News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by hinkley on Monday March 14, 2022 @01:44PM (#30675497)
The 'man behind the throne' in these forest dynamics is fungi. Trees can fuse roots with their offspring and sometimes cousins (related species). If fungi and humans disappeared tomorrow some trees would still be mother trees, boosting the metabolism of their neighbors. But most of the water and nutrient transport between trees and the ground in temperate forests (where most of the soil carbon exists) is brokered by fungi, and the carbon they trade it for makes up a lot of that soil carbon.

And when you cut down a tree, more than half of the carbon in that tree stays behind in the ground (although I implore scientists to challenge and test this result further. A few of you and a number of the rest of us think this number is low and these numbers influence climate policy a great deal).

If you're engineering trees for carbon sequestration - for actual carbon sequestration, instead of for profiting off carbon sequestration - you probably need to look at root fusion and fungal symbiosis, rather than trunk volume and canopy size. One is fixing a problem. The other is gaming a system that is trying to save us from destroying ourselves. It's tantamount to wartime profiteering.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by jazzyjackson on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:02PM (#30675745)
> root fusion and fungal symbiosis, rather than trunk volume and canopy size

one could consider the soil itself as a living organism by the ton, and I would hope conversations around sequestering carbon will transition into conversations around increasing total biomass on earth.

Carbon gets top billing because its easily measurable and has a direct influence on the greenhouse effect, but the costs of climate change really come from the climate becoming more chaotic - every living organism acts as a buffer for storing energy, carbon, and water - the more life on earth, the more stable the atmosphere becomes.

(I'm no climate scientist, this is my impression from reading Charles Eisenstein's Climate: a New Story, totally turned me around on being fatalistic about climate change)

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by hinkley on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @03:36PM (#30690310)
Gabe Brown refers to the sugars plants offer to fungi as 'liquid carbon'. Ingham calls them 'soil exudates', which is technically more accurate but I think both get the point across.

We can definitely use soil recarbonization as an air brake (pun not intended) for atmospheric carbon increases, but at the end of the day we enjoy an environment that was created by trees running unchecked for millions of years depositing carbon dioxide in the ground, before other fungi learned to eat lignin and slowed the process down.

When you're trying to change habits you need something to do, instead of a list of things not to do, and planting trees and learning how to make them happy are certainly things we can do.