News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by gjvc on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:33AM (#30477843)
The common characteristic is that "early adopters" get disproportionately large returns compared to later adopters. Indeed those later adopters are financing the exit of the participants who "got in first". In this way it's like a Ponzi scheme, but the same could be said for stocks.

You might call the above a simplification; that is fine -- my point is that this is a (inaccurate) linguistic shorthand -- calling something by the name of something else which shares a characteristic, but it is inaccurate (a Ponzi scheme has a central organizer / hub), and bitcoin does not.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by adam_arthur on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:02PM (#30480651)
Stocks pay dividends, or have the potential to pay dividends in the future.

You're right that if you look strictly at the now, it resembles a Ponzi scheme, but there's an underlying intrinsic value that supports a given price. If there's not intrinsic value, price usually collapses in the longer run. E.g dotcom, many of the 200x price sales companies over the last year.

Many growth stocks with valuations far detached from fundamentals are very crypto like. Trading on likeability/goodwill rather than anything real.

The lack of intrinsic value is why Crypto is probably doomed to volatility forever.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by Hallucinaut on Saturday February 26, 2022 @09:41AM (#30477917)
It's grossly untrue to say it's a Ponzi scheme "like stocks" which are part ownership in companies that actually sell things in the real world and are valued by the present value of their future expected cash flows, rather than cryptocurrencies which have no such relationship to the real world, and some would argue are valued entirely on the premise of returns that can only be sustained by finding the next sucker.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by gjvc on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:14AM (#30478171)
I think we are in violent agreement. Two things can share a characteristic and yet be completely different, but people focus on the similarity (which is easily understood and explainable) and ignore the differences (which can be more difficult to understand and explain).
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by throw_nbvc1234 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:15PM (#30480792)
Blockchains (like eth and its alternatives) sell blocks (compute with a ledger). Those blocks "have value" to the people who build things on them like NFT's, defi, ponzi schemes, etc... One can argue that those applications don't have value, are scams, are unethical but people are paying a lot of money for those blocks on a daily basis; and holders of those L1 tokens benefit from that value. If you think of eth as a niche cloud provider providing compute with a ledger, then it looks like a stock who's long-term value will depend on useful and legal it's niche becomes after people (do or don't) come up with products and regulation is implemented.

> cryptocurrencies which have no such relationship to the real world

This is a key point unless the concept of the metaverse takes off; you're starting to see this change though. Look at the Coachella NFT as an example. People will pay to have guaranteed weekend 1 tickets for multiple years; there are years where this is basically sold out before public ticket sales but there's a status element to be able to go W1. These people (like young adults) will probably go for a few years, get bored (or have a change in lifestyle/priorities), then probably resell those NFT's to someone who's a few years earlier in their lives and wants guaranteed W1. This sounds like a ponzi scheme by the description many commenters here are using; the only value is getting some sucker down the road to waste their money for a guaranteed W1 ticket. There's a non-zero chance that coachella doesn't even exist 5 years from now. There's a bigger chance that it's not as popular and the value of any NFT is worth less then it is today. Yet it doesn't feel as scammy because of the real world event that's involved.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by CPLX on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:22PM (#30482545)
But the product being sold in this example is a season ticket, not an NFT.

The NFT part of the product has no relevance to why it’s valuable. The valuable part is the promise by the event organizer to save a spot for you.

Every major sports team has had this product for decades. It’s literally the same thing as having season tickets to the White Sox or something. The blockchain has added no value to the transaction.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by leeoniya on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:37PM (#30482661)
> The blockchain has added no value to the transaction.

it does make it impossible to make and sell fakes?

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by scatters on Saturday February 26, 2022 @06:28PM (#30483190)
Hah, no it doesn't; anyone can mint what they claim is a season ticket right now. The buyer still has to verify that what they're purchasing is genuine.

On the other hand, it's probably easier for Coachella to maintain a public list of valid ticket NFTs than it is for them to maintain a P2P marketplace for items that change hands very rarely. And also it means that any fraud that occurs is Not Their Problem.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by yunohn on Sunday February 27, 2022 @02:31AM (#30486192)
> Yet it doesn't feel as scammy because of the real world event that's involved.

Well, yes… Buying a season ticket is primarily for the perks, events, etc - not as a long-term average Joe investment.

You can’t just call anything that can be resold as a Ponzi.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by datadata on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:31AM (#30478985)
There are stocks which are fraudulent, e.g Theranos, Enron, or ZZZZ Best. The fact that a company might have expected cash flows does not make them impervious to defrauding investors. Similarly, something issued without any claims of future cash flows does not imply that it must be a fraud.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:36PM (#30480338)
Some stocks have no expected cash flows, some cryptocurrencies have expected cash flows. You can't generalize entire asset classes like that.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cuteboy19 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:09PM (#30485339)
Why would anyone buy something with no positive expected cash flow? That's the same as buying into a greater fools scheme
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:30PM (#30485422)
Read my comment more closely.

> some cryptocurrencies have expected cash flows

Ethereum has cash flow which is expected to go positive after they switch their consensus model from mining to staking this year.

At this point, I wouldn't buy any crypto that doesn't at least have a credible roadmap towards positive cash flow.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by cuteboy19 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:39PM (#30485457)
No, you mentioned stocks not having future expected cash flows. I just don't see the difference between that and Ponzi schemes, even if there are some real examples of this
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by everfree on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:52PM (#30485524)
Many popular stocks (all stocks without dividends or buybacks) are like a Ponzi scheme in that all of the money used to pay early investors (through sale of the security) comes from later investors (buying into the security).

However, they are different from a Ponzi scheme in that there is a real business behind them, and no deception/fraud.

Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by bnralt on Saturday February 26, 2022 @10:32AM (#30478352)
It's like a stock market for companies that don't exist.
Re:Bitconnect founder indicted in global $2.4B cryptocurrenc... by ls15 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:06AM (#30478690)
If we compare crypto to stocks, then Bitcoin is Apple and Bitconnect is Theranos.