Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by bell-cot on Thursday May 26, 2022 @01:41PM
(#31521238)
First reaction (to the "imagine you are giving awards..." challenge) -
The "hard technical skills" award goes to a fairly-introverted IC, who is quite productive on difficult stuff (given good leadership), but not so great with people. At least recognize the guy's contributions. Yes, that's a male.
The "soft technical skills" award goes to a low-to-mid-level manager who clearly understands both the technology (though maybe not all the low-level details) and the human IC's and lower-level managers who make it happen. (And "uses those powers for good", if it needs be mentioned.) I'd be a bit biased toward a female, if only to send a "people skills good, machismo bad" message to certain less-skilled managers.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by Jensson on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:47PM
(#31525835)
Soft technical skills would mostly be the architect who creates structure to the software project, or the scientists who solves previously unsolved problems. Hard technical skills would be things like knowing a specific programming language, mastery of a framework, or having a degree, or other things you can put down as a checkbox.
What you are talking about are people who mix hard technical skills with social skills, that is also valuable but it is a different thing. Soft skills as a concept was invented to show that even skills you couldn't put in a checkbox could also be valuable, and is mostly for HR because for them it is easy to just rank candidates by which boxes they check.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:49PM
(#31525844)
I think a better way to look at stuff, is to think of the Pareto Principle or the 80/20 rule.
I would guess, with deliberate practice and hard work, many people are able to hit the 80th percentile of skill at something. Going beyond that likely takes some natural talent or luck.
The thing is, that getting to the 80th percentile in multiple areas makes you more valuable, than if you just spent the time getting to 95th percentile in a single area.
So if you 80th percentile programmer, maybe you shift and study writing and communication and you become an 80th percentile writer. Now as an individual contributor you are 96th percentile (1 - (.2*.2)). You study some management and work on becoming an 80th percentile manager, and now you are a 99th percentile employee (1 - (.2 * .2 *.2)).
Programming skills are for the most part table stakes. Once you reach a certain level of proficiency, work on communication and leadership.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by azangru on Thursday May 26, 2022 @01:20PM
(#31520981)
> I don't have time to go through all the societal reasons why we associate things that are difficult or hard as 'masculine' or 'manly', but it immediately moves us to why I should value these skills more than others
"Value"? Aren't managers compensated better than individual contributors?
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by ryanjmo on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:14AM
(#31525959)
If we use a reasonable definition of hard, like what percentage of the population can learn a task/skill/subject. We could say the smaller percentage of people that can do a task/skill/subject the harder it is.
And the larger the percentage of the population can learn the task/skill/subject the softer it is.
With this definition we can still use the words hard and soft and I don’t think it changes too much how we use them now.
And then any social consequences that come from the use of the words would just be inherent based on a reasonable definition.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by tbrownaw on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:05AM
(#31526170)
That's the version of "hard" that is opposite "easy", not the version that's opposite "soft". It's perfectly doable to use a hard/soft split without making up a new definition for one of them.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by tbrownaw on Friday May 27, 2022 @01:06AM
(#31526178)
> Hard implies easiert to see, interact with and measure which correleates with more impact. Soft is 'fuzzy', harder to read and understand. (Again, false)
"If you can't measure it, it doesn't matter" is I think fairly well known to be false.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by ritmatter on Thursday May 26, 2022 @03:44PM
(#31522564)
I like the idea of moving away from the hard/soft delineation and towards a more qualitative description of each skill. The focus on bucketing into just two things distracts from the differences between all of the things.
I also think, as you describe, that it's very valuable when technical folks have at least some baseline of communication skills (not specifying whether that is hard/soft, especially considering that they may need to communicate about very complex topics). I'm not optimistic about anyone being the best at both, but it's not impossible.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by IceMetalPunk on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:40AM
(#31519702)
I don't know that I've heard the terms "hard and soft skills" before, but I've definitely heard it about "hard and soft sciences", and it's equally frustrating and detrimental in that domain. Psychology specifically comes to mind: I've constantly heard people saying psychology is a "soft science" or even "not a real science" to discredit it, which is absolute BS. People do the same for economics. Thing is, psychology is based in neurology -- a very real physical/chemical/biological science -- and economics is based on psychology. The named fields of "neuropsychology" and "neuroeconomics" make that foundation clear. If abstracting a concept makes the result "not real", then I guess 99% of computer applications are "soft apps" or "not real apps", since they basically always use an abstraction of some sort to work (anything from assembly as an abstraction of machine code, to higher-level programming languages as abstractions of assembly, to external libraries as abstractions of their common functionalities).
People will say psychology is a "soft science" because "it's based on statistics and general probabilities, not hard rules and guarantees". But quantum mechanics is founded on the idea that nothing in it can be guaranteed and it's all just statistics and probability -- yet we consider QM a "hard science".
TL;DR: Can we stop qualifying knowledge and skills based on arbitrary rules about what make them "true Scots-knowledge"?
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by jfengel on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:58PM
(#31520696)
The concepts are different, but the similarity is that anything easy to measure is "hard" and anything difficult to measure is "soft".
Soft sciences measure complex things, like human behavior, that are challenging to define in a rigorous fashion. People are more comfortable with simple things, like atoms and subatomic particles and rigid objects, which behave as a simple unit following simple laws. That makes biology a "softer" science -- not because it's easier, but because it's more difficult.
Hard skills are easy to measure: can you write the code that does the thing, quickly? But soft skills like "can you figure out what needs to be done?" and "can you communicate with clients and coworkers?" and "can you write clear instructions?" are hard to measure.
We have a notion that only things that can be measured are real. But that skips over the fact that some things are important, but difficult or impossible to measure. It's poor reasoning to assume that only things that have already been given rigorous definitions are relevant, but it's popular among people who don't wish to practice soft skills.
It would be great if we could appreciate that science, and software, are human activities done by humans for humans, requiring a mix of skills both easy and hard to measure.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by medstrom on Friday May 27, 2022 @03:03AM
(#31526798)
Maybe "hard/soft" is a bad word couple because "hard" also sounds like "difficult", implying it's higher-value. Maybe it's better to speak of "firm and fuzzy sciences".
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by Jensson on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:33PM
(#31525770)
> But quantum mechanics is founded on the idea that nothing in it can be guaranteed and it's all just statistics and probability -- yet we consider QM a "hard science".
Quantum mechanics describes the probabilities exactly, it includes every single way the particle can behave. There is no statistics here, it just gives an exact probability distribution. This is not like psychology at all where we don't have any exact descriptions of how humans can behave in different situations.
Or in another way, the results of physics are "hard" (unyielding) since we have yet found any experiment where the particles don't behave according to the distributions we get from quantum physics. Those distributions are therefore as exact as anything humans can know can be exact.
Psychological experiments aren't that exact, the psychological experiments run produces different distributions all the time since they don't have hard requirements on the input, humans aren't exact, humans are very fuzzy data wise so until we can specify a human precisely psychology will remain a soft science.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by drewcoo on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:55PM
(#31525881)
Psychology is more like a set of disciplines. Some hard, some soft. Some real and some woo. Lots of great stuff to learn from cognitive psychology, especially for the AI-interested in this forum. Evolutionary psych, though, is a bunch of post facto "just so stories," with my apologies to Kiplng for the comparison.
And no, we can't stop seeming to clam no true Scotsman. That's because there are things masquerading as legitimate. And we're on HN. So any time someone points out the divide, those accusations are inevitable.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by Jensson on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:27PM
(#31525739)
Hard skills are skills that are easy to measure. For example, the score on a specific test, you can measure wither the person can do arithmetic's, algebra, spell words etc. This gives you hard evidence that the person possesses these skills.
Soft skills are skills that are hard to measure. This includes social skills, but also other things like being able to create a good architecture for a complex software project etc.
There is nothing stating that soft skills needs to be social and hard skills needs to be technical, if you mean those then just say social or technical instead of soft or hard.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by wrnr on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:45PM
(#31525828)
Thank you for putting software engineering into the soft skill bucket, but I think the word soft skill sort of means social/interpersonal skills. What you describe is more the difference between open and closed problems.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by Jensson on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:43AM
(#31526066)
Defining soft skills so that they are only social skills is just the bias people have against technical skills. It comes from the biased view that all programmers do is equivalent to solving middle school math problems over and over, so there is no creativity in it.
It is also a redundant definition, if you say that soft == social and hard == technical, then why not just say social and technical skills? However any experienced programmer knows that there is much more to programming than just knowing a language and frameworks, so to us it makes perfect sense to talk about soft technical skills even though a manager might think that we only have hard skills that can be jotted down as a list of checkboxes. So I think that breaking this misconception is very important, there are plenty of soft technical skills to care about when evaluating a hire!
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by witheld on Thursday May 26, 2022 @03:16PM
(#31522308)
You can’t sit here and say that you know the answers to the questions, despite the fact that you can’t define what a hard or soft skill is. You gotta pick one stance here man.
Have you never heard of “soft skills” OR the genders are the same, which is it? If you don’t know what a soft skill is, how are concluding that they’re both the same gender? You literally said you don’t understand the question.
Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by karmakaze on Friday May 27, 2022 @12:15AM
(#31525964)
I know what a "soft skill" is, but the article said "hard and soft technical skills" and I don't know what a "soft technical skill" is which I think should have been defined so we all know what's being talked about rather than guessing which is what I did.
Another comment suggested that "create a good architecture for a complex software project" can be a soft tech skill. I don't see how this is gender-biased other than the number of males in the profession largely outnumbers women so the answer to both is more likely male.
The "hard technical skills" award goes to a fairly-introverted IC, who is quite productive on difficult stuff (given good leadership), but not so great with people. At least recognize the guy's contributions. Yes, that's a male.
The "soft technical skills" award goes to a low-to-mid-level manager who clearly understands both the technology (though maybe not all the low-level details) and the human IC's and lower-level managers who make it happen. (And "uses those powers for good", if it needs be mentioned.) I'd be a bit biased toward a female, if only to send a "people skills good, machismo bad" message to certain less-skilled managers.
What you are talking about are people who mix hard technical skills with social skills, that is also valuable but it is a different thing. Soft skills as a concept was invented to show that even skills you couldn't put in a checkbox could also be valuable, and is mostly for HR because for them it is easy to just rank candidates by which boxes they check.
I would guess, with deliberate practice and hard work, many people are able to hit the 80th percentile of skill at something. Going beyond that likely takes some natural talent or luck.
The thing is, that getting to the 80th percentile in multiple areas makes you more valuable, than if you just spent the time getting to 95th percentile in a single area.
So if you 80th percentile programmer, maybe you shift and study writing and communication and you become an 80th percentile writer. Now as an individual contributor you are 96th percentile (1 - (.2*.2)). You study some management and work on becoming an 80th percentile manager, and now you are a 99th percentile employee (1 - (.2 * .2 *.2)).
Programming skills are for the most part table stakes. Once you reach a certain level of proficiency, work on communication and leadership.
[1] https://michelleockers.com/2019/12/02/skill-stacking-with-sc...
[2] https://forge.medium.com/how-to-become-the-best-in-the-world...
"Value"? Aren't managers compensated better than individual contributors?
And the larger the percentage of the population can learn the task/skill/subject the softer it is.
With this definition we can still use the words hard and soft and I don’t think it changes too much how we use them now.
And then any social consequences that come from the use of the words would just be inherent based on a reasonable definition.
"If you can't measure it, it doesn't matter" is I think fairly well known to be false.
I also think, as you describe, that it's very valuable when technical folks have at least some baseline of communication skills (not specifying whether that is hard/soft, especially considering that they may need to communicate about very complex topics). I'm not optimistic about anyone being the best at both, but it's not impossible.
People will say psychology is a "soft science" because "it's based on statistics and general probabilities, not hard rules and guarantees". But quantum mechanics is founded on the idea that nothing in it can be guaranteed and it's all just statistics and probability -- yet we consider QM a "hard science".
TL;DR: Can we stop qualifying knowledge and skills based on arbitrary rules about what make them "true Scots-knowledge"?
Soft sciences measure complex things, like human behavior, that are challenging to define in a rigorous fashion. People are more comfortable with simple things, like atoms and subatomic particles and rigid objects, which behave as a simple unit following simple laws. That makes biology a "softer" science -- not because it's easier, but because it's more difficult.
Hard skills are easy to measure: can you write the code that does the thing, quickly? But soft skills like "can you figure out what needs to be done?" and "can you communicate with clients and coworkers?" and "can you write clear instructions?" are hard to measure.
We have a notion that only things that can be measured are real. But that skips over the fact that some things are important, but difficult or impossible to measure. It's poor reasoning to assume that only things that have already been given rigorous definitions are relevant, but it's popular among people who don't wish to practice soft skills.
It would be great if we could appreciate that science, and software, are human activities done by humans for humans, requiring a mix of skills both easy and hard to measure.
It's soft science because it's squishy. The rules are soft and malleable, depending on the context of the question.
Quantum mechanics describes the probabilities exactly, it includes every single way the particle can behave. There is no statistics here, it just gives an exact probability distribution. This is not like psychology at all where we don't have any exact descriptions of how humans can behave in different situations.
Or in another way, the results of physics are "hard" (unyielding) since we have yet found any experiment where the particles don't behave according to the distributions we get from quantum physics. Those distributions are therefore as exact as anything humans can know can be exact.
Psychological experiments aren't that exact, the psychological experiments run produces different distributions all the time since they don't have hard requirements on the input, humans aren't exact, humans are very fuzzy data wise so until we can specify a human precisely psychology will remain a soft science.
And no, we can't stop seeming to clam no true Scotsman. That's because there are things masquerading as legitimate. And we're on HN. So any time someone points out the divide, those accusations are inevitable.
It isn't though. It's not like math, built on axiomatic foundations. Psychology predates the discovery of neurons.
(Math isn't really like that either.)
I've never heard of a "soft technical skill"
Because they're different skills and the odds that the same person is the best both is small.> Why aren't the genders the same?
They are. Not getting the point of this lead in.
Soft skills are skills that are hard to measure. This includes social skills, but also other things like being able to create a good architecture for a complex software project etc.
There is nothing stating that soft skills needs to be social and hard skills needs to be technical, if you mean those then just say social or technical instead of soft or hard.
It is also a redundant definition, if you say that soft == social and hard == technical, then why not just say social and technical skills? However any experienced programmer knows that there is much more to programming than just knowing a language and frameworks, so to us it makes perfect sense to talk about soft technical skills even though a manager might think that we only have hard skills that can be jotted down as a list of checkboxes. So I think that breaking this misconception is very important, there are plenty of soft technical skills to care about when evaluating a hire!
Have you never heard of “soft skills” OR the genders are the same, which is it? If you don’t know what a soft skill is, how are concluding that they’re both the same gender? You literally said you don’t understand the question.
Another comment suggested that "create a good architecture for a complex software project" can be a soft tech skill. I don't see how this is gender-biased other than the number of males in the profession largely outnumbers women so the answer to both is more likely male.