maddiehalla
maddiehalla on Hacker News
Yes, lead, nickel, iron, copper and lithium are all metals that in theory can be hyperaccumulated. We have spent some time on nickel, copper and lithium so far but haven't shared any of this research yet.
Good questions! The end use of the wood depends on the location of the pilot project and how close it is to a mill. Given the duration of our pilot projects, the trees will be too large to be used for anything outside of saw timber for furniture of construction. We don't allow for our seedlings to be used for pulp / paper in our landowner agreements. Decay can also refer to the decay of wood products etc.
One of the biggest issues with forest carbon in general is the duration in which the CO2 can be stored before it is released back into the atmosphere. While trees have the benefit of being able to be planted right now at scale, climate change is a problem of relative rates. Currently, trees do lack the ability to store carbon for thousands of years underground. Of course you can coppice and keep replanting them post harvest but there will be some carbon returned to the atmosphere even if all your timber goes to wood products that have a long lifespan. Trees can't solve climate change on their own but they can quickly remove carbon in a low cost way buying ourselves more time to scale up other types of CDR solutions.
would be happy to discuss with you and see if doing a pilot project make sense! land (@) livingcarbon.com
I think I mentioned this in my other comment but durability and grow rate increase are two different traits we are working on at Living Carbon. I agree it's near impossible to address both in one trait.
In the conversations we have had with landowners, they are much more interested in planting Loblolly pine or poplar, which are naturalized and / or native than Empress. I think Empress trees are very cool but hybrid poplar and loblolly pine are better suited for the types of sites we are planting seedlings on.
We would not use any trees with metal for pellets. Because the landowners we work with grow the trees for over 25 years the type of wood produced is better for saw timber or timber that is used in building materials. it wouldn't be pellet grade wood.
Good question, the research we are doing on increasing the durability of wood is separate from the research on photosynthesis. The durability of wood largely has to do with the ratio of lignin to cellulose. Historically organizations focused on increasing growth rate for bioenergy have worked on changing that ration to create fast growing but less dense wood. That's different from what we are doing at Living Carbon. We don't expect to see increases in wood durability from photosynthesis-enhancement alone.
Biochemically our photosynthesis-enhancement strategy is a metabolic bypass pathway that reduces the energy that goes towards photorespiration allowing for more energy to go toward growth. When talking to investors I sometimes say it's like putting the plant into ketosis :) albeit that is not the perfect analog.
When it comes to improving the durability of wood, one of our approaches focuses on improving the ability of trees to accumulate and store metals in their lignin. Metals act as natural fungicides and slow the decomposition of trees. Other ideas include some of the world the Salk Institute has done on increasing Suberin production. Here's a paper that demonstrates how a doubling in nickel concentration in norwegian spruce led to slower decomposition: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09291...
The crazy thing here is that there is SO MUCH precedent from accumulation of metals by trees in nature. In certain parts of New Caledonia a tree called pycnandra acuminata thrives in ultramorph aka Nickel rich soil. It has up to 24% nickel sap concentration and can be tapped for nickel citrate actually.
https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-45398434
Wow - this post is getting a lot of great discussion. We are working on responding to the comments directly. A few key points to add that help frame how we think about the role biotechnology plays in carbon capture and removal.
Similar to how advanced biotechnology was able to help develop covid vaccines in record time, biotechnology can and should be used a tool in our fight against climate change. Living Carbon works on a broad array of biotech projects to help improve the carbon capture and sequestration of carbon underground.
We chose to share our work on photosynthesis-enhancement as an example of one of the biotechnology tools that can be utilized because 1) there is precedent in literature for similar pathways working in other crops and RuBisCO engineering has been worked on for decades 2) many of the solutions to storing carbon underground for longer are metabolically taxing to plants and can benefit from biotechnology.
In response to vague fears around genetic engineering, if Living Carbon’s work resulted in ecosystem destruction we would not have achieved any of the goals we set out to achieve as a company. We have warmed the world so quickly plants do not have the time to evolve to survive in the harsher world we have created.
It would be silly to think that our trees alone could or should stop climate change. We view each pilot project as an opportunity to study trees in different ecosystem and understand any impacts they have on underlying ecosystems.
We’re intentionally planting trees on land that human previously degraded - such as abandoned mine lands. We’re working to restore ecosystems that have already faced the consequences of human intervention, rather than integrating our trees into already-thriving wild forests.
Many of our test pilot projects include the testing of different microbial treatments to help quantify the impact on photosynthesis and the growth rate of trees.
75% of the earth’s land has already been degraded by humans. 60% of plants are struggling to survive because there are fewer animals and arable land to spread their seeds and maintain a meaningful population. Whether it’s through paving over our rivers or our urban sprawl, we’ve been modifying our world for centuries. Evolution, which is essentially sums of averages over, cannot move at the speed that humans have moved to degrade our plant and warm it.
There is not silver bullet to climate change. Many solutions like mineralization, biochar, and DAC can increase their rate of carbon removal using biotechnology and more efficiently remove carbon from the atmosphere. We need to use human technology to help reintegrate ourselves into our ecosystem and understand how carbon farming using many different carbon removal technologies can help remove carbon from our ecosystem.
The concentrations of metal that would occur from natural hyperacclumulation is actually much less that what occur in the process of pressure treated wood for common commercial uses like decks and building materials. In this case any wood that accumulated metals would be harvested for useful products that benefit from being decomposition resistant. Think wood used in the outside of buildings.
Trees like poplar are often used for phytoremediation projects. There's a lot of prescient for doing this in scientific literature. Check out a few papers here:
Chen, E. L., Chen,Y. A., Chen, L. M., & Liu, Z. H. (2002). Effect of copper on peroxidase activity and lignin content in Raphanus sativus . Plant Physiology and Biochemistry , 40 (5). doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0981-9428(02)01392-X
Hietala, A. M., Nagy, N. E., Burchardt, E. C., & Solheim, H. (2016). Interactions between soil pH, wood heavy metal content and fungal decay at Norway spruce stands. Applied Soil Ecology, 107. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsoil.2016.06.008
Trees have proven incredibly adept at restabilizing the climate over eons. However, to continue to sustainably inhabit the earth as a species, we need to address the imbalance of anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions over the scale of a human lifetime.
We’ve developed a photosynthesis enhancement trait to increase plants’ growth rate and carbon sequestration potential. Some plants have naturally developed a similar method of photosynthesis efficiency increase, known as C4 photosynthesis, which relies on anatomical changes that are only possible in a certain group of plants. Our method achieves similar carbon capture results without requiring elaborate anatomical changes. This is incredibly different from developing an organism that is resistant to glyphosate.
Additionally, while trees sequester an enormous amount of carbon, they also release it back into the air through decomposition. We are developing a range of tree species, with characteristics similar to a slow-decomposing spruce, that are able to keep carbon stored in the high-quality wood for longer.
Similar to the work of the American chestnut, we focus on studying our seedlings on land that otherwise would not be productive for carbon drawdown like abandon mine lands.
Right now we are planting them in controlled environments for further study or on land where other plants cannot grow well - such as abandoned minelands. Our goal is to draw down 1GT of carbon in lands where trees don’t currently thrive; therefore we’re working to restore ecosystems that have already faced the consequences of human intervention, rather than integrating our trees into already-thriving wild forests.
All our current poplar trees are female and do not produce pollen, thus instilling a low fertility rate while maintaining the integrity of the tree to integrate with local ecosystems.
We take an ecosystem approach to everything we do. This includes understanding the interrelationships among species in a given location as well as understanding the economics to help local land stewards thrive. With access to over 17,000 tree variations, we are focused on identifying the most helpful species for a given local area.
We focus on carbon projects that create true additionality. We focus on restoring land that has been degraded or is underperforming. We are specifically interested in abandoned mine land, reclamation land, former range land or farm land. We also work with farmers to plant trees alongside agricultural crops for shade management, riparian buffers and windbreaks.
C4 plants evolved when CO₂ partial pressure was low and there was a higher partial pressure of oxygen in the air, which is the opposite of the trajectory we see today. Therefore, we have reduced the selection pressure on C4 plants.
Rather than try to go against this evolutionary process, we have incorporated natural processes from other plants and algae to achieve the same effect of avoiding photorespiration.
We could but our main focus has been improving the land efficiency of carbon projects and allowing trees to be planted on land that would not otherwise be arable for crops and other trees. We specifically focus using our trees to help clean polluted soil by accumulating excess metals in the lignin and stems of trees. This results in natural fungal decay resistance and improved durability of wood.
We cover the cost of site prep and seedlings for landowners we partner with and retain the rights to the carbon captured by our seedlings. We then monetize the carbon captured by our seedlings.
How and why we have genetically enhanced our seedlings matter a lot. we only include genes from other plants and don't use any genes known to increase plant pet risk or weediness. we have confirmation that we do not require further deregulation by USDA.
Good questions!
1. We are still studying tradeoffs. Given the biochemical mechanism (how we change the trees), we are essentially increasing the amount of energy going to growth and not changing any fundamental ratios between lignin and cellulose. Think of this as similar to when humans go into ketosis :) We have seen some evidence of increased temperature resistance and wilt resistance but not enough data yet to come to any conclusions.
2. Empress trees grow very fast but there is not much of a market for their wood because it is very light. this means it is harder to get landowners to plant these trees. Poplar trees are commonly planted for environmental services like cleaning up of abandon mine lands and loblolly pines which are commonly used for saw timber. The varieties of trees we start with have been studied in the field for decades and we have access to that field trial data to start with.
They do not meet the USDA definition of GMO but FSC is a different story. FSC right now is quite exclusionary and so we are not eligible for FSC certification. I do think that FSC certification is quite challenging for most family foresters to obtain given the price and other challenging criteria. FSC is set up to be easy for large timber companies to obtain but harder for family foresters. Given the work that is being done with the American chestnut and other advances in forest biotechnology, our hope is that FSC will update their definition along the lines of what other certifying bodies like the Tree System and SFI certification organizations have done.
This is a good reminder of how important it is we study ecosystem impacts of any of the work we do. Right now our seedling are female hybrids that don't produce pollen so this is less of a worry. We are working with third party institutions to help us robustly understand our impact.
When it comes to biotechnology a lot of what matters is how you engineering an organism and why. Improving the photosynthetic efficiency of C3 plants to be similar to C4 plants is very different than something like antibiotic or pest resistance.
Luckily, the US plants 1.6B trees a year. The world already knows how to scale up very similar supply chains to what we need to propagate Living Carbon seedlings. We work with a large scale nursery that produces over 300M trees a year right now and they are increase their greenhouse capacity for us. You're correct in needing to include the emissions from planting in how we do our lifecycle carbon analysis. Once upon a time we tried to drive the seedlings up to a planting site in a Model X and it was quite the hassle. Needless to say we need a Remora enable truck or electric truck.
Selective breeding is helpful to get ~1% increase in growth rate per year. Given we use biotechnology to enhance natural processes, we haven't seen the same pushback as if we had added a completely new trait in plants that doesn't occur naturally. When it comes to enhancing our seedlings with microbes for secondary metabolic pathways, additional nutrient fixation or finding specific varieties of trees that preform well in a localized region, we are using methods like selective breeding.
Posted by
maddiehalla on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:28AM
from the self-post dept.
Hi HN! Maddie and Patrick here. We founded Living Carbon (https://www.livingcarbon.com), a biotech company developing trees that grow faster, capture more carbon, and produce more durable wood. Our mission is to help rebalance the planet's carbon cycle using the power of plants.We released research results indicating that photosynthesis enhanced trees grow faster and capture more carbon...