out to 4 days to make a round trip, whereas today's airliners can make the round trip in a day, the capital cost of a seat on an airship has to be multiplied by 4 compared to the capital cost of an airliner because the seat on the airliner can move 4x as many people.

On top of that, the airship is going to need to provide a much higher level of amenity (space, food, water, supplies, staff) to be comfortable for a much longer trip.

Ocean liners became uneconomical early in the jet age for this exact reason: you're not just burning up your own time riding a slow boat, but you have to pay for a much longer time on that boat.

In the 1960s, Boeing thought the 747 was a stop-gap solution because it was commonly thought supersonic airliners would be able to manage at least twice as many flights per unit time as subsonic airliners. When the Concorde came along it became clear that you couldn't manage this trick because you'd have to take off and land late at night, something the community finds unacceptable.

The odd thing about supersonics is that the fuel economy gets better as you go faster (in the range from Mach 1 to the low 3's) and if you were able to make an airliner that flew at SR-71 speeds you might be able to manage a double flight rate.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by gumby on Sunday June 26, 2022 @09:08PM (#31889580)
All true but the economics are different when there is little cap ex budget. You don’t have to build an airstrip or lay rail to ship bulk goods like grain this way, and it need only go from inland to a port.

Think Almaty to Singapore or Lusaka to Luanda. Any passengers for such a journey can put up with a lot of privation for a low cost trip (but I imagine passenger traffic would be fit into a cargo trip on a space available basis; I can’t imagine passengers being primary)

You could use containers for some goods; bulk goods like grain could be decanted straight into the hold of a bulk carrier

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by notahacker on Monday June 27, 2022 @05:48AM (#31892438)
Fuel cost (which heavier than air aircraft really ought to be able to reduce) is double the amortised capital cost in an airline's budget, and there are plausible reasons to believe the capital cost of airships will be smaller (greater size, but less stress placed on parts). So everything else really isn't equal.

For related reasons turboprop aircraft are more economical for short haul flight than jets which could notionally fly more sectors, and Concorde flew very little during the daytime either because the fuel cost of getting to supersonic relegated it to niche use to transport rich people.

I think passenger dislike of longer trips is a bigger obstacle to widespread adoption, but a significant proportion of [potential] flight doesn't involve passengers

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by credit_guy on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:03AM (#31893349)
> which heavier than air aircraft really ought to be able to reduce

It's not clear. Dirigibles travel at very low altitude, where the air is dense and they have a very high cross-section area. Very high as in absurdly high (A Goodyear-Zeppelin blimp has a diameter of 14m and a gross weight of 10 tons. So the cross-section area is about 600 m2 )

Jet airplanes travel at 10 km high, where it's almost vacuum. They are also very slender. They have a very high lift-to-drag ratio. A modern B-787 (Dreamliner) has an L/D ratio of 20, most other aircraft capable of crossing the Atlantic have an L/D ratio above 15.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by notahacker on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:34AM (#31895129)
On the other hand, dirigibles don't need to worry about lift to drag ratio at all on account of not needing to generate enough thrust to produce lift.

Which is why the litres of fuel per passenger km for the Hindenburg, with 1920s diesel engines mounted on platforms where fuel economy was barely a consideration compares favourably with the same economy metric for modern transatlantic flight after half a century of innovation in jet fuel economy (and cramming passengers into smaller spaces). Needless to say lighter than air platforms without comparable worries about the impact of weight on fuel consumption and with large surface areas are also theoretically superior platforms for electric engines and [partial] use of solar power than heavier than air platforms.

Obviously they're not a pure emissions silver bullet, and plenty of other practical problems would need to be overcome for airships to fill more than tiny niches, but the evidence favours my statement.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by credit_guy on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:36PM (#31903478)
I checked your numbers, and you are right.

The Hindenburg had a total mass of about 240 tons. In its last voyage it burned 42 tons of fuel over 77 hours. It was an unusually long voyage due to high winds, but presumably the engineers who built it took these type of conditions into account, so the takeoff fuel was probably 50 tons or so.

A modern airplane of the same size (mass) is A-330. It has a (fully loaded takoff) mass of 240 tons, and a takeoff fuel mass of about 110 tons, so more than double the Hindenburg's.

Hindenburg's speed was about 125 km/h, while A-330's speed is about 1000 km/h, so about 8 times faster. Indeed, a Frankfurt-New York flight takes about 8-9 hours in an Airbus, it used to take about 60 to 70 hours in a Hindenburg.

Of course, if it takes you 2 days to cross the Atlantic, you need a bed. So, Hindenburg was able to accommodate only about 70 passengers, while an A-330 can easily fly 250.

Finally, regarding solar power. Hindenburg's area as seen from above was about 10000 m2. Current solar panels can produce up to 220 w/m2, so if we cover a Hindenburg with such panels we'd get 2.2 MW peak power, or about 3000 horse-power. Hindenburg's engines were producing about 3300 HP in cruise mode. Today, with better propellers and CFD modeling, you may not need more than 3000 HP to get the same thrust, so at peak solar radiance (noon), you would not need to burn any gas at all. Of course, during the night, the solar panels' output will be zero, but the modern engines may be more efficient, so all in all it's likely that instead of 50 tons you may only need 25 tons.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by rich_sasha on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:11AM (#31894834)
Air drag increases with speed too. Air pressure at Mount Everest is, IIRC, 30% of sea level value, for a roughly 70% reduction in drag i guess, but if you're moving 5-10x faster, that's a 25-100x penalty.

Airline jets fly at transonic speeds which complicates the calculation a bit but i think not in the favour of the aeroplane.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by p_l on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:26PM (#31899539)
A little remembered thing about Concorde is that it was wildly popular for charter flights from UK to various warm island countries during the winter - to the point that Concorde revenues would be majority in some winter quarters.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday June 26, 2022 @09:29PM (#31889702)
> When the Concorde came along it became clear that you couldn't manage this trick because you'd have to take off and land late at night

What are you referring to here? Is it the noise restrictions? The Concorde was restricted from flying over land because of sonic booms, but that just means you slow down to subsonic speeds just before hitting land on transoceanic flights.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by PaulHoule on Sunday June 26, 2022 @09:33PM (#31889728)
It was noisy as hell taking off because the engines and wing were not optimized for low speed flight.

Airports like JFK and Heathrow all close down in sleeping hours because even conventional aircraft (especially the 737) would wake people up at 2 am.

It is a tough problem balancing good supersonic performance with being able to take off and land. This is why people have considered radical solutions such as an airplane that turns 90 degrees when it goes transsonic. One reason why the SR-71 was successful was that it took off with just barely enough fuel to reach a refueling tanker, a trick you can’t manage with a civil airliner.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by Fatnino on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:06AM (#31890473)
You dont need to carry fuel though. Solar on top of the airship can keep it moving along indefinitely, paired the ability to hang around aloft while waiting for more sun.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by walrus01 on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:57AM (#31890727)
Photovoltaics are way less powerful than you give them credit for, unless you want the electric motors to only push it at 10 knots... Where pv excels is cumulative kWh per month collection from something like a big cheap ground based array, the amount of watt hours you could collect in 12 hours from a top half of an airship covered in PV is not a lot, compared to the load of powerful electric motors.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by Tade0 on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:11AM (#31891847)
I did the math for USS Akron, which was around 240x40m and was propelled by a 3.3MW power plant.

It has a projected surface area of 7500m2, which, using modern, 22% efficient monocrystalline panels, yields 1.65MW, or half the desired amount, which I assume was used mostly for liftoff.

In any case it's the same order of magnitude, so should be at least somewhat useful.

There's always the question of weight, but much of that is the usual glass and aluminium casing.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by Denvercoder9 on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:45AM (#31892022)
> which I assume was used mostly for liftoff

Doubtful. It was filled with helium, so it would lift off on its own by virtue of being lighter than air. That power was necessary for propulsion.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by sandworm101 on Monday June 27, 2022 @06:19AM (#31892598)
The devide your numbers in half because sun will only ever hit half the airship. Then realize that when you neee power the most, in bad weather, the sun wont be there. Then subtract the mass of all those panels from the availible payload.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by ben_w on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:23AM (#31893535)
From @Tade0 writing "projected surface area", they have already accounted for the fraction in sunlight. You can also tell this is what was meant by noting a rectangle of those dimensions is larger than the stated projected area, which you should expect from the pointy bits on the ends.

The weather that destroyed the USS Akron seems rather more important than the power source. I wonder if we can reliably make them go above or around clouds these days? I’ve not noticed clear air turbulence in air travel since I was a kid.

If you have a positive answer on the weather safety, and if the PV is light enough that it could be considered a way of reducing fuel use rather than a Boolean yes/no decision to either fully replace a chemical fuel or not use it at all, it seems worth investigating.

Edit: Just realised, while I’m usually unconvinced by RF beamed power, but with that surface area, and the general form of the inner frame, and it being in the sky so less danger from industrial accidents, this might possibly be a case where it could work.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by TylerE on Monday June 27, 2022 @03:41AM (#31891661)
Not indefinitely.

Do descend they must vent lifting gas, and you can never get that back.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by smolder on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:14AM (#31891858)
Alternatively, the lifting gas can be compressed to raise the density and descend.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by TylerE on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:48AM (#31895325)
Why would that change anything? Neither mass nor volume (of the craft) changs.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by Fatnino on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:38PM (#31900466)
Volume is changing somewhere. You compressed a gas bag so now normal outside air fills that space and your airship is heavier.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by TylerE on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:49PM (#31900596)
It's a rigid envelope, not a gas bag. The volume doesn't change, and you certainly wouldn't mix in atmospheric air.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by smolder on Monday June 27, 2022 @10:00PM (#31903289)
I don't think it's infeasible that air could displace the lifting gas that was compressed, even in a rigid envelope. You could maybe build flexible bladders on the inside for this purpose. Another way to add weight using the same principle would just be to compress outside air into rigid tanks on the craft, making it heavier.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by devilbunny on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @03:51PM (#31912195)
Dirigibles are rigid airframes, not rigid gas containers. They used gas bags to displace normal air from inside the frame and replace it with lifting gas.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by jhgb on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:21AM (#31893519)
Why would you vent it? That's what ballonets are for.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by cagenut on Sunday June 26, 2022 @09:31PM (#31889721)
I feel like doing this analysis without accounting for carbon is the mathematical version of climate change denial. Like, to not account for it is to deny it needs to be.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by jessriedel on Sunday June 26, 2022 @08:31PM (#31889400)
Airships can also be useful over land even in places with dense rail/road networks if the cargo is too large for rail/road. A primary example is factory-built housing: currently, such houses have to be manufactured in pieces small enough to go on a truck and then assembled on-site, increasing cost. But if you can build larger sections (or even the whole house) at the factory and just air-lift it to the site, it could be much more efficient.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by m4rtink on Monday June 27, 2022 @04:28AM (#31891937)
Note that when the airship drops a heavy load, it might shoot into the stratosphere unless an action is taken due to suddenly having so much lift.

So either you have to vent potentially expensive lifting gas - or get some replacement load, such as water or even a load of rocks. Not an impossible to solve but some site preparation is needed.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by usrusr on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:14AM (#31893445)
But it's much easier to truck in a few dozen tons of ballast than to truck in, say, a 400 ft rotor blade. Transport is seriously limiting wind power, not just because larger gets better wind but also because larger would actually get less nimby, not more: rpm scales inversely with size, and rpm is what draws our attention to where we don't want it.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by bewo001 on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:22AM (#31893524)
That was the idea of CargoLifter (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter). The plan was to build an airship that can lift 160 t of oversized payload and beat train or road transport on price and speed.

They ran out of money before they could build anything useful (besides a mighty hangar).

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by killjoywashere on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:33PM (#31890312)
Yeah, uncontested landlocked airspace is a clear winner for blimps, and the US military didn't forget that:

https://www.lockheedmartin.com/en-us/news/features/history/p...

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by echelon on Sunday June 26, 2022 @08:30PM (#31889396)
If airship startups stopped trying to make them safe by filling them with precious helium, we could have affordable autonomous bulk cargo transports.

If hydrogen airships "explode" at some small rate < 0.0001%, they can stick to transportation corridors away from population centers for the majority of their route to destination.

It seems easier to replace a trucking fleet with autonomous hydrogen-powered airships than to have 100% safe self-driving semis operating on the road alongside human drivers.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by nradov on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:29PM (#31890296)
There might be a niche market for autonomous hydrogen airships in some other countries, but it would be decades before the FAA allowed commercial use anywhere in the USA.
Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by worik on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:38AM (#31890639)
Really?

Given jets take off in very marginal conditions with tonnes of high octane fuel n their wings.

Is the FAA that much of a bigot? The Hindenburg was minor compared to what we regularly see in crashing jets.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by nradov on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:30AM (#31894340)
Yes really. Hydrogen isn't allowed as a lifting gas. Congress would probably have to pass legislation to allow it.

https://www.thecgo.org/benchmark/bring-back-hydrogen-lifting...

Besides the lifting gas, the previous comment mentioned "autonomous". The FAA also prohibits autonomous aircraft outside some very limited designated airspace. Until that ban is lifted, they can't be used for any real commercial service.

Re:The giant hangar poised for an aviation revolution by holri on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:36AM (#31893681)
I think it is shortsighted to look at it with the economics of the past. CO2 emissions change the equation significantly.