News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by steve_adams_86 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @12:55AM (#31537711)
The market being harder for juniors seems correct from what I’m seeing. I’ve been looking frequently for the last month to see what’s out there, and virtually no one I’ve noticed is seeking junior developers.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by AlchemistCamp on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:17AM (#31537802)
I haven't really paid attention to that market for quite a while, but when I was actively looking for a job as a junior dev in SF in 2012, I remember being absolutely maddened by patio11's repeated comments the roaring demand for devs. "Anyone who can fizzbuzz" was the phrase I remember him using.

At that time I was junior, but I'd made and published 3 flash games, hacked on the UI of my WP blog quite a bit and made some basic tools with Node.js. I could definitely fizzbuzz, discuss time and space complexity, solve the equivalent of today's easy leetcode questions and more. And yet I saw my savings dwindle towards zero while reading on HN about how easy it was to get a job as a dev.

My feeling is that there's always been a considerable demand for great devs and very little demand for juniors. I've seen companies advertise positions for interns but I honestly can't recall a single time they were advertising roles for junior or entry level devs.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by BigJono on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:54AM (#31537955)
I lucked into my first job with a startup and never had to go through the job hunt as a junior candidate (other than through a few big company mass grad hire processes which were an absolute fucking joke, and thank god I didn't actually pass any of them), but this mirrors my experience with hiring juniors.

Every time I've done it I've been inundated with candidates. You pretty much have the pick of the litter.

Personally I'd prefer to hire a lot more juniors. I think most senior front-end developers are pretty rubbish at their jobs and have spent most of an easy career on autopilot learning bad habits and bad development practices. I much prefer to work with juniors, before those "senior" (mostly enterprise and consulting) devs have got to them.

The problem is it's just not possible to train juniors the right way fast enough. I'm confident I can train almost anyone with basic programming aptitude to be a 95th percentile front-end dev, but it'll take a year or two, and my already average productivity will tank during it.

Most managers won't understand or accept that. They would, except that there's always someone else selling them the "get people productive in 2 weeks!" bullshit, which you can't compete with. Big companies (the ones with the budget to train juniors) pay a huge amount of lip service to training, but are pretty much universally bad places to actually train great devs. They're good at turning them into average consultants that get flustered with their tools and stuck all the time, because they overengineer everything and never bothered to learn from first principles. (Then they give up and pretend to work while spending 8 hours a day whinging on HN about how bad the JS ecosystem is).

And if you're doing your own thing without managers to mess it up, then you probably live and die by your productivity. Unless someone wants to throw a stack of money at you just to create great devs without accomplishing much else, then it's not gonna happen naturally.

There's other impediments too. I love working in person with juniors, but not as much as I hate commuting. And I think training juniors is one of the few things that's much harder to do remotely.

This is why there's so much demand for great devs. There's just so few of them. The industry isn't set up to train juniors, and the places that can waste the resources to do it are the ones that have environments which turn them into idiots.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DeathArrow on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:08AM (#31540892)
>The problem is it's just not possible to train juniors the right way fast enough. I'm confident I can train almost anyone with basic programming aptitude to be a 95th percentile front-end dev, but it'll take a year or two, and my already average productivity will tank during it.

Nobody taught me anything, apart my teachers at University. Nobody hand holded me. I was able to learn and grow by myself, by reading, applying, trying to find solutions, applying those solutions. Which I continue to this day.

Why should be juniors hand holded? You show them the application, you explain it to them, you give them time to look into it, you reply to their questions about the application and you give them tasks. If they are any good, they should be capable to learn without hand holding.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by b3morales on Saturday May 28, 2022 @12:40PM (#31541692)
I don't think parent was talking about hand-holding at all.

> You show them the application, you explain it to them, you give them time to look into it, you reply to their questions about the application and you give them tasks.

Exactly; this is the training. Choosing tasks that match the other person's level, and being available to give good guidance, takes time, effort, and some skill.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by Apocryphon on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:52AM (#31538175)
It’s really a sad state of affairs. An industry that hates its own young in experience while pushing ageism on its elderly in age. An ouroboros industry.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by Silhouette on Saturday May 28, 2022 @03:06AM (#31538231)
Ironically a downturn might help with that culture. The problems you mention have been exacerbated by the "tech bro" attitudes of twenty-something or maybe thirty-something seniors and founders working in businesses that have been more about winning the next funding round than making a good product that produces a sustainable profit. That gravy train is probably off the rails for a while now and it's possible that we will see more interest in hiring or retaining older devs with the experience to actually get results. We might also see less emphasis on job-hopping very frequently for career growth and that will make hiring and training up juniors more attractive.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by bigDinosaur on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:27AM (#31537845)
Part of the problem is perhaps that you were looking for titles explicitly coded 'junior' at all. Title inflation basically means that many devs that would basically be juniors in real engineering companies are considered senior.

It's a weird market where the difference between 0 and 1 year of experience can be so dramatically reflected in salaries and opportunities.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by AlchemistCamp on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:40AM (#31537896)
I had 1.5 years of experience (in China). I hustled hard in SF, got rejected by 100+ companies, and really, really struggled to scrape by on some set price contract gigs.

All of that changed one night when I showed a demo of a browser game I'd made at a meetup some Groupon devs happened to be at. That lead to a phone screen, an onsite, a job and then never another time when I couldn't get a decent tech job. Of course my skills improved over time, but the biggest delta was just getting a single name on my resume that hiring recruiters respected.

I sometimes wonder how many people are out there are like me a decade ago—able to do well in whiteboard interviews, capable enough to contribute, eager... and consistently denied a chance to even try.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by AlotOfReading on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:13AM (#31538026)
I suspect the answer is rather high. I had similar experiences getting back into tech when I decided archeology wasn't the field for me. I had about some years of experience paying my way through college with contract dev work, but after several offers were retracted once a execs saw my background I managed to find an old school hacker in SF said yes. They were filling in while the real boss was on medical leave. When the real boss got back, I was immediately informed shouldn't have been hired despite doing my job well.

Years and companies later, I've brought it up in those diversity hiring meetings, but that's not the sort of changes that are being sought at most places.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by viceroyalbean on Saturday May 28, 2022 @05:10AM (#31538824)
I saw a job posting recently looking for senior developers with 3 years of work experience. I mean, I have 3 years of full time experience + a little more experience working part time and internships, and I would consider myself a junior dev.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by steve_adams_86 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @10:35AM (#31540655)
I’m in over 10 years now and I find the deeper I go, the less I like this senior title. I mean, what will I be in another 10 years? In 15? These titles are meaningless, really.

I agree though, at 3 years I was still fairly junior in the scheme of things. I was doing full stack work and building money-making applications from scratch, but it wasn’t great work. It wasn’t going to scale well, the front end was based on an ad-hoc framework because I was afraid of learning and implementing new tools like backbone.js, there were very few tests, not great internal tooling to aid workflows, I wasn’t a great mentor, etc. A lot of what I did was because it worked once before, and not because I knew exactly how and why. My fourth year was when I got my first senior title, though.

I like when companies distinguish engineering levels by capability. E1 through E7 for example, where E5+ would be approximately what people imagine when they hear the term senior. Unfortunately everyone uses different leveling, so it’s hard to adhere to that. Our industry would benefit from standards.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by KptMarchewa on Saturday May 28, 2022 @08:09PM (#31545005)
Existence of staff (and less prominently, senior staff/principal) titles is now common - IC hierarchy does not end at senior as it did few years ago at 95% companies.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by redisman on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:46PM (#31542249)
I’m hitting 15 years in the industry. I think I’m like 3x better at my job than 10 years ago when I first got my current title
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DANK_YACHT on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:48AM (#31537922)
I got a job at a FAANG by writing a for loop to check if a number was prime right around that time. The solution was completely naive and the interview was done over the phone in less than an hour. This is an anecdote, but there were some opportunities like this.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by AlchemistCamp on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:07AM (#31538001)
Were you just out of school or at the beginning of your career? I've never heard of anything remotely like that but there does seem to be a very different set of expectations for 22 year-olds than for 32 or 42 year-olds with a similar set of skills and amount of experience in the industry.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DANK_YACHT on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:09AM (#31538006)
Yea I was in school at the time.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:19AM (#31538585)
Were you studying at an "approved" school? Back then that was a big thing for some of the FAANGs.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DANK_YACHT on Saturday May 28, 2022 @08:24AM (#31539776)
I don’t know. My school wasn’t very good, so I can’t imagine it was on any type of approved school list.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by hycaria on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:14AM (#31538028)
I don’t know what you graduated in. But I was given a chance at my first good company because I followed a pretty elitist (natural sciences I must add) curriculum. But in the meantime, I had found consulting jobs pretty easily. And even if they’re crap it launches you in the career.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by AlchemistCamp on Saturday May 28, 2022 @03:05AM (#31538226)
> I don't know what you graduated in.

You don't know I graduated at all.

I'm not saying either way, but if I did, it had zero utility in my software career. Credentialism on degree subject matter for people making mid-career moves is misguided at best.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by hycaria on Friday June 10, 2022 @11:23AM (#31695437)
You were talking about a junior position in your post, not mid-career move.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by devwastaken on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:36AM (#31538101)
As Ive said for over a year now - CS grads cant get hired. Companies are not knocking on their door. Unis have to go out of their way to get companies to even associate.

What you hear of big hiring is select schools in select places.

Corps want experienced devs, they do not want to create experienced devs. They get away with this because there's no standards like any other field of engineering. We don't band together and create avenues for education, employment and advancement. This is largely the fault of existing devs knowing the above to be true, and they want it for themselves despite harming the market overall.

Degrees have largely become meaningless. Uni's have become democratic political battlegrounds that push activism above academics. There isn't anything learned in a 4 year degree that you couldn't get with a healthy appetite for YouTube. But they're just adult daycares for parents that think the system will work for their kids. I say that as someone whom unfortunately has to work at such a place.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by pharmakom on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:02AM (#31538491)
My 4 year degree had some hard theoretical CS content. Yes I could have learned it all on YouTube or whatever, but I did the assignments and the exams so I have proven I could learn the stuff - of course it’s all pretty rusty now. I see a quality degree as a great signal when hiring, and I don’t just mean a few elite schools. If evaluating a degree from somewhere I haven’t heard of, I will poke around the course website a little.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by BlargMcLarg on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:41AM (#31538689)
I don't think my degrees are worthless either, as at the very least they exposed me to certain types of content. However, my experiences (non-SV) have been that even if these degrees show one can pick up difficult things fast, hiring managers basically wave it off. They are looking for individuals who can effectively step into most of their (absurdly bloated) tech stack by tomorrow.

Maybe it's another story in SV/US, but capacity to learn seems to be about as useful to hiring managers as knowing how to bake eggs.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by pharmakom on Saturday May 28, 2022 @06:34AM (#31539172)
This is a huge market inefficiency being exploited by firms like Jane Street.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DeathArrow on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:32AM (#31541080)
Can you you develop this a bit farther? How is it being exploited?
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by throwaway675309 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:21PM (#31543458)
As a senior in software development, I frequently help out with the recruitment side of whatever companies I'm employed with, and an applicant with a formally accredited degree in computer science definitely stands out as a strong signal to pursue a potential interview with them.

I know at least nominally they'll have some passing familiarity with simulations, discrete mathematics, linear algebra, data structures and algorithms. You can learn all of this information on your own but it's more difficult for me to verify.

While this is not as true if I'm looking to hire a senior engineer, it is significantly more important for entry level positions.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DeathArrow on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:30AM (#31541067)
>There isn't anything learned in a 4 year degree that you couldn't get with a healthy appetite for YouTube. But they're just adult daycares for parents that think the system will work for their kids.

Would you rather go to a surgery with a doctor who "learned" by watching YouTube or with one spent his time in University and residency?

The state of political activism eating from the inside and destroying the higher learning in US is pretty sad. But the reaction to that shouldn't stopping learning but kicking political activism out from schools.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by mirntyfirty on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:06AM (#31537759)
Unless it’s a “junior” developer with 5 years of experience willing to “wear multiple hats” and “go the extra mile to deliver requirements.”
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by Clubber on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:24AM (#31537828)
I mean if that's what you gotta to do get your foot in the door, that's what you gotta do. My first job out of college in the late 90s took 3 months to find. I already had an internship where I did development for money and networking and workstation support. For the first job, I built the applications, designed the database, setup all the servers and all the workstations. I even crimped network cables and managed a fire/move within a week. I did everything for little pay (relative to the market, it was a living wage and I was salary + benefits) and I absolutely busted my ass to do it well. I worked there for two years and then one day, the director of customer service said she knew someone who was looking for someone and if I was interested. I said yes and that was the first Fortune 500 on my resume.

It won't be given to you (unless you're extremely lucky) but if you bust your ass like you're trying to impress the hell out of someone, people will notice and eventually, good things will happen. Always bust your ass like you're trying to impress the hell out of someone, it will take you far.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by kqr on Saturday May 28, 2022 @03:26AM (#31538321)
This is part of the reason I tell people not to take their first job too seriously. It's highly likely to be crap, and teach them what they don't want rather than what they want. But that's also why it's useful. Stick around for a bit but don't feel bad for leaving soon.

It sucks that inexperienced people get exploited, but to do the best of it you have to learn as much as you can and then get out rather quickly.

(Of course, who am I to talk? I'm happily married to my first girlfriend. Sometimes you get lucky.)

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by Comevius on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:54AM (#31537957)
"if you bust your ass like you're trying to impress the hell out of someone, people will notice and eventually, good things will happen"

In most industries, most of the time hard work no longer pays off. It is not rewarded, it is exploited. The people who would notice are increasingly sociopathic and short-highted, because that's how you make it these days.

Hard work can still open doors, but you have to be smart about who you work for.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by Clubber on Tuesday May 31, 2022 @11:30AM (#31570691)
>Hard work can still open doors, but you have to be smart about who you work for.

Agree. Notice in my little story, the good thing didn't happen until I got a job offer at another company, leaving the shit-hole I was working for. Also had I not busted my ass at the shit-hole, I never would have been noticed/recommended as a good performer for a better company. Point is, people notice when you work hard and notice when you don't. Just because you work in a dump, slacking off might actually hurt you, or at least exclude you from further opportunities, internal or external. My baseline is if you aren't seeing improvement in your prospects after a couple of years at a company, consider leaving.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by baq on Saturday May 28, 2022 @04:57AM (#31538763)
the point is to impress while delivering, not delivering to impress. perhaps a subtle difference, but of huge importance to priorities of the individual.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by Silhouette on Saturday May 28, 2022 @02:53AM (#31538179)
The market is always harder for juniors whether times are easy or hard.

The unfortunate difference this time is that today's juniors might have spent their last couple of years reading stories on sites like HN and levels.fyi about starting on six-figure salaries at big name companies and maybe doubling that with the other perks. They might have also been exposed to some of the most mercenary attitudes to career development I can ever recall seeing where loyalty is a dirty word and jumping ship every few months for a pay bump is the norm.

At the same time they still have the usual conceit of most new grads in this industry and don't understand that at best they will probably contribute little real value to begin with while taking up a lot of time from other people who could. In other words juniors almost always have negative immediate value to their employer.

In the boom times we have enjoyed in tech for the past few years a lot of newbies could get away with that and make a lot of money but really that has been the exception and it's not normal. Now the reality is setting in that you can't reasonably expect an employer to invest a huge amount of money to pay you to cost them even more money and then leave before you get better and make them enough money to become a net contributor. In a world without the weird employment market dynamics of the recent boom times that just doesn't make any sense.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by vinyl7 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @10:49AM (#31540770)
I've been searching for my first junior/entry level position for 4 months now. There's very few junior/entry positions, and the ones that are posted are asking for 2-3 years experience, and a Bachelors/Masters/PHD...for web development. The market is either asking for senior developers at senior pay, or mid-senior level developers at entry level pay.

I'm not the kind of person who would job hop every 2 years like what seems to be common in the industry. If a company is willing to take me on and help train me and bring me up to speed, I'd stay with them for 4+ years. I'd think that would be very valuable to a company, but at least what I read on the internet...companies have come to expect a high turnover for developers and thus are unwilling to put in any effort into a new employee.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by dghlsakjg on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:26AM (#31541013)
If no one’s told you yet: the experience list on a job listing are a wish list, not a requirement list.

Frequently it is a wildly unrealistic wish list. I have NEVER seen all of those requirements fulfilled.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by b3morales on Saturday May 28, 2022 @12:43PM (#31541718)
This. Crucially, the actual interviewers/hiring committee may not have even read the job posting. They have the technical expertise and know what they are looking for; the HR/recruiters filtering at the front end are considerably less clueful. You do need to get past that filter, but after that, the bullet list is all but irrelevant.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DeathArrow on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:20AM (#31540970)
What kind of studies do you have?

Do you know the basics of like CS, algorithms, data structures?

Do you know a programming language at a decent level?

For the field you are trying to get in, do you know some common used frameworks, libraries and tools?

If the answer is yes to all, you shouldn't have trouble to find a job. If one of the answers is a no, then you have to solve that problem.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by vinyl7 on Saturday May 28, 2022 @11:33AM (#31541090)
I'm mostly self taught. Been programming as a hobby for 10+ years, mostly focused on learning game development but have also done web development. I have "shipped" two Ludum Dare games done in C++, and I have a web app I recently developed with React/PHP/MySQL for an organization that is deployed.

The only credential I have is a Full Stack Web development cert from a bootcamp at a big name university. The DSA stuff I self-taught because it's pretty essential to game dev, and the bootcamp taught me the MERN stack.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by DeathArrow on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:10PM (#31541953)
Without formal education it is going to be a bit harder.

You can test yourself by seeing if you can answer typical interview questions which can be found online.

You can see if you can solve the stuff from Codility, Leetcode, Hackerranck in a reasonable amount of time.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by KptMarchewa on Saturday May 28, 2022 @08:13PM (#31545024)
>I'm not the kind of person who would job hop every 2 years like what seems to be common in the industry.

...you haven't even started. If you were regularly getting offers with 50%, 100%, or 200% more than you currently earn you'd rethink that position pretty quick.

Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by acchow on Saturday May 28, 2022 @01:38AM (#31537885)
If the funnel for juniors tightens up for a couple years, won't the shortage for senior+ worsen down the road? I see this as overall bad for innovation.
Re:What would a recession mean for developers? by imtringued on Saturday May 28, 2022 @07:31AM (#31539479)
Abandoning people with long term consequences for short term gain is a hallmark of capitalism. If it doesn't pay a positive interest rate throw it in the trash and save the money that would have to be spent to keep it alive. By "it" I include humans.