I constantly see Teslas suddenly zoom in parking lots or on crowded roadways. I've also seen them seemingly lose control and weave in their lane, slightly into the next ones when there's not even any traffic around them.
I've also seen the Remote Parking/Recall function totally fail where a Tesla nearly hits me as it attempts a U-turn perpendicular to the row of parking spaces to get through a line of parked cars to its owner in the next row.
I'd say any fears of drivers not being able to handle the cars, or even fears of the cars not being able to handle themselves, are quite valid.
Once upon a time I owned a '67 mustang, I know how to change my own oil, I learned to drive on a stick, and I know what a hemi is, and I concur.
The submission clearly doesn't violate the HN guidelines, but article like this make me wonder if someone would be willing to develop a crowdsourced extension for HN that would let adoptees flag posts as "written by a fuckwit" to filter them out for each other.
As a sidenote, your "written by a fuckwit" came very close to me having to clean Mac and Cheese off my monitor.
Seems fair, given that some of them come with a "launch control mode / drag strip mode" right in the UI, expressly for the purpose of doing that.
If you look at the top 10 cars involved in accidents (per 1000 cars), it's not a particularly powerful bunch. In the USA last year the stop accident prone car was a Scion FR-S with under 200 HP (150 lb-feet). The Toyota Prius (even Toyota marketing makes fun of it's performance) is at #8.
Personally I feel safer in a capable car, even if it has crazy 0-60 times and impressive HP/Torque numbers.
https://www.iihs.org/ratings/driver-death-rates-by-make-and-...
Individual model comparisons aren't of much consequence (especially with such incomplete data), but trends are. If you scan the MV and SV columns in the midsize and large sections and compare it to the sports car and 2-door sections you'll see the trend I'm highlighting. The pdf linked on that page is helpful for this.
https://www.iihs.org/api/datastoredocument/status-report/pdf...
The data seams to be screaming "driver demographics" at you.
Generally the lower the performance of a car, the longer in the future you have to predict your power needs, which makes things like on ramps, highway passing (especially on uphills), and of course getting across intersections quickly.
I think one correction for the OP is that while instant torque is a huge change for the driver, it's not so for anyone outside the car. Much of the lag in the throttle, engine (waiting for RPMs to increase), torque converter, automatic to shift, driveline slack, etc is invisible to people outside. What pedestrian notices is the launch after all that happens, and said launch is much like an EV launch.
Sure $50-$75k Teslas are quick, but I don't expect cheaper EVs to be particularly faster than the cheaper gas cars.
Analogy: my kid has an electric dirt bike, and it has a knob to control throttle response, and a knob to control speed. He can rock top speed, but he still can't handle more than 1/3rd up the dial on throttle response. He doesn't have good enough throttle control to handle the torque, and this is a tiny little thing. I base much of my thoughts off the experience of working with him to learn throttle control (he accidentally power slides in turns all the time, which is iffy on a dirtbike for a kid), and my experience with other drivers.
I found switching to an EV dramatically easier to drive, despite having about twice the performance.
Nearly every driver on the planet handles nearly 1G braking on nearly every car on the planet from the last decade, even the outliers like the cars with drum brakes. The improved modern brake caused no rash of problems with over braking, no huge spike in crashes, no calls for strong laws to control braking speeds. Why should accelerating at nearly 1G be any different than braking at 1G? The key to safe driving is predictable performance, giving drivers what they expect.
Even fairly midrange cars like the Subaru crosstrek ($22.6k), Toyota RAV4 ($26.5k), and Honda CR-v ($26.4k) have pretty advanced traction control systems and the average cost of a new car in the USA is $47,077. In fact the traction control system is the number one complaint for those driving in the snow, except for the Subaru. Not of those 3 cars are particularly fast and reviews often mention the lack of power.
The implementation of that is so much more complicated in something like a Tesla S vs the others. Things like independent torque vectoring is not common in most gas vehicles. I thought Car and Driver or Road and Track did a great write-up on it, but I can't find it. This one is meh, but has some details in it. The second one talks about stuff like slip-start mode.
https://plugincarworld.com/does-a-tesla-have-traction-contro...
https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/modely/en_us/GUID-CC0F27E...
Sure the Tesla has an advantage over ICE cars in that it can produce positive or negative torque near instantly on either axle. But braking is a good substitute. I didn't really fully understand differentials till I built one for an RC car and played with it enough. If you turn the car upside down you can immediately tell that dragging your finger on one wheel, speeds up the other wheel, thus the dangers of an open differential (my WRX had two limited slip differentials and one open slip). Open differentials + braking give you the best of both worlds. You get a cheap, less drag, lighter differential, but you can still transfer torque from the slipping wheel to the non-slipping as needed.
Most don't realize that most cars (when it's slippery) are one wheel drive (fwd or rwd with an open differential), some are rear or front wheel drive and have limited slip so they are 2wd. AWD can be 1, 2, 3 or 4wd when slippery, depending on the configuration of open and closed differentials. My WRX was 3wd (1 open and 2 LSD). Hardcore offroad vehicles have locking hubs or full sync mode for very slipper conditions, but it's hell on tires if used on a normal road since every turn will scrub tires for the difference between inside and outside curve distances.
However if you google snow testing and the 3 cars I mention above you'll find a report basically saying the Subaru was awesome in the snow, predictable, could climb, turn, and brake as well as traction allowed. The toyota and honda however were pretty terrible in comparison despite all being a similar price, similar power, similar tires, and AWD. I was amused to find that Subaru's were really better in the snow.
I spent a year of commuting through six 7,200 foot peaks every weekend and went through many snow storms, blizzards, freezing fog, etc. My WRX did awesome, except when the snow was so high it would life the car off the tires. It didn't use anything active for traction control, but was awesomely predictable in the snow. I thought rally drivers had inhuman skills in their ability to drift sideways through corners and stay in their lane.... till the WRX and found it easy to do the same. Great fun.
Sure my old WRX couldn't do torque vectoring, or even active traction control, but was so predictable that it didn't particularly matter if there was some slipping. It also communicated exceedingly well, one treacherous night descending from 7,200 feet or so into Carson City I was at 10 mph or so, any slower and I'd slide to the inside of corners. I could tell not only that the ABS was going off, but which wheel. I tuned my speed as a result so I'd slow so one wheel would occasionally trigger, but not so slow that I'd slide to the inside of corners. Pretty eerie with the slow rumble of the boxer engine near idle, silence from the heavy falling snow, and the noise of the ABS floating between the 4 wheels. As you might imagine it had my full attention.
As you can probably tell despite my m3p being faster and more advanced in many ways, I still miss my WRX.
The subaru on the hand just shrugs, slips a bit, but does what it's asked.
The M3P for instance isn't particularly good at donuts, even in track mode, at least with the settings I tried. I've definitely been in scary situations where not being able to slip would have meant getting stuck. In my m3p I've even gotten stuck trying to get into my driveway, even with "slip start" mode enabled. Had to get a running start just to get over the curb of my almost flat driveway that my subaru (either the forester or wrx) would have just slipped a bit and gotten up.
Instant torque is alot of fun, but in terms of power, you're only ahead for the few moments until a gassers torque curve catches up.
That's what I was thinking. EVs have a totally different torque curve than ICE cars, but that doesn't imply faster acceleration. In fact, there are a few cars in the non-performance Model 3s price range that will out-accelerate it 0-60.
At least the guy was honest about not being a "car guy", though; he's got a 12 year old car, half the stuff he mentions have been standard features on cars for 5+ years.
This is the same thing, but for a polar opposite demographic. The pitch is more or less "do you hate driving? well you'll be happy to hear that even we have a car that people who hate driving think is pretty ok."
It didn't have the required safety equipment. The rules have changed recently, it's allowed now.
https://www.musclecarsandtrucks.com/dodge-demon-nhra-ban-lif...
Is that really why you think those warnings are there?
No. Drug ads in the US have to include (and I'm no authority) information about possible side effects. Most drug ads will downplay that part and have someone read off the list quickly. The Viagra ads seems to have no shame about that particular possibility though. So my guess is it's required but they're also kind of happy to include it.
For example when I'm a pedestrian/on bicycle I can hear when petrol cars get closer and I also know that a car that I just checked is not going to suddenly teleport next to me while I turn the head to check the other direction.
Having said that, I also would not trust IIHS safety ratings as evidence that new automotive technologies will ultimately make us safer. For one thing, the vehicle-to-pedestrian evaluations typically seem like an afterthought compared to the evaluation done for the vehicle occupants. For another thing, it's entirely possible that many of these new safety features make us collectively less safe by inducing people to drive more miles, faster, and pay less attention while doing so.
It took more than a decade before it became clear that the increase in pedestrian fatality rates was largely due to the increase in trucks and SUVs. I suspect it'll take a similar amount of time to find out (empirically) whether electric cars result in communities that are safer or less safe.
Everything needs reasonable limitations that balance the rights of others in society. Surely there are reasonable limitations on how much acceleration a stock car should have.
It always turns me off when someone says something like "people from some country do/don't do/can/can't" when almost every time it has nothing to do with what country the person is from.
If most people switched from driving cars to riding motorcycles I would be willing to wager that they would find it fun and that traffic fatalities would increase.
(I say this not to discourage anyone from riding motorcycles but to point out that "fun" and "dangerous" are often positively correlated.)
Given I am a poorly coordinated and easily distracted, I only own dull knives. It takes twice as long to saw through meats which equates to an extra minute. I have that kind of time.
You do not want someone like me owning a car with godlike acceleration. And we all know how this story ends -- regulations on acceleration. Knowing that, why wait ? Because the anti-regulatory alter of freedom needs human sacrifices first ?
https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?con....
Hahaha succinctly put.
I've been a performance automotive enthusiast for decades, competed in autocross for years, visited the Houston drag strip many times, and own a 500 horsepower Tesla, and I still agree there should be some kind of power to weight ratio limit on cars used on public roads.
The report said he was driving at 113 MPH, which is easily achievable in most modern cars way below even your 500 HP Tesla.
A bit off-topic, but having seen a picture of the aftermath of the house (https://www.tampabay.com/news/crime/2021/10/08/man-who-crash...) I have to say I'm glad we build houses out of brick where I live. While there are no guarantees at that speed, it would have definitely slowed the car down more than wood framing.
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=weight%20of%20a%20tesla...
My point is that drivers licenses seem have such a low bar and, anecdotally and quite possibly related, many people are really bad at driving, and it seems like something that can be improved.
At least having done autoX we know the limits of our vehicles, and even more importantly of our skills. Understanding how a small change in conditions can drastically change performance and create an unsafe situation is hugely valuable, as is the mindset to pay attention to it.
I've got a M3P and after keen observation of ever Tesla I see on the road they are the last car I worry about safety wise. The ones I worry about are mostly WRXs, riced out Hondas, and Minivans.
Seems like it's a very popular opinion that "my car is fast, but faster cars are insane" ... without much data to prove it.
I've participated in FT86 (BRZ/FRS) communities for years now and the constant factor in crashed ones is almost always the age/immaturity of the driver. Most times it also boils down to simply not knowing how to operate the (or a) car properly on the road.
It is _because_ this car is so "underpowered", that young people think they can get away with driving so terribly, that they inevitably crash/get into accidents.
Meanwhile when I see Teslas lose control or get crazy, they are almost always being driven by 25-50 year old people, sometimes even older.
This is a bad comparison, honestly.
The FRS is cheap, looks fast/sexy, and is fun to drive... which encourages exploring the limits. Thus new enthusiasts explore (and cross) the limit. Not sure another 25% HP/torque would really make it safer. Maybe another 2x-3x would be enough to scare people into being careful. Trick is most don't know where the limit is, after crossing the perceived limits a few times, they are in for a surprise when they find the real limits.
I even tried an E85 tune for a bit but honestly stock tune is perfect for me with the 2017+'s gearing ratio. It feels snappy, feels great to rev high, etc.
I've known people to turn off traction control thinking they can handle it and then they don't even think about situations like the road surface being too cold or damp from light drizzle/rain. Known two young guys who wrecked with those exact situations.
Here’s his intro bio: “I should note that I’m not a car guy. I don’t know much about them, don’t much like them, and don’t much like driving them. I never learned to drive a stick shift or change the oil. I don’t drool over muscle cars or know what “hemi” means. Truth be told, I kind of hate car culture.”
Further on he has an opinion on what American drivers can handle. There’s literally thousands of Teslas on the road and he has fears of them “leaping” across intersections.
How about some facts from IIHS: https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/with-more-electric-vehicles...