News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by evancoop on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:16AM (#30272236)
Academia risks becoming another such field. Professorial salaries are not commensurate with the educational years, as there is little demand for published research in journals. As a result, journals demand payment from the writers themselves.

While certainly not every doctoral candidate hails from a wealthy family, there is a pursuit of status that does lead to similarly homogeneous views.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:27AM (#30272350)
Paying for journals to publish your papers is a thing academia did to itself. Publish or perish, demanding papers in a few cherry-picked journals to continue your career, and basically funneling grant money into journals hands is something that can only be changed from within academia.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by dmix on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @04:51PM (#30279057)
A lot of industries make sense in the context of their time, I'm sure having a few papers with esteem and influence as primary status indicators made a lot sense back in the day.

There's just some things that are stuck in rigid unchanging organizations/industries. Anything heavily government reliant or bureaucratic, which universities are probably the best example of, is going to be extremely slow at adapting to the world.

Just like how lawyers still use fax machines.

It's extremely hard to be different and make change/stand-out in those organizations. Which also relates back to the articles point about cultural insularity.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by tannhaeuser on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:41AM (#30272476)
Somewhat comparable to F/OSS, except without the grants.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by moffkalast on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:21AM (#30272908)
Ah yes just like every open source project must pay a grand to github to host their code. /s

What are you even talking about?

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by matheusmoreira on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:49AM (#30273219)
I don't have to pay anything to publish code I wrote. Peer review only happens in Linux distributions.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by hiptobecubic on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:11AM (#30272779)
How is that similar to foss?
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by 3pt14159 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:52AM (#30272582)
Big time. I remember hanging out with the AI team here in Toronto before deep learning took off. Then it took off and Microsoft just bought the research team out from under UoT's feet. It was a sky high payout.

Same thing for the government too. I'm civically minded, so I've taken a couple contracts here and there to help out the Government of Canada, but man is it a pay cut. But what are they going to do? Pay more than the Chief Justice of the Canadian Supreme Court?

Sometimes governments try to work around this with contracting companies so that they don't have to see the salaries directly. But this is just padding extra waste and cost.

But this is what exponential tech is going to look like, at least until AI replaces us then who knows.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by jonnycomputer on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:41AM (#30273121)
Here in the US, politicians, especially on the right, love to highlight and criticize public employees, especially if their salaries seem too large. But Federal employees salaries are not too large, barely competitive with the private sector. If you want government to work well, attract talent by paying them what they'd earn outside of it. But all that just comes from an ideological interest in shrinking government so they can drown it in a bathtub. If you make sure government doesn't work well, then you have an excuse for eliminating it.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by yibg on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:18AM (#30274421)
I think the problem is the distribution. SOME government employees (at least in Canada) are seen as being paid too much because the pay is clustered really closely together and often don’t reflect market pay.

You get software engineers that get paid 70k a year but also janitors that get paid 70k a year with the same number of years in.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by everforward on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:50AM (#30273227)
From what I've heard, another part of why the government struggles to get good IT workers is that the processes for getting anything done are Kafkaesque, even compared to large enterprise roles.

There are other things governments could do though.

Coming from a US perspective, the biggest one would be to pass some kind of law that employment contracts can't prevent you moonlighting for the government. I'd probably be willing to pick up some contract work to do on the cheap, but I can't because of my employment contract.

Another is that the government already has access to a lot of things I don't, and I'd be willing to trade my time for access to some of those things. Free flights on army cargo planes would be a great perk. I would totally do some work if they'd let me drive a tank for like 30 minutes and fire the cannon down the range a couple times. They probably have access to HPC clusters that would tempt some (I don't have the skills to have the interest, but I'm sure many do).

Government pensions are another option, although they'd have to require less than 40 hours a week of work to qualify. It might end up being more expensive than just paying more.

Tax breaks are another option. Someone would have to figure up the demand curve, but a 10% cut to my effective tax rate would be tempting depending on the amount of work required.

Free education would be another option if they could offer it for part time work.

I don't feel that the government has gotten particularly creative in trying to attract talent. The pay is bad, the job is a bureaucratic nightmare, and the perks kind of suck other than the pension.

The downside is that a lot of those are likely to piss off the rest of the government employees.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by throwaway2037 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:56AM (#30274920)
You wrote: <<to pass some kind of law that employment contracts can't prevent you moonlighting for the government>>

This is a brilliant idea. In some sense, the gov't is the biggest non-profit in any modern nation. Large corporations love it when you "moonlight" at a non-profit. Your are idea is not so far-fetched! I'm sure lots of techies would love to pitch-in and help to improve an online gov't service -- be it local, regional, or national.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by 3pt14159 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:33AM (#30273798)
There is red tape, yes, but there are upsides to doing contract work for them too. The sheer scale of impact is daunting. Millions of people looking for work and you help them figure out the areas their recommender system needs improvement? That's tens of thousands of homes that now have employment where they wouldn't have. Just think of the cascading impact.

I don't know how to do it in the US, but in Canada you should be able to get these types of short-term gigs if you do a bit of networking in Ottawa and mention that you're a specialist in X, and that you want to help out here and there to give back. Wont take long. People want to bring in experts that will take occasional lower pay for impact.

Edit:

Also, the servers are BEEEEFY, haha. They might be cloud first these days, but when I was there it was still all on-premises and man alive are those machines huge.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by mabub24 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:55AM (#30274143)
I think the Public Service in Canada also suffers from extremely opaque hiring practices. Unless you're aware of what they're looking for in a resume or the PS style cover letter, you're just sending in your resume to the void. FSWEP is the unofficial actual hiring route. Then the average time for a lot of hiring outside of getting "bridged in" is 9 months or more. Most people find that absurd.

I do know some CCs and branches are trying to make changes but the PS in general is an absolute dinosaur for hiring and shows no signs of improving to match the bleed they'll have as people start retiring out.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by 908B64B197 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:50PM (#30282258)
> Then the average time for a lot of hiring outside of getting "bridged in" is 9 months or more

I recall someone I hired had also applied for a government job while completing his degree. They called him back a little more than a year after. Of course, his salary out of college was 4x what they were offering but can you imagine what candidate the government ends up with? The people who are still looking for a job in tech a whole year after graduation…

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by 3pt14159 on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:32AM (#30284816)
Yeah I don't know what it's like going in the front door. I just sounded smart at a lunch with someone that worked for the Prime Ministers Office. When they were having trouble with something I got a really random email haha.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by sjg007 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:36AM (#30273835)
It's also one reason most Senators are millionaires.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by 908B64B197 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:25PM (#30282443)
> But what are they going to do? Pay more than the Chief Justice of the Canadian Supreme Court?

No need to look at a few prestigious positions. Aren’t doctors on government payroll over there? There’s already a precedent to paying some government employees market rates it seems.

> Sometimes governments try to work around this with contracting companies so that they don't have to see the salaries directly. But this is just padding extra waste and cost.

It also changes the dynamic to fixed price bids where the government has to understand its own needs well enough to write such a bid. Probably the best case-study of that going extremely wrong is, ironically also Canadian, with the Phenix pay system. The government gave the contractor what they understood to be their payroll rules but it turns out they were not what was agreed to. The whole saga lasted almost a decade and cost billions.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by dmurray on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:42AM (#30273955)
> But what are they going to do? Pay more than the Chief Justice of the Canadian Supreme Court?

Pay your consulting firm 100x more than they would pay any one government employee, and not ask questions about how much of that goes to each consultant.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by xxpor on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @05:00PM (#30279150)
>Pay more than the Chief Justice of the Canadian Supreme Court?

Yes. Why not?

One is a job in a market, with no "external" validation to make up for the lack of pay. The other is one of the most elite legal jobs in the world.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by asdff on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @02:29PM (#30277246)
Grad students are so terribly underpaid in Academia. Salaries should go up 3x at least across the board for stipends. Grant funding agencies are spending millions of dollars on scientists who are only seeing salaries of at most $35k in the highest cost of living areas to do things like study cancer or climate change.

It's kind of an open secret, but usually grant aims are somewhat vague. It's up to the grad student saddled with those couple of aims for their thesis work to identify what exactly to do. To vet the literature for methods. To order equipment or reagents. To conduct the experiment or analysis. To write up and interperete the results. To outreach to collaborators and set up meetings. To draft up the results into a published paper. Sometimes grad students are even relied upon to pen the next grant. The big joke is by the time you are done with your PhD project, you know more about the topic than anyone in the department or your professor or your committee. I think that actually typically happens by third year. Professors are tied up with administerial duties, class, and several other projects they may be juggling, along with their personal lives. You are lucky if your professor has five hours a week to devote to your particular project.

It is so shameful that grad students are the backbone of modern research yet we pay them competitive salaries with In n Out. It's no surprise how grad students are so likely to have significant mental health issues considering the workload doled upon them for pittance pay that they have to figure out how to make work over years of other costs rising, while they are often without a raise.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by DiggyJohnson on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @05:43PM (#30279705)
Why should they increase? Please don't shoot the questioner, but is your thought that this would increase the quality of scientific output?
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by asdff on Thursday February 10, 2022 @01:55PM (#30290792)
Yes, because people are depressed. People are committing suicide. People are opting to not go to grad school in the first place. Why put people through that pain when they don't have to be put through it if they were only paid more fairly for their responsibilities and the skills they bring to the table?
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by soniman on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:05AM (#30272724)
There was an academic fellowship with something like a $40 application fee and it got like 1000 applicants so the fellowship was funded by the application fee! That is literally a circular prestige economy.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by HPsquared on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:40AM (#30272465)
This could be a reversion to the mean. Historically the arts, science and philosophy were mostly hobbies of the wealthy - either doing the work itself or sponsoring it. Not really a "money-making" activity but a hobby or clout-chasing activity.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ren_engineer on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:26AM (#30272966)
this is the answer, STEM could easily fund itself in a free market. The same can't be said of the many other college degrees that are now funded mainly by student loans. Government created a distorted market that ruined many people's lives by trapping them with debt for a degree that provided no real world value
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ghaff on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:51AM (#30273236)
STEM covers a lot of ground. Undergraduate biology and mathematics degrees probably don't confer any great employment advantage other than as a generic degree that demonstrates you have some facility with technical stuff--which isn't necessarily that much better than an English-adjacent degree depending upon what you want to do.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by dodobirdlord on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:12PM (#30275120)
Undergrad math degrees pay off pretty well. As a group math degrees are second after engineering degrees for highest median starting and lifetime salary for people with only an undergraduate education.

Relevant graphs on pages 12, 13, and 19. Math, statistics, and computer science are lumped in together on pages 12 and 13, but the graph on page 19 shows that the median salary for all three is very similar.

https://1gyhoq479ufd3yna29x7ubjn-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-...

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ghaff on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:19PM (#30276104)
That makes sense I guess. Even if you don't go on to do grad-level math or physics, it's a good foundation and preparation for a lot of other quantitative occupations. Whereas chemistry and biology have often been considered being "pre-med" majors to a non-trivial degree. They're less of a foundation at the undergraduate level for well-paying jobs.

>the median salary for all three is very similar.

Though note that this data is almost 10 years old. It wouldn't surprise if computers rose more than the average.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ren_engineer on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @01:45PM (#30276601)
if you have a math degree you can do pretty much anything you want. Pure math as an academic probably isn't great pay but FAANG and hedge funds will pay massive money for people good at math who are willing to learn to code
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by asdff on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @02:34PM (#30277304)
I feel like the student loan issue wouldn't have been so bad if they were mandated to be used in state for public schools. You aren't going to be six figures underwater with an in state tuition bill of what like $14k before any aid or scholarship at UCLA. If you work full time in the summer you can put a huge dent in that too. Landing a favorable internship in a summer can actually net you ahead.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by chaosbutters314 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:32AM (#30273037)
just as a data point to this. I worked for a PepsiCo, massive company. The position requires a PhD and you have to live in metro NYC, pay was only 80k.

So not just professors, but a lot of positions that "require" a PhD pay poverty wages when someone has given up any kind of earnings for 5-6 years developing skills getting a PhD.

There is a big problem with east coast jobs (mid-atlantic to NYC) from "older" companies that require tech experience and a PhD but do not want to pay accordingly because theyre stuck in an 80s mindset.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by fennecfoxen on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:46AM (#30274007)
As a PhD you might aspire to better but a position in NYC on $80k is hardly "poverty wages".

For starters, there's this little thing called "commuting" you may have heard of. Ordinary people, without PhDs, do it plenty. The NYC Pepsi offices seem to be a medium-short walk from Christopher St. PATH; you would have no trouble living in Jersey City or Hoboken on the (computes) ~$2000/mo rent that would be 'affordable' at such pay. I bet you get tax-deductible transit benefits, too, and a monthly pass is around $100.

There are people in New York working full time jobs to make $15/hr, $30k a year. That's a lot more like the "poverty wages" you name.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by 999900000999 on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:48AM (#30274827)
80k a year minus student loan payments.

I couldn't imagine living in any HCOL city with less than 100k minimum. If others want to struggle, fine.

But logically why not live in Chicago off that 80k, and take a 20 minute L ride to work.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by chrisseaton on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @08:59AM (#30272662)
> as there is little demand for published research in journals

Not sure what you mean by this - for advancement in academia this is 90% of what hiring or promotion committees demand.

> journals demand payment from the writers themselves

From the institution, not the authors.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by derbOac on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @11:05AM (#30274271)
Nowadays though the research is secondary to grant funding, so hiring and promotion committees don't even care about that.

I was on a promotion committee where someone had a large grant but was not publishing. This went on for years and the response from significant segments of the department every year was literally something like "they have a large grant, it's fine, of course they'll publish".

Publications are seen as a dime a dozen, and open access and issues about replicability and so forth have just added to the sense they're not worth much. The attitude is more along the lines of "if your ideas are really that important and high impact, it will convince the federal government to pay for them." It's very much the classic betting market idea, that true value is revealed only when money is on the line.

I'm not saying this is good or bad, just my experience, in the US. I personally think the current funding system creates distorted incentive and reward systems, and that the original idea of academics was to insulate from that a bit or at least provide an alternative to traditional for-profit models.

If something doesn't change I think this trend will only accelerate. Journals will maybe become seen as irrelevant, with grant or funding receipt being seen as the actually rigorous form of peer review. Everything will become a form of seeking VC funding, either from private or public funders. Again, whether that's the best model for funding anything in the US, private or public, profit or nonprofit, is a different issue.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by jbsimpson on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:32AM (#30273039)
> From the institution, not the authors.

Typically the authors pay the journal out of their own funding.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by chrisseaton on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:36AM (#30273069)
Well I'd call that institutional money. 'Writers have to pay' makes it sound like they're paying from their own personal cash.
Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by derbOac on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:55AM (#30274132)
Sometimes they do. Regardless, if it's often coming from funding that implies the authors have to have grants or come from institutions that are willing to pay, which disadvantages individuals without resources (they often have discounts for those without resources but in my personal experience the discount is absurdly small, like 15%, which is a lot for someone who just doesn't have external resources to publish under that model, if they're asking for 2k+ per paper).

Either way it creates a backward incentive structure, of pay to access.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by ebiester on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:02AM (#30273392)
However, professors were historically from the gentry. It was always a position of status and privilege, especially before World War 2. It was only when the demand for higher education surged (largely by the GI bill but also by the computer revolution that created the white collar jobs today) that this changed.

Further, the amount of published research has also exploded as the supply of qualified applicants has surged. That said, I think eventually the journals problem will solve itself - people inside academia are trying to figure a way out already.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by unemphysbro on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @12:40PM (#30275502)
Universities take a cut (30 - 50%) of grant money brought in by profs. The incentive structure for good science is broken.

Academia is a racket.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by asdff on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @02:42PM (#30277405)
They also charge tuition that doesn't exist for grad students. Your classes year 1 or two in most stem phd programs are going to basically be the professors from the department giving research talks trying to get you to join their lab. Then they end and you are doing research or TAing for the department for the next 3-however many years. Only the thing is, the school still makes you sign up for tuition units, for a special class that only has grad students in it, and when you look at your bill you are charged full tution for this nonexistant class that just exists on paper. Your funding, whether it be the from your professor in an RAship or from the department in a TAship or an outside fund like the NSF, has to pay for this nonexistant classes tuition. You might be a line item of 90k a year on the grant budget, but you only see 35k from the nonexistent tuition. The rest just poofs into smoke into the inner workings of the school bureaucracy.

It's basically money laundering with extra steps, and there is no way out because literally every school does this and too many people on academia have Stockholm syndrome.

Re:The dangers of high status, low wage jobs by derbOac on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @10:55AM (#30274138)
Not risks, has become.