Re:The problem with hard and soft skills
by Jensson on Thursday May 26, 2022 @11:33PM
(#31525770)
> But quantum mechanics is founded on the idea that nothing in it can be guaranteed and it's all just statistics and probability -- yet we consider QM a "hard science".
Quantum mechanics describes the probabilities exactly, it includes every single way the particle can behave. There is no statistics here, it just gives an exact probability distribution. This is not like psychology at all where we don't have any exact descriptions of how humans can behave in different situations.
Or in another way, the results of physics are "hard" (unyielding) since we have yet found any experiment where the particles don't behave according to the distributions we get from quantum physics. Those distributions are therefore as exact as anything humans can know can be exact.
Psychological experiments aren't that exact, the psychological experiments run produces different distributions all the time since they don't have hard requirements on the input, humans aren't exact, humans are very fuzzy data wise so until we can specify a human precisely psychology will remain a soft science.
Quantum mechanics describes the probabilities exactly, it includes every single way the particle can behave. There is no statistics here, it just gives an exact probability distribution. This is not like psychology at all where we don't have any exact descriptions of how humans can behave in different situations.
Or in another way, the results of physics are "hard" (unyielding) since we have yet found any experiment where the particles don't behave according to the distributions we get from quantum physics. Those distributions are therefore as exact as anything humans can know can be exact.
Psychological experiments aren't that exact, the psychological experiments run produces different distributions all the time since they don't have hard requirements on the input, humans aren't exact, humans are very fuzzy data wise so until we can specify a human precisely psychology will remain a soft science.