The alternative to algorithmic scoring is often worse: someone making a subjective judgement call. Which, historically, is fraught with discrimination.
Edit: I stand corrected. Thanks, I understand now.
This is not a very smart way to do things. You'd be much better off getting a credit card with no fees and rewards points, buying everything with that, and then paying it off every month. You'll have stronger legal protections on your purchases, and you'll earn reward money without paying any extra. You can even pay off your bill with the reward points. And as a bonus you'll build up your credit score, which can affect you in lots of ways unrelated to loan rates.
No. Rewards are funded by merchants (interchange) and by people who actually pay the 19.9% annual interest.
But I hate it. It feels insane to me that we as citizens don't have more regulatory control over credit systems. I envy you, but I also know that what you are doing is not practical for me.
They'll likely close your account for inactivity after a few years, and the account stays on the credit report for a decade after it's closed.
Not exactly. There are MANY credit scores in the US and several credit agencies. Different score calculations occur for different purposes, mortgages, credit card, automobile, and so forth. Plus there are different versions of each credit score's model. Each credit reporting agency keeps a separate credit file per person. Each person's credit file contains credit histories from various creditors. Not all creditors report to all credit reporting agencies. Not all credit reporting agencies receive the same information from a creditor, even when receiving information. The score for a particular person may differ between different credit reporting agencies, credit scoring models, or any of various other factors.
We effectively have a form of wage slavery by law. If a person has debts that are unpayably big and is not (or no longer) eligible for the once-each-lifetime-only "personal bankruptcy", where one signs a contract to pay all property and incomes for five years towards one's debts before the remaining is erased, one is on the hook for the remaining debt for the rest of one's life.
No recourse. Economic damage judgements in court do not qualify even for the five-year 100% garnishment contract. Someone impacted by this has no incentive to work ever again, because everything they earn above the survival minimum will be garnished. I'd hazard a guess that most of them end up on welfare.
So it's not all good, unfortunately. I mentioned social unity punishments in our culture in a different thread the other day; this is another example of that.
source for bankruptcy being "once-each-lifetime-only"? A quick search says that's false: https://www.findlaw.com/bankruptcy/after-bankruptcy/how-ofte...
Over here, we can't really just "declare bankruptcy", it's a very lengthy process - which takes years. It's more like a court ordered program where the debtor and creditor agrees that the debtor is going to pay as much as possible towards the debt owed, for the next N years, and after that - all debt is erased. You're allowed to keep just enough of your salary to cover the most basic living expenses, everything else goes to the creditor.
This also means not being credit worthy, which in turn could mean no cellphone plan, no insurance, no mortgage, no auto loans, no consumer loans, etc. Everything you buy, you have to buy with cash up-front.
From start to finish, all that could take 5-10 years. And before you even sign a contract where you and the creditor agrees upon such a plan, the debt collection agencies are probably hounding you down on a daily basis, making whatever debt you had to begin with N times more expensive.
The good news is that when you've held up your end of the agreement, it's gone. But you only get once chance. If you - for whatever reason, any reason at all - end up in the same situation, you're practically a debt slave. Which could mean wage/welfare garnishments for the rest of your life. This is especially true if you have multiple debt collection agencies bogging down individual debts with added and compounding fees.
But to be fair, this is not normal. Very few end up being two-time losers - but sadly it could be entrepreneurs and small business owners, if they haven't structured their companies the right way.
Can you inherit debt in Norway? You can in Germany. You don't in the USA.
Can you as a Norwegian declare bankruptcy in the UK or is that off the table now that they're out of the EU?
You can, but it would be voluntary. Inheritors can choose all assets and all debts, or nothing.
Unsure about the bankruptcy tourism idea. I'm pretty sure it would take many years. Moving countries for tax purposes, for instance, takes five years for all obligations to clear.
> TransUnion, one of Canada’s two main credit bureaus, had reported her as deceased.
We also moved out of the stone age and faxes practically don't exist and all certificates are digital:
> Two years of faxing in detailed documents—including Dave’s death certificate
Just being a deadbeat will do exactly that. It takes 0 effort. Put your purchases on a credit card, and settle it in full every month.
If you don't need credit then taking on credit is an extra thing to manage. I personally like all my spending being on my debit card and coming out of my account so I have a single balance that reflects how much money I have. I don't want to deal with an extra company especially when their business model ultimately relies on trying to get me to miss a payment so they can charge fees/interest.
Not sure how it is where you are, but where I am the payment is automatically done every month from your bank account. There is 0 chance of missing a payment, as long as you have a sufficiently positive floating balance in your account. If someone do not, then I would question their suitability for a credit card in the first place.
Maybe in the US - in Europe where interchange is capped, credit card rewards aren't worth it. Not to mention, I like my privacy and don't want to deal with any rewards or offers programs anyway.
> but you have added fraud protection also.
In practice, all the fraud I've been victim of always fit within the card networks' dispute resolution rules. The only time I can think of this being necessary is airlines that go bust (where a card network dispute would technically succeed but fails because there's literally no money to claim back anymore).
> where I am the payment is automatically done every month from your bank account. There is 0 chance of missing a payment, as long as you have a sufficiently positive floating balance in your account. If someone do not, then I would question their suitability for a credit card in the first place.
See my other comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31504046
Does the dispute process have all disputed money be instantly returned to the account? With a credit card, you can simply turn off the auto payment system, and simply not pay the fraudulent part, and you still have your money in the bank account. With a debit card, in the US the banks typically have 10 business days to determine if there was fraud and give your money back. (If the investigation takes longer they return the money on the tenth business day pending the results of the investigation, and if they determine it was not fraud they will take the money back again.)
And in the US many people life paycheck to paycheck with effectively zero savings. If their account is zeroed out due to fraud, Things can get expensive quick.
For example, your rent payment is probably too large to be covered by banks overdraft protection, so you will likely get hit with three bounced check fees. of at least $25. One from you bank from the first attempt. Then a later re-presentment attempt will also fail, and you will get a second fee from your bank. Finally, you will get a bounced check fee from your landlord. Of course since your payment did not go through, you will likely end up with a late fee. etc.
For other bills they could be small enough that you only get hit with overdraft fees, and not the rest. But if not, then things can snowball VERY quickly. And There could be other consequential damages like losses from being unable to get certain items while they are on sale, or even things like the stress of all of this preventing you from closing a sales deal, meaning you lose out on a substantial commission, etc.
And while you can typically get the bank imposed fees waived due to the fraud, as long as they can determine that you would not have suffered those fees if the money had been there, the bank won't always cover all the the incidental and consequential damages. (The terms of service always exclude those).
>In practice, all the fraud I've been victim of always fit within the card networks' dispute resolution rules
I think there's an element of "fraud protection" that you're missing. If your debit card gets breached and someone racks up $2000 worth of charges on it, the $2000 is immediately gone from your bank account. If rent/bills are due soon, that might be bad. On the other hand if you have a credit card, you have at least 3-4 weeks since the bill is issued before you have to pay, which means 3-4 extra weeks to get it resolved/refunded without having it affect your finances.
Not if you have an American Express card. Interchange is capped only if there's more than 3 parties to the transaction, which is not the case on AmEx.
My bank provides fraud protection for my debit card. A card for my account got skimmed and was used to withdraw cash from an ATM. Got my money back with a single phone call to report the fraudulent activity.
This is a genuine question; I know that other countries do things differently. Is that not an option where you are?
If you’re not using a credit card, you’re:
- Adopting significant risk (debit card protections are not as strong as credit card protections)
- Failing to establish a credit history
- Giving away a significant amount of money.
Credit card transaction fees are included in all prices.
I use a card that gives me 2% cash back on all purchases — effectively, most or all of the transaction fee.
I fail to understand how you are giving away 'significant' money by spending from your own account? Are you referring to being able to earn interest on savings for the month before you have to settle the credit line?
And as the other commenter's reply says, all my credit cards pay me cash back or a points system which is redeemable for things with high cash value. There's a real quantifiable cost to not using them.
Here in the US it is common for banks to both provide traditional banking services and credit cards, and when you open your banking app, both accounts are together.
You depend on your bank for this type of stuff? Isn't that basically begging for vendor lock-in? It makes far more sense to have a vendor-agnostic solution (eg. mint or personal spreadsheet), so your analytics aren't at the whims of your bank.
A credit card would break that and introduce unnecessarily complexity including another company that I'd rather not have to deal with (also, I'm not aware of any modern credit card providers that would give me a decent experience).
If I look at my recent expenses in my banking app, I can see that I got a coffee (food&beverage), bought fuel (transport) and paid freight cost on a case of wine from my frequent flyer miles rewards program (incorrectly classed as travel).
It's not 100% accurate but gives a good enough overview in the app week by week, and I sit down quarterly to look at things properly in a spreadsheet.
It always shows as pending in the morning and clears that evening.
I can also make a payment and it will update my CC limit the same day if needed.
I don't give out my debit card and I only use it at trusted ATMs.
They make money on interest also, but they would rather have someone that spends and pays off a lot than someone that carries a modest balance.
In Europe and the UK, interchange is capped to a level that wouldn't support running a financial institution.
> They make money on interest also
Interest only gets charged a month after (at least on most UK credit cards), so if you're using it "the right way" and paying it off every month you will never incur any interest. It's good for you but ultimately proves that credit card providers rely on the (generally less financially-savvy) people who don't/can't use it "the right way" and incur interest or fees. That's honestly a pretty predatory business model I have no interest in supporting.
> My credit card company sends me a notification when a statement is ready and another friendly reminder a week before the bill is due.
True but why should I even statements and bills for spending what is my money in the first place? My argument is that you should only use a credit card when you actually need credit and not to merely game a broken system.
Does your bank not have a system showing you what transactions you did in a month? The credit card statement is the same thing, for a different account.
Credit cards are literally the dumbest way to borrow money, second only to payday loans. So you definitely shouldn't use them when you _actually need credit_.
But you should use them to build up your credit score, so you can get extremely cheap credit when you actually need it.
So if I paid off my debt on time, and you made your creditor fight tooth and nail for five years and get a court judgment to get your debt paid (but it is paid now), future lenders would have to treat us the same?
-When there's been registered wage garnishment (by court) against you.
-When there's been registered a lien against your property.
-When you've entered a court-ordered debt payment program.
-When you've been registered as bankrupt.
And by law, these things have to be deleted when you've settled your debt. In any case, it's difficult to get those things by accident. Usually you're at the end of the process, and have been through civil court.
With that said - it should be mentioned that Norway is a INCREDIBLY creditor friendly country, as far as the law goes. If a creditor really want their money back, they can / will take you to court, and eventually get a garnishment on your wage or welfare money. Or property/vehicles/personal belongings lien if you don't have any income.
I like the system as it is. I really don't like the idea of constantly having to do things with respect to a credit score - and I'm not talking about gaming the system or being a deadbeat, but trying to maximize my credit score for the sake of keeping it high.