- zero interest
- {snip} you end up having to pay 150% of the principal loan (assuming you have a high enough paying job for long enough within those 5 years)
Those two things don't line up, and repeating the 'zero interest' line in an edit doesn't change that. If your repayment is 150%, you've paid interest.That just means it's not compound interest.
A loan with a very reasonable 5% overall interest if paid on time can have unbounded interest if paid late enough.
The student dept crisis is dominated by the latter kind of situations.
(still yes, it is zero compound interest + 50% fixed interest)
The problem is a lack of financial literacy education on one side and a lack of career options for decent-paying jobs on the other side - a lot of office jobs these days require college degrees, and not everyone can work in the trades or join the military.
Personally, I believe that all of this is actually designed the way it is to make money for the banks handing out student loans.
It's such a non-standard contract that the terms loan and interest are kinda fuzzy
that's not true. simple interest is calculated on the remaining principal, thus it does continue to accrue with time (which this "zero interest 50%" does not)
compound interest means interest calculated on the remaining principal and on accrued interest.
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042315/what-differe...
IMO, this is the essence of why ISAs have become so scammy.
ISA-based bootcamps are doing a fantastic job of competing against the perceived cost of a college education. We've all seen news headlines about how private college tuition is reaching $200K. What most people miss is that almost nobody pays full price for college. They have a high headline number for the wealthiest families, but virtually everyone else pays a fraction of this cost or some times nothing at all.
People see the "$30K" price tag for Lambda School and other programs and assume it's a steal, yet most in-state tuitions are in the same range and provide substantially more education.
I've also been completely stunned by how bad some of these programs are. I took the bait about Lambda School back when PG was promoting it all over Twitter, but it has been a terrible disappointment for the small handful of bright students I've known who went through it. Maybe it's changed, but at the time it felt like they were paying $30K of future earnings to have an inexperienced person point them to simple tutorials that they could have found by themselves online. They were basically paying for the certificate that said they completed the program, which is ironically the stereotype that people were using for 4-year colleges at the time.
on the other hand, the time cost of a bachelor's in CS is much higher than that of an 8 month (?) bootcamp. four years is a long time to spend treading water wrt employable skills.
I do feel that the degree is better long-term if it's at all possible. but that's not realistic for everyone. if at the end of the bootcamp you get a decent job that you wouldn't have otherwise, that seems like a good deal. if not, you're out a lot less money and time than flunking out of undergrad halfway through.
Only if your sole goal in life is the pursuit of money. Most of the people I know enjoyed their time at university, they got to learn in a structured manner about philosophy and other interesting topics while having freedom to indulge in intellectual curiosity. Life isn't a race to get on a career path.
I do agree that flunking out is probably the worst outcome though, so if academia isn't for you don't feel pressured to pursue it - it certainly won't make any difference in terms of your job prospects by the time you're 30 as a developer. We just need to stop treating university as a vocational training session.
Is it treated as a vocational training session? I thought university was more about signaling some combination of socioeconomic status and ability to learn/motivation. More selective schools and more difficult coursework (such as hard sciences or engineering) signal a potential employee who is able to learn and manipulate the system they are put in, as well as possibly bringing useful connections.
Presumably life isn't a race at all, which makes you wonder why everyone is in such a rush to attend university when they are young and don't yet have the resources to pay for it. It will be still be there when you are older and the pursuit of knowledge will still be every bit as enjoyable. It may be even more enjoyable as you then have the life experience to appreciate it. Retirement is meant for these types of hobbies.
It’s the networking opportunities (i.e. “the college experience”) which suffer as the age gap grows between you and the other students. Since networking is the bulk of the value of university, your age during attendance is of disproportionate consequence. I’m speaking from personal experience here — going into a post-grad program, it was immediately obvious to me that the age gap would act as an all but uncrossable chasm. And I’ve seen this chasm in action in undergrad, where it was even more pronounced.
Simply put, university is a lot harder to justify when a significant age gap exists. To your point, maybe most people should wait a few years before attending university, but they don’t, and those who’d otherwise prefer to wait before starting university — which is doubtlessly a wise move for some — have to risk their college experience to do so.
The move to taking university online, and the masses of students following, through the COVID period suggests not. Online university does not provide any unique networking opportunities that aren't already available through every other online service, HN included.
If I thought I could take a three- or four-year break to study in my thirties or forties without it hurting my career I absolutely would. But employers seem to be suspicious of that kind of thing (unless it's something like a 1-year MBA). So if I want a sabbatical without hurting my earnings too much, a college degree seems like my best option.
Internships during school can be a massive salary increase for many people. Even 25+$/hour is quite a large pay bump for a large chunk of the population, and many internships go well past that.
You're using this statement to claim that college is not actually expensive but I'm pretty sure it supports the opposite claim. Anecdotally, I was accepted into a range of universities and ended up picking ~ the worst one because that was the university which gave me the best scholarships.
If college is extremely expensive then it makes perfect sense that the only people paying full price are the people who have a lot of money: everybody else is filtered out by the high price.
That being said, I think ISAs are actually partially successful in that they provided a way for someone broke like me to try something and not have to worry too much about the impact if it doesn't end up succeeding. I wish people in my position had more negotiating power to avoid being overcharged, but that's not a problem unique to ISAs
You pay if you have no job, or any job. Debt has no expiration and is not disc arable in bankruptcy.
It is clear that ISAs are worse if you will be successful. It is also clear that traditional loans are worse if you are wildly unsuccessful.
The tradeoff is the tricky part.
A better alternative that you can pursue today is just to seek education abroad, Canadian universities are a fraction of the cost for an equivalent service - or be careful about the education you choose, most state colleges are very reasonable for in-state tuition and you can potentially save on room and board.
Ivy-league schools are overpriced and a waste of money.
In California, tuition at community colleges is $1,300/year and $5,700/yr for state colleges.
Even the expensive Universities of California are 14k/year.
The real costs are room, board, and entertainment. For example, a shared dormitory room and food plan is easily 20k/year
If we start with other countries, there will be many other catches. Such as personal bankruptcy not being a concept at all in many jurisdictions.
I'll take it.
That extra 50% is a once-off fee.
A high fee, to be sure, and one that is deferred, but a fee nonetheless.
So the actual interest is like 100%? Though it's fixed over a 5 year period, so that turns to around 30% yearly interest rate. Hardly zero.
-> Most people that get jobs in tech will have paid the 150% before the 5 year mark
That's even higher interest for these people. But I guess it's an incentive for the program to get people good jobs.
In straight amortization using $30k tuition, $45k repayment, over 60 months is $750/mo which works out to 17.25% rate.
It isn't a great deal but it's not terrible vs. other low recourse private loan options.
https://www.calculator.net/loan-calculator.html?cloanamount=...
In reality the APY will be heavily dependent and on your income (as a high income will result in repayment period less than 5 years, while a low income will result in only partial repayment by the end of the 5 years).
EDIT: To clarify, zero interest means zero interest. The 150% is the terms of the ISA agreement. You pay 10% of your paychecks to them until it's either been 5 years or you've payed 150% of the principle amount. Most people that get jobs in tech will have paid the 150% before the 5 year mark