The app does not have the ability to sign transactions on your behalf without your explicit approval.
It's used by a lot of DeFi apps, often with an unlimited amount. It doesn't give control of the tokens to a website, but rather to a contract. It's fine if the contract is secure and immutable, but of course that's not always the case.
It is easy to create a site that asks you to provide your wallet private phrase. The DNS MyEtherWallet hack that I vaguely recall exploited this.
On the other hand, good crypto citizens will just use the web3 library that will request permissions on an ad-hoc basis from your wallet extension (such as MetaMask).
However even then you can scam someone using social engineering: Just tell them "how" to do XYZ. E.g. "To get your free mini-monkey NFT, just connect your wallet with your bored ape, and when the confirm box pops up from metamask just click OK".
The fiat equivalent of course is a site that asks you to log into paypal and send them $1000 - but that is way more obvious than the crypto equivalent, where you interact with a smart contract and it isn't necessary clear ahead of time what will happen. Especially as smart contracts might be used for, for example user registration. If the user registration endpoint asks for money then you could get scammed that way.
When a site initiates a transaction, you can see the address you're interacting with. You should then look up the address on etherscan to see if it has public code and a lot of transactions. Then you should search that address in google and see if the main site links to it. A lot of projects have a list of addresses in their github. You can also inspect the function code. Once you're comfortable, you should add it to your saved addresses on your wallet and next time you'll see the name of the address.
Also you can create a new throw away address, transfer just a little bit of coins to it and interact with the contract. If it does what you think it should do, then you can create a new account and do it again.
It's not perfect. It could be a proxy, so you're not guaranteed the contract you're interacting with.
There's no easy way to "see what a transaction does". You just need to do risk management.
Oh, that’s it? So simple.
How much money would you be spending on this scheme (in transaction fees)?
I wish wallets made it easier to create a burner throw away account or there were some trusted contracts that would create an account, do something and then transfer back to another account. I don't know if anything like that exists or even if the workflow is generalizable enough
https://www.savings.com.au/news/scamwatch-2021
Australians lost a record $323 million to scams in 2021
--
So glad they solved fraud prevention 'decades ago'.
But in the regular banking system we have decades of experience in how to mitigate the impacts of them e.g. account insurance, MFA for any new transfers or over a certain limit, auditing by independent regulators.
The tech community should be keenly aware of this because there are new apps, new languages, new libraries, new plugins, etc all the time, which solve a problem that was pretty much solved already.
You might counter that new things usually have to have some value proposition to gain a footing, like cheaper, faster, more reliable, etc. For one, that's not always true, but also crypto does have a value proposition like that. It's immutable, trustless, and can be anonymous. And it is even cheaper and faster than the regular banking system in some circumstances, depending on the sum being sent and where it goes.
(let's keep the discussions civil)
The only thing I can imagine you’re talking about is when some wannabe domestic terrorists rightfully had their funding declined.
Crypto seems like a convenient way to do this, and the more repressive governments get, the more of a use-case there'll be!
So it's safest to just avoid debit cards, unless you know that the issuer has their own legally-binding limits on cardholder liability.
If entered, the transaction happens on the Maestro et. al. network and you can’t do chargebacks.
If no PIN was entered, the transaction happens on Visa/MC systems and you can chargeback.
Your bank irrespective of whether it's a savings account, credit card etc will almost always insure you against fraud provided you didn't do anything reckless e.g. write your PIN on the card.
This is a well known fact in secure system design. Most people just click through dialogs. If you must get their attention you have to make the dialog huge and scary but then people will usually just turn back instead of reading. Scary dialogs make it seem like you should never say OK.
“Undo” is powerful in any app, not just because it can roll a change back with a single click, but because scary dialog boxes (“Really, really REALLY delete this file? It can not be recovered once deleted, so check this box saying you know what you’re doing before clicking OK”) don’t work for regular apps, either.
Always someone getting burned, but in this case it's the "idiots" for lack of better word. Don't try to make cryptocurrencies work like fiat, that's exactly the kind of problems they're trying to solve.
And let's say someone implements your solution, years later you will read how a bad actor did a chargeback for all the coins in those contracts and you will claim it was a retarded feature from the start.
You didn't even explore any of the options for different types of "undo" operations that could be possible in contracts. You seemed to simply assume recreating the exact same situation that exists in traditional finance and responded based on that.
There are several other ways of doing it that I can think of, all with their own pros and cons. There are even a couple that have already been applied in crypto that I can think of and I'm sure many that I'm not aware of.
And why would you assume I even meant "reimplement traditional chargebacks as they are today"? My recommendation: Hold off on forming strong opinions too early in the process of learning about something.
The internet has kind of conditioned all of us to be OK with passing around complex payment instruments without paying too much attention. If you're a hardcore believer in cryptocurrency as a political project, you almost certainly understand the difference and see the "code is law" dark forest as a feature, not a bug. But if you started buying crypto and NFTs because Matt Damon and Larry David told you to, then you're in for a world of hurt.
"A religion cannot fail, it can only be failed"; I admire your optimism, but I expect that the true believers will not question whether the premise of cryptocurrencies is wrong, but rather will twist themselves in knots to find new scapegoats as to why it doesn't work the way they expected.
This criticism of cryptocurrency would be analogous to criticizing the concept of fiat currency by pointing to the inflation of the deutsche mark as an example. The cryptocurrencies being discussed here are real cryptocurrencies, they are bloated and useless shitcoins. Any credible project would not have all the bloated crap that enables the "exploits" mentioned in the article in the first place.
If it's harder and riskier then the user isn't going to care if it's their fault or not.
Do you want a world where crypto is common and useful, or do you want it where it's the web equivalent of casinos, with some sharks making money off suckers but most people not taking it seriously as a "real" or useful business?
I can and I will. People know not to give out their credit card numbers to fishy businesses or install untrustworthy software on their computer. Why does that personal responsibility suddenly disappear when we talk about cryptocurrency?
>Do you want a world where crypto is common and useful, or do you want it where it's the web equivalent of casinos, with some sharks making money off suckers but most people not taking it seriously as a "real" or useful business?
The path to the world where crypto is a common and useful tool starts with these speculators and gamblers losing all their monopoly money and leaving. It's no surprise to me that the "scams" and "exploits" mentioned in the article are enabled by bloated "smart contract" cryptocurrencies like etherium that serve little real purpose.
I don't believe victims should be punished. I just don't think victims should be rewarded either. I do think that the perpetrators should be punished.
>Wouldn't it be more compassionate to recover their losses
It would be "compassionate", but it would also encourage people to make risky and stupid decisions. Tough love I suppose.
>Trust shouldn't be seen as a weakness. Trust powers all the best things humans can do. Trust should be rewarded, not punished.
There is a difference between knowledge, trust, and blind faith. Your inability to discriminate between the three is what allows you to mix these unrelated platitudes.
What you call tough love, I call inflicting trauma that makes everyone worse off. No one should ever risk being destitute. There's no societal benefit to risks with a downside of total loss.
And that's why I think your comment of blind faith was a non-sequitor. I'm not advocating for blind faith, I'm advocating for informed faith. I think we should have an informed assumption that the risk in a scam is on the part of the scammer. When something blows up, the scammer pays. Let's go ahead and reward people for blowing up scams from the inside.
In the case of crypto/investment fraud, you have to take into account that all investments and transactions bear a certain amount of risk and reward. It's not fair to expect the public to bail you out for risks that you knowingly accepted when they wouldn't get a slice of the reward. In the conventional financial system, the public sees a slice of that reward through taxation. The same is not true of cryptocurrency, so why use everyone else's tax dollars to regulate it?
The only reason authorities like the SEC exist is to reduce risk, thus increasing the amount that ordinary people can safely invest. It's not a matter of ethics, it's a matter of economics.
You should maybe run that past a tax attorney just to make sure. I'm in the US, where capital gains from cryptocurrency are taxed just like capital gains from stocks, but of course this may not be true in your jurisdiction.
> The only reason authorities like the SEC exist is to reduce risk, thus increasing the amount that ordinary people can safely invest. It's not a matter of ethics, it's a matter of economics.
I don't think that's correct, but if it is, yeesh! What a bleak hellscape we live in, where the only reason to add safety to anything is to prevent the plebs from getting too scared to spend money.
I take it from your responses that you're one of the "hardcore believers in the 'code is law' dark forest" mentioned in an earlier comment, so I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree.
Of course cryptocurrencies do not have such regulations. the purpose of cryptocurrency is to facilitate exchange with untrusted parties.
I mean, really. The security of the banking/credit system is not even based on public/private key cryptography. There is no notion of a separate spend address vs a sending address. Anyone with access to your (usually open source or easily findable) information can make a transaction on your behalf. Identity theft is a massive problem which is enabled by the current state of the industry.
I think it’s the nature of crypto that part of the benefit comes from the cost of it being up to the individual to maintain. Selling a product/service that consumes crypto or holds it easily might be the answer (like a bank is to usd), now the individual is giving up the keys though.
There’s a trade-off there that is very cool because it only exists because bitcoin adds the option of more reliably securing the money “all by yourself” rather than needing a bank due to physical limitations.
In that sense there are many crypto holders out there that may wish they had just kept it on Coinbase…
TLDR the cost of having it be serious to use crypto is well worth it for the power and value of crypto itself, it’s like the cost otherwise paid to run a bank, put into a different form, the average economy of carelessness
Is it worse than browsers+OSes allowing you to download and run a program? Or Github or npm or browser extensions? All 4 of those could steal all your crypto too if you install them.
The fact that gas fees even exist just boggles the mind.
Bank fees at least on paper pay for overhead of running the wire transfer system. Gas fees (to my uninitiated understanding) literally just pay for the excess waste that is Ethereum, by design.
Basically the fraud described is a twist on the classic "Musk giving away BTC" scam that's all over Youtube because Google is apparently unable to prevent it. You have to be fairly naive to fall for it in the first place. But ok, no victim-blaming. The way you can prevent it on smart contract platforms is simply holding the funds in a smart contract that allows users to set restrictions so that they couldn't take that expensive NFT even if the user mindlessly clicks on a fishing link, connects the wallet and approves the transaction without checking what it is. Same as having a withdrawal limit on your bank card. And you can also whitelist wallets, the contract then automatically blocks any transfers to untrusted wallets. If the user manually overrides this by getting his guardians to agree, there's no stopping them of course.
Ultimately you won't be able to protect everyone. A determined enough fool can also go to Western Union and mail money to the scammer. In the US they have those prepaid card scammers. Or they come to your home, telling you they're police and need to inspect your valuables. Yes, that's a real actual scam that exists in Europe.
You're making a great example of the victim-blaming I mentioned in my comment: That anyone who is surprised by their money disappearing clearly just didn't do all of the right research and use the right wallets and set all the right options to set the right limits and so on and so on.
Obviously there are right ways to navigate the crypto space and not get burned, but the issue is that the crypto community seems to think it's okay that everything is complicated and prone to new users making mistakes that people are routinely losing huge amounts of money due to not being 100% up to date on the right way to do everything.
> The way you can prevent it on smart contract platforms is simply holding the funds in a smart contract that allows users to set restrictions so that they couldn't take that expensive NFT even if the user mindlessly clicks on a fishing link, connects the wallet and approves the transaction without checking what it is.
Yep, sounds easy. To avoid losing everything you just have to set up a smart contract and then...
I can't believe this stuff passes for reasonable suggestions in the crypto world.
With Crypto, payments are irreversible, all transactions are transfers, all payees are equal (no merchants for payments and P2P for transfers) and it all combines together to be the perfect scammer heaven - you can scam people without any repercussions anonymously.
Of course people can use other wallets if they like to. These are open networks just like the internet itself. No one can stop folks from doing dumb stuff online, input their credit card information where they shouldn't, wire thousands of dollars to a "girl" overseas who "loves" them, visit shady sites with their outdated Internet Explorer on a WindowsXP machine... Why didn't Microsoft prevent this!?
Yes, so simple! Just put your coins into this website’s smart contract and you’ll be much more secure.
Btw yes, from a user perspective it actually is very simple and easy to use. It's a good wallet for beginners. Most who're more active and understand the tech have hardware wallets. You could combine the two solutions as well.
The regular non-tech savvy user doesn't necessarily have to understand the details. That's why people are working on such solutions in the first place. Someone experienced with blockchains would never connect their wallet to a random stranger's and approve draining their funds. However the massive hype around them has brought in a lot of new users.
Wallets have come a long way from people writing their private key on a piece of paper back in the early days. The above complaint is bizarre in this context, because what they described is the exact opposite of what's actually happened. Every reputable wallet team has worked hard on improving security over the past years using strategies like social recovery, multi sig, cold storage of keys, etc.
If they got someone to execute a malicious transaction, couldn’t the scammer just `curl etherscan.io/VICTIM`, get the restriction amount and go just under that? With normal banking, everything is closed so you can’t access that kind of information that easily, but since crypto is so open, isn’t this possible?
I see a lot of victim-blaming suggestions that it's the fault of the person who didn't set up a new crypto wallet for every interaction they might want to make and then transfer enough money into said wallet to cover unpredictable gas fees (while also paying gas fees to transfer the money) and then, presumably pay even more gas fees to transfer everything back out of the wallet if it turns out to not be a scam. It's incredible that crypto has reached a point where some people seem to think this is all totally reasonable and natural to expect the average user to know.