News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by verdverm on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:30PM (#30470484)
I think worse than keyloggers is that people are learning how to make the yellow lines in Grammarly go away rather than learning to write better. The training of humans on AI which was trained to be a (dull) average of prior humans has unforeseen consequences. I've seen Google grammar suggestions getting worse with time.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Arubis on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:53PM (#30470740)
This may be the case, but "this tool is a potentially massive privacy and security intrusion" is a drastically different conversation than "calculators mean students can't do arithmetic anymore".
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by mattnewton on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:58PM (#30470805)
I think "calculators mean students can't do arithmetic anymore" is perhaps an uncharitable take because it ignores that calculators aren't also trying to learn arithmetic from examples of people using them. Eventually grammar correction algorithms will injest text written with them or other grammar correction algorithms as ground truth in their efforts to improve and adapt to new idioms- this may already be the case.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by uoaei on Friday February 25, 2022 @02:21PM (#30471078)
NLP researchers are tearing their hair out about this right now, since people are posting mountains of GPT/etc.-generated text online with no easy way to distinguish whether it's of human or other origin.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by adhesive_wombat on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:49PM (#30472199)
Reminds me of a scifi book where the Internet-analogue is so corrupted with junk deliberately injected by filtering services so that they can sell you the filters that it's impossible to use "naked".

I think it's either Neal Stephenson or maybe Stephen Baxter, but I'm not sure which book it was an aside in (it's not Fall, I haven't read that yet, though that appears to have a similar idea).

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Kim_Bruning on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:17PM (#30472479)
I guess we're entering a new phase of language evolution, then; whether we want it or not.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by wyldfire on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:29PM (#30471995)
Maybe we should create a neural network model that could label arbitrary text as -- nah!
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Tyr42 on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:08PM (#30472396)
That's a Gan but with more steps right?
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by NateEag on Friday February 25, 2022 @02:59PM (#30471656)
Well... you can read it.

I might be wrong, but so far I think it's been pretty easy to tell if text came from a human or a deep-learning system.

Granted, that probably doesn't scale well.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by uoaei on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:16PM (#30473546)
That has been true up until very recently, but lately there has emerged an uncanny valley that has confused the distinction between "underpaid freelance (ESL) writer farm" and "shoddy but roughly convincing neural language model" so that you may be convinced the blogspam you may happen upon across the internet may just as easily be computer-generated as anything else.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by MichaelZuo on Saturday February 26, 2022 @08:04AM (#30477207)
If GPT-3 et al. are producing results on par with "underpaid freelance (ESL) writer farm" then wouldn’t the next step be to focus only on better writing? i.e. books, newspapers, magazines, etc.

Obviously the corpus (perhaps 1 trillion to to 10 trillion words?) will be exhausted by a sufficiently large model so there’s an upper bound.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by NateEag on Friday February 25, 2022 @11:52PM (#30475292)
Okay, interesting.

Thanks for sharing!

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by aaaaaaaaata on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:17PM (#30471856)
Most, not all.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by andrewjl on Friday February 25, 2022 @08:48PM (#30474579)
This sounds like a case of "garbage in garbage out". Machine learning needs to account for that regardless.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by eternityforest on Friday February 25, 2022 @07:41PM (#30474233)
Writing and arithmetic are a lot different. Activities involving math are very rarely done away from a phone, and computers are for all intents and purposes 100% reliable at it.

The best mathematician in the world will probably get the same answer I will on a calculator. At most maybe I'll get an irrelevant rounding error.

If there was only one good way to state any idea, no matter the context or intent, it would be different.

I could choose not to use grammarly if I had something to hide, with little trouble. It doesn't do anything most can't do themselves, or anything a local FOSS checker can't do once browsers start integrating them as they probably will someday.

The real danger would be a world in which I can't legally choose not to use it or for some other reason it is no longer a free choice.

Is journalism not part of how we prevent that?

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by kohllision on Friday February 25, 2022 @05:59PM (#30473410)
This is comparable to the argument that programmers are learning how to eliminate compiler/linter warnings rather than learning how to program better. Immediate feedback is the best learning tool and one leads to the other. Of course, natural languages are far more complex and have no universal standard. While it is true that no easy way to check for style, be it in programming or writing, we should encourage the use of such tools (once they are secure and privacy-friendly) as writing assistants.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by voakbasda on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:54PM (#30481187)
No, it’s comparable to your compiler/linter suggesting fixes when it spots issues. Pointing out an error is one level of knowledge, suggesting a fix is not in the same class. Take away the grammar tools’ ability to make suggestions, and you have something equivalent. You still have to know how to math/program with a calculator/compiler.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by tasn on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:46PM (#30470641)
I couldn't agree more. Every now and then I let gmail auto complete for me, but it feels like my writing is just becoming generic.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by mhitza on Saturday February 26, 2022 @04:30AM (#30476329)
Yet, I've used the same closing line for my emails for years. And Gmail still doesn't suggest it as completion.

"AI powered".

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by bananamerica on Friday February 25, 2022 @02:23PM (#30471091)
English is not my first language. Grammarly greatly improved my English, even when I'm not using it.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by hef19898 on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:09PM (#30472403)
One of the beat ways to tell really peoficient foreign speaker of, in my case, German isn't the accent (as some people don't have one anymore) but a too perfect Grammar usage, either in writing (less obvious) or speaking (clear as day). I yried one of the German grammar tests of my son, and failed miserable, despite being a native speaker. My wife isn't, and she's so much better in German grammar then I am.

The gist: Don't worry too mich, just use the language. Most people are than delighted to meet a foreigner trying to speak their language.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by bananamerica on Friday February 25, 2022 @07:24PM (#30474091)
"Perfect grammar usage" is only a negative when you have "perfect grammar knowledge", whatever that means. I'm actually knowledgeable enough to to be more spontaneous if I want. In reality I only use Grammarly on the desktop, which is only a tiny fraction of my usage of the English language. Things are not as black and white as they seem. I'm neither a child nor a robot.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by colejohnson66 on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:14PM (#30472453)
It's the same with English. Maybe it's confirmation bias, but I've noticed many non-native speakers either write too formally, or choose the wrong synonym for the context. Everything is grammatically correct, but it just feels wrong.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by bananamerica on Friday February 25, 2022 @07:29PM (#30474140)
Non native speakers are generally more formal regardless of their usage of formal. I'm autistic so I'm highly formal in my native language as well!
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by a_e_k on Friday February 25, 2022 @05:02PM (#30472880)
My wife told me that when she was studying Russian in college, some of the professors in the advanced courses would refer to certain phrasings as the "spy's variant."
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by lbriner on Friday February 25, 2022 @02:49PM (#30471512)
You might be worrying a bit too much about what others think. I am English and if someone is, say, Russian, and writes to me in English, I don't care if their grammar is a little poor. The great thing about English is you can understand even when most of the words are in the wrong order :-)

Also, most English people don't know much about grammar anyway and lots of people still confuse things like there/their/they're; are/our; its/it's etc.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by witrak on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:21PM (#30471912)
I think you skip the case when both communicating parties are not native speakers which is probably much more often case than when at least one side knows English well. And risk related to a misunderstanding caused by breaking grammar rules is much higher.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by jazzyjackson on Friday February 25, 2022 @05:05PM (#30472910)
Also if you're not native speaker how do you know if the computer's suggestion is an improvement or a regression?
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by bananamerica on Friday February 25, 2022 @07:30PM (#30474150)
It is possible to have relevant knowledge in languages that are not your own.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by terracatta on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:37PM (#30470562)
Totally agree, we already have a generation of folks who don't know how to spell without the crutch of a spell-checker (I include myself as a victim), does Grammarly produce even worse outcomes?

The one caveat here (which I try to cover in this post) is there are definitely people who suffer from things like dyslexia who heavily rely on these types of tools to be able to communicate confidently. In that way, they are very useful.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by beambot on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:52PM (#30470727)
Even worse: entirely new language primitives based on 10wpm mobile keyboards.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by adhesive_wombat on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:58PM (#30472308)
Despite the moral panic over the OG mobile keyboards in the noughties (remember the breathless "kids these days write txt spk, m8 in their English exams" headlines every year?), the pandemic of inability to "write good" never actually materialised among Millenials.

Indeed, it has been suggested that reductions like "wait" to "w8" even represent the same kind of phonological awareness of language that's correlated with better spelling.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by kevin_thibedeau on Friday February 25, 2022 @09:25PM (#30474761)
The same thing happened in the 19th century when coded abbreviations to save money on telegrams became a fad and infected everyday writing. Newspapers and periodicals both celebrated and decried them. Civilization didn't collapse. TTFN.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by LAC-Tech on Saturday February 26, 2022 @03:14AM (#30476009)
Well WWI happened towards the very end of the telegraph age, so civilisation did collapse.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by adhesive_wombat on Monday February 28, 2022 @02:34AM (#30497326)
What could be more civilised than murdering thousands at a time with science (e.g. gas attacks and aviation)?
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Spivak on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:51PM (#30472208)
I mean "txt" speak is something only my parents still use. There are some shortenings like omw, ngl, ikr but they're not inventing new words.

I mean hell if this is the straw than the internet ruined that before I was born -- tldr, imho, afaik, mfw, /s.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by beambot on Friday February 25, 2022 @07:24PM (#30474098)
Heh, now it's just emojis and memes for communication.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by leetcrew on Friday February 25, 2022 @02:47PM (#30471484)
does it actually matter that people don't all the grammar rules or how to spell things? an english sentence contains a lot of parity data. when you do know all the rules, it can be painful to see the mistakes people make, but confusing "principle" with "principal" or using "who" when you should have used "whom" doesn't really obscure the meaning of the sentence.

when it comes to formal correspondence, spellcheck is always there to help. or better yet, get a copywriter or technical writer to help you and go back to your main responsibilities.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Teever on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:05PM (#30471716)
> does it actually matter that people don't all the grammar rules or how to spell things?

It does if you hold the view that teaching someone to speak and write is teaching them them think.

If that is correct than if someone does not know how to speak and write in a grammatically correct fashion then the implication is that they do not know how to think properly.

Even if there isn't a perfect 1to1 mapping between grammatically correct writing and thinking skills, I still think it's a good proxy for measuring a persons ability to think because in general the more you read, the better you get at writing, and the more you read, the more you know.*

* the traditional caveats apply with garbage in, garbage out.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by diputsmonro on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:56PM (#30472280)
> It does if you hold the view that teaching someone to speak and write is teaching them *them think*.

> If that is correct *than* if someone does not know how to speak and write in a grammatically correct fashion then the implication is that they do not know how to think properly.

And you immediately defeat yourself with your own argument.

Nobody ever has, nor should strive to, follow every grammatical rule perfectly. Errors only matter if they create actual ambiguity; if you understand my intent, then I have used language effectively.

As human thought evolves, language should too. Poets are always breaking rules in the name of art, and many of those changes get codified as new rules. Shakespeare simply made up dozens of words that we use today without a second thought. Over the last decade, modern poets steeped in the culture of sarcasm have given the word "literally" a new meaning. Those deviations and inventions made sense, both to the speakers and listeners, so new words, rules, and understandings were created. The only people left confused are the prescriptionists who cling to outdated rules that describe how people used to talk.

As long as humans can turn these AI assistants off and share their imperfect creativity, I'm not too concerned.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by thaumasiotes on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:35PM (#30473716)
> Nobody ever has, nor should strive to, follow every grammatical rule perfectly.

Actually, this is untrue; people automatically follow the rules of their language with extreme accuracy. They don't "strive" only in that following the rules doesn't involve any conscious effort.

This is behind the principle articulated for HTML of "be strict in what you emit and liberal in what you accept". That is how people behave when speaking. But it's not something they're capable of doing in HTML, and trying to apply it there was a mistake.

> Errors only matter if they create actual ambiguity; if you understand my intent, then I have used language effectively.

This isn't right either, in a couple of more serious ways:

First, ambiguity is always present regardless of whether any errors have been made or not. A fun example of ambiguity I noticed recently is "Flemish is more influenced by French than Dutch". Perfect grammar, but the two obvious parses have opposite meanings. Ambiguity arising from a grammatical error is no more serious than ambiguity arising from a lack of errors.

Second, the major problem with failing to follow the grammar of a language is that it prevents your audience from knowing whether they understand you or not. One thing I can say if you speak to me in broken English is that you aren't aware of the rules of English. Given that, even your apparently flawless sentences might have been intended to mean something quite different from what they would mean if spoken by an English speaker.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by cik2e on Friday February 25, 2022 @09:23PM (#30474753)
> Actually, this is untrue; people automatically follow the rules of their language with extreme accuracy. They don't "strive" only in that following the rules doesn't involve any conscious effort.

You can't possibly be serious! If this view is based on your real-life experience then I am amazed at the rarefied circles to which you belong.

https://www.thinkimpact.com/literacy-statistics/

- Nationwide, on average, 79% of U.S. adults are literate in 2022.

- 21% of adults in the US are illiterate in 2022.

- 54% of adults have a literacy below 6th grade level.

- 34% of adults who lack proficiency in literacy were born outside the US.

Based on these stats, you can rest assured that at least half of the adults in the United States do not have perfect grammar. And although "proficiency" is not precisely defined, I think it's safe to assume that a majority of these low-literacy adults are native speakers.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by thaumasiotes on Friday February 25, 2022 @09:27PM (#30474775)
> If this view is based on your real-life experience then I am amazed

How much effort did it take you to select the form 'am' in 'I am amazed' while selecting 'is' in 'this view is based'?

When's the last time you heard anyone make a mistake in conjugating be?

That's what a grammatical rule looks like.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by diputsmonro on Thursday March 10, 2022 @03:39PM (#30632142)
People always be conjugating "be" incorrectly. It's actually hallmark of a very common English dialect, which people speak and understand all the time without issue:

https://abagond.wordpress.com/2008/09/09/ebonics-time-and-te...

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by nescioquid on Friday February 25, 2022 @05:45PM (#30473297)
> if you understand my intent, then I have used language effectively.

I'll agree as far as it goes, but it ignores the burden of understanding on the the part of your interlocutor.

Have you ever been in a conversation where either you or the other party didn't speak the language well? It is a strain on all parties, even if sufficient information was transmitted and understood. I might consider this merely sufficient or barely "effective". I'd hope we aim for clearly expressing oneself without causing strain on your conversation partner or reader.

A good deal of what people quibble over regarding "grammar" has more to do with good style (whatever that means to you -- proper use of less/fewer, who/whom, capitalization and punctuation, etc) and achieving a certain verbal register.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Teever on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:12PM (#30472431)
You're not even wrong.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by leetcrew on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:36PM (#30472056)
> It does if you hold the view that teaching someone to speak and write is teaching them them think.

I don't hold that view. at least, I don't think effective communication requires mastering the formal rules of a natural language. I'm not even sure communication itself is that closely tied to complex thought. I've known a few brilliant engineers whose english was barely sufficient for work. perhaps they were quite elegant in their native tongues; I wouldn't be able to say.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by LadyCoconut on Friday February 25, 2022 @07:21PM (#30474064)
> I'm not even sure communication itself is that closely tied to complex thought.

I think it does in some respect; our language's grammar and vocabulary litteraly govern the way we see the world, after all[1]. As a personal anecdote, I'm ESL and write as a hobby, both in my native language and English, and I do feel the differences (and limitations) in the way my mind works depending on language.

I know that my inadequacies in English mean that my style is different. Descriptions and reasonings are simpler. In my native language, I can easily use word plays, ambiguities, be bolder and "more clever" (or less stupid :p). In English, I unconsciously keep things less complex. I'm a different author, and so the worlds I describe in my texts are simpler, too.

English is also far more "pragmatic" than my birth language. I can't word things the same way. Thus, my thinking as an "English writer" is far more rational and cause-to-effect-ish.

It's like any tool: you can absolutely use a programming language through tutorial and google searches, but you have to truly master it to really understand its concepts, to really use it to do something cleverly and intelligently -- and you won't plan a complex task the very same way in two different programming languages.

[1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/03/110314132531.h...

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Silhouette on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:06PM (#30472377)
does it actually matter that people don't all the grammar rules or how to spell things?

Does it matter if someone does not write with perfect grammar and spelling? Probably not.

However at some point you have drifted so far from normal conventions that you are no longer communicating effectively. You can make reasonable arguments about both prescriptivism and descriptivism but if your spelling and grammar are so bad that someone can't understand you then you're not a descriptivist, you're just wrong.

I have encountered this more often than I'd like in professional settings. I work in software development, a field where precision is important, so if I'm looking at your job application and it's full of basic language errors then I absolutely will judge you for that.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by apazzolini on Friday February 25, 2022 @02:58PM (#30471642)
Yes, clarity and grammar matter. For example, with your lack of capitalization, I wouldn't know if you were trying to help your Uncle Jack off a horse or your uncle jack off a horse.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by NateEag on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:02PM (#30471683)
Though no one has ever written either of those sentences for any reason other than to put up a strawman to tear down in their defense of grammar.

I'm a fan of learning grammar well, to be clear, and wish mine were better, but this is not a good argument for grammar mattering.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by leetcrew on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:31PM (#30472002)
okay, you can also come up with plenty of examples of ambiguous parses that don't require violating any grammar rules. fortunately humans are a bit more intelligent than compilers and can use their knowledge of context to settle on the more reasonable interpretation.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by jamiek88 on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:41PM (#30473769)
But why make other humans do extra work to parse you? It’s arrogant in the extreme to say ‘that’s good enough you figure it out’.

Even scanning text is jarring when the rules aren’t followed, takes extra time to comprehend and adds to the minor irritants of daily life and will have people judging you, even subconsciously, as unintelligent.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by exikyut on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:05PM (#30471722)
> does it actually matter that people don't all the grammar rules

No.

*ducks*

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by leetcrew on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:22PM (#30471922)
ironic, but it actually supports my point so I'll leave it that way :)
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by not1ofU on Friday February 25, 2022 @03:48PM (#30472171)
I for one blame the Grammar-Nazis and their anti-semantic ways

ok, i'll let myself out.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by pinephoneguy on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:07AM (#30475325)
Good writing is probably like dressing up. It's not just what people think of you, you think of yourself better too.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by syshum on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:00PM (#30472327)
I know, we should also get rid of Calculators because people should just do all math in there head

Hell let get rid of computers as well, people should just do everything manually, if you need to communicate drive to the person an talk to them, if you need to write something get out the hammer, chisel and rock...

</endsarcasm>

No Computers, Spell Check, nor grammar check has not ruined civilization or made people stop learning things...

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Barrin92 on Friday February 25, 2022 @04:20PM (#30472504)
we use calculators because you can't do the kind of arithmetic in your head that calculators are made to perform, and because random arithmetic isn't conducive to understanding math. If you can't add two single digit numbers any more I'd start to be concerned.

Having a proper understanding of grammar and spelling is relevant even in verbal communication. Tools should be used to augment human capacity, not used as an excuse to justify atrophy of basic skills.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by sacrosancty on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:36PM (#30473721)
You can see that's false by the existence of languages with simpler grammar than English whose users are still able to function to as high or a higher level than English speakers. Some of the grammar in English is redundant. We shouldn't waste our brainpower on it any more than on mental arithmetic/etc.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by Barrin92 on Friday February 25, 2022 @10:03PM (#30474930)
I don't necessarily disagree but that doesn't have much to do with my point. Simple or complicated grammar, you as a person having command of it rather than outsourcing it to a tool is a skill you need often.

It's irritating how often people even confuse "your" and "you're" nowadays. Some simplifications are harmless but plenty of them can change meaning. And it seems like texting and autocompletion makes people care less and less.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by rhino369 on Friday February 25, 2022 @01:49PM (#30470684)
I use it, but only as a suggestion.
Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by greggsy on Friday February 25, 2022 @06:59PM (#30473900)
Having been subjected to a thrashing early on by a really good editor, they will stress that their isn’t always to correct and re-write your work - they’re often there to mark areas that need clarity or don’t fit the norms of editorial standards.

If they just fixed everything for you, you wouldn’t improve at all.

This experience made me much more careful about the way I write, and who I write for.

Re:Is Grammarly a keylogger? What can you do about it? by lifeplusplus on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:38AM (#30475633)
my grammar actually improved from proof-editing my essays on grammarly