News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by Nextgrid on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:43AM (#31503131)
> Put your purchases on a credit card, and settle it in full every month.

If you don't need credit then taking on credit is an extra thing to manage. I personally like all my spending being on my debit card and coming out of my account so I have a single balance that reflects how much money I have. I don't want to deal with an extra company especially when their business model ultimately relies on trying to get me to miss a payment so they can charge fees/interest.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by is0tope on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:55AM (#31503240)
While I see your logic, ultimately using a credit card makes a lot of sense as long as you pay it off on time. Not only do you get the (small) benefits of the cashback or points, but you have added fraud protection also.

Not sure how it is where you are, but where I am the payment is automatically done every month from your bank account. There is 0 chance of missing a payment, as long as you have a sufficiently positive floating balance in your account. If someone do not, then I would question their suitability for a credit card in the first place.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by Nextgrid on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @09:17AM (#31504088)
> Not only do you get the (small) benefits of the cashback or points

Maybe in the US - in Europe where interchange is capped, credit card rewards aren't worth it. Not to mention, I like my privacy and don't want to deal with any rewards or offers programs anyway.

> but you have added fraud protection also.

In practice, all the fraud I've been victim of always fit within the card networks' dispute resolution rules. The only time I can think of this being necessary is airlines that go bust (where a card network dispute would technically succeed but fails because there's literally no money to claim back anymore).

> where I am the payment is automatically done every month from your bank account. There is 0 chance of missing a payment, as long as you have a sufficiently positive floating balance in your account. If someone do not, then I would question their suitability for a credit card in the first place.

See my other comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31504046

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by jsmith45 on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @12:05PM (#31506485)
> In practice, all the fraud I've been victim of always fit within the card networks' dispute resolution rules. The only time I can think of this being necessary is airlines that go bust (where a card network dispute would technically succeed but fails because there's literally no money to claim back anymore).

Does the dispute process have all disputed money be instantly returned to the account? With a credit card, you can simply turn off the auto payment system, and simply not pay the fraudulent part, and you still have your money in the bank account. With a debit card, in the US the banks typically have 10 business days to determine if there was fraud and give your money back. (If the investigation takes longer they return the money on the tenth business day pending the results of the investigation, and if they determine it was not fraud they will take the money back again.)

And in the US many people life paycheck to paycheck with effectively zero savings. If their account is zeroed out due to fraud, Things can get expensive quick.

For example, your rent payment is probably too large to be covered by banks overdraft protection, so you will likely get hit with three bounced check fees. of at least $25. One from you bank from the first attempt. Then a later re-presentment attempt will also fail, and you will get a second fee from your bank. Finally, you will get a bounced check fee from your landlord. Of course since your payment did not go through, you will likely end up with a late fee. etc.

For other bills they could be small enough that you only get hit with overdraft fees, and not the rest. But if not, then things can snowball VERY quickly. And There could be other consequential damages like losses from being unable to get certain items while they are on sale, or even things like the stress of all of this preventing you from closing a sales deal, meaning you lose out on a substantial commission, etc.

And while you can typically get the bank imposed fees waived due to the fraud, as long as they can determine that you would not have suffered those fees if the money had been there, the bank won't always cover all the the incidental and consequential damages. (The terms of service always exclude those).

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by gruez on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:42AM (#31506140)
>> but you have added fraud protection also.

>In practice, all the fraud I've been victim of always fit within the card networks' dispute resolution rules

I think there's an element of "fraud protection" that you're missing. If your debit card gets breached and someone racks up $2000 worth of charges on it, the $2000 is immediately gone from your bank account. If rent/bills are due soon, that might be bad. On the other hand if you have a credit card, you have at least 3-4 weeks since the bill is issued before you have to pay, which means 3-4 extra weeks to get it resolved/refunded without having it affect your finances.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by sgjohnson on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @02:57PM (#31508958)
> Maybe in the US - in Europe where interchange is capped, credit card rewards aren't worth it. Not to mention, I like my privacy and don't want to deal with any rewards or offers programs anyway.

Not if you have an American Express card. Interchange is capped only if there's more than 3 parties to the transaction, which is not the case on AmEx.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by bee_rider on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:38AM (#31506080)
These companies are making money somehow. If they are exploiting people more clever than me, then I'll probably fall for it too. If they are exploiting people less clever than me, seems pretty evil, I don't want anything to do with that.
Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by CPLX on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:49AM (#31506247)
How they are making money isn't a secret. They take a percentage of the transaction from the merchant you pay every time you make a charge. It's effectively free from your perspective, the merchant is willing to share some of your money to allow you the convenience of paying by card.
Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by steelframe on Thursday May 26, 2022 @12:15AM (#31514449)
> you have added fraud protection also

My bank provides fraud protection for my debit card. A card for my account got skimmed and was used to withdraw cash from an ATM. Got my money back with a single phone call to report the fraudulent activity.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by EliRivers on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:56AM (#31503257)
Do you not have an option to just automatically have the full amount paid off from your account every month? I've never had to do anything involving paying a credit card; on getting the card, I tell them to just take the full amount every month from my bank and that's what happens until years later for whatever reason I cancel the card. They might well like me to miss a payment so they can charge me interest, but it's never going to happen.

This is a genuine question; I know that other countries do things differently. Is that not an option where you are?

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by Nextgrid on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @09:13AM (#31504046)
It does, but that payment takes several days to clear and messes up your bank's analytics. I use a modern bank that gives me a real-time overview of my spending and categories it, but this all goes out the window if all your spending is on a credit card and the only thing your bank sees is a single payment (to your credit card provider) once a month.
Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by teakettle42 on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @09:58AM (#31504601)
Not a very modern system if it cannot account for a credit card.

If you’re not using a credit card, you’re:

- Adopting significant risk (debit card protections are not as strong as credit card protections)

- Failing to establish a credit history

- Giving away a significant amount of money.

Credit card transaction fees are included in all prices.

I use a card that gives me 2% cash back on all purchases — effectively, most or all of the transaction fee.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by ikr678 on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @08:50PM (#31512895)
Other countries have stronger/ better enforced consumer protection laws so credit card chargebacks are less necessary.

I fail to understand how you are giving away 'significant' money by spending from your own account? Are you referring to being able to earn interest on savings for the month before you have to settle the credit line?

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by kzrdude on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @09:51AM (#31504506)
I don't enable these bank analytics (sweden) since that accepts their laundry list of terms for that service, suddenly opening for the bank to mine that data. Without agreeing to it, I have more protection.
Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by jkaplowitz on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @10:17AM (#31504851)
The vast majority of my monthly spending (with a few notable exceptions like mortgage and electricity bill) goes on a single credit card. That card's website and app also gives me an overview of my spending and categorizes it. What you say can work in the credit card world.

And as the other commenter's reply says, all my credit cards pay me cash back or a points system which is redeemable for things with high cash value. There's a real quantifiable cost to not using them.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by kube-system on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @04:31PM (#31510132)
Does your bank not offer a credit card?

Here in the US it is common for banks to both provide traditional banking services and credit cards, and when you open your banking app, both accounts are together.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by gruez on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:46AM (#31506187)
>I use a modern bank that gives me a real-time overview of my spending and categories it

You depend on your bank for this type of stuff? Isn't that basically begging for vendor lock-in? It makes far more sense to have a vendor-agnostic solution (eg. mint or personal spreadsheet), so your analytics aren't at the whims of your bank.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by Nextgrid on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @12:03PM (#31506469)
I don't have enough money to care seriously about this yet, so I don't mind if my bank discontinues the service (and can reevaluate then). However, in the meantime it's there and it's convenient so I use it and the simplicity of my financial "stack" (one account for everything) makes it work well.

A credit card would break that and introduce unnecessarily complexity including another company that I'd rather not have to deal with (also, I'm not aware of any modern credit card providers that would give me a decent experience).

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by nradov on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @04:45PM (#31510296)
Almost every major US bank also issues Visa or MasterCard credit cards, and integrates spending on those cards into their account analytics.
Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by ikr678 on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @09:02PM (#31512989)
In Australia at least, all banks/institutions provide those transaction analytics as the registered business number of the company you transact with has a category attached to it by our tax office.

If I look at my recent expenses in my banking app, I can see that I got a coffee (food&beverage), bought fuel (transport) and paid freight cost on a case of wine from my frequent flyer miles rewards program (incorrectly classed as travel).

It's not 100% accurate but gives a good enough overview in the app week by week, and I sit down quarterly to look at things properly in a spreadsheet.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by pnutjam on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @10:25AM (#31504985)
Just a customer, but I use Cap1 and I can make a payment on my card and unless it's Fri/Sat/Sun, it will post to my bank the next day.

It always shows as pending in the morning and clears that evening.

I can also make a payment and it will update my CC limit the same day if needed.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by 2rsf on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:51AM (#31503210)
That. I was addicted to credit cards and small payments but now I pay everything debit, cash in other words, and life became much more simple and predictable
Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by xeromal on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @11:37AM (#31506070)
I don't like anyone having access to my bank account so I tend to see a credit card as an abstraction. If someone skims my debit card, that's my problem. If someone skims my credit card, that's my credit card's company's problem.

I don't give out my debit card and I only use it at trusted ATMs.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by maxerickson on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @07:48AM (#31503180)
Their business model is a 1 to 3 percent fee on every transaction they are involved in. My credit card company sends me a notification when a statement is ready and another friendly reminder a week before the bill is due.

They make money on interest also, but they would rather have someone that spends and pays off a lot than someone that carries a modest balance.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by Nextgrid on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @09:20AM (#31504120)
> Their business model is a 1 to 3 percent fee on every transaction they are involved in.

In Europe and the UK, interchange is capped to a level that wouldn't support running a financial institution.

> They make money on interest also

Interest only gets charged a month after (at least on most UK credit cards), so if you're using it "the right way" and paying it off every month you will never incur any interest. It's good for you but ultimately proves that credit card providers rely on the (generally less financially-savvy) people who don't/can't use it "the right way" and incur interest or fees. That's honestly a pretty predatory business model I have no interest in supporting.

> My credit card company sends me a notification when a statement is ready and another friendly reminder a week before the bill is due.

True but why should I even statements and bills for spending what is my money in the first place? My argument is that you should only use a credit card when you actually need credit and not to merely game a broken system.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by maxerickson on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @09:42AM (#31504386)
The article is about North American credit scores, so I guess it isn't completely ridiculous to assume that if it is unstated.

Does your bank not have a system showing you what transactions you did in a month? The credit card statement is the same thing, for a different account.

Re:Credit Scores Can Run – and Ruin – Our Lives by sgjohnson on Wednesday May 25, 2022 @03:10PM (#31509128)
> My argument is that you should only use a credit card when you actually need credit and not to merely game a broken system.

Credit cards are literally the dumbest way to borrow money, second only to payday loans. So you definitely shouldn't use them when you _actually need credit_.

But you should use them to build up your credit score, so you can get extremely cheap credit when you actually need it.