> People like him and their mind viruses are destructive to proper civil society.
I don't think the "proper civil society" response is that they should be subject to criminal attacks.
I am considerably less certain given some of his Twitter postings.
“Police protection” tends to imply that you get treated as a special person, someone super important — like a head of state or a political dissident. It’s a bit like having Mark Zuckerberg’s security detail, but through the use of taxpayer funds. In a country where most people don’t have guns and don’t resolve problems through violence, the need for this sort of thing is extremely rare.
As someone who is clearly “not poor,” as he says repeatedly, he should be asked to source his own protection rather than being an undue burden on the South Korean taxpayer. The funds and resources earmarked for police protection would be better spent protecting women fighting for equal representation, against corruption, etc.
Of course, if the guy is actually poor, well, that’s another thing. I don’t think that is what we are dealing with here, however. Keep in mind that he dissolved the South Korean entity for Terra on April 30th…
Too many people being able to just disregard the law when they see fit is not an argument for either
* Letting them off
* Allowing more people to break the law as they see fit
Which are the alternatives.
> a strong and powerful position against illegal and unethical actions should be taken to return to a civil society.
This would, imo, be the "arrest them" part of the argument.
Police deciding whether to protect you based on whether you said “governments are bad, people have to be able to stand up to them” or “stay poor” is absurd. It's sad how much hating crypto clouds people's opinions here and elsewhere. You can dislike crypto without basing every tangentially related opinion on what would be disliked most by a crypto investor without other considerations.
Many people in Korea have faced far worse threats than having their doorbell rung without getting personal police protection. If this is indeed the new standard for getting police protection, the Seoul police force needs to start a huge recruitment drive.
It's not the "bell ringing" part that's worrying it's the "people lost tons of money and potentially seek revenge" part
GP is arguing that certain taxpayers should not receive the services they paid for, on political grounds.
Crypto bros spend all their energy slamming the government. Why should they get to enjoy the protections of the government they hate so much?
Vice versa, endlessly praising your government does not suddenly grant you greater rights and privileges
Well, it shouldn’t anyways.
I think we can discuss the protagonist's hypocrisy, but that's very separate from a government's obligation to its citizens.
Also, a similar standard of need to other requests for protection should be applied to this case.
Who are these people? Can you please bring up one specific example of a person who (1) expresses those views, (2) lives in an area where fire service is opt-in, (3) didn't opt-in for fire service, (4) had his house burn down and (5) is upset about not receiving help?
[1] https://www.firehouse.com/operations-training/news/10472820/...
Which people?
Will be interesting to see what happens with Elizabeth Holmes.
I personally call this the French/Guillotine Deterrent.
Readers: please upvote this. I don’t normally ask, and it’s a breach of etiquette to talk about votes. But there’s a line, and I think calling someone a pampered brat while his wife is requesting police protection is the one.
Those can both easily be true, though? And the theoretical protection is for both of them, right? Unless there's a huge amount missing in the story.
Wait... So if he had pulled the exact same scam while longing for more government employees and a bigger part of the public sector in countries' GDP, then he'd be worthy of police protection?
So basically the government should protect people depending whether or not they're pro-government?
I want to see that scammer rot in jail but there's no reason, if he go death threat, that public mob lynching is suddenly okay because he's not a leftist.
Asking someone to stick to their principles or accept they were wrong earlier may not be very kind in this case, but expecting someone to die by the sword they lived by hardly sounds wrong.
I'll agree this shouldn't happen in a civil society, but I also wish people were smart enough to recognize that government and rule of law are a prerequisite for civil society.
I vehemently disagree on this. Regardless of what you think of a person, no one should be subject to the violence of a vigilantist mob. Anything else is a huge step back into the middle ages.
It saddens me to no end that the kind of inhuman sentiment that is displayed in comments like the above is becoming more and more en vogue in modern civilization.
I don't think I'm the one here feeling righteous.
But tons of people are at mild risk that doesn't warrant paying 1-6 cops' salaries to keep watch.
I know the world isn't just, but it would be nice to see these shysters getting some form of comeuppance. At least Madoff and Skilling ended up in jail.
Why? States have a monopoly on violence for good reason. If a disgruntled speculator decides to do something stupid for revenge, it's much better for the police to deal with rather than a private guard.
When people push for something, they rarely get what they want. Even when there is a lot of support, the end result is a compromise with the previous status quo. If you push for minimum wage to be $10 and it is currently $5, with enough support you will see an increase but it won't be up to $10.
In turn, people will ask for more than what they actually want. If someone wants a minimum wage of $10, they might ask for $15. So when there is a compromise they are more likely to get what they actually wanted to start with, and maybe even hope for a little more than the minimum of what they wanted.
This of course has limits. If you instead were to push for a minimum wage of $100, you won't get enough support to have any impact at all. But exactly where this threshold is located is something only well known in hindsight, if even then.
So people who push for completely removal of government positions are likely much more interested in a compromise that still has a great deal of government power left, but are using rhetoric that will hopefully shift the window of compromise to be more in their favor. This is why things like 'defund the police' become supported even by people who can easily predict what would happen if the police really were defunded.
Lastly, I am speaking of people who would take positions similar to Do Kwon in general, and not about Do Kwon in specific. I realize that's slightly off topic, but I think it is worth clarifying that not everyone with positions similar to Do Kwon hold such positions for the same reason that Do Kwon does and many of them would be open to reasonable discussions and compromises.
An individual is not destructive to civil society if civil society is healthy.
The request should be evaluated without bias
If I read your argument correctly. It's OK for the police to remove protection from people based on the court of public opinion without due process if they are "bad hombres."
If that's true, you are casually suggesting is disregarding the core principles of rule of law and human rights in the society.
I find this attitude very disturbing and discussing. Maybe it's lack of understanding or genuine want to abandon principles of liberal democracies, I don't know.
Based on numair HN comment. It's funny the dude is angry at another dude because of lawlessness and suggests applying lawlessness to the other dude to teach about lawlessness.
New one for me:
> As early as 2012, he proposed the acronym RAGE—Retire All Government Employees—as a shorthand for a first step in the overthrow of the American “regime.” What we needed, Yarvin thought, was a “national CEO, [or] what’s called a dictator.” Yarvin now shies away from the word dictator and seems to be trying to promote a friendlier face of authoritarianism as the solution to our political warfare: “If you’re going to have a monarchy, it has to be a monarchy of everyone,” he said.
* https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2022/04/inside-the-new-right...
> Under his Moldbug pseudonym, Yarvin gave a talk about "rebooting" the American government at the 2012 BIL Conference. He used it to advocate the acronym "RAGE", which he defined as "Retire All Government Employees". Acting as a provocateur, he described what he felt were flaws in the accepted "World War II mythology" alluding to the idea that Hitler's invasions were acts of self-defense. He argued these discrepancies were pushed by America's "ruling communists", who invented political correctness as an "extremely elaborate mechanism for persecuting racists and fascists". "If Americans want to change their government," he said, "they're going to have to get over their dictator phobia."[36]
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_Yarvin#Dark_Enlightenme...
Doesn't seem like a ridiculous position to me.
Given this context, I do not think the police should honor his request. If Do Kwon was American, he would be the sort that would support utter trash like RAGE (Retire All Government Employees). People like him and their mind viruses are destructive to proper civil society.
Then again, the Korean police aren’t stupid. I am guessing they will “protect” him so he can be handed over to the US federal authorities, who haven’t been shy about the fact that they’re looking for him.
Also — if you work in crypto, you want this guy arrested and gone from the scene. These are the sort of selfish bad actors who will shamelessly blow up an industry and blame it on the industry rather than themselves. I can already see Do Kwon becoming the singing voice of why crypto is bad, as a way to save himself.