News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cinntaile on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:37AM (#30477443)
Nice job. Now if only some people would see the difference between an actual ponzi scheme like this one and bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. That would be nice.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by gjvc on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:33AM (#30477843)
The common characteristic is that "early adopters" get disproportionately large returns compared to later adopters. Indeed those later adopters are financing the exit of the participants who "got in first". In this way it's like a Ponzi scheme, but the same could be said for stocks.

You might call the above a simplification; that is fine -- my point is that this is a (inaccurate) linguistic shorthand -- calling something by the name of something else which shares a characteristic, but it is inaccurate (a Ponzi scheme has a central organizer / hub), and bitcoin does not.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by adam_arthur on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:02PM (#30480651)
Stocks pay dividends, or have the potential to pay dividends in the future.

You're right that if you look strictly at the now, it resembles a Ponzi scheme, but there's an underlying intrinsic value that supports a given price. If there's not intrinsic value, price usually collapses in the longer run. E.g dotcom, many of the 200x price sales companies over the last year.

Many growth stocks with valuations far detached from fundamentals are very crypto like. Trading on likeability/goodwill rather than anything real.

The lack of intrinsic value is why Crypto is probably doomed to volatility forever.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by Hallucinaut on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:41AM (#30477917)
It's grossly untrue to say it's a Ponzi scheme "like stocks" which are part ownership in companies that actually sell things in the real world and are valued by the present value of their future expected cash flows, rather than cryptocurrencies which have no such relationship to the real world, and some would argue are valued entirely on the premise of returns that can only be sustained by finding the next sucker.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by gjvc on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:14AM (#30478171)
I think we are in violent agreement. Two things can share a characteristic and yet be completely different, but people focus on the similarity (which is easily understood and explainable) and ignore the differences (which can be more difficult to understand and explain).
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by throw_nbvc1234 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:15PM (#30480792)
Blockchains (like eth and its alternatives) sell blocks (compute with a ledger). Those blocks "have value" to the people who build things on them like NFT's, defi, ponzi schemes, etc... One can argue that those applications don't have value, are scams, are unethical but people are paying a lot of money for those blocks on a daily basis; and holders of those L1 tokens benefit from that value. If you think of eth as a niche cloud provider providing compute with a ledger, then it looks like a stock who's long-term value will depend on useful and legal it's niche becomes after people (do or don't) come up with products and regulation is implemented.

> cryptocurrencies which have no such relationship to the real world

This is a key point unless the concept of the metaverse takes off; you're starting to see this change though. Look at the Coachella NFT as an example. People will pay to have guaranteed weekend 1 tickets for multiple years; there are years where this is basically sold out before public ticket sales but there's a status element to be able to go W1. These people (like young adults) will probably go for a few years, get bored (or have a change in lifestyle/priorities), then probably resell those NFT's to someone who's a few years earlier in their lives and wants guaranteed W1. This sounds like a ponzi scheme by the description many commenters here are using; the only value is getting some sucker down the road to waste their money for a guaranteed W1 ticket. There's a non-zero chance that coachella doesn't even exist 5 years from now. There's a bigger chance that it's not as popular and the value of any NFT is worth less then it is today. Yet it doesn't feel as scammy because of the real world event that's involved.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by CPLX on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:22PM (#30482545)
But the product being sold in this example is a season ticket, not an NFT.

The NFT part of the product has no relevance to why it’s valuable. The valuable part is the promise by the event organizer to save a spot for you.

Every major sports team has had this product for decades. It’s literally the same thing as having season tickets to the White Sox or something. The blockchain has added no value to the transaction.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by leeoniya on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:37PM (#30482661)
> The blockchain has added no value to the transaction.

it does make it impossible to make and sell fakes?

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by scatters on Saturday February 26, 2022 @06:28PM (#30483190)
Hah, no it doesn't; anyone can mint what they claim is a season ticket right now. The buyer still has to verify that what they're purchasing is genuine.

On the other hand, it's probably easier for Coachella to maintain a public list of valid ticket NFTs than it is for them to maintain a P2P marketplace for items that change hands very rarely. And also it means that any fraud that occurs is Not Their Problem.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by yunohn on Sunday February 27, 2022 @02:31AM (#30486192)
> Yet it doesn't feel as scammy because of the real world event that's involved.

Well, yes… Buying a season ticket is primarily for the perks, events, etc - not as a long-term average Joe investment.

You can’t just call anything that can be resold as a Ponzi.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by datadata on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:31AM (#30478985)
There are stocks which are fraudulent, e.g Theranos, Enron, or ZZZZ Best. The fact that a company might have expected cash flows does not make them impervious to defrauding investors. Similarly, something issued without any claims of future cash flows does not imply that it must be a fraud.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:36PM (#30480338)
Some stocks have no expected cash flows, some cryptocurrencies have expected cash flows. You can't generalize entire asset classes like that.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cuteboy19 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:09PM (#30485339)
Why would anyone buy something with no positive expected cash flow? That's the same as buying into a greater fools scheme
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:30PM (#30485422)
Read my comment more closely.

> some cryptocurrencies have expected cash flows

Ethereum has cash flow which is expected to go positive after they switch their consensus model from mining to staking this year.

At this point, I wouldn't buy any crypto that doesn't at least have a credible roadmap towards positive cash flow.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cuteboy19 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:39PM (#30485457)
No, you mentioned stocks not having future expected cash flows. I just don't see the difference between that and Ponzi schemes, even if there are some real examples of this
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:52PM (#30485524)
Many popular stocks (all stocks without dividends or buybacks) are like a Ponzi scheme in that all of the money used to pay early investors (through sale of the security) comes from later investors (buying into the security).

However, they are different from a Ponzi scheme in that there is a real business behind them, and no deception/fraud.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by bnralt on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:32AM (#30478352)
It's like a stock market for companies that don't exist.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by ls15 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:06AM (#30478690)
If we compare crypto to stocks, then Bitcoin is Apple and Bitconnect is Theranos.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by NeutralForest on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:15AM (#30477709)
If it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck... Even without the Ponzi scheme and market manipulation; Proof-of-Work based cryptocurrencies are an ecological catastrophe. Other Proof-of-Something™ currencies do not bring much to the table either.

At some point it's only normal there's a push back against cryptocurrencies.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by samarama on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:30AM (#30477811)
That’s why the vast majority of L1s are not proof of work.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by NeutralForest on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:45AM (#30477943)
Yet Bitcoin is still considered the OG token and a "true" cryptocurrency as mentioned above and not old dangerous tech.

Also in the last 10 years, only a handful of tokens have had a somewhat usable blockchain which grinds to a halt anytime people share pictures of cats or monkeys and we're told to wait for another year or two for an update to whatever protocol is trendy at the moment. Rinse and repeat every year. Also also, every other year a cryptocurrency comes along and professes to be the second coming of God with solutions to problems with don't have.

So no, not interested.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:17PM (#30482506)
> Yet Bitcoin is still considered the OG token and a "true" cryptocurrency as mentioned above and not old dangerous tech.

The solution to that is to educate people on how Bitcoin is old dangerous tech, not to throw out all other blockchains along with Bitcoin.

> a somewhat usable blockchain which grinds to a halt anytime people share pictures of cats or monkeys

These chains don't "grind to a halt" in any sense of that phrase, they dynamically price a scarce resource (block space). The chain runs at 100% capacity during these spikes in demand.

> we're told to wait for another year or two for an update to whatever protocol is trendy at the moment. Rinse and repeat every year.

Every few years, cryptocurrencies upgrade their capacity using new technology, and every few years, enough new people start using them to saturate the new, higher capacity. There's nothing contradictory about that.

> Also also, every other year a cryptocurrency comes along and professes to be the second coming of God with solutions to problems with don't have.

Every other year a traditional tech company also comes along and professes to be the second coming of God with solutions to problems we don't have. But we don't judge Apple based on the failure of Juicero.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law

> So no, not interested.

You have a right to not be interested, but you're choosing to share your take, and your take is incorrect.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by beaconstudios on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:49AM (#30477534)
Show me one cryptocurrency that has driven real world industry more than financial speculation and scamming.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cinntaile on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:01AM (#30477612)
You're moving the goal posts. It's fine to be against cryptocurrencies, but I think it damages your credibility when you claim bitcoin is a ponzi scheme. Since it shows a lack of understanding of what a ponzi scheme actually is. By you I don't mean you in particular, I mean it in a more general sense.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by shock-value on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:31AM (#30477824)
We can argue about what constitutes a proper Ponzi scheme, but the idea that the promotion of crypto thus far has existed to allow early adopters to cash out at the apparent expense of later adopters, while bringing essentially no other utility to any of its backers or the public at large, is pretty obvious.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by anm89 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:52AM (#30478551)
This is just plainly not the definition of a ponzi scheme

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponzi_scheme

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by ohyoutravel on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:07AM (#30478706)
That’s just semantics at this point. I would encourage you to address the statement being made and ignore the technical definition of the phrase. To restate without the offending phrase:

[T]he idea that the promotion of crypto thus far has existed to allow early adopters to cash out at the apparent expense of later adopters, while bringing essentially no other utility to any of its backers or the public at large, is pretty obvious.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by Ekaros on Saturday February 26, 2022 @06:19PM (#30483067)
And the semantics matter. When we are using words that mean specific things. Other wise why even care what words we use? Just throw something and expect everyone automatically understand.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by anm89 on Monday February 28, 2022 @06:01PM (#30506385)
I wasn't trying to debate the merits of crypto. I'm pointing out that the parent has a clear misunderstanding of what a ponzi scheme is. The semantics is the whole point. He's using the word incorrectly.

By your definition, every successful stock on the planet is a ponzi scheme

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cinntaile on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:17AM (#30478819)
It is very much not just semantics. Ponzi schemes are illegal so the difference matters.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by ohyoutravel on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:42PM (#30480410)
I double checked and no one in our comment chain has said anything about legality at all, or even implied same, so you pointing that out as the defining distinction is not really relevant, don't you think? Besides, pump and dump schemes of securities are illegal, though notably most crypto is in the grey area because the SEC doesn’t classify it as a security.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cinntaile on Saturday February 26, 2022 @04:24PM (#30482100)
It's a bit of a shortcut. It implies that cryptocurrencies like bitcoin and ethereum don't fulfill the necessary criteria to be deemed a ponzi scheme. If we look at all the red flags mentioned in the wikipedia article.... I shortened some criteria, for a more detailed explanation of each criterium I suggest you check the Wikipedia article.

High investment returns with little or no risk. --- Not true.

Overly consistent returns --- Not true.

Unregistered investments --- True in some cases, not true in others.

Unlicensed sellers --- same as above.

Secretive or complex strategies --- Not true.

Issues with paperwork --- Not true

Difficulty receiving payments --- Not true. Actually irrelevant.

The sales personnel or adviser are overly pushy or aggressive. --- Not true. Actually irrelevant. Not bitcoin or ethereum sales personnel or advisers exist.

The initial contact took place by a cold call or through a social network, a language-based radio or a religious radio advertisement. --- This one is a tough one since there are definitely devotees that likely were vital in the initial spread. In most cases people probably came into contact with crypto through the mainstream media though.

The client cannot determine the actual trades or investments that have been carried out. --- Not true

The clients are asked to write checks with a different name than the name of the corporation (such as an individual) or to send checks to a different address than the corporate address. --- Not true. Actually irrelevant.

Once the maturity date of their investment arrives, clients are pressured to roll over the principal and the profits. --- Not true. Also irrelevant.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cuteboy19 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:12PM (#30485349)
There are many MLMs that are legal despite being thinly disguised Ponzi schemes.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by rsstack on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:19AM (#30477744)
From Wikipedia:

A Ponzi scheme (/ˈpɒnzi/, Italian: [ˈpontsi]) is a form of fraud that lures investors and pays profits to earlier investors with funds from more recent investors.[1] The scheme leads victims to believe that profits are coming from legitimate business activity (e.g., product sales or successful investments), and they remain unaware that other investors are the source of funds. A Ponzi scheme can maintain the illusion of a sustainable business as long as new investors contribute new funds, and as long as most of the investors do not demand full repayment and still believe in the non-existent assets they are purported to own.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:21PM (#30482538)
> The scheme leads victims to believe that profits are coming from legitimate business activity (e.g., product sales or successful investments), and they remain unaware that other investors are the source of funds.

I think that's the key part that contradicts Bitcoin. Nobody believes that Bitcoin is a business that generates profits, and everyone is aware that when they cash out, other investors are the source of funds.

There's no illusion of a business, and no assets that are promised to exist but don't.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by mdoms on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:27PM (#30480913)
Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by Ekaros on Saturday February 26, 2022 @06:19PM (#30483075)
What isn't Ponzi scheme then?
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by deadalus on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:52AM (#30477554)
Monero because its untraceable(real world industry - underground drug markets)

IRS wants to crack it and awarded $1.25 million contract: https://cointelegraph.com/news/chainalysis-and-texas-firm-wi...

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by beaconstudios on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:36AM (#30477875)
This doesn't really shift my priors that the only practical use of crypto is illegal transactions.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by politician on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:58AM (#30478612)
El Salvador legalized Bitcoin for use in fee-free cross-border remittances.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by mdoms on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:28PM (#30480930)
Fee free bitcoin transactions? How does that work?
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by politician on Saturday February 26, 2022 @04:44PM (#30482274)
Bank fee free.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by mdoms on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:13PM (#30482473)
So, not fee free?
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by toomuchtodo on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:19AM (#30477749)
Do you need to crack it if the government can be a majority hashrate of the miner pool? One need not crack it to control it. You'd be able to double spend, mine empty blocks, orphan blocks from other miners, etc. Just need to get to and sustain 51% of the hash pool, which sounds trivial considering nation state compute resources.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by Tenoke on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:06AM (#30478088)
I see no scamming in say Link (bringing offchain data on-chain for other projects to use) or SNX (on-chain synthetic assets). There's a ton of examples of projects that have nothing to do with scams and are more akin to normal companies providing blockchain-related services.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by beaconstudios on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:09AM (#30478116)
That may be true, but I was looking for positive outcomes from the industry as a whole. Of course there are companies like metamask as well that just provide services within the crypto industry.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by TimJRobinson on Tuesday March 01, 2022 @01:53AM (#30510541)
Alchemix, Axie Infinity, Balancer, Aave, Pool Together, DyDx, Sorare.

Hundreds more too, I list them in most of these threads and yet every time, same question. The amount of people who confidently proclaim crypto does nothing useful without actually looking into the cool things that are happening is getting old.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by DonHopkins on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:32AM (#30477841)
The fact that cryptocurrencies are even Ponzier than any Ponzi scheme, more pyramidal than any pyramid scheme, much getter, richer, and quicker than any get-rich-quick scheme, and more shaggily carpeted and vigorously jerked than any rug-pull scheme, doesn't mean they're not scams.

Edit: when shills gets called on purposefully missing the point by arguing over semantics, they switch to outright denial and making stuff up. Actually, ethereum and bitcoin ARE both scams, in fact the biggest ones of them all. And that IS the point.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cinntaile on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:24AM (#30478897)
> Edit: when shills gets called on purposefully missing the point by arguing over semantics, they switch to outright denial and making stuff up. Actually, ethereum and bitcoin ARE both scams, in fact the biggest ones of them all. And that IS the point.

I think I replied in a respectful way to your original comment that was essentially just poisoning the well. I also feel it's a bit dishonest to reply to my comment by editing your post. You are now deliberately trying to discredit what I say by calling me a shill, this is not how we can have a curious discussion.

What is it that I am outright denying and making up?

Just claiming something is a scam doesn't make it so, you have to provide some sort of arguments to support your thesis.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cinntaile on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:49AM (#30477965)
There are definitely cryptocurrencies out there that are scams, but big ones like ethereum and bitcoin for example are not. This is besides the point though.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by mdoms on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:29PM (#30480940)
Bitcoin and Ethereum are scams.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:25PM (#30482575)
Why?
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:45PM (#30485487)
A friend asked me to watch that video back when it came out, but I couldn't get past all the technical inaccuracies about Bitcoin and Ethereum in the first half hour or so.

Most of those links are about artwork NFTs, not Bitcoin or Ethereum.

There are a lot of cryptocurrencies that are scams, and there are a lot of NFT projects that are scams. I've heard respectable arguments that Bitcoin and Ethereum are not actually all that useful (which is for the most part the point your remaining sources attempt to make), but that's a whole world of difference from them being scams.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by DonHopkins on Sunday February 27, 2022 @05:40AM (#30487056)
And just what specifically were those "technical inaccuracies" that were so intolerable to you that you couldn't stomach watching the whole thing?

You should thank your friend for trying to deprogram you from the cult you've fallen for, and go back and watch the entire video. Because he makes excellent and "technically accurate" points about the cult-like behavior of that community, which explains why you're so quick to "ignore warning signs and dismiss criticism", and have a such a difficult time perceiving the pervasive fraud that's so stunningly obvious to everyone else:

>The shorthand WAGMI, We’re All Going To Make It, is aphoristically bandied about even in openly zero-sum competitions where, by definition, most participants explicitly won’t make it.

>But you can’t point that out, because that would be FUD.

>And if you’re spreading FUD then you’re NGMI, Not Going to Make It.

>And making it, getting rich, is all that matters.

>HFSP, have fun staying poor.

>These are synthesized into a No True Scotsman paradigm.

>The “we” in We’re All Going To Make It does not refer to we all, it refers to the select, the chosen, the Diamond Hands and the hodlers.

>Those who make it are clearly the We, and if you didn’t make it, then you weren’t.

>People who get angry about being scammed by a rug-pull or by malware or by social engineering are berated and belittled for not following the crowd.

>This incubates a community trained to ignore warning signs and dismiss criticism, a community with internal language and customs that are explicitly incompatible with outside communications.

>Skepticism is FUD from non-believers who are trying to undermine the value of your assets and manipulate a crash or trick you into being a paper hands.

>It all maps onto narratives of sin and deception, a chosen-few who are privileged with advance knowledge about the promised land, which they can achieve by holding strong to the rituals and expelling all doubt.

>The end product is a self-organizing high-control group.

But back to the main point: Do you earnestly believe that his extremely well-documented point that Bitcoin and Ethereum are riddled with fraud that's pervasively promoted by shills is "technically inaccurate"? Are you asking us to believe all those shills are actually correct and telling the truth, or do you deny the existence of shills and their get-rich-quick pyramid schemes?

Since you asked "why" "Bitcoin and Ethereum are scams", here is the transcript of Line Goes Up, which decidedly answers your question.

https://eizebasa.baby/line-goes-up

Which of the following quotes do you claim are "technically inaccurate"? And what do you claim are the "technically accurate" counter-arguments? Please refer to specific quotes.

>And as far as banking is concerned, Bitcoin was never designed to solve the actual problems created by the banking industry, only to be the new medium by which they operated.

>Peter Thiel, who also went from wealthy to ultra-wealthy off the Web2 boom via PayPal, loves crypto, and is friends with a bunch of eugenics advocates who promote cryptocurrency as a return to “sound money” for a whole bunch of extremely racist reasons because when they start talking about banks and bankers, they mean Jews.

>So just to head all this off at the pass, Bitcoin and proof-of-work cryptocurrency aren’t incentivizing a move to green energy sources, like solar and wind, they are offsetting it.

>Because electrical consumption, electrical waste, is the value that underpins Bitcoin.

>Miners spend X dollars in electricity to mine a Bitcoin, they expect to be able to sell that coin for at least X plus profit.

>When new power sources come online and the price of electricity goes down, they don’t let X go down, they build a bigger machine.

>[Drumming] In 2012 Vitalik Buterin, a crypto enthusiast and butthurt Warlock main set out to fix what he saw as the failings and inflexibilities of Bitcoin.

>Rather than becoming the new digital currency, a thing that people actually used to buy stuff, Bitcoin had become an unwieldy speculative financial instrument, too slow and expensive to use for anything other than stunt purchases of expensive cars.

>It was infested with money laundering and mired in bad press.

>After the FBI shut down Silk Road you couldn’t even buy drugs with it anymore.

>In practice you couldn’t do anything with your Bitcoin but bet on it, lock up money you already have in the hopes that Bitcoin goes up later, and pray you don’t lose it all in a scam, lose access to your wallet, or have it all stolen by an exchange.

>In terms of problems with Bitcoin, Ethereum solves none of them and introduces a whole new suite of problems driven by the technofetishistic egotism of assuming that programmers are uniquely suited to solve society’s problems.

>Bitcoin in particular, owing to its glacial transaction times, suffers from problems where the value of the coin can change dramatically between the start and end of a transaction.

>Ethereum is ultimately a central platform, and the fact that a few dozen people need to sign off on every major change before it can be implemented is largely meaningless and symbolic, with the validation network ultimately sitting somewhere between consortium and cartel.

>While the network of Ethereum miners and validators are not a formal corporation Yet There’s no mechanism in existence that compels them to act in the interest of users, particularly poor and disempowered users, where those interests conflict with their own.

>The movement of Ethereum from proof of work to proof of stake has been vapourware in no small part because the validators simply choose not to.

>The entire market is absolutely lousy with scams, and has been since Bitcoin first gained any traction.

>Every single scam structure imaginable has been dusted off and redeployed into this explicitly unregulated market where victims are largely without recourse.

>These range from institutional scams, like Ponzi schemes, pump and dumps, and insider trading, to middle-weight scams like gold brick and wash trading, to grittier scams like phishing and sending fake links.

>Pump and dumps, in particular, are conducted in broad daylight, since it’s not illegal, it’s just against the terms of service of the exchanges that you use to do it, so the worst case scenario is you burn your account.

>They’ll straight up walk you through the process of doing a pump and dump, no codewords, diagrams and everything.

>They’re notable as they’re actually a two-headed scam because, you see, you might get recruited onto the pump half of the scheme, or you might think you’re being recruited to pump, but you’re actually the dump.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cinntaile on Sunday February 27, 2022 @07:24AM (#30487714)
Not who you asked but I'll reply anyway.

>And as far as banking is concerned, Bitcoin was never designed to solve the actual problems created by the banking industry, only to be the new medium by which they operated.

Bitcoins original goal was to try and solve the trusted third-party issue. "A peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution." So definitely not be the new medium through which banks operated.

> Peter Thiel, who also went from wealthy to ultra-wealthy off the Web2 boom via PayPal, loves crypto, and is friends with a bunch of eugenics advocates who promote cryptocurrency as a return to “sound money” for a whole bunch of extremely racist reasons because when they start talking about banks and bankers, they mean Jews.

Guilt by association isn't an argument. You tried to use the same trick on me by calling me a shill, so maybe that's why you don't recognize the logical fallacy. Either way, it's not valid. It's a staple in any propaganda handbook though. Web2.0 was coined in 2004, two years after Paypal IPOd by the way.

We're on quote number two and the "arguments" are already at rock bottom, I'll stop here.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Sunday February 27, 2022 @01:19PM (#30490917)
None of that speaks to Bitcoin or Ethereum being scams.

You've posted a wall of text about how they enable scams and how the community is riddled with fraud and pyramid schemes. Guess what, I agree with you.

You accuse me of ignoring the cult-like behavior of the crypto community, when I am more familiar with it than anyone. But the behavior of a community has nothing to do with whether a network communications protocol is a scam.

You accuse me of "ignoring warning signs and dismissing criticism" when I am intimately familiar with the warning signs that many cryptos besides Bitcoin and Ethereum have, and I welcome criticism as long as it's not based on a foundation of misunderstandings of the technical workings of the protocol.

You accuse me of having a difficult time perceiving the pervasive fraud that's so stunningly obvious to everyone else. I am acutely aware of the pervasive fraud, but fraud being pervasive doesn't mean that the Bitcoin or Ethereum protocols themselves are frauds.

You know what else is riddled with fraud? The internet, the telephone, and originally the telegraph (leading to a whole new class of crimes called wire fraud).

But to pick at just one of the technical inaccuracies:

>Ethereum is ultimately a central platform, and the fact that a few dozen people need to sign off on every major change before it can be implemented is largely meaningless and symbolic, with the validation network ultimately sitting somewhere between consortium and cartel.

Ethereum has roughly 2,000 nodes, the operator of each of which must approve a change and manually upgrade, otherwise they continue to participate in the unchanged version of the network. In practice, this means that every customer-facing exchange, custodial wallet, and service provider needs to "sign off" on a change in order for the fork to be legitimized.

>The movement of Ethereum from proof of work to proof of stake has been vapourware

Ethereum's beacon chain proof of stake network has been running since November 2020 and has received its first hard fork upgrade, Altair. Currently, there is a public merge testnet named Kiln, the second testnet rehearsing the "merge" event where Proof Of Stake replaces Proof Of Work as the Ethereum execution chain's consensus model. The code is there, the network is there, and it's all running publicly. You can download the client software today from the public github repo and run it to join the network and help rehearse the merge, in a way that is very close to the final specifications. That's the opposite of vaporware.

> in no small part because the validators simply choose not to.

Moving consensus models is done by hard fork, it has absolutely nothing to do with "validators choosing not to." Think of it like the Ethereum development team, with the explicit permission of the exchanges and service providers, changing the direction of a firehose to point at the PoS validators instead of the PoW validators. The PoW validators can't grab on to the stream of water and wrestle the hose away, their income stream just vanishes.

Those are 2-3 examples of technical inaccuracies. More technical inaccuracies in that video surround the characteristics, economics, minimums, and protocol liveness guarantees for Proof Of Stake, the nature and maturity of protocol scaling, the nature of bounded historical data size, and the nature of network congestion (it does not in any circumstances lead to forks, that's complete bunk).

If I chose to indulge your shotgun approach, we'd both be here all day and I don't really want that. This comment is already getting long and took a lot of effort for me to write up. Most of your copypasta can be summed up as problems with the community, not problems with the network protocols themselves.

I'm not here to try to convince you to like cryptocurrency, you're free to hold whatever opinion about it you want. It just really annoys me when people spread misinformation about how the protocols are constructed, and try to characterize them as scams when they are nothing more than distributed database software.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by lawn on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:19AM (#30478846)
> The fact that cryptocurrencies are even Ponzier than any Ponzi scheme

What does that even mean?

Especially since most cryptocurrencies factually doesn't fit the definition of a Ponzi scheme.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cuteboy19 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:21PM (#30485384)
What is the factual difference? The similarities being that both rely on finding an ever greater number of people to buy in so that early investors can cash out.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by lawn on Sunday February 27, 2022 @02:13AM (#30486121)
That's a pyramid scheme, a Ponzi scheme is a subset where earlier investors are paid profit using money from the later investors, giving the appearance of a functioning business.

In the same way you can argue that investing in gold is a pyramid scheme (since it relies on its price going up), you can argue that crypto is too.

(Note that there are some real Ponzi schemes in crypto too, but they're not real cryptocurrencies either.)

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cuteboy19 on Sunday February 27, 2022 @05:51AM (#30487109)
Gold is a physical commodity with plenty of uses (ornaments, electronics etc). This is not true for cryptocurrency.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by mdoms on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:25PM (#30480888)
They're all Ponzi schemes. Every last one of them.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by capableweb on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:52AM (#30477550)
Let's assume for the faith of your argument that Bitcoin is a ponzi scheme. Who is at the top that gains from all of this? And how are you gonna indict "them" when seemingly no one knows who they are?
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by espadrine on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:17AM (#30477725)
Names are hard, because it is common to name something with what looks most like it, even when there are differences.

There are two separate phenomena that give it the appearance of a Ponzi.

First, a Ponzi works by taking the money of new investors, and distributing it to past investors that cash out with “profit”. Similarly, BTC investing (as in, intending to make a profit from the difference between the buy and the sell price) works by taking the money of new investors (in an exchange) and distributing it to past investors that cash out, yielding a profit that, from a systemic perspective, will eventually cause someone’s loss. From that viewpoint, successful investors are unwittingly taking the money of people that may not afford the loss.

Second, a Ponzi works by making up assets (typically financial instruments) out of thin air, and selling them to victims (some of which will profit, many will lose), making a profit out of thin air. Similarly, the creator of a cryptocurrency typically puts itself in a position where they either premine the coins, or create an algorithmic schedule where most of the coins are created in the first few years, making them out of thin air, and giving themselves a significant advantage, as they will give themselves a generous chunk. They then sell those coins to victims, making a profit out of thin air. Even Nakamoto famously was flagged as an intensive miner in early years, and clearly did not expect to be deanonymized by the coinbase counter, since they changed it once it was found out.

It is true that there are dissimilarities as well. The largest one is the failure mode. A traditional Ponzi fails because people that did not get their “guaranteed profit, whisper past performances is not a guide for future performance”, are unlikely to reinvest, leading to a breaking point where everyone takes their money out until none is left. In the types of cryptocurrencies described above, people are often willing to reinvest even when they lost substantial amounts.

The failure mode typically comes many decades later, when lost keys (deaths etc) cause a slow deflation until no coin remains in use.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by TheFreim on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:59AM (#30477603)
> Who is at the top that gains from all of this?

In a ponzi scheme the people higher in the pyramid are anyone who joined in the past and is trying to grow it. You could say Satoshi with his early mining and various other "insiders", whether their identity is known or not, are at the top. I don't necessarily agree that it's a ponzi scheme, although I'm sympathetic with many anti-crypto arguments, but that's the reasoning if expect they'd use.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by chiefalchemist on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:03AM (#30477628)
Ponzi scheme? Perhaps not. So maybe we need a new word? It's a new invention, and thus might require a new lexicon to capture its essence.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by jtbayly on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:43AM (#30477929)
Sounds like a fiat currency in many respects. Which is funny since that’s what it was supposed to not be.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by DonHopkins on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:57AM (#30478023)
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cygx on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:39AM (#30477898)
Here are some terms that already exists: 'economic bubble', 'pump and dump', 'greater fool theory', ...
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by Ekaros on Saturday February 26, 2022 @06:22PM (#30483125)
'Mania' etc.

There is nothing special about crypto apart it being digital and new... Art, collectibles, real estate... Many things have been overvalued with basis that prices have always gone up and being paid by those acquiring them later...

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by keithalewis on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:06AM (#30477644)
Let's just agree to call it a distributed digital Ponzi scheme used for ledgerdemain.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by jtbayly on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:43AM (#30477934)
Ledger. I see what you did there.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by Ekaros on Saturday February 26, 2022 @06:15PM (#30483027)
I keep being annoyed that people keep throwing ponzi at things that really aren't that. Words has meaning and Ponzi describe certain kind of scheme. Not a scam in general...
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by louwrentius on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:43AM (#30477488)
There isn't any difference.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by TheFreim on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:54AM (#30477568)
I'm very sympathetic with many of the "anti"-crypto arguments but to say there is no difference between BitConnect and Bitcoin/Ethereum is just wrong. You might believe their value is based on a similar concept, pyramid scheme type construct, but they still have massive differences. Bitcoin/Ethereum/etc actually do /something/ (even if you ultimately come to the conclusion that that something is bad).
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by astoor on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:42AM (#30477919)
Plausible deniability is one of ways the cryptocurrency schemes have continued for so long without collapsing - members can convince themselves that Bitcoin/Ethereum/etc. aren't ponzi/pyramid schemes because they "do something". Furthermore, that "something" can keep changing over time (e.g. for Ethereum it was first ICOs and DApps, currently it is NFTs and DeFi, and in future likely to be something else), which keeps the schemes self-sustaining. It is the plausible deniability and evolving self-sustainability which are the main advantages Bitcoin/Ethereum/etc. have over simpler schemes like BitConnect.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by TheFreim on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:12AM (#30478140)
> Furthermore, that "something" can keep changing over time

I don't follow. DApps didn't change to nfts, did they? I'm pretty sure they still are used and developed.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by astoor on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:40AM (#30479099)
No, DApps didn't change into NFTs, and yes, DApps and ICOs still exist. But DApps and ICOs are not the current "revolutionary" "game changing" drivers for "line goes up" in the Ethereum world. Similarly I'd expect NFTs and DeFi to continue to exist after whatever supersedes them as the main attraction to draw in new members. Just like there are still people who talk about Bitcoin as "electronic cash" even though most have moved on to other narratives like "digital gold". That is the evolving self-sustainability aspect of plausible deniability. The schemes are flexible enough for existing scheme members to claim they are whatever they need to be to continue drawing in those all-important new scheme members, although most likely only for a finite period of time.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by JackFr on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:15AM (#30477708)
> Bitcoin/Ethereum/etc actually do /something/

Big if true.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by TheFreim on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:37AM (#30477878)
You might think that the "something" "legit" crypto does isn't a good solution even though it IS doing "something". Bitcoin works as a distributed ledger, depending on your view that might be a solution in search if a problem but it's still something.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by danaris on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:01AM (#30478634)
"Working as a distribute ledger" is a means to an end, not an end in itself. It's a tool.

What is that tool useful for that isn't better served by other tools?

That is the question that has never been answered, at least not to my satisfaction.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by qzx_pierri on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:47AM (#30477517)
I don't think crypto is a ponzi scheme, but I DO think storing your crypto on third party servers is dangerous.

Although whenever I hear claims of "guaranteed returns" or "proprietary investment technologies" I do think it may be a ponzi scheme lol

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by z3c0 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:50AM (#30477540)
It will take time. Upsetting technologies attract conartists like flies to honey. Critics will deliberately conflate the cons with the rest until then, as it's a very convenient argument (though obviously fallacious.)
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by spicyusername on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:52AM (#30477551)
> It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.

> - Upton Sinclair

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by sbarre on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:58AM (#30477596)
Is this a pro or con comment? Could be both I suppose.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by DonHopkins on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:39AM (#30477893)
Pro-cryptocurrency comments are usually cons.

And unfortunately nobody's salary depends on preventing other people from shilling get-rich-quick pyramid schemes. (Except maybe for dang's.)

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by dennis_jeeves1 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:10AM (#30478124)
It's a relatively objective assessment of the topic, and human nature in general.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by TheFreim on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:04AM (#30477632)
Alternatively, con-artists pose as upsetting technologies to convince people to get in on the "ground floor" of the exciting hyped tech (doesn't necessarily apply to crypto).
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by logicalmonster on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:51AM (#30477548)
The really fascinating bit isn't that they're currently programmed to think that crypto is doubleplusungood, it's the 180 narrative flip they'll do the second that their chosen media entities tells them to view crypto as doubleplusgood. You're going to see hordes of former crypto detractors rewrite history in their minds and come out with a new viewpoint without an inkling of self-awareness.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by civilized on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:58AM (#30477599)
I'll ask you the same question I ask everyone who spouts nonsense - when it turns out you're wrong, will you care? Or is possessing this worldview somehow intrinsically satisfying to you, regardless of reality?
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by logicalmonster on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:34AM (#30477855)
1) What exactly would I be wrong about? A good test for cognitive dissonance is comparing your predictions to reality, and I do not believe that I ever stated that BitCoin is inevitably going to become the most important currency in the world. I think crypto is great conceptually (which will never be not true) and that it may or may not succeed in the marketplace. Bitcoin itself may not succeed long-term even if crypto does. I acknowledge all of those things.

2) If crypto "fails", I'd say that the reason for the failure is important in making an assessment. If it fails because the technology is too slow long-term or not enough people choose not to use it for a very long-time, that's one thing that would be harder to argue against. If crypto fails because it's effectively legislated out of existence, that would be hard to see that as anything but a vindication of the concept.

3) For what it's worth, while I consider myself to be a fairly rational person, nobody is absolutely immune to cognitive dissonance. You should constantly check your premises and examine your past predictions. That's part of why I support the absolute right to free speech and debate ideas and play devil's advocate a lot.

4) I stand firm on one prediction. If some government out there decides to use some crypto for their central bank, they're going to have their media pump out support for it, and many former crypto opponents will be reprogrammed on the fly and take on a pro-crypto viewpoint without skipping a beat if they're told to.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by civilized on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:33AM (#30478364)
That's all well and good. The only thing I'll say is, I think you vastly overestimate how many people are programmed one way or the other. I think a few people have formed their own opinions, a few people have been politically programmed, and the vast majority have no real opinion on the goodness or badness. For them, Bitcoin is just a curiosity or a fun casino to play in.

I also wouldn't neglect that a lot of people have been programmed by crypto ideology.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by lolinder on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:08AM (#30478717)
> If crypto fails because it's effectively legislated out of existence, that would be hard to see that as anything but a vindication of the concept.

If the concept is "decentralized payments are resistant to government intervention", then wouldn't the government killing crypto be proof that the concept failed?

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by logicalmonster on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:57PM (#30480586)
> If the concept is "decentralized payments are resistant to government intervention", then wouldn't the government killing crypto be proof that the concept failed?

Anything can be physically destroyed and anybody can be physically jailed or killed, so I suppose there will never be a currency that is 100% immune to punitive government action.

But it seems like a vindication of the concept if some government felt threatened enough by crypto to have to forcibly go after it. Harmless bad ideas are generally not targeted (see furries for example) the only things that are forcibly banned are things that pose some kind of threat to the power structure.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by civilized on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:57PM (#30481211)
A lot of people want crypto banned simply because its uses seem to be almost entirely restricted to criminal activity and speculation (i.e. gambling).
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by logicalmonster on Saturday February 26, 2022 @03:35PM (#30481680)
> A lot of people

1) Despite crypto being around for just over a decade and real commerce being transacted with it, we're still in the frighteningly early days of its use. I'd say that even super-smart technical people are just barely scratching the surface and it's probably going to be about 3-5 years before an average technical person has a proper understanding of what a blockchain is and how it works, let alone understanding the ramifications of oracles when combined with smart contracts. Everybody is entitled to their opinion, but there's no chance that the general public really understands crypto right now, especially when their impression of it comes from a media that doesn't understand it either.

2) Regardless of most peoples' understanding of it, it should go without saying that human rights should not be up to a poll.

> want crypto banned simply because its uses seem to be almost entirely restricted to criminal activity

1) I don't know what percentage of crypto uses are normal commerce and which are criminal actions, but I know firsthand that crypto is used for all kinds of business payments for years.

2) You might as well advocate banning paper cash, most banks, etc if you want to ban something tied to crime.

> and speculation (i.e. gambling).

It should go without saying that even the worst excesses of gambling are legal in a free society.

If you want to ban all financial speculation, you might as well ban all betting and the stock market too.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by civilized on Saturday February 26, 2022 @04:02PM (#30481940)
I stand by my statements. Bitcoin is a bad currency for anyone but criminals and speculators. People toy with using it for legitimate purposes, but it's fundamentally not competitive.

Most of your response is based on a failure to understand how useful things that can be misused are different from things that have virtually no good use and lots of bad ones. If Bitcoin was banned tomorrow, the world would be no worse off.