The consequence of this is that they have to lean into inequality: get their existing high income customers to pay them more money. This is why services are such a good strategy and they are so unwilling to give up on that revenue, and it is also why they are planning to launch very expensive (and therefore high profit) new product categories like vr goggles and cars targeted at their existing customer base.
Apple is so ridiculously big that it is fun to map them back onto the world economy. Their yearly revenue is 0.4% of the world economy. Their market cap is 0.6% of global wealth. But that does present a real challenge to Tim Cook to keep growing. If apple doubles again they will be 1% of the world economy. Does that make sense for what amounts to a luxury brand?
They don't have to do this at all. They could decide that they have 1 billion customers which is plenty and stick with that.
Is that what happens to a piece of software after it has eaten the world?
Lets say it looks like this for the sake of argument: stage - organizational mode - goals
Idea / Proof of Concept - individual or team - prove the idea out
Growth Software Product - startup - carve a space for the product, grow its useful user base to a target number, transition to Utility
Utility Software Product - utility - maintain the project and optimize costs and delivered value, transition back up to Growth or down to Archived
Archived Software Product - library / anthropology - tell the story of the project, minimize costs, make it available to a wide audience, organize its community, transition back up to Utility
The idea is to have a pool of teams and organization templates where you aim to "pass the baton" between modes depending on the lifecycle stage of the software, and individual teams and orgs are rewarded based on how they meet their objectives including delivering a seamless transition to the next stage.If this isn't a perversion within capitalism I don't know what is. Heck, a market failure of capitalism itself.
"There's nothing worse than making something everybody uses."
How can you ignore this past week when this past week is _directly related_ to their account growth falling off a cliff because of the exact over-saturation of the market we're discussing here?
This looks like another example of how low interest rates cause stock valuations to run up until their long-term yields end up only slightly higher than bond yields. Investors expecting that rapid growth to continue might be disappointed.
Android OEM are incentivized to sell as many phones as they can. They only make money on new hardware. Apple on the other hand still makes money on older hardware as long as the user still buy from the ecosystem. So it makes sense for them to keep the products working longer.
Apple's support window advantage long predates their services initiative.
Every flagship iPhone since the iPhone 4s in 2011 has gotten at least five years of OS and security updates.
If you count years where you only get a security update, but not an OS update the way the Android ecosystem does, they have devices that have gotten eight years of support.
However, the claim made was that Apple only started offering a longer update period after they started calling out service growth. This simply isn't true.
Not to mention the ability of any company to make demands of their suppliers. If Google can demand device makers not use a fork of Android, they can demand suppliers offer support for their products.
Google simply doesn't care, because the customers they care about are the advertisers, not device purchasers.
Also there's an upper-bound on price for an iPhone Apple is able to charge and if I can speculate, the "Pro" lineup does not outsell the "base" iPhone significantly. For one, there isn't enough product differentiation for an average consumer to pay the $300/40% price premium.
So in the world of 3-4 year iPhone cycles, keeping up the walled garden and monetizing those within is the surest path to revenue growth.
What is altruistic in this world? Government welfare? parental love? I don't know of anything that is truly altruistic.
Android meanwhile supports 32 and 64 bit, multiple instruction sets, multiple (incompatible) SOCs etc. That is a lot more challenging.
The iPhone with the oldest version of a 64 bit processor (the A7 used in the 2013 iPhone 5s) fell out of support after six years because it no longer had enough RAM for the new version of the OS.
Apple TV+ and Apple Arcade are examples of good services where Apple are commissioning and paying content producers. The services are good value, good quality and have competition on a level playing field (e.g. Netflix directly compete against both and don't have to pay a commission to Apple despite both their games and video services appearing on the App Store).
Other services from Apple like cloud storage, Apple News and Apple Music are more debatable value but they have competition so if you don't like them, use something else.
The App Store is different because you don't have an alternative. It is a parasitic system where where 70% of revenue (not a guess, that's the real number according to emails in the Epic lawsuit) comes from loot box grifting in games and there's literally no alternative to Apple's 30% tax. It is a poison chalice from top to bottom.
It comes down to the monopoly.
The fact they are trying to keep a stranglehold on this revenue seems penny wise and dollar foolish. Clearly regulators are gunning for them and it's not long before they lose this and don't get to set the standard.
It's pretty good stuff.
But they seem to be admitting that the payment processing is only worth a 3% cut. And you wouldn't charge apps for the email hiding.
There are no wholesale prices for digital goods so they get tacked on as fees. All Apple is really doing is asking developers to give their customers an all-in price that they’ll display. You as a developer are free to raise your prices 30% on iOS, and many in fact do.
Every segment of every market does not need to be relentlessly competitive. Apple’s App Store rules are obvious, and if you don’t like them, you’re free not to develop for their platform (which itself is the product they sell to their consumers; not your app and of which the iPhone is only one component).
You are not entitled to be profitable any way you want; you have to find a niche in the market that’s profitable and if you can’t make money on iOS, the market solution is to just do something else. Countries — especially relatively small ones — that try to legislate around this are just as likely to be seen as more trouble for Apple than they’re worth to have an official presence in.
Yes but they're overcharging.
> Every segment of every market does not need to be relentlessly competitive.
It's significantly better for consumers if a 27% distribution fee faces competition.
Alternate app stores are a poor way to achieve this, but that doesn't mean the status quo is good.
> You are not entitled to be profitable any way you want
Same to apple. They want to control things they shouldn't have this much control over.
> Countries — especially relatively small ones — that try to legislate around this are just as likely to be seen as more trouble for Apple than they’re worth to have an official presence in.
If they get that aggressive, then thank goodness for the EU.
I think that’s their right as a platform owner. They have no responsibility to sellers setting up shop in their walled garden. If the App Store was the busiest shopping mall in the world, they’re not obligated to make rent cheap; if your business model doesn’t work, apples rules are not new and you knew them before rolling the dice on an iOS app.
Under US law there is no guarantee it’s possible to craft a law that would stand up in court anyway.
If there were only 2 major places in the entire world to buy things from, and Apple had 57% of that shopping revenue, then yes, absolutely they would be obligated to do a lot of things.
Based on latest Q4 earnings, Services is one of the highest growth segment of Apple at 25% YoY (others being Mac at 25%, Other Products at 13%). As the clamor for M1-based Macs subsides, monetizing its existing 500M+ users is the only major revenue-growth area. But what happens if their commission rate is cut in half to 15%? Apple doesn't break out the specific App Store revenue amount or percentage but it must be quite significant.
Hence they're willing to risk these continued lawsuits and regulatory backlash. The day that Services division no longer reports 20%+ YoY growth could well be one when Apple stock faces the reckoning like FB/Meta.