News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by Waterluvian on Thursday June 23, 2022 @07:56PM (#31856503)
“but at least it's a law, created by a democratically accountable legislature.”

I feel like we need to stop lying to ourselves like this.

Copyright is getting ridiculously out of hand because lobbyists hold the power and the system is not really accountable anymore.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by zdragnar on Thursday June 23, 2022 @08:19PM (#31856624)
Congress doesn't even bother reading the bills they pass. Most of the actual details are deferred to the administrative bureaucracy.

That's where the real power is.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by bitexploder on Thursday June 23, 2022 @08:51PM (#31856785)
The deep state is a real thing. I don’t think it has to be explicitly negative, but there are a lot of unelected bureaucrats that hold a lot of power with minimal accountability and visibility.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by sailfast on Thursday June 23, 2022 @11:24PM (#31857454)
Such as? Not trying to be pedantic, just looking for a more specific example. Are you talking about political appointees or public servants? If so, where? What agencies?
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by thaumasiotes on Friday June 24, 2022 @05:59AM (#31859672)
Here is a right-coded example of a hypothetical agency behavior with many claimed historical occurrences:

Suppose you are the EPA and you'd like to implement some environmental rule that might or might not be strictly within your legal powers.

You work out a deal with a friendly organization and they sue you for improper stewardship of the environment (with details, obviously, according to the rule you want to implement). Then, instead of fighting their lawsuit, you settle it, agreeing to their demands -- which consist of the rule you wanted to implement. That rule is now one you are obligated to enforce pursuant to a legal agreement, instead of something you implemented on your own authority. This structure tends to prevent normal accountability mechanisms from working.

(As a side note, I'm always surprised, when I see descriptions of this tactic, that it's permissible for an agency to agree to take actions that are notionally not within the power of the agency. I would be interested to know more about what exactly is going on there.)

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by zdragnar on Friday June 24, 2022 @08:02AM (#31860494)
On June 17, the Secretary of Interior ordered the Department of Interior to take down a public website detailing settlement agreements and final dispositions.

Score one for losing transparency into the cycle of bureaucrats funding former bureaucrats of similar political alignment by abusing the courts.

It's really sad when you realize that Trump's administration (when the initial rule establishing the website) was more transparent than Bidens. Before, the settlements were posted immediately; now, if you even know about them at all, you need to wait months after filing a FOIA to find out about it.

Some of the more prolific groups have been getting 1 to 3 million dollars a year from the settlements alone.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by sailfast on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @08:47PM (#31915116)
Fascinating. Thanks. It's not surprising to see some of these types of things getting thrown out in the end when challenged by someone on the other side of the agreement.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by bitexploder on Friday June 24, 2022 @10:36PM (#31871968)
Rocky flats was one of the only times one agency raided another. Wild stuff.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by bitexploder on Friday June 24, 2022 @07:50AM (#31860393)
Heads of many agencies are appointed, but all of the institutional knowledge of say the NSA, CIA, FBI, etc is buried within the organization. If you want anything done you must work within those organizations. Places like the OMB and the layers that support congress. Power brokers from their day like Karl Rove and Grover Norquist. The lobbyists that actually write the laws congress signs, the “negotiators” they use to horse trader. The military more directly serves the president, but these other agencies have accreted tremendous power. I don’t think it is some grand conspiracy, but the US government is a massive organism and some of its organs are harder to control than others.

In simple terms: were they elected and do you pay for their salary?

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by vajrabum on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:00PM (#31856823)
Are you talking about Government employees or lobbyists? BTW, notice that their power is circumscribed by the law. When that changes their powers change.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:01PM (#31856826)
Lmao what? They write the laws! Think tanks are literally paid to draft legislation
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by sailfast on Thursday June 23, 2022 @11:25PM (#31857456)
Think tanks are not the government. They are private institutions.

Typically when one uses the term "deep state" you mean someone working in the government that has their own agenda and/or are acting on a specific conspiracy / cabal agenda counter to the direction of, say, the administration providing the guidance and direction. This is why the person asked about employees vs. lobbyists.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Friday June 24, 2022 @06:34AM (#31859864)
Yea, its the normal government and the deep state is the fact that its actually controlled by corporations and lobbyists. The corporations and lobbyists and think tanks are the deep state. They're the ones really in control, spreading propaganda and getting Americans to vote against their personal interests. Politicians are the biggest cucks for capitalism because they all get rich in office by fearing the corporate lobbyists and giving them the legislation that they want. That's the deep state
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by ajvs on Saturday June 25, 2022 @04:33AM (#31873519)
Whilst I agree that external moneyed interests control the US government to a large degree via the aforementioned mechanisms, this is not what people refer to when they say Deep State.

Deep State refers to government employees who hold a lot of power e.g. heads of alphabet agencies, their close underlings, etc and wield it in such a way that there's little recourse for the average American.

Both these moneyed interests AND the Deep State exert an influence that citizens should seek to regulate.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Saturday June 25, 2022 @10:09AM (#31875423)
What I'm saying is that those people in government who could be considered "deep state" are the ones appointed due to the money in politics. I agree that there is unaccountability but it all comes down to money and corporate power

The ones with the money and corporate power are pulling the strings of those who they install

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Thursday June 23, 2022 @08:59PM (#31856821)
Yea its the corporations, lobbyists, think-tanks and those who pay them. Its consolidation of corporate power. Its fascism
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by sailfast on Thursday June 23, 2022 @11:23PM (#31857445)
It's a nice fantasy, but it's simply not the case in my experience. The details are deferred because you want to be able to adapt some things faster than you can change a law and you want it done with a comment period by subject matter experts, rather than by legislators.

In general, however, those agencies are slow moving (requires comment period, must decide given bounds, funding limited, etc) and pretty narrowly handcuffed / acting within the statute. Recently even those narrow powers have been rejected by the courts (see admin law judges, CFPB single director, etc).

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by thfuran on Friday June 24, 2022 @07:31AM (#31860243)
>it's simply not the case in my experience

And how much US Congressional experience do you have?

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by sailfast on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @08:51PM (#31915145)
US Congress is explicitly elected. OP mentions UNelected bureaucrats. I have many years of experience as an unelected bureaucrat at the federal level.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by GaylordTuring on Friday June 24, 2022 @06:10AM (#31859726)
If that's the case, that's because the people are choosing crappy politicians who let that happen. If a father of a family lets the five-year old decide where to live, what to eat, and what to buy, that doesn't mean the five-year old has the power, it just means that the father has voluntarily given the power to him. However, he could take it back whenever he felt like it.

Same thing goes for lobbyists. They would have zero power if politicians gave them zero power. If the population would be smart and informed, this wouldn't happen. So, what's happening now is totally a result of democracy, which of course is a totally ridiculous idea^1, but it's still democratic.

[1]: Let people who have absolutely no idea how to run things decide who should run things. That's like if the passengers of an airplane, having zero experience with aviation, deciding on who the captain should be.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by rightbyte on Friday June 24, 2022 @07:14AM (#31860111)
> That's like if the passengers of an airplane, having zero experience with aviation, deciding on who the captain should be.

I guess they would vote for an airliner captain? E.g. most people go to doctors for medical adcive rather than new age mumbo jumbo. I don't see the problem in this particular case.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by thfuran on Friday June 24, 2022 @07:27AM (#31860207)
A surprisingly large number of people go in for the new age mumbo jumbo or, uh, old-timey mumbo jumbo. And that despite quite heavy regulation on medical claims and on the qualifications of medical practicianers.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by sailfast on Thursday June 23, 2022 @11:19PM (#31857429)
Folks still need to get re-elected, even if it's heavily favoring lobbyists. That is still SOMETHING, rather than a company creating something out of thin air. In this the OP is correct. It's not a lie, and your vote counts.

For what it's worth, it's not so much lobbyists as the ability to generate dollars period (many lobbyists aren't actually very good at this), and there's still power there in numbers as seen in recent elections so don't sell yourself short if you have a compelling case to make. Just sayin'! :)

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by ww520 on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:12PM (#31856876)
We need to have a national proposition system that let citizens put forth legislative bills into the ballots, to let the citizens vote on the strongly concerned matters. When Congress obviously is not doing their jobs, the citizens should have a way to pick up the slack. It's a better way to check and balance the sellout of the legislative branch to the lobbyists.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by toast0 on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:20AM (#31858347)
Please no. I lived in California for much of my life. Statewide propositions are plenty thanks.

It's too easy to get voters to vote for things that are deceptively drafted, and then you're stuck with it forever.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:19PM (#31856917)
Our system was literally designed to prevent citizens from having any say. See the supreme court and the reasons Alexander Hamilton said it was needed
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by clucas on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:51PM (#31857054)
"Prevent us from having any say"??

Legislators are directly elected, president is elected somewhat indirectly but largely by popular vote, administrative rule making has notice and comment process, Article 3 judges are appointed by President and confirmed by legislature... everything derived from the will of the people. It sounds like you are upset that more people aren't as upset at the same things you are. That's not a problem with the government, that's a problem with the populace.

Organize a petition to have your congressional rep submit a bill for what you want. If they refuse, find someone to run who will do it. Actually do something, don't just post online about how the government isn't working... make it work for you!

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by ceejayoz on Thursday June 23, 2022 @11:01PM (#31857340)
Much of what you describe is an evolution from the original design.

https://theconversation.com/the-right-to-vote-is-not-in-the-...

> At the Constitutional Convention in 1787, Madison expressed the prevailing view that “the freeholders of the country would be the safest depositories of republican liberty,” meaning only people who owned land debt-free, without mortgages, would be able to vote. The Constitution left voting rules to individual states, which had long-standing laws limiting the vote to those freeholders.

> In the debates over the ratification of the Constitution, Madison trumpeted a benefit of the new system: the “total exclusion of the people in their collective capacity.” Even as the nation shifted toward broader inclusion in politics, Madison maintained his view that rights were fragile and ordinary people untrustworthy. In his 70s, he opposed the expansion of the franchise to nonlanded citizens when it was considered at Virginia’s Constitutional Convention in 1829, emphasizing that “the great danger is that the majority may not sufficiently respect the rights of the Minority.”

There's a reason the Constitution, as originally written, doesn't actually guarantee anyone the right to vote. Even today, it wouldn't be unconstitutional to, say, ban redheads or people born on Tuesday from voting.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by Dylan16807 on Friday June 24, 2022 @02:57AM (#31858553)
> Even today, it wouldn't be unconstitutional to, say, ban redheads or people born on Tuesday from voting.

I think the 14th amendment would block any such ban, since 15/19/24/26 make it clear that this is a right people have by default.

And that's ignoring how hair color ties into race.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by ceejayoz on Friday June 24, 2022 @10:03AM (#31861981)
> since 15/19/24/26 make it clear that this is a right people have by default

No, they say the opposite. They set up specific conditions you can't use to disqualify for voting. It's a short list.

> And that's ignoring how hair color ties into race.

SCOTUS is pretty good at that. See the just announced Marietta case; Congress said you can't discriminate against end-stage renal failure patients. An insurer decided they'd get around it by not covering outpatient dialysis - of which 99.5% of patients are end-stage renal failure - and SCOTUS permitted it.

Kagan's dissent correctly pointed out it's like banning yarmulkes and claiming you're not discriminating against Jews.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by Dylan16807 on Friday June 24, 2022 @10:42AM (#31862749)
> No, they say the opposite. They set up specific conditions you can't use to disqualify for voting. It's a short list.

Those amendments don't directly give maximum protection, but they establish it as a right, which seems to indirectly give pretty good protection.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by ceejayoz on Friday June 24, 2022 @11:10AM (#31863428)
We needed the various amendments because it was entirely legal to forbid voting based on race, gender, age, etc. That implies it's still legal to forbid voting based on other reasons not listed.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by Dylan16807 on Friday June 24, 2022 @04:02PM (#31868544)
The 24th and 26th were making adjustments to voting restrictions that were allowed by the 14th. Those rules applied to everyone in theory.

The 15th is kind of iffy, but slavery interacts weirdly with citizenship to begin with. And before the 15th there was nothing calling voting a right.

As far as the 19th goes, the 14th was in big part scoped to male voters at the time.

Overall I think it would be pretty hard to argue the constitutionality of any restriction that isn't applied "evenly".

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Friday June 24, 2022 @01:32PM (#31866244)
Wow it sounds like we shouldn't be forbidding people from voting at all, why the hell would we make specific carve outs. Its absolutely absurd, almost like the people who wrote the legislation wanted it that way
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Friday June 24, 2022 @06:37AM (#31859878)
Its only illegal if you're explicitly excluding people

Oh but if you make laws that just happen to make it harder for black people and Latinos to vote, its just a bad coincidence yea? Awe so sad, wish we could do something about it!

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by oyashirochama on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:47PM (#31857036)
I feel that both are needed, almost like a third house that is a populist based voting system. You get issues with mob mentality and it can cause tragedies just as easy as representative systems can.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by nabla9 on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:08AM (#31858599)
That is lame counterargument from lazy and ignorant citizenry.

Democratically accountable legislature is still democratically accountable legislature when the citizens pay attention or participate or not. People are supposed to work their ass off in democracy when they fight for political power. Instead they treat it as a opinion contest that should have options they like.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by krnlpnc on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:03PM (#31856835)
> lobbyists hold the power and the system is not really accountable anymore

Yes, and the problem is not limited to copyright

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by totetsu on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:13AM (#31858622)
https://citizenstakeaction.org/ Organizing for campaign finance reforms to return power to voters.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by kubanczyk on Friday June 24, 2022 @03:52AM (#31858865)
I like the format of your comment (leaving aside the political agenda):

"This is the organization. And this is the idea."

All I see on the sociopolitical HN threads is an avalanche of brilliant ideas. But ~nobody is organized, is trying to organize, or even is theorizing about it. It just feels so empty and futile, makes me weep deep inside.

Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by ntoskrnl on Thursday June 23, 2022 @08:38PM (#31856706)
I think he's talking about the original copyright law from 1790, back before congress lost the ability to pass productive legislation
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by feet on Thursday June 23, 2022 @08:51PM (#31856781)
Yea, too bad that doesn't matter because it was modified. So that literally doesn't matter
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by Schroedingersat on Thursday June 23, 2022 @09:12PM (#31856874)
Well that was a top down undemocratic law designed to enforce censorship and stop the proles getting out of line, so not really.
Re:Schroedinger's streaming service just died by raverbashing on Friday June 24, 2022 @12:41AM (#31857875)
"Easy" solution: have the people who got rich with alternative platforms lobby as well