We’ve developed a photosynthesis enhancement trait to increase plants’ growth rate and carbon sequestration potential. Some plants have naturally developed a similar method of photosynthesis efficiency increase, known as C4 photosynthesis, which relies on anatomical changes that are only possible in a certain group of plants. Our method achieves similar carbon capture results without requiring elaborate anatomical changes. This is incredibly different from developing an organism that is resistant to glyphosate.
Additionally, while trees sequester an enormous amount of carbon, they also release it back into the air through decomposition. We are developing a range of tree species, with characteristics similar to a slow-decomposing spruce, that are able to keep carbon stored in the high-quality wood for longer.
Similar to the work of the American chestnut, we focus on studying our seedlings on land that otherwise would not be productive for carbon drawdown like abandon mine lands.
And when you cut down a tree, more than half of the carbon in that tree stays behind in the ground (although I implore scientists to challenge and test this result further. A few of you and a number of the rest of us think this number is low and these numbers influence climate policy a great deal).
If you're engineering trees for carbon sequestration - for actual carbon sequestration, instead of for profiting off carbon sequestration - you probably need to look at root fusion and fungal symbiosis, rather than trunk volume and canopy size. One is fixing a problem. The other is gaming a system that is trying to save us from destroying ourselves. It's tantamount to wartime profiteering.
one could consider the soil itself as a living organism by the ton, and I would hope conversations around sequestering carbon will transition into conversations around increasing total biomass on earth.
Carbon gets top billing because its easily measurable and has a direct influence on the greenhouse effect, but the costs of climate change really come from the climate becoming more chaotic - every living organism acts as a buffer for storing energy, carbon, and water - the more life on earth, the more stable the atmosphere becomes.
(I'm no climate scientist, this is my impression from reading Charles Eisenstein's Climate: a New Story, totally turned me around on being fatalistic about climate change)
We can definitely use soil recarbonization as an air brake (pun not intended) for atmospheric carbon increases, but at the end of the day we enjoy an environment that was created by trees running unchecked for millions of years depositing carbon dioxide in the ground, before other fungi learned to eat lignin and slowed the process down.
When you're trying to change habits you need something to do, instead of a list of things not to do, and planting trees and learning how to make them happy are certainly things we can do.
Having said that, the naive and (forgive me for saying) faulty science behind the idea of using these for "stabilizing" climate is alarming. Ecology and the processes responsible for climate stability is infinitely more complex, and most importantly CO2 does not play central role in it per se. The amount of information processing by micro-biota to render the service of climate stabilization against equilibrium thermodynamics is unreachable in any foreseeable future by humans (ie. there is not even a hope to begin modeling this from first principles -- ignoring the fact for now that no theories exists on the hierarchical correlations among the ecological levels).
Of cause I understand the "advertising" element this work needs to attract funds and investments. That is why I would not unleash my criticism in full scale here (also not appropriate here), but (humbly) I would like to see that you attract real ecologists under the umbrella, and update the narrative to account for the dominant role forests play in on-land water cycle at least on the rudimentary level. Sure, I do not mean to uproot your efforts focusing on details of photosyntheis, but climate stabilization (mean for real, not just advertisement statements) is worth to acknowledge to come as a system. At the same time, I have anxiety that with all the good intentions we can easily cause more harm (as has been done many times prior , eg. corn-ethanol additives, palm oil, etc).
It's always a privilege to receive such a well thought out answer to an off the cuff post like mine above.
I believe we are both arguing from two orthogonal axes. You are responding from the rational perspective and I am responding from an emotional one.
From my perspective, so many promises like this have been made to fix the world with this 'one simple trick' that it raises way to many alarm bells for me.
I go on vacation at a town where there was a famous protest which prevented a forestry company from cutting a large swath of old growth.
The natives managed to defend their claim and the land is uncut to this day. I spoke to some of them and their leaders said more or less: "The forest has always taken care of us, and we don't know how it works so we should leave it the way it is."
And this is from people who have been observing nature in this one spot for 10 000 years. They might have figured some stuff out along the way but generally the white man won't believe them. Both communities are talking past each other because they don't publish papers, and also because we don't spend much time observing nature do its thing.
I guess all I can say is I wish it worked this way, and that fixing our mistakes would be this easy.
Solutions that address 1% of the problem are worth doing-- no single approach will be able to dig us out of the hole we are in and we need to attempt to address it from all angles.
It's hard to say what approach to take, and information is scarce. It would be great if projects such as yours advertised net CO2 captured per acre per year, and also $ per CO2-equivalent greenhouse reduction.
Climate ranges would also be good. Do these trees grow well in dry areas, for example?
Perhaps with trees it's easier to get carbon credits
The best storage is to leave what already is underground right there, until/unless there is plenty of energy to influence the carbon cycle above ground by putting it back deep below with technology without requiring the energy to be supplied by even more below-ground-carbon.
Would it be too much to ask to make replies that take the context into consideration, instead of using "autobot" mode posting generic standard text based on keywords?
Also it can be impossible to process in sawmills because of the dust, and it will chew through sawblades like no wood you’ve ever seen before!
I find this theoretical comment so strange because it completely contradicts our experimental knowledge of plants.
Humans been selectively breeding plants for food for thousands of years. Corn that was selectively bred in the Americas looks and functions almost nothing like its wild ancestors. But - by this theoretical argument - this selective breeding shouldn't have worked! If making the plant more food-efficient was possible the corn "would already be doing it".
It would do that because it would be in a community again and not in a mono-culture farm field supported by synthetic inputs.
You 100% will not get teosinte from unattended corn. They're genetically so different after thousands of years of agriculture that there's no turning back the clock. It would probably occupy a fairly different niche if it were left alone.
It might not revert to teosinte (maybe how much time have you got?) but it also wouldn't stay as the corn we are used to with eight inch corn cobs either.
But my main point stands. Just because we were able to selectively breed something doesn't mean we 'improved it' we improved it for very specific purposes and to be grown with additional inputs in poor soil.
And we also bred it to match our industrial processes. Etc...
A wild plant wouldn't care about any of that, and it would quickly morph into something that exchanges nutrients with other plant in a community, not in neat rows of green desert.
It's so genetically different that it definitely would not. But honestly who cares what it would do if you just tossed out some seed and walked away?
> Just because we were able to selectively breed something doesn't mean we 'improved it' we improved it for very specific purposes
Definitionally that is an improvement. What are you trying to say here?
Also corn was selectively bred for thousands of years to grow in relatively poor soil, it just doesn't fix nitrogen.
> A wild plant wouldn't care about any of that, and it would quickly morph into something that exchanges nutrients with other plant in a community
You can already plant beans with corn to fix nitrogen and you don't need to fertilize, you just get lower yields per acre. Not all plants share nutrients like that, and certainly not all of the plants we might want to eat.
This line of thinking totally ignores how much food we're now able to grow on so little land. Obviously we could make better use of cover crops, advancements in no til planting, drip irrigation, and managing soil health but we've done something really amazing. For the first time in human history, there's plenty of food for everyone year after year.
> spraying glyphosate all over public lands to create 'free to grow'
yes, this is bad. what does it have to do with the post.
> by forestry companies on public land.
also a bummer, but...what does that have to do with the post.
> If trees needed to photosynthesise faster they would already be doing it.
they don't? we just want to use them to accomplish a goal.
> We didn't even understand basic things about trees till like a few decades ago
Ok? Again, so what.
Some of humanities greatest triumphs are from selective breeding. Wolves didn't "need" to "evolve" into dogs. But we did that because dogs are great. And Brassica oleracea didn't need to turn into broccoli but we made it happen because it's delicious. And we did all this thousands of years ago, without understanding the underlying mechanisms. If OP can accomplish a goal of "eat up more Co2" who cares if humanity doesn't know everything about trees.
That being said, I do have plenty of skepticism about VC funding for this (and most projects in general). There are some really perverse incentives and VCs are generally vultures, so I'd be cautious on how this particular venture shakes out long term. But I don't think the underlying premise can be dismissed with such a superficial understanding of the topic.
What's best for the tree might not be best for us. Human civilization is in a time and resource crunch. This isn't about making better trees for trees sake, this is about solving the immediate problem of too much carbon in the atmosphere.
I'll give you though, that once we solve this carbon problem it's possible we might have another problem. So hopefully we keep a backup of some of these "heritage" trees.
You are anthropomorphizing nature. We human have needs, we modified crops and plants for bigger and tastier fruits and vegetables. Trees and nature doesn't have "needs". During the carboniferous, trees set the atmosphere on fire due to excess of dead trees (wood) and oxygen. They "didn't care". Hopefully, later, creatures evolved & processed trees and a balance was achieved.
Instead of trying to make trees capture more CO2 artificially or feed seaweed to cows to make them burp less methane, let's just eat less animal products?
I know, it's hard to change people's behaviors. But if you really want to make a dent in climate change, find ways how we can incentivize people to change their behavior (either by financial means like tax and subsidies, or by making better products like plant-based meats).
I'm making a similar comment like I made at yesterday's (?) YC launch of that lab-grown meat company. But that's because for me something like this, while it might be interesting research, is just one of those "future tech magic" things (just like carbon capture and lab-grown meat). We need real solutions, and we need them to work today. Not in 2 years from now.
0: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-020-00603-4.epdf?shar...
'We' don't even understand basic things about trees now, because we're operating on old information.
I'm hearing soil scientists griping and sniping about their peers dragging their feet in acknowledging new research. The future is here, but unevenly distributed.
Elaine Ingham has a sometimes-awkward dislike for actinobacteria (formerly called actinomyces, because it looks like a fungus but turns out is not). She has complained on more than one occasion about people still calling it actinomyces. They are a useful microbe, but from a soil metabolism standpoint bacteria tend to be in the 'minus' column and fungi in the 'plus' column. If you've ever done a budget and put something in the wrong column, you know how quickly that can screw up your conclusions.
> If trees needed to photosynthesise faster they would already be doing it.
I recall someone discovering a while back that chloroplasts have a defense mechanism that reduces photon absorption when transpiration can't keep up with waste (heat?) production from photosynthesis. If they stayed on they would fry themselves, so they shut down by degrees. Whether that's a global optimization or a local one I couldn't say. But if the leaf is the bottleneck, then plants could in fact be photosynthesizing faster. At least during midday.
If someone could select or engineer more efficient pathways, then it could stay 'on' for longer. A chloroplast that produces less waste heat. A more efficient capillary system for bringing water and removing sugars. Maybe even something as simple as min-maxing soil moisture so the leaves have as much water as they could ever want.
Or, it could make a tree that cannot reach the canopy in an established forest, because it's overtrained for full sun.
Evolution is not immune to getting stuck in local maxima.
Perhaps trees haven't had the time to adjust to 400+ppm CO2?
Stressors in microgravity could shed clues on optimization for a changing climate and off-world production.
Post flight research (tomography, electron microscopy, single cell transcriptomics) is being done at Lawrence Berkeley National Lab and the Joint Genomics Institute. HTTPS://magnitude.io
We didn't even understand basic things about trees till like a few decades ago leading to stupidly counterproductive practices like spraying glyphosate all over public lands to create 'free to grow' tree plantations on what used to be forests.
All of this is done by forestry companies on public land.
If trees needed to photosynthesise faster they would already be doing it.
The fact that they aren't using this adaptation (or some other one) means that probably photosynthesis speed is already being traded off against some other factor in their communities (they form relationships with other species which we barely understand).
Edit: About those free to grow plantations? It turns out that they were trying to get rid of Alder which they thought was competing with Spruce. It turns out that the Alder were feeding the Spruce seedlings instead.