News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by carlhjerpe on Thursday February 03, 2022 @11:40AM (#30194681)
In Sweden there are 2 separate charges, one for infrastructure and one for consumption. The infrastructure bill scales with how big your breakers/fuses (English) are while consumption scales with how many KWh you've used. You often have a different infra provider and power provider.

For someone living in a condo/apt the infra cost is usually higher than consumption while in houses where heating often is powered by some heat-pump system(drill, air, ground) consumption is higher.

Houses with district heating can scale down their capacity to lower the infra price.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by tempnow987 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:12PM (#30195200)
This is common in the US as well actually.

A-10 rates for example in PG&E land have a demand charge -

https://www.pge.com/en_US/small-medium-business/your-account....

Basically, based on breaker size. If you have a 400A breaker you might pay $2,000 / month demand charge. Usage might be small (sometimes these loads are spikey). It's not uncommon for folks to then pay more attention to peak load if you pay based on breaker size effectively.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by clairity on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:19PM (#30196340)
this is a form of two-part pricing[0], which is a compromise between simple (single) pricing and continuous pricing (aka perfect price discrimination) to maximize value capture with minimal complexity.

two-part pricing also tends to make markets (from the demand-side) more rational and efficient, but that's not often the reason it's employed, which is why regulation is often needed (particularly in monopoly markets).

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-part_tariff

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by cameldrv on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:37PM (#30195648)
It seems like what is getting lost here is that the reason PG&E only charges for usage and not a fixed connection fee is that that's what the state wanted. They wanted heavy users to pay a disproportionate share of costs to encourage lower usage. In fact, they even put in a "climate credit", which is a fixed rebate users get that effectively makes the connection fee be negative.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by m463 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:53PM (#30196868)
Punative pricing in california is really a disservice to customers/consumers.

In just about every other business, if you use a lot of something, you get a discount. For california electricity, it's the opposite.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:16PM (#30198169)
It's capacity pricing. If you want to buy same-day tickets for your whole family to board a full flight, the airline will sell the tickets to you, but it might be at a 5x or 10x mark up. The airline is betting that they'll be able to talk people into forfeiting their seats by giving them airline credits, and tickets on a later (less crowded) flight, then pocket the difference.

Expecting the airline to give you and your giant family a discount in the situation is obviously absurd. When you're at capacity, it's in your best interest to encourage people to shift their consumption to off-peak times, and to punitively charge the people that insist on consuming a disproportionate amount during full capacity.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by ketzo on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:14PM (#30197252)
It's a matter of tradeoffs. California electric companies – and PG&E in particular – desperately need to decrease load during fire season so that they have more flexibility in the grid. It's important for them to try and disincentivize power usage pretty much however they can.

Plus, using less power is better for the environment.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by zbrozek on Friday February 04, 2022 @12:23PM (#30209683)
Is using less power really better? People are going to use energy and this is driving loads to other sources of energy, typically gas. Most (but not all) people I know are avoiding electrification on economic grounds.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by cool_dude85 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:19PM (#30197336)
It's a disservice to the high-usage customers, who want to offload their environmental costs onto their grandkids and/or countries less equipped to deal with climate change. Soak 'em, I say.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by axlee on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:21PM (#30200474)
Why would anybody get a discount to pollute more?
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by tguvot on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:14PM (#30196258)
there is a minimal usage fee, which is essentially connection fee
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by secabeen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:00PM (#30194999)
Yes, this model is common in other utilities in the US (both by water and gas bills are structured this way), with a large meter fee and a consumption charge in line with the resource cost.

Electricity could certainly be charged this way (and should), but it would be a huge change in how electricity is billed here, and the PUC would rather just make changes to just the net-metering system rather than open the can of worms of a full rate re-write.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Bilal_io on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:11PM (#30195177)
That's how it is for electricity in Texas. You pay a delivery charge, and then usage charge, both based on kw/h.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by secabeen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:19PM (#30195330)
But that's the problem! The cost of the grid is the same whether it delivers you 100kWh or 10,000kWh. The delivery charge should be a fixed monthly charge, based on the size of your meter, not scaled to the number of kWh you consume.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by brohee on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:58PM (#30196012)
That's not true at all, as people use more electricity, aggregate usage gets higher and the grid eventually needs beefier interconnections, beefier transformers... The delivery charge would actually be fairer based on peak usage, as it has more relevance to the sizing of the grid.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by secabeen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:04PM (#30196108)
> That's not true at all, as people use more electricity, aggregate usage gets higher and the grid eventually needs beefier interconnections, beefier transformers...

To a degree, but not in a linear fashion to the amount of power delivered, and certainly not on a unit-power delivery basis.

>The delivery charge would actually be fairer based on peak usage, as it has more relevance to the sizing of the grid.

Very true, and also very common in commercial power billing, usually called a "demand charge" where you pay a specific tariff based of that peak of usage. Unfortunately, it can create really spikey and hard to manage bills, so I accept the argument that it's not appropriate for residential use. Thus, a flat charge on your meter size. On many commercial bills, the demand charge can exceed 75% of the total bill!

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by cool_dude85 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:15PM (#30197268)
Even demand charges often do a bad job of matching utility costs. If I run a church and my peak demand is consistently reached at 11 AM on Sunday morning, guess what, I'm way overpaying relative to my cost to the utility.

The problem with high meter charges (or charging based on panel amperage/etc.) is that it doesn't do a good job matching utility costs either. Let's say I have a 2-story house and split it into a duplex. I add a second panel on the top floor and live on the bottom. Did my second panel double costs for the utility? Absolutely not. If I build a carriage house in my backyard with a 200 amp panel, does it cost the same to the utility as if I put a 200 amp panel on my new house in my far-off exurb? Absolutely not.

That's not to get into the distributional effects of these kinds of changes. Any kind of base-rate increase will absolutely hammer the poor in order to save lots for suburb mcmansions. This may be economically more efficient, but good luck selling it.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by jabl on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:24PM (#30199109)
If you'd want the transmission charges to match the cost to the utility you should have a base charge consisting of basically the cost to the utility of maintaining your customer relationship after the initial hookup cost, and another part to match the utility O&M cost of the grid distributed over all the customers. Then on top of that a time-varying per-kWh charge for the electricity transferred. This would probably in most cases be pretty cheap, except when the grid (either the utility grid as a whole or the local part that you're connected to) starts to become overloaded; in that case scarcity pricing would apply which would presumably be very high. This would incite customers to reduce usage during scarcity, or give the utility funds to invest in grid expansion.

Similarly for the energy price, that should match the wholesale price. Though see the $10k bills some people on a wholesale price plan got during last year's Texas freeze for why such an idea might not be so popular in practice, theoretically beautiful as it may be.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by thatfrenchguy on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:54PM (#30195933)
It encourages you to use more electricity though, which is not good.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by sokoloff on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:19PM (#30196347)
Encourages you in what way? Your bill is still higher the more energy you consume, just increasing more slowly than if the rates were higher.

Many believe (and I’m inclined to agree) that encouraging a switch from locally burned fossil fuels to electricity is better even if that electricity is currently* generated partially from fossil fuel. The theory is the electric plants could more easily become cleaner than if millions of home need to have their heating equipment upgraded.

The problem where I am is that natural gas is so cheap (though less than previously) that it’s hard to make electric heating competitive.

* no pun intended

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by cool_dude85 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:17PM (#30197300)
It encourages you in the sense that the marginal cost of turning your heat up to 75 in the winter instead of 70 is much lower, or that buying a 4000 sq. ft. house will not come with as big an increase on your monthly costs as it does now.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by zbrozek on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:07PM (#30196153)
The current system in PG&E territory encourages me to prefer gas to electricity everywhere I'm able to make the choice. That's surely worse.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Panzer04 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @11:54PM (#30203031)
Only if it means you’d prefer resistive heaters to heat pumps. In home gas is more efficient than a resistance heater.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by zbrozek on Friday February 04, 2022 @12:47PM (#30210062)
False; the heat pump is still more expensive. You need COP of >=4 with baseline rates, and it only gets worse from there (the baselines are tiny, and TOU is also bad). Heat pump water heaters only barely scratch 4 under ideal conditions, so you'll generally do worse with a HPWH than with a condensing gas one. Arithmetic is about the same for home heating systems.

Basically around here (PG&E) you should only electrify if you can also get your electrons from not-the-grid.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by secabeen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:23PM (#30196403)
There are ways around that though; you could give a small rebate on the meter fee for low-use customers, to encourage conservation. (My water bill is that way, the full meter charge is around $50/month, but if you use less than 700 Cubic-feet of water a month, the meter fee drops to $30/mo.) Is a little less pure than just charging a fair rate, but seems a reasonable hybrid approach.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by junon on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:13PM (#30195210)
You also pay for power you don't even use, from other power providers, in the case of extreme crisis, it seems. I've never lived there but from the outside Texas's power situation seems broken at best.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Bilal_io on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:18PM (#30195313)
That's accurate. We're in constant fear of losing power whenever there is a freeze warning (we're on that today and tomorrow at least), rain or heat. That's all thanks to the greedy for-profit system enabled by "conservative" politicians.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by hunterb123 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:35PM (#30195617)
That's not really accurate. I've lost power 4 times total in 30 years here. Usually big Texas thunderstorms, never heat.

The 100 year winter freeze I lost power for two days, that was the longest ever.

Haven't lost power since then, didn't lose power for a couple years before that.

We have the cheapest rates because of the way distribution and providers are setup.

The problem with big user bills were SV companies like Griddy tricking people into buying variable rate electricity, something we made illegal since then.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by sfteus on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:08PM (#30196164)
That's great that your power has been mostly reliable, but it is not the case for a lot of the people here.

In my family alone, my brother and his wife lost power at the apartment they had then for 3 days during the ~2014 winter storm, during which our apartment lost power for around a day. My parents lost their power for all 4 days of the storm last year, and had to travel 15 miles or so to my brothers house after their inside temperature dropped below freezing on day 3. They just let us know their power is out again this afternoon. My wife and I are lucky enough to have since purchased a house close to some critical infrastructure so we've rarely lost power comparatively, but we still lose power several times throughout each summer during heat waves.

I also want to reiterate: this happened in 2011, again in 2014, again in 2021, and again in 2022. The storm in 2021 was objectively the worst of the bunch, but 2011 was similar. It is _not_ a 100 year freeze. It is happening more regularly, and our government has ignored recommendations to better prepare for it going on over a decade now.

EDIT: Just to round this out, a federal report was provided in the wake of the last "100 year" storm that occurred in 2011[1]. In it, there are several dozen recommendations, many of which were at least in part the cause of the 2021 outages as well.

-----

[1]: https://www.ferc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-04/08-16-11-re...

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by hunterb123 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:11PM (#30196219)
Just replying to other anecdotes with my own.

And I disagree with your assessment of our weather and government.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by shkkmo on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:12PM (#30200385)
This is one of those cases where annecdotes of power loss have a much higher informative value than annecdotes of stability. The former tell you there is a bad situation wheras the later just add a little bit of context about the severity.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by hunterb123 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @08:15PM (#30201544)
It's not, that's your rationalization to make your anecdote more important.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Bilal_io on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:52PM (#30195889)
I am not denying your experience, but I was talking about my own. I lost power for over 3 hours just 2 nights ago. And since the horrible experience we had in February 2021 we (me and everyone I know) have been living in fear it might happen again.

A quick look at Centerpoint's own outage tracker[1] shows outages everywhere in different parts of Texas.

1. https://gis.centerpointenergy.com/outagetracker/?WT.ac=OC_Im...

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by nomel on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:45PM (#30197736)
I don't see why "fear" is necessary. Power has never been a constant. When I was a kid we had a box of candles under the sink and warm blankets stacked in the garage, and some emergency food/water to last a week. Now that I'm an adult, I still have the same. I don't understand this trust and expectation of flawless infrastructure, where "fear" would come into play. Inconvenience, sure. You should be able to easily remove the fear aspect, with minimal preparation.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Bilal_io on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:48PM (#30197779)
"fear" is necessary because I was stuck at an apartment for 3 days and nowhere to go with no heat and no water when the weather outside was -17 degrees.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by nomel on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:00PM (#30197935)
As my comment suggested, you could change that fear to inconvenience with minimal preparation: put some water jugs, canned/packaged food, and blankets+cheap snow outfit in your closet, and throw in a little campground propane burner for a nice warm meal. -17 outdoors is a warm ski day indoors. If you've known anyone that lives in a cold part of the country, having some preparation is an extremely common practice.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Bilal_io on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:05PM (#30197993)
Or fix the damn infrastructure. Other states and other countries get worse cold waves and others get worse heat waves and they don't lose power. Stop putting the blame on people.

> Campground You realize most people love in apartments right? Most apartments don't have fireplaces.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by nomel on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:15PM (#30198155)
> You realize most people love in apartments right? Most apartments don't have fireplaces.

No, I mean the little burners you put on top of portable propane tanks, that are usually used for BBQ's or while camping. Searching "campground propane burner" in Amazon shows several hundred results of what I'm talking about. They don't require a campground to operate.

> Or fix the damn infrastructure.

You and your fear exists in the reality that is right now, which includes bad infrastructure, that will almost certainly take years to fix. If you desire to not live in fear, for the next few years, you can easily do it with minimal, extremely common in places where it's cold, preparation. If you desire to continue living in short term fear, when it's so easy to mitigate that fear, then well I guess you do you.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Bilal_io on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:26PM (#30198298)
Thank you for the advise. I will invest in one of those burners.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by ska on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:47PM (#30200721)
They are great to have around in this situation. Just be careful with ventilation always and don't leave untended. Not suitable as a heater.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by helpm33 on Friday February 04, 2022 @12:05AM (#30203099)
You have to be careful using these burners in in-building enclosed spaces---they can produce carbon monoxide. They are really designed for open air use.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by autoexec on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:50PM (#30200752)
Good advice for folks stuck in a place where corruption makes basic utility service unreliable, but doing a bunch of extra work to make getting through those times when you are without power a little less painful is no replacement for solving the problem. If I were in that situation I'd just move. There are plenty of states in the US that do not regularly have problems providing power, heat, and water to the folks who pay for them.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by nomel on Thursday February 03, 2022 @08:53PM (#30201829)
> a bunch of extra work

I'm having trouble believing that having a bit of extra food and water available is considered some large burden. It's universally suggested by all entities that deal with emergencies: https://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/f&web.pdf

> If I were in that situation I'd just move.

It's great that you have the freedom and resources to move around the country so easily, but I think that's a fairly rare privilege.

> is no replacement for solving the problem

I don't think I suggested it was. But it's not feasible that the problem will be solved in the next few weeks. For those next few weeks, fear and risk can be minimized with some "extra work".

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by sidewndr46 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:37PM (#30199271)
That would actually do something to address the risk, removing their ability to complain.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Spooky23 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:21PM (#30200469)
Because in the pursuit of efficiency, we are less resilient.

I maintain a old inefficient boiler for my home. It has a pilot light and stays lit as long as there is service.

It costs me about $250-400 more annually vs an efficient boiler.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by danans on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:10PM (#30200368)
In CA it's the same these days with the advent of community choice aggregators (CCA) [1].

If a CCA is available in your area, and you choose to use it, you pay the main utility for transmission/distribution, but the CCA for energy, both on per kWh basis. It all gets aggregated on the same (confusing) bill. Because they control the energy sourcing, CCAs can offer things like 100% carbon-free or 100% renewable plans. Some even subsidize batteries to add to homes in exchange for a portion of the stored energy capacity.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_Choice_Aggregation

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Dma54rhs on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:33PM (#30198393)
The way electricity market in Texas works in general looks very similar to EU countries.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Arainach on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:15PM (#30195253)
I've seen this model, but it seems counterproductive to any environmental goals. For instance, my water infrastructure bill absolutely dwarfs my usage. I could take an hourlong shower every day and barely notice the increase in my bill. It seems like it's sending the wrong message.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by secabeen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:48PM (#30195842)
Is water scarcity a thing in your area? Perhaps your water is cheap because its readily available in your area. In Chicago, they have so much water in Lake Michigan, most homes don't even have water meters.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by jabl on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:30PM (#30199181)
Where I live we have plentiful of clean water. However what constitutes a major part of the water bill is the sewage treatment. No separate metering for clean water vs sewage, they just assume that everything you use also goes out as sewage.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by manquer on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:03PM (#30196101)
Living close to a water source or reservoir doesn’t make conservation less important.It is a intricate system with complex interconnects

A lot of places downstream will be using the water from your Lake /Dam /river as their only source. Same reason why in some states like Colarado it is illegal to rain water harvest. Riparian rights and ethics are complex

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by appletrotter on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:45PM (#30196756)
Maybe it does sometimes though? Speaking of the great lakes, if you live in the region it doesn’t take you very long to drive out of the watershed for your respective lake. That should be where the bounds of effect end, and that entire region will generally have plenty of water. For example, Ohio has two watersheds, one for the lake up north and another for the Ohio river which takes up 2/3 of the state. Excess water consumption in the lake erie watershed shouldn’t ever hurt the ohio river watershed. Issues with the rivers that feed the ohio river might cause issues, but the point is this: the degrees to which regions are linked in terms of water varies dramatically.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by brnt on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:13PM (#30198119)
Waterpipes have been known to cross watershed boundaries. Or am I missing your point?
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by appletrotter on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @04:23PM (#30352934)
That using water within a watershed is fine. Piping out water is different.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by secabeen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:20PM (#30196350)
Fair. I still prefer an honest system that charges a fair, flat rate for the infrastructure, and then a usage charge for usage. If we want to disincentive usage, we can put a tax on the consumption rate; that's certainly better than wrapping up some/all of the infrastructure costs into the consumption rate just to make the latter higher.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by manquer on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:32PM (#30199205)
It is not just about conservation and high consumption.

For example, it is lot easier to build infra when you charge people 4x their consumption cost as single item, than split into line items. When you need to build a new power plant the infra costs are going to shoot a lot and nobody would want to pay for that when they see an line item for infra.

Every SaaS company and all of Cloud is built on this human behavior . I would even go so far to say that even mortgage, insurance, any credit business depends on this behavior. Most people would pay extra for their server by hour or second rather than pay for consumption + infra.

Also infra costs split equally is unfair ? if you consume more, more of the infra costs have to be apportioned to that person right ? Basically if power plant producer 1000MW the person consuming 900MW has to pay 90% cost of building the plant in addition to paying 90% for consumables for generating that 1000MW .

The solution here is to have spread between buy / sell rates which account for distribution losses, maintenance, infra and storage and peak capacity planning etc

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by jabl on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:34PM (#30199239)
> I still prefer an honest system that charges a fair, flat rate for the infrastructure, and then a usage charge for usage.

There's a lot of things where the infrastructure costs are baked into the per-unit cost of stuff you buy. I'd say it's even vastly more common than separate infrastructure vs. per-unit charges. You don't pay a separate constant infrastructure fee for the petroleum refinery infrastructure when filling up your car, it's all baked into the per-liter (or per-gallon) cost. Nor do you pay a fixed cost for funding the astronomically expensive semiconductor fabs when you buy something containing electronics, it's all baked into the per-unit cost. Etc. etc.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by rhino369 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:59PM (#30196985)
>Living close to a water source or reservoir doesn’t make conservation less important.

It doesn't necessarily make conservation less important. But it certainly does in some places like Chicago. They pull water from the same water shed that it eventually flows back into after use. And they control how much water flows from Lake Michigan into the Chicago river (and eventually the Mississippi River) via a damn.

It's probably a bit more complex than that, and creating that system did change the water flow in the Great lakes (but that damage was done 130 years ago). But right now, its essentially free water. In Illinois, all roads (waterways) lead to Rome (the Mississippi).

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by manquer on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:39PM (#30199286)
I don't have detailed knowledge of Great lakes to give you specifics on why this is a problem

However generally no water system is closed or independent of each other. Precipitation, weather and other cycles (wind, heat, underground etc) make even small changes in distant places drastically impact outcomes anywhere ( the OG butterfly effect).

So I would still say conservation of use is independent of how abundant it seems locally and how disconnected it looks on the surface to other problems.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by SilasX on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:10AM (#30207689)
Thank you! I thought I was insane for being the only one who noticed this, though on my natural gas bill instead of water. I have a mandatory $16 base charge and $1.50 payment fee on every bill. That's huge relative to the variable part! [1] So, estimating from non-winter months, I could avoid all cooking, laundry, and hot water for showers, and it would save me ... $5/month.

They should amortize the cost of the infra over actual usage, so that incentives are properly aligned -- your bill should mainly depend on how much you use!

[1] Total bill is like $45 for winter, $22 otherwise.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Rebelgecko on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:56PM (#30199529)
The problem we've had where I live, is that when people do a good job reducing water/electricity consumption the utility companies have to either jack up their rates, do layoffs, or go broke because they aren't able to amortize their fixed costs as well.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by SilasX on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:11AM (#30207700)
So? They should be able to adjust to correct for misestimation. That's not a dealbreaker for the idea.
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by OJFord on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:04PM (#30195065)
Yeah, similarly in the UK we have a 'standing charge' (£/day) in addition to the 'unit charge' (£/kWh) - same provider though.

And I can't see why it wouldn't tie up with the reality of the costs. (Competitive downward pressure, and no silly anti-competitive cap as there is on variable £/kWh pricing.) From memory mine's about £6-7pcm.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by pmyteh on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:26PM (#30195468)
The cap was never really intended to be a fixed price for electricity: the main purpose was to ensure people with an arbitrary supplier (chosen by previous tenants, or the landlord, say) and who weren't canny enough to notice they were being overcharged and shop around, didn't get ripped off too badly. Lots of people who stayed with the descendant of their old regional electricity board paid over the odds, for example, because consumer inertia meant it was profitable for them not to have competitive prices.

That all electricity prices are now essentially at the cap, so it's also acting as a floor, was not intended or particularly anticipated, I think.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by emeraldd on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:04PM (#30195069)
Had to look up `district heating` ... that's a not a common thing in the US.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/District_heating
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by FabHK on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:45PM (#30195794)
Ha, in Germany it's called "Fernwärme", which corresponds nicely to "teleheating" (which Wikipedia lists as an alternative name). It's great, not only does electricity and water magically come from a wall in your basement, but also heat :-)

I thought they had abandoned the idea of using heat from a nuclear power plant for district heating in Russia, but apparently that is actually done [1, 2] extensively.

Having a pipe into your house directly (well, not directly, indirectly, but still) from the nuclear power plant next door... not sure how I'd feel about that.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VVER#Tertiary_cooling_circuit_...

[2] https://www.powermag.com/district-heating-supply-from-nuclea...

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by ptaipale on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:18PM (#30198204)
District heating from nuclear used to be a no-no but has recently gained momentum in Finland (as an idea). Build an SMR near the city for electricity, and use the excess heat for district warming (which is needed during most of the year).
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by moogly on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:19AM (#30204163)
It really is a no-brainer when ~40% of the energy produced by a nuclear reactor is currently pumped out as warm water in the ocean (about 10-12ºC warmer than when it was pumped in).
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by jrockway on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:08PM (#30195125)
It's a thing in the US. If you're ever walking around Manhattan and see steam coming out of a traffic cone, that's the side effect of district heating (groundwater hitting the very hot steam pipes and vaporizing).
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by andi999 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:39PM (#30195686)
Which should not happen, I mean do you not insulate the pipes?
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by Rebelgecko on Thursday February 03, 2022 @04:57PM (#30199551)
Won't insulating the pipes reduce the heating effectiveness?
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by KptMarchewa on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:32PM (#30200586)
No. It would reduce transport losses.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insulated_pipe

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by carlhjerpe on Thursday February 03, 2022 @03:08PM (#30198034)
Not a common thing != not a thing
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by sfteus on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:44PM (#30195761)
This is the case at least in some parts of the US as well.

I believe in all of Texas (North Texas here), your costs are broken down by energy costs and delivery costs, the latter of which is paid to your TDU to maintain the infrastructure. For our plan the delivery charge is roughly 45% of the kWh price.

Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by pabs3 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @11:04PM (#30202728)
Why is it based on breaker/fuse size? Surely the cost should be based on cost of maintenance over the entire grid over the last year divided by the amount of customers using the grid?
Re:How should net metering affect your electric bill? by moogly on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:23AM (#30204196)
Overprovisioning/grid stability.