News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by HillRat on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:45AM (#31779922)
Even so, they're not protected against being fired -- circulating an internal letter criticizing leadership is, in a right to work state without existing workplace union agreements and outside of a whistleblower or other protected situation, enough to get you fired, though not fired for cause. Are the optics bad? Yes. Is it indicative that "free speech absolutist" Musk believes your right to speech ends where his feelings get hurt? Certainly! But there isn't much the employees can do other than claim unemployment and then bring their talents to a competitor.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by toomanyrichies on Friday June 17, 2022 @11:56AM (#31780103)
Except for Montana, every state in the US is an at-will employment state. Meaning the employer (and the employee) may terminate employment at any time, with or without cause or prior notice. In circumstances like this, the idea of "X is enough to get you fired" loses its meaning, since "X" could mean anything or nothing at all.

Therefore, the relevant question is not "is the company within its rights to fire these employees", but rather "was it a good idea for the company to fire these employees".

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by BobbyJo on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:38PM (#31780772)
> "X" could mean anything or nothing at all.

Somewhat untrue in theory. Completely untrue in practice. There are a few things you legally cannot be fired for, and a whole plethora of things a company would need to very very careful about firing you for, lest they wind up in court.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by mbesto on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:35PM (#31780725)
Which makes this whole thread hilarious, because so many people are implying wrongful termination, which, to your point, doesn't really matter. Unless of course the individual is a protected class.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by kube-system on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:40PM (#31780808)
Firing someone for belonging to a protected class is only one of many types of wrongful termination. There are several other types of illegal terminations.

There are also laws that prohibit employers from punishing employees in certain circumstances relating to organizing/petitioning when in regard to concerns about workplace issues.

For example:

>You have the right to act with co-workers to address work-related issues in many ways. Examples include: [...] joining with co-workers to talk directly to your employer, to a government agency, or to the media about problems in your workplace

https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/em...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by noasaservice on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:30PM (#31780651)
And in many of those states, you can be fired for simply being gay or trans.

edit: Given how fast this post hit -4, I have to assume that these people are *OK* with being able to fire gay or trans people at a whim. That ain't cool, one bit.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by fknorangesite on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:51PM (#31780959)
No, you're being downvoted because you are, thankfully, wrong:

Supreme Court rules workers can’t be fired for being gay or transgender

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/06/15/supreme-court-rules-workers-...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by noasaservice on Saturday June 18, 2022 @07:00PM (#31794570)
Oh please. You're "technically right", being the worst kind of right... And also just plain wrong.

Instead it's called "lack of culture fit", "insubordination", or a myriad of any other right-to-work excuses as to fire someone you disagree with.

But yes, for those stupid enough to put "Fired because of gay", well, it still is legal due to the loopholes a Mack Truck could drive through. https://www.courierpress.com/story/opinion/columnists/jon-we...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by bko on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:15PM (#31780387)
What other organization wouldn't let go of someone under these circumstances? Are there any employees that openly, pulicaly and very vocally criticize their leadership

Imagine working with someone like this? If you've been in an organization with people are constantly getting into flame wars about political issues, its incredibly distracting to those that want to get work done.

Some people buy the whole "we're a family" HR spin, but its not true. You're there to do a job and you're paid to do so.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:20PM (#31780477)
> What other organization wouldn't let go of someone under these circumstances?

Any organization that's worth working at, obviously. And there are plenty of them.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by kube-system on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:27PM (#31780601)
The organizations that are worth working at don't have employees who have a reason to publicly criticize their leaders because their leaders effectively manage internal affairs internally.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by fundad on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:57PM (#31781038)
Yeah people give him the benefit of the doubt that the is meeting his fiduciary obligations because he's CEO. They assume if the CEO does it, it's good for what he wants for his companies. We know it's more about his ego but are we going to argue that fiduciary obligation isn't enforced to people who are obviously part of a death cult?
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:11PM (#31781209)
Yep, exactly right. Instead SpaceX gets Gwynne acting as Musk’s mouthpiece/enforcer. I would kill to know how she really feels about all this considering that the company is primarily her success.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by bko on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:25PM (#31780559)
Give me an example of someone doing this in another organization. Would you be willing to share your organization and any criticism you have of leadership?
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:31PM (#31780670)
https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/9/22375913/alphabet-employee...

I don't have any complaints about my current organization, but whenever I feel something has transgressed my personal code of ethics I'm first very vocal about it internally and if necessary externally. I've only ever left companies voluntarily after this, and most have made efforts for me to stay. And it's not like I've been working at the most progressive companies ever.. maybe just don't work at a Musk company.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by bko on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:46PM (#31780883)
Google has fired plenty of people for openly criticizing them. I never said an organization will necessarily fire someone for openly criticizing leadership. It's a case by case but within their right.

I personally think its obnoxious and counterproductive for someone to call management out publicly. That's no way to operate an organization. Its a sign that someone is toxic. Some orgs like Bridgewater tried that but that's def not a place I would want to work. The appropriate channels and structure exist for a reason. They're not perfect but I'm not arrogant enough to think I know better than everyone else

https://www.cnet.com/tech/google-fires-another-ai-researcher...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:03PM (#31781121)
> I personally think its obnoxious and counterproductive for someone to call management out publicly. That's no way to operate an organization. Its a sign that someone is toxic.

Seems like we have come to the real root of things! We can agree to disagree.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by sanity31415 on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:14PM (#31781256)
I'd hate to work anywhere that tolerated this kind of narcissistic employee "activism", glad that companies are finally putting a stop to it.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by femiagbabiaka on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:31PM (#31781486)
Interesting! What would you do if, for example, the leadership of your company said they were going to start implementing illegal policies preferring people of certain races or sexes for job reqs? Would you say nothing? Leave?
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by andrepd on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:33PM (#31780696)
I have privately and openly criticised my employer on several occasions, and never have I been sacked for that.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:47PM (#31780899)
> have privately and openly criticised my employer on several occasions

Huge difference between calling out issues and publicly demanding the CEO to be fired.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by kube-system on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:54PM (#31781011)
The letter being circulated doesn't ask for Elon to be fired.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by fundad on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:47PM (#31780903)
Chances are it won't be found to be retaliation against workers organizing for working conditions with less drama. Even if it is and they get fined, for them it's just a fee.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by stevenwoo on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:38PM (#31780770)
Basecamp and github most recently off the top of my head. IIRC one of Basecamp's founders is about the same ballpark as Musk and was called out to his face at a company meeting and on the other side Github kept the Nazi sympathizer who criticized the Jewish employee for complaining about Nazis, but fired the HR decision maker and tried to rehire the Jewish employee.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by fundad on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:50PM (#31780952)
Yeah it's not about progressive vs conservative, it's industry vs workers. The managers who are good to their workers get weeded out before making it to the top.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by runarberg on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:43PM (#31780837)
Common. If your CEO is making extremely inflammatory political statements publicly, and you don’t agree with those statements you are kind of in a dilemma. You either remain silent and and be perceived as broadly agreeing with—or at least tolerating—the CEO’s statements, or you speak out against them. In either case you are making a political decision.

Elon Musk put his workers in this dilemma and he should have expected a subset of them to speak out critically against him. I honestly don’t know other large organizations in our industry that is in the same situation, so there is really nothing to compare it with.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by logifail on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:34PM (#31780708)
> Musk believes your right to speech ends where his feelings get hurt?

It could be that Musk recognises that a significant group of his staff - likely the majority - simply don't want a loud minority group - possibly a tiny minority - "making waves" and intimidating others into joining their cause.

I've just started Nassim Nicholas Taleb's latest book, but in previous work he wrote about "The Most Intolerant Wins: The Dictatorship of the Small Minority"[0]

This example could easily be one of those instances.

Back in the old days(!) one was expected to do one's job well, to treat others professionally - and to expect others to treat you well - but don't bring your private causes into the workplace and expect everyone to love you for it. Do what you like on your own time, but on the company's time, follow the rules.

[0]https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dict...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by trs8080 on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:49PM (#31780930)
> Back in the old days(!) one was expected to do one's job well, to treat others professionally - and to expect others to treat you well - but don't bring your private causes into the workplace and expect everyone to love you for it.

Excluding of course, the CEO of the company in question. He can say anything he wants, fight with and call people pedophiles on Twitter, run a crypto pump and dump scheme, spread pandemic conspiracies, etc etc etc to the point that investors in his companies have spoken up about it and now his own employees are writing letters. That behavior is totally professional and ok.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by HillRat on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:31PM (#31786220)
Also worth noting that in “the old days,” the sphere of “treating others professionally” didn’t encompass women, gays, blacks, Jews, and other ethnic, religious, or social minorities — and protesting that was considered “bringing your private causes into the workplace.”
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by notahacker on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:48PM (#31780918)
> It could be that Musk recognises that a significant group of his staff - likely the majority - simply don't want a loud minority group - possibly a tiny minority - "making waves" and intimidating others

That's also Twitter's policy on trolling and harassment which his totally sincere "free speech absolutism" seeks to end.

Intimidation isn't asking fellow employees if they agree with the content of an open letter, it's public figures calling a blogger and telling them if their blog criticising Tesla isn't taken down, their totally unrelated boss will be getting a phone call . Guess which one Musk personally involved himself in...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by logifail on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:16PM (#31782166)
> Intimidation isn't asking fellow employees if they agree with the content of an open letter [..]

Errm, if fellow employees feel intimidated by you pitching up and asking them to sign, that's what we call intimidation, at least these days.

If you want to organise an open letter, put it up somewhere public, tell everyone involved, and wait for people to sign it? Or not, it's their choice.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by notahacker on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:29PM (#31782362)
Like... send email circular asking people if they wanted to participate in a survey and maybe sign an open letter posted on SpaceX communication channels you mean?

So far, the only person who has suggested employees felt intimidated is the COO defending the decision to fire them. Just in case you were inclined to actually believe that her priority was to encourage employees to speak out against harassment and not intimidate them into silence she added that the company had "too much critical work to accomplish", no place for "activism" and told remaining employees to "stay focused",

I mean, I accept it's theoretically possible the real intimidation wasn't the COO firing 5 people for the "unacceptable" sending of emails asking people if they agreed with their views about management and the anti-harassment policy "during the work day", but I'm going to file that one away under very unlikely

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by logifail on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:36PM (#31782454)
Q: Are there (m)any COOs who think their companies should focus on activism and not, you know, actual work?

Perhaps people who support activism should just start their own companies - as majority shareholders they could easily mandate that management specify time to be spent on activism... no need for focus.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by notahacker on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:55PM (#31782702)
> If you want to organise an open letter, put it up somewhere public, tell everyone involved, and wait for people to sign it? Or not, it's their choice.

> Perhaps people who support activism should just start their own companies

Got it. Employees should sort of organise an open letter and tell everyone involved but also not organise an open letter or tell anyone because how employees spend their waking hours and what they should think is up to management.

Also, sending an email circular asking people to sign a petition is intimidation, but telling people that activism is an "unacceptable" loss of focus whilst announcing firings is all about protecting people from intolerance of other viewpoints.

I mean, employers can and do fire people all the time for embarrassing the company, though doing it for criticising the CEO and insufficiently strong protections from harassment tends to be dodgy ground. But the idea that they're doing so to promote tolerance is the most Orwellian bullshit take imaginable. Popper's paradox of tolerance is about what level of safeguard is necessary to prevent free speech democracies from collapsing, not making it clear that people aren't allowed to criticise their boss and especially not on company time.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by logifail on Friday June 17, 2022 @03:21PM (#31783034)
> Employees should sort of organise [..]

It's not clear whether employees should be using company resources and company time to organise against the company or its management. Is that something we think is a given right? If so, why?

There is a reason that during a (legitimate!) strike pickets have to stand off their employer's property. We had that in the 70s with the NUM, we had that in 2010 when BA strikers were prohibited from entering (private) Heathrow property[1]

> the idea that they're doing so to promote tolerance is the most Orwellian bullshit take imaginable

1) there's quite a lack of tolerance left of centre, and 2) context is everything.

Your starter for ten: I'll give you a quote, so without searching, take a wild guess who said it...

> "Everybody understands all lives matter. Everybody wants strong, effective law enforcement."

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2010/mar/16/british-air...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by notahacker on Friday June 17, 2022 @05:48PM (#31784823)
2) context is everything.

Indeed. The context has nothing to do with weird digressions about the tolerance of the left or picket line legislation in the UK. The context is that a company fired some people for sending emails criticising a CEO with a long track record of being even less tolerant of criticism than the average CEO whilst asserting it's unacceptable for staff to question the company's anti-harassment policies. The context is the CEO also has a track record of threatening to get people who never worked with him fired from their completely unrelated job if they don't take their blog posts criticising him and his company down. Stating that he may be legally entitled to do this is one thing. Citing the paradox of tolerance to argue that cancelling people who criticise Elon Musk and ruling out the possibility of debate on SpaceX harassment policy is in fact compatible with "free speech absolutism", because email circulars questioning the boss' behaviour and harassment policies (or blogging on SeekingAlpha, I guess) intimidates people is... something else entirely.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by dlp211 on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:51PM (#31780960)
I think that it's interesting that you cite "the most intolerant win" and assume that it applies to those trying to change the workplace today and not the de facto work place that you so cherished.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by kmeisthax on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:35PM (#31781545)
This isn't entirely applicable here - the minority group isn't being picky, they are alleging misconduct.

Also, that linked post is something else. In the span of one really long essay, he went from halal food, to trying to intellectually rehabilitate Brexit, to a maximally-extended version of the Paradox of Tolerance, and then finally to disproving the right-libertarian thesis that market manipulation is impossible. I genuinely can't tell if this is brilliantly considered, or just authoritarian right-wingers trying to specifically feed me propaganda.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by mempko on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:15PM (#31781266)
Isn't a group of 1 still a minority? Isn't Musk himself a loud minority of the company who wields lots of power? Isn't SpaceX in this case already a Dictatorship of the Small Minority?
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by willis936 on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:54PM (#31781007)
This take seems to flip reality on its head. The tiny minority is Musk and his followers.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by k1ko on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:15PM (#31782147)
Funny you mention reality. I don't even consider Musk Republican, but let's assume that for the sake of argument. Latest generic congressional polling has Republicans leading by handful of points.

https://ballotpedia.org/Ballotpedia%27s_Polling_Index:_Gener...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by logifail on Friday June 17, 2022 @02:26PM (#31782314)
> The tiny minority is Musk

As Terry Pratchett so wonderfully put it in Making Money (Discworld #36)[0], there is "a piece of ancient magic called [..] fifty-one percent of the shares".

As far as what happens at SpaceX goes, Musk isn't the minority. He's the (?? 78%) majority owner.

So, if you work at SpaceX and don't like him, I think the options boil down to: a) suck it up, or b) find somewhere else to work ...

... or maybe c) leave and start your own SpaceX? We all know competition is good. Of course in that case you'll really have Skin In The Game[1] - and coincidentally that's the Taleb book I've been reading this afternoon.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Making_Money [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skin_in_the_Game_(book)

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by colpabar on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:14PM (#31780364)
> Is it indicative that "free speech absolutist" Musk believes your right to speech ends where his feelings get hurt? Certainly!

I don't really get how musk's feelings on free speech apply here. SpaceX is not the government, and it's not a communications platform. I also think it's unfair to say "his feelings are hurt" - it seems perfectly logical to get rid of employees that so strongly disagree with the way the company is being run.

And I have to wonder, why even work there if that's how you feel? This just looks like another example of a group of people who have "problems" with their company but don't want to give up the pay that it provides them.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by cloutchaser on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:44PM (#31780859)
I think it’s probably even worse than that, it’s a group of people wanting attention and publicity, using a cause that an Elon hating mainstream can use, for mutually helping each other.

I principled person would at least quit before making a scene in the media, rather than spamming many people in the company.

This is look at me behaviour coupled with politics at its worse.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by soSadm4n on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:20PM (#31780470)
Oh but there is more employees can do than just work elsewhere for some other indifferent, childish blowhard; employees could not work until these childish snowflakes are dealt with.

Real trade can happen without the speculation game. Some people may not get to build rocket engines in such a system but the species doesn’t owe a minority of first world engineers everything they want anymore than it owes an even smaller minority of billionaires.

The propaganda has worked really well; you seem to actually believe human agency is coupled only to the money making endeavors before us today.

Past technology is a joke relative to ours and so will these fancy things we make today seem to the future. Fleeing Earth on rockets is not the only path. It’s the only path we are allowed to speak to. Alternatives would cause the wrong people to lose privilege and power.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by Alex3917 on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:33PM (#31780684)
> they're not protected against being fired

Of course they are. Concerted workplace activity to improve workplace conditions is protected under NLRB. It's literally the definition of protected activity.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by steve_g on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:05PM (#31780246)
Could this be a protected concerted activity? In the US, there are some basic protections when two or more employees work together to improve the conditions of their employment. I don't know what does or doesn't qualify for this protection, though.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by Tagbert on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:12PM (#31780332)
And there are probably not clearly defined rules for this. What would need to happen now is for them to file a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board and that group could make a ruling about whether this is protected activity or not.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by groby_b on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:39PM (#31780794)
Ayup. And if they're smart, they hire a lawyer for that.
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by concordDance on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:43PM (#31780843)
> Is it indicative that "free speech absolutist" Musk believes your right to speech ends where his feelings get hurt? Certainly!

I'm sure you can think of reasons other than "feelings getting hurt" for these firings...

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by usrusr on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:38PM (#31780768)
Is there any indication that free speech absolutism of the Muskian kind might also extend to people who aren't "financially independent"?
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by groby_b on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:38PM (#31780777)
The NLRB would like a word with you. They've held that public complaints might qualify as protected activity - and "right to work" doesn't get you a get-out-of-jail-free card for that. The key is that this was "concerted" activity - a group of employees, not a single individual grousing.

I strongly hope the fired individuals do look into getting a labor lawyer representing them.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by thehappypm on Friday June 17, 2022 @12:45PM (#31780879)
“Musk believes your right to speech ends where his feelings get hurt? Certainly! ”

This is totally incorrect.

Free speech in this case is an opinion. The right to free speech is not freedom from consequences for voicing opinions.

Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by davidcbc on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:34PM (#31781531)
Consequences like... being banned by Twitter perhaps?
Re:SpaceX said to fire employees involved in letter rebuking... by mwint on Friday June 17, 2022 @01:54PM (#31781842)
You don’t have a right to not be banned from Twitter. Musk has been saying he thinks the way Twitter bans people is unhealthy for democracy.

Point me to the place he’s said you have a capital-R Right to not be banned from Twitter.